arXiv:2610.38832
Gravitational Interactions in Nuclear Clocks
Konstantin Beyer, Niklas E. Önne, Shimon Kolkowitz, Dolev Bluvstein, Mikhail Lukin, Jun Ye, Igor Pikovski
Abstract
Atomic clocks achieve extraordinary precision through quantum control over large ensembles of atoms, with precision increasing and atom number advancing steadily. Emerging nuclear clock technology encodes clock states in nuclear rather than electronic transitions, offering a new frontier for precision measurement. Here we study whether a large ensemble of such clock nuclei could be used to observe their mutual gravitational interaction. We investigate the gravitational redshift induced by neighboring atoms, including nuclear energy superpositions as sources of gravity, giving rise to a genuinely quantum gravitational interaction between pairs of nuclei. We find that the resulting clock frequency shift due to mutual gravity may become non-negligible for a macroscopic number of nuclei, for instance in a solid-state thorium clock, and we propose approaches to mitigate electromagnetic field effects by exploiting spatial symmetry and high-precision spectroscopy. We further discuss how energy-induced mass superpositions could be directly probed using external gravitational field sensors. By contrast, observing gravity-induced entanglement involving clocks would require substantially greater experimental advances due to decoherence from spontaneous emission. Taken together, our results suggest that nuclear clocks, either alone or in combination with complementary sensors such as optomechanical systems, may offer a future route toward probing gravity at short distances and testing gravitating quantum source masses beyond the Newtonian limit.
AI Summary
Can macroscopic ensembles of nuclear-clock nuclei reveal their mutual gravitational interaction, including gravity sourced by internal excitation energy? The paper models fixed two-level nuclei with pair interaction $H_{\mathrm{int}}=-G H^A H^B/(c^4r)$, separating rest-mass-induced redshifts from internal-energy couplings. Reduced dynamics and continuum integrals for uniform spherical ensembles establish the collective shifts and their atom-number scaling. At fixed density, the mean redshift grows as $N^{2/3}$. Combining this with ideal, lifetime-limited quantum-projection-noise sensitivity gives a required averaging time scaling as $N^{-7/3}$. For thorium-229, the rest-mass shift reaches this ideal sensitivity around $N\sim10^{18}$ after 100 hours. Detecting the internal-energy contribution is much harder: at $N\approx6\times10^{23}$, the estimates are approximately 9 million years for thorium, 357 years for uranium-235, and 21 hours for scandium-45. A concentric scandium source–probe arrangement gives a fractional shift near $10^{-34}$ and an ideal averaging time of 1.7 days. Proposed detection strategies include synchronized source modulation and probe spin echoes, spherical averaging, opposite-spin transitions, shielding, and entanglement-assisted magnetic-noise cancellation. Mechanical sensing would instead target roughly $10^{-18}\,\mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}$ at centimetre separation for an excited thorium ensemble. These estimates assume macroscopic coherent control and ideal readout; scalable uranium and scandium clocks are unavailable, and magnetic shifts can exceed the gravitational signal by about twenty orders of magnitude. The frequency shift depends only on mean source energy and therefore does not distinguish quantum gravity from semiclassical gravity. Gravity-mediated entanglement is separately assessed as inaccessible under the assumed spontaneous-emission rates.
Central claim may not hold: The proposed excitation-dependent gravitational signal depends only on source energy populations and is unchanged by removing source coherences, so it cannot by itself establish the claimed superposition of gravitational fields, despite stronger statements in the experimental section and discussion. Table 1 incorrectly extrapolates lifetime-limited clock averaging to nanosecond acquisition times shorter than a single assumed interrogation; ideal short-time Ramsey estimates instead give approximately 8 milliseconds for the thorium benchmark.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.