arXiv:2610.37854
Quantum Foundations Beyond Bell's Theorem: A Topical Review
Flavio Del Santo, Nicolas Gisin
Abstract
We review a series of recent no-go theorems that extend the methodological and conceptual framework introduced by Bell's theorem to more sophisticated operational scenarios involving independent sources, quantum networks, joint measurements, and multiple observers. Many of these results were originally developed within quantum information science and are scattered across the literature, where their technical and application-driven success has partly obscured their broader foundational significance. We organize them around a common Bell-inspired methodology that extends beyond quantum nonlocality, and emphasize how increasingly rich operational structures change which physical assumptions can be tested.
AI Summary
This topical review asks how Bell’s operational methodology extends beyond standard nonlocality tests to constrain physical explanations of quantum phenomena. It organizes established no-go theorems around richer experimental structures: independent sources, networks, joint measurements, supplementary information, and nested observers. It provides assumptions, illustrative constructions, proof sketches, and a comparison table, rather than new no-go results. The review covers nonlocality without measurement inputs in triangle networks; the incompatibility of finite-speed superluminal hidden influences with both quantum correlations and operational no-signaling; PBR’s exclusion of preparation-independent $\psi$-epistemic models; and Colbeck–Renner’s restrictions on predictive extensions using accessible, static supplementary information. It also explains how independent-source networks distinguish real from complex quantum theory under tensor-product composition, using conditional tests attaining $\mathrm{CHSH3}=6\sqrt{2}$, and how extended Wigner’s-friend scenarios violate local-friendliness inequalities, with a representative quantum value $I_{\mathrm{LF}}\simeq7.345$ against a bound of $6$. Proof methods include inflation, conditional-locality inequalities, antidistinguishability, chained Bell inequalities, and self-testing. The stated qualifications are central: input-free network certification is vulnerable to cross-round memory without an i.i.d. assumption; PBR requires preparation independence; Colbeck–Renner uses stronger-than-standard freedom of choice and additional dynamical assumptions; and the real–complex separation depends on a debated composition rule. Multipartite finite-speed-influence tests remain experimentally unperformed, while conclusive Wigner’s-friend tests face unresolved questions about what constitutes an observer. Contextuality is excluded from the review’s scope; causal order, nonlocal measurements, and gravity receive shorter outlook discussions.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 18 pages, 11 figures