Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.36997

The Disordered Universe 2025: Statistical Systems Out of Equilibrium

Weam Abou Hamdan, Martí Berenguer Mimó, Rafael Carrasco Carmona, Silvia Pla, Omkar Shetye, Tarek Anous, Paolo Benincasa, Guilherme L. Pimentel

Published Oct 27, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

These lecture notes provide an introduction to quantum spin glasses, with a particular emphasis on their application to open problems in cosmology and holography. Focusing on the spherical $p$-spin model, we develop a complete and self-contained analysis of its thermodynamic and dynamical properties. We introduce the replica method, discuss both replica-symmetric and one-step replica symmetry-broken solutions, and characterise the resulting glassy phase. The framework is then extended to the quantum model, where we study the emergence of slow dynamics and the role of quantum correlations through Euclidean and real-time correlation functions. Finally, we explore how concepts such as replica symmetry breaking and disorder naturally arise in cosmological and holographic systems related to black hole fragmentation, highlighting spin glass models as useful theoretical laboratories for these phenomena. These notes are based on a series of lectures held during the La Ricotta Summer School: The Disordered Universe 2025 from 21 July to 1 August 2025.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2610.36997

Related papers

The quantum p -spin glass model: a user manual for holographers

Tarek Anous, Felix M. Haehl

Abstract We study a large- N bosonic quantum mechanical sigma-model with a spherical target space subject to disordered interactions, more colloquially known as the p -spin spherical model. Replica symmetry is broken at low temperatures and for sufficiently weak quantum fluctuations, which drives the system into a spin glass (SG) phase. The first half of this paper is dedicated to a discussion of this model’s thermodynamics, with particular emphasis on the marginally stable SG . This phase exhibits an emergent conformal symmetry in the strong coupling regime, which dictates its thermodynamic properties. It is associated with an extensive number of nearby states in the free energy landscape. We discuss in detail an elegant approximate solution to the SG equations, which interpolates between the conformal regime and an ultraviolet-complete short distance solution. In the second half of this paper we explore the real-time dynamics of the model and uncover quantum chaos as measured by out-of-time-order four-point functions, both numerically and analytically. We find exponential Lyapunov growth, which intricately depends on the model’s couplings and becomes strongest in the quantum critical regime. We emphasize that the SG phase also exhibits quantum chaos, albeit with parametrically smaller Lyapunov exponent than in the replica symmetric phase. An analytical calculation in the marginal SG phase suggests that this Lyapunov exponent vanishes in a particular infinite coupling limit. We comment on the potential meaning of these observations from the perspective of holography.

arXiv:2106.03838•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Nov 1, 2021•27 citations

Equilibrium Dynamics of Infinite-Range Quantum Spin Glasses in a Field

Maria Tikhanovskaya, Subir Sachdev A, Rhine Samajdar

We determine the low-energy spectrum and Parisi replica-symmetry-breaking function for the spin-glass phase of the quantum Ising model with infinite-range random exchange interactions and transverse and longitudinal ( h ) fields. We show that, for all h , the spin-glass state has full replica symmetry breaking and the local spin spectrum is gapless, with a spectral density that vanishes linearly with frequency. These results are obtained using an action functional—argued to yield exact results at low frequencies—that expands in powers of a spin-glass order parameter, which is bilocal in time, and a matrix in replica space. We also present the exact solution of the infinite-range spherical quantum p -rotor model at nonzero h : here, the spin-glass state has one-step replica symmetry breaking and gaplessness only appears after imposition of an additional marginal stability condition. Possible connections to experiments on random arrays of trapped Rydberg atoms are noted. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2309.03255•PRX Quantum•Apr 17, 2024•9 citations

Replica symmetry breaking in spin glasses in the replica-free Keldysh formalism

Johannes Lang, Subir Sachdev A, Sebastian Diehl

We show that the algebra of Parisi ultrametric matrices is recovered by the real-time, replica-free, Dyson-Keldysh equations of infinite-range quantum spin glasses in the late time glassy limit. This connects to earlier results on classical and quantum systems showing how ultrametricity emerges from the persistent slow aging dynamics of the glass phase. The stationary spin glass state thereby spontaneously breaks thermal symmetry, or the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger relation of a state in global thermal equilibrium. We describe the Keldysh path integral of the infinite-range Ising model in transverse and longitudinal fields, and in the context of the Landau expansion of the action functional, show how the long-time limit connects to the full replica symmetry breaking obtained in the equilibrium formalism. We also illustrate our formalism by applying it to the spherical quantum p p -spin model, which only exhibits one-step replica symmetry breaking.

arXiv:2406.05842•SciPost Physics•Dec 9, 2024•5 citations

Equilibrium dynamics of spin-glass systems

A. Crisanti, Luca Leuzzi

We present a critical analysis of the Sompolinsky theory of equilibrium dynamics. By using the spherical $2+p$ spin-glass model we test the asymptotic static limit of the Sompolinsky solution showing that it fails to yield a thermodynamically stable solution. We then present an alternative formulation, based on the Crisanti, H\"orner, and Sommers [Z. Phys. B: Condens. Matter 92, 257 (1993)] dynamical solution of the spherical $p$-spin spin-glass model, reproducing a stable static limit that coincides, in the case of a one step replica symmetry breaking ansatz, with the solution at the dynamic free energy threshold at which the relaxing system gets stuck off equilibrium. We formally extend our analysis to any number of replica symmetry breakings $R$. In the limit $R\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, both formulations lead to the Parisi antiparabolic differential equation. This is the special case, though, where no dynamic blocking threshold occurs. The formulation does not contain the additional order parameter $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ of the Sompolinsky theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/0606425•Physical Review B•Apr 5, 2007•17 citations

Imaginary-time replica formalism study of a quantum sphericalp-spin-glass model

Leticia F. Cugliandolo, Daniel R. Grempel, Constantino A. da Silva Santos

We study a quantum extension of the spherical p-spin-glass model using the imaginary-time replica formalism. We solve the model numerically and we discuss two analytical approximation schemes that capture most of the features of the solution. The phase diagram and the physical properties of the system are determined in thermodynamic equilibrium and under conditions of marginal stability. In both cases, the phase diagram consists of two qualitatively different regions. If the transition temperature is higher than a certain value ${T}^{*},$ quantum effects are qualitatively irrelevant and the phase transition is second order, as in the classical case. When quantum fluctuations depress the transition temperature below ${T}^{*},$ the transition becomes first order. The susceptibility is discontinuous and shows hysteresis across the first-order line. This behavior is reminiscent of that observed in the dipolar Ising spin-glass ${\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}$ in an external transverse magnetic field. We discuss the thermodynamics and the stationary dynamics of both states. The spectrum of magnetic excitations of the equilibrium spin-glass state is gapped, leading to an exponentially small specific heat at low temperatures. That of the marginally stable state is gapless and its specific heat varies linearly with temperature, as generally observed in glasses at low temperature. We show that the properties of the marginally stable state are closely related to those obtained in studies of the real-time dynamics of the system weakly coupled to a quantum thermal bath. Finally, we discuss a possible application of our results to the problem of polymers in random media.

arXiv:cond-mat/0012222•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 5, 2001•89 citations

Physical manifestation of replica symmetry breaking in a quantum glass of bosons with off-diagonal disorder

Anna M. Piekarska, T. K. Kopeć

Glassiness occurs when disorder and frustration cause local degrees of freedom to freeze despite the lack of long-range order. In systems of interacting bosons, such glassiness may involve a purely quantum degree of freedom$\unicode{x2014}$local phases of particle wave functions$\unicode{x2014}$partly analogous to spins in spin glasses. However, experimental identification of such phases is difficult because it requires prohibitively long measurement times or recourse to the elusive Edwards-Anderson order parameter. Moreover, the off-diagonal character of the phase makes it seemingly even harder to capture via typical observables. To address this issue, we study a system of strongly interacting bosons with random hoppings that features off-diagonal glassiness exhibiting replica symmetry breaking (RSB). We find that the glass phase is compressible, which distinguishes it from the Mott insulator. Thus, we establish a direct correspondence between phase-based glassy order and a measurable density-based thermodynamic observable. We use a framework adopted from spin glasses, including the replica trick within the one-step RSB scheme, to obtain meaningful results in the glass phase and to characterize the order parameters, RSB structure, slow relaxation, and compressibility. Glassiness in particle systems could thus be experimentally identified via measurements of compressibility, such as probing density fluctuations or the particle-number response to a trapping potential.

arXiv:2603.20949•Mar 21, 2026•0 citations
These lecture notes provide an introduction to quantum spin glasses, with a particular emphasis on their application to open problems in cosmology and holography. Focusing on the spherical ppp-spin model, we develop a complete and self-contained analysis of its thermodynamic and dynamical properties. We introduce the replica method, discuss both replica-symmetric and one-step replica symmetry-broken solutions, and characterise the resulting glassy phase. The framework is then extended to the quantum model, where we study the emergence of slow dynamics and the role of quantum correlations through Euclidean and real-time correlation functions. Finally, we explore how concepts such as replica symmetry breaking and disorder naturally arise in cosmological and holographic systems related to black hole fragmentation, highlighting spin glass models as useful theoretical laboratories for these phenomena. These notes are based on a series of lectures held during the La Ricotta Summer School: The Disordered Universe 2025 from 21 July to 1 August 2025.
Abstract We study a large- N bosonic quantum mechanical sigma-model with a spherical target space subject to disordered interactions, more colloquially known as the p -spin spherical model. Replica symmetry is broken at low temperatures and for sufficiently weak quantum fluctuations, which drives the system into a spin glass (SG) phase. The first half of this paper is dedicated to a discussion of this model’s thermodynamics, with particular emphasis on the marginally stable SG . This phase exhibits an emergent conformal symmetry in the strong coupling regime, which dictates its thermodynamic properties. It is associated with an extensive number of nearby states in the free energy landscape. We discuss in detail an elegant approximate solution to the SG equations, which interpolates between the conformal regime and an ultraviolet-complete short distance solution. In the second half of this paper we explore the real-time dynamics of the model and uncover quantum chaos as measured by out-of-time-order four-point functions, both numerically and analytically. We find exponential Lyapunov growth, which intricately depends on the model’s couplings and becomes strongest in the quantum critical regime. We emphasize that the SG phase also exhibits quantum chaos, albeit with parametrically smaller Lyapunov exponent than in the replica symmetric phase. An analytical calculation in the marginal SG phase suggests that this Lyapunov exponent vanishes in a particular infinite coupling limit. We comment on the potential meaning of these observations from the perspective of holography.
We determine the low-energy spectrum and Parisi replica-symmetry-breaking function for the spin-glass phase of the quantum Ising model with infinite-range random exchange interactions and transverse and longitudinal ( h ) fields. We show that, for all h , the spin-glass state has full replica symmetry breaking and the local spin spectrum is gapless, with a spectral density that vanishes linearly with frequency. These results are obtained using an action functional—argued to yield exact results at low frequencies—that expands in powers of a spin-glass order parameter, which is bilocal in time, and a matrix in replica space. We also present the exact solution of the infinite-range spherical quantum p -rotor model at nonzero h : here, the spin-glass state has one-step replica symmetry breaking and gaplessness only appears after imposition of an additional marginal stability condition. Possible connections to experiments on random arrays of trapped Rydberg atoms are noted. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We show that the algebra of Parisi ultrametric matrices is recovered by the real-time, replica-free, Dyson-Keldysh equations of infinite-range quantum spin glasses in the late time glassy limit. This connects to earlier results on classical and quantum systems showing how ultrametricity emerges from the persistent slow aging dynamics of the glass phase. The stationary spin glass state thereby spontaneously breaks thermal symmetry, or the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger relation of a state in global thermal equilibrium. We describe the Keldysh path integral of the infinite-range Ising model in transverse and longitudinal fields, and in the context of the Landau expansion of the action functional, show how the long-time limit connects to the full replica symmetry breaking obtained in the equilibrium formalism. We also illustrate our formalism by applying it to the spherical quantum p p -spin model, which only exhibits one-step replica symmetry breaking.
We present a critical analysis of the Sompolinsky theory of equilibrium dynamics. By using the spherical 2+p2+p2+p spin-glass model we test the asymptotic static limit of the Sompolinsky solution showing that it fails to yield a thermodynamically stable solution. We then present an alternative formulation, based on the Crisanti, H\"orner, and Sommers [Z. Phys. B: Condens. Matter 92, 257 (1993)] dynamical solution of the spherical ppp-spin spin-glass model, reproducing a stable static limit that coincides, in the case of a one step replica symmetry breaking ansatz, with the solution at the dynamic free energy threshold at which the relaxing system gets stuck off equilibrium. We formally extend our analysis to any number of replica symmetry breakings RRR. In the limit $R\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, both formulations lead to the Parisi antiparabolic differential equation. This is the special case, though, where no dynamic blocking threshold occurs. The formulation does not contain the additional order parameter $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ of the Sompolinsky theory.
We study a quantum extension of the spherical p-spin-glass model using the imaginary-time replica formalism. We solve the model numerically and we discuss two analytical approximation schemes that capture most of the features of the solution. The phase diagram and the physical properties of the system are determined in thermodynamic equilibrium and under conditions of marginal stability. In both cases, the phase diagram consists of two qualitatively different regions. If the transition temperature is higher than a certain value T∗,{T}^{*},T∗, quantum effects are qualitatively irrelevant and the phase transition is second order, as in the classical case. When quantum fluctuations depress the transition temperature below T∗,{T}^{*},T∗, the transition becomes first order. The susceptibility is discontinuous and shows hysteresis across the first-order line. This behavior is reminiscent of that observed in the dipolar Ising spin-glass ${\mathrm{LiHo}}_{x}{\mathrm{Y}}_{1\ensuremath{-}x}{\mathrm{F}}_{4}$ in an external transverse magnetic field. We discuss the thermodynamics and the stationary dynamics of both states. The spectrum of magnetic excitations of the equilibrium spin-glass state is gapped, leading to an exponentially small specific heat at low temperatures. That of the marginally stable state is gapless and its specific heat varies linearly with temperature, as generally observed in glasses at low temperature. We show that the properties of the marginally stable state are closely related to those obtained in studies of the real-time dynamics of the system weakly coupled to a quantum thermal bath. Finally, we discuss a possible application of our results to the problem of polymers in random media.
Glassiness occurs when disorder and frustration cause local degrees of freedom to freeze despite the lack of long-range order. In systems of interacting bosons, such glassiness may involve a purely quantum degree of freedom$\unicode{x2014}$local phases of particle wave functions$\unicode{x2014}$partly analogous to spins in spin glasses. However, experimental identification of such phases is difficult because it requires prohibitively long measurement times or recourse to the elusive Edwards-Anderson order parameter. Moreover, the off-diagonal character of the phase makes it seemingly even harder to capture via typical observables. To address this issue, we study a system of strongly interacting bosons with random hoppings that features off-diagonal glassiness exhibiting replica symmetry breaking (RSB). We find that the glass phase is compressible, which distinguishes it from the Mott insulator. Thus, we establish a direct correspondence between phase-based glassy order and a measurable density-based thermodynamic observable. We use a framework adopted from spin glasses, including the replica trick within the one-step RSB scheme, to obtain meaningful results in the glass phase and to characterize the order parameters, RSB structure, slow relaxation, and compressibility. Glassiness in particle systems could thus be experimentally identified via measurements of compressibility, such as probing density fluctuations or the particle-number response to a trapping potential.