Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.33294

Twirled and swirled worlds: a compositional approach

Sina Soltani, Thomas D. Galley, Marco Erba, John H. Selby

quant-phSubmitted Oct 23, 2026• Announced Oct 27, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Twirled and swirled worlds describe generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs) restricted by symmetry-imposed superselection rules. We extend these constructions to a fully compositional setting for finite-dimensional GPTs and compact groups, treating states, effects, and multipartite transformations uniformly as processes. We distinguish system actions from process-space actions. We define actions on a theory as a whole by requiring the corresponding process-space actions to respect sequential and parallel composition. Averaging physical theory actions defines twirling, while averaging nonphysical theory actions defines swirling. We show that invariant subtheories might not satisfy process tomography, and establish conditions under which they do, involving invariant dynamically faithful states or internal classical reference frames. For locally tomographic parent theories, we prove that every theory symmetry admits a representation by linear system actions and that the invariant subtheory satisfies process tomography. An invariant multipartite process space fails local tomography if and only if some bipartition has sides sharing a non-trivial irreducible representation. We characterise when ancillary systems are necessary, which representations they must carry, and when entanglement is required for ancilla-free process tomography. We develop a framework for unifying twirled subtheories and extend incoherent simulations to compact groups. Finally, we recover bilocal classical theory as a twirled subtheory of classical theory and real quantum theory as a swirled subtheory of complex quantum theory, deriving their tomographic properties from their representation structure.

AI Summary

The paper asks how symmetry-restricted generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs) can be defined consistently for arbitrary multipartite processes, and which forms of tomography survive the restriction. It treats finite-dimensional GPTs and compact groups, distinguishing actions on systems, process spaces, and entire theories. Theory actions must preserve sequential and parallel composition; Haar averaging of physical actions is called twirling, and averaging of nonphysical actions swirling. The resulting invariant processes form compositionally closed subtheories. Invariant states and effects always distinguish one another, but this argument does not automatically establish process tomography. Sufficient conditions include invariant dynamically faithful states—or faithful vectors in the span of invariant states—and internal classical reference frames with suitable control. For locally tomographic parent GPTs, every theory action admits a linear system-level representation, and every invariant subtheory satisfies process tomography. Representation theory characterises failure of local tomography: it occurs precisely when some bipartition has sides sharing a nontrivial irreducible representation. Related criteria identify ancillary representation requirements and when entanglement is necessary for ancilla-free process tomography. The framework also unifies different system-induced twirled worlds, extends incoherent simulations to compact groups, and recovers bilocal classical theory and real quantum theory as symmetry restrictions. The proofs use compositional identities, Haar averaging, and invariant-sector decompositions. Beyond locally tomographic parents, necessary and sufficient conditions for process tomography remain open; no explicit counterexample exhibiting its failure is supplied. Continuous classical reference frames require infinite-dimensional extensions whose detailed construction is deferred.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The abstract presents possible failure of process tomography as an established result, whereas the body establishes sufficient conditions for tomography and leaves whether failure actually occurs as an open question.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Symmetry-induced failures of tomographic locality: Constructing foil theories by twirling

Daniel Centeno, Marco Erba, Thomas D. Galley +7 more

Tomographic locality is a principle commonly used in the program of finding axioms that pick out quantum theory within the landscape of possible theories. The principle asserts the sufficiency of local measurements for achieving a tomographic characterization of any bipartite state. In this work, we explore the meaning of the principle of tomographic locality by developing a simple scheme for generating a wide variety of theories that violate the principle. In this scheme, one starts with a tomographically local theory -- which can be classical, quantum or post-quantum -- and a physical symmetry, and one restricts the processes in the theory to all and only those that are covariant with respect to the collective action of that symmetry. We refer to the resulting theories as twirled worlds. We show that failures of tomographic locality are ubiquitous in twirled worlds. From the possibility of such failures in classical twirled worlds, we argue that the failure of tomographic locality (i.e., tomographic nonlocality) does not imply ontological holism. Our results also demonstrate the need for researchers seeking to axiomatize quantum theory to take a stand on the question of whether there are superselection rules that have a fundamental status.

arXiv:2407.21688•Physical Review A•Jul 15, 2025•10 citations

Choi-level twirling of quantum channels: finite constructions and non-compact transformations

Marcin Markiewicz, Łukasz Pawela, Zbigniew Puchała

Twirling, i.e. averaging over symmetry actions, is a standard tool for reducing quantum states and channels to a symmetry-invariant form. We study channel twirling from the perspective of the channel-state duality and provide a constructive Choi-level description of the averaging map induced by arbitrary input/output representations. Our main technical result concerns the collective setting: for $π^{\textrm{in}}(U)=U^{\otimes t_{\textrm{in}}}$ and $π^{\textrm{out}}(U)=U^{\otimes t_{\textrm{out}}}$, we introduce a partial-transpose reduction that removes the contragredient action and converts the mixed (walled Brauer) channel twirl into an ordinary Schur-Weyl twirl of the partially transposed Choi operator under $U^{\otimes(t_{\textrm{in}}+t_{\textrm{out}})}$, enabling explicit permutation-based formulas without constructing walled Brauer idempotents or mixed Schur transforms. Beyond compact symmetries, we extend channel twirling to reductive, generally non-unitary groups via Cartan decomposition and obtain an invariant-sector decomposition of the averaged Choi operator with weights determined solely by the Abelian Cartan component. Finally, we provide two finite realizations of channel averaging: a "dual" implementation as a convex mixture of unitary-$1$-design channels acting on invariant sectors, and a design-like reconstruction showing that weighted group $t$-designs induce channel $t$-designs for $t=t_{\textrm{in}}+t_{\textrm{out}}$.

quant-pharXiv:2512.23586•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 30, 2025•1 citation

Whether quantum theory needs complex numbers: The foil theories perspective

Yìlè Yīng, Maria Ciudad Alañón, Daniel Centeno +5 more

Recent work by Renou et al. (2021) has led to some controversy concerning the question of whether quantum theory requires complex numbers for its formulation. We promote the view that the main result of that work is best understood not as a claim about the relative merits of different representations of quantum theory, but rather as a claim about the possibility of experimentally adjudicating between standard quantum theory and an alternative theory -- a foil theory -- known as real-amplitude quantum theory (RQT). In particular, the claim is that this adjudication can be achieved given only an assumption about the causal structure of the experiment. Here, we aim to shed some light on why this is possible, by reconceptualizing the comparison of the two theories as an instance of a broader class of such theory comparisons. By recasting RQT as the subtheory of quantum theory that arises by symmetrizing with respect to the collective action of a time-reversal symmetry, we can compare it to other subtheories that arise by symmetrization, but for different symmetries. If the symmetry has a unitary representation, the resulting foil theory is termed a twirled quantum world, and if it does not (as is the case in RQT), the resulting foil theory is termed a swirled quantum world. We show that, in contrast to RQT, there is no possibility of distinguishing any twirled quantum world from quantum theory given only an assumption about causal structure. We also define analogues of twirling and swirling for an arbitrary generalized probabilistic theory and identify certain necessary conditions on a causal structure for it to be able to support a causal compatibility gap between the theory and its symmetrized version. We draw out the implications of these analyses for the question of how a lack of a shared reference frame state features into the possibility of such a gap.

arXiv:2506.08091•Physical Review A•Oct 9, 2026•19 citations

Process matrices on generalised theories

Matt Wilson, James Hefford, Timothée Hoffreumon

We extend the process-matrix framework for defining indefinite causal orders to a broad class of generalised physical theories. We give a simple re-axiomatisation of spacetime contexts in terms of naturality over classical probes, which precisely captures non-contextual assignment together with compatibility with convexity and coarse-graining within local laboratories. Using this compositional perspective, we give a clean characterisation of theories in which abstract spacetime contexts admit a process-matrix representation, and we pin down the precise conditions (satisfied by classical theory, quantum theory, and a Boxworld-like theory) under which the supermap and process-matrix perspectives on higher-order processes coincide.

quant-pharXiv:2610.40448•Oct 30, 2026•0 citations

Unitary operator bases as reduced size universal averaging sets

Marcin Markiewicz, Konrad Schlichtholz

We construct finite averaging sets for twirling finite-dimensional quantum states over a broad class of symmetry transformations represented by reductive Lie groups. The averaging is defined through the Cartan decomposition of the group, with Haar-uniform integration over the compact components and an arbitrary normalized measure over the non-compact Abelian component. We show that the resulting twirling map can always be represented as a finite probabilistic mixture of unitary 1-design channels acting on irreducible sectors of the representation restricted to the maximal compact subgroup. Thus, the finite construction is determined by the compact-sector decomposition, while the non-compact Cartan component contributes only scalar sector weights. This distinction is important for implementation: no Schur transform for the full reductive group is required. Compared with standard t -design-based finite averaging, our construction generally uses fewer averaging operators, at the price of replacing local tensor-power sampling by sector-wise unitary averaging. This could be especially beneficial for simulations and quantum algorithms on higher-dimensional systems as reduction of the size of the averaging set relatively increases with dimension.

Scientific Reports•Aug 24, 2026•0 citations

A structure theorem for complex-valued quasiprobability representations of physical theories

Rafael Wagner, Roberto D. Baldijão, Matthias Salzger +3 more

Quasiprobability representations are well-established tools in quantum information science, with applications ranging from the classical simulability of quantum computation to quantum process tomography, quantum error correction, and quantum sensing. While traditional quasiprobability representations typically employ real-valued distributions, recent developments highlight the usefulness of complex-valued ones -- most notably, via the family of Kirkwood--Dirac quasiprobability distributions. Building on the framework of Schmid et al. [Quantum 8, 1283 (2024)], we extend the analysis to encompass complex-valued quasiprobability representations that need not preserve the identity channel. Additionally, we also extend previous results to consider mappings towards infinite-dimensional spaces. We show that, for each system, every such representation can be expressed as the composition of two maps that are completely characterized by their action on states and on the identity (equivalently, on effects) for that system. Our results apply to all complex-valued quasiprobability representations of any finite-dimensional, tomographically-local generalized probabilistic theory, with finite-dimensional quantum theory serving as a paradigmatic example. In the quantum case, the maps' action on states and effects corresponds to choices of frames and dual frames for the representation. This work offers a unified mathematical framework for analyzing complex-valued quasiprobability representations in generalized probabilistic theories.

arXiv:2509.10949•Sep 13, 2025•5 citations
Twirled and swirled worlds describe generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs) restricted by symmetry-imposed superselection rules. We extend these constructions to a fully compositional setting for finite-dimensional GPTs and compact groups, treating states, effects, and multipartite transformations uniformly as processes. We distinguish system actions from process-space actions. We define actions on a theory as a whole by requiring the corresponding process-space actions to respect sequential and parallel composition. Averaging physical theory actions defines twirling, while averaging nonphysical theory actions defines swirling. We show that invariant subtheories might not satisfy process tomography, and establish conditions under which they do, involving invariant dynamically faithful states or internal classical reference frames. For locally tomographic parent theories, we prove that every theory symmetry admits a representation by linear system actions and that the invariant subtheory satisfies process tomography. An invariant multipartite process space fails local tomography if and only if some bipartition has sides sharing a non-trivial irreducible representation. We characterise when ancillary systems are necessary, which representations they must carry, and when entanglement is required for ancilla-free process tomography. We develop a framework for unifying twirled subtheories and extend incoherent simulations to compact groups. Finally, we recover bilocal classical theory as a twirled subtheory of classical theory and real quantum theory as a swirled subtheory of complex quantum theory, deriving their tomographic properties from their representation structure.
The paper asks how symmetry-restricted generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs) can be defined consistently for arbitrary multipartite processes, and which forms of tomography survive the restriction. It treats finite-dimensional GPTs and compact groups, distinguishing actions on systems, process spaces, and entire theories. Theory actions must preserve sequential and parallel composition; Haar averaging of physical actions is called twirling, and averaging of nonphysical actions swirling.
The resulting invariant processes form compositionally closed subtheories. Invariant states and effects always distinguish one another, but this argument does not automatically establish process tomography. Sufficient conditions include invariant dynamically faithful states—or faithful vectors in the span of invariant states—and internal classical reference frames with suitable control. For locally tomographic parent GPTs, every theory action admits a linear system-level representation, and every invariant subtheory satisfies process tomography. Representation theory characterises failure of local tomography: it occurs precisely when some bipartition has sides sharing a nontrivial irreducible representation. Related criteria identify ancillary representation requirements and when entanglement is necessary for ancilla-free process tomography.
The framework also unifies different system-induced twirled worlds, extends incoherent simulations to compact groups, and recovers bilocal classical theory and real quantum theory as symmetry restrictions. The proofs use compositional identities, Haar averaging, and invariant-sector decompositions. Beyond locally tomographic parents, necessary and sufficient conditions for process tomography remain open; no explicit counterexample exhibiting its failure is supplied. Continuous classical reference frames require infinite-dimensional extensions whose detailed construction is deferred.
Tomographic locality is a principle commonly used in the program of finding axioms that pick out quantum theory within the landscape of possible theories. The principle asserts the sufficiency of local measurements for achieving a tomographic characterization of any bipartite state. In this work, we explore the meaning of the principle of tomographic locality by developing a simple scheme for generating a wide variety of theories that violate the principle. In this scheme, one starts with a tomographically local theory -- which can be classical, quantum or post-quantum -- and a physical symmetry, and one restricts the processes in the theory to all and only those that are covariant with respect to the collective action of that symmetry. We refer to the resulting theories as twirled worlds. We show that failures of tomographic locality are ubiquitous in twirled worlds. From the possibility of such failures in classical twirled worlds, we argue that the failure of tomographic locality (i.e., tomographic nonlocality) does not imply ontological holism. Our results also demonstrate the need for researchers seeking to axiomatize quantum theory to take a stand on the question of whether there are superselection rules that have a fundamental status.
Twirling, i.e. averaging over symmetry actions, is a standard tool for reducing quantum states and channels to a symmetry-invariant form. We study channel twirling from the perspective of the channel-state duality and provide a constructive Choi-level description of the averaging map induced by arbitrary input/output representations. Our main technical result concerns the collective setting: for πin(U)=U⊗tinπ^{\textrm{in}}(U)=U^{\otimes t_{\textrm{in}}}πin(U)=U⊗tin​ and πout(U)=U⊗toutπ^{\textrm{out}}(U)=U^{\otimes t_{\textrm{out}}}πout(U)=U⊗tout​, we introduce a partial-transpose reduction that removes the contragredient action and converts the mixed (walled Brauer) channel twirl into an ordinary Schur-Weyl twirl of the partially transposed Choi operator under U⊗(tin+tout)U^{\otimes(t_{\textrm{in}}+t_{\textrm{out}})}U⊗(tin​+tout​), enabling explicit permutation-based formulas without constructing walled Brauer idempotents or mixed Schur transforms. Beyond compact symmetries, we extend channel twirling to reductive, generally non-unitary groups via Cartan decomposition and obtain an invariant-sector decomposition of the averaged Choi operator with weights determined solely by the Abelian Cartan component. Finally, we provide two finite realizations of channel averaging: a "dual" implementation as a convex mixture of unitary-111-design channels acting on invariant sectors, and a design-like reconstruction showing that weighted group ttt-designs induce channel ttt-designs for t=tin+toutt=t_{\textrm{in}}+t_{\textrm{out}}t=tin​+tout​.
Recent work by Renou et al. (2021) has led to some controversy concerning the question of whether quantum theory requires complex numbers for its formulation. We promote the view that the main result of that work is best understood not as a claim about the relative merits of different representations of quantum theory, but rather as a claim about the possibility of experimentally adjudicating between standard quantum theory and an alternative theory -- a foil theory -- known as real-amplitude quantum theory (RQT). In particular, the claim is that this adjudication can be achieved given only an assumption about the causal structure of the experiment. Here, we aim to shed some light on why this is possible, by reconceptualizing the comparison of the two theories as an instance of a broader class of such theory comparisons. By recasting RQT as the subtheory of quantum theory that arises by symmetrizing with respect to the collective action of a time-reversal symmetry, we can compare it to other subtheories that arise by symmetrization, but for different symmetries. If the symmetry has a unitary representation, the resulting foil theory is termed a twirled quantum world, and if it does not (as is the case in RQT), the resulting foil theory is termed a swirled quantum world. We show that, in contrast to RQT, there is no possibility of distinguishing any twirled quantum world from quantum theory given only an assumption about causal structure. We also define analogues of twirling and swirling for an arbitrary generalized probabilistic theory and identify certain necessary conditions on a causal structure for it to be able to support a causal compatibility gap between the theory and its symmetrized version. We draw out the implications of these analyses for the question of how a lack of a shared reference frame state features into the possibility of such a gap.
We extend the process-matrix framework for defining indefinite causal orders to a broad class of generalised physical theories. We give a simple re-axiomatisation of spacetime contexts in terms of naturality over classical probes, which precisely captures non-contextual assignment together with compatibility with convexity and coarse-graining within local laboratories. Using this compositional perspective, we give a clean characterisation of theories in which abstract spacetime contexts admit a process-matrix representation, and we pin down the precise conditions (satisfied by classical theory, quantum theory, and a Boxworld-like theory) under which the supermap and process-matrix perspectives on higher-order processes coincide.
We construct finite averaging sets for twirling finite-dimensional quantum states over a broad class of symmetry transformations represented by reductive Lie groups. The averaging is defined through the Cartan decomposition of the group, with Haar-uniform integration over the compact components and an arbitrary normalized measure over the non-compact Abelian component. We show that the resulting twirling map can always be represented as a finite probabilistic mixture of unitary 1-design channels acting on irreducible sectors of the representation restricted to the maximal compact subgroup. Thus, the finite construction is determined by the compact-sector decomposition, while the non-compact Cartan component contributes only scalar sector weights. This distinction is important for implementation: no Schur transform for the full reductive group is required. Compared with standard t -design-based finite averaging, our construction generally uses fewer averaging operators, at the price of replacing local tensor-power sampling by sector-wise unitary averaging. This could be especially beneficial for simulations and quantum algorithms on higher-dimensional systems as reduction of the size of the averaging set relatively increases with dimension.
Quasiprobability representations are well-established tools in quantum information science, with applications ranging from the classical simulability of quantum computation to quantum process tomography, quantum error correction, and quantum sensing. While traditional quasiprobability representations typically employ real-valued distributions, recent developments highlight the usefulness of complex-valued ones -- most notably, via the family of Kirkwood--Dirac quasiprobability distributions. Building on the framework of Schmid et al. [Quantum 8, 1283 (2024)], we extend the analysis to encompass complex-valued quasiprobability representations that need not preserve the identity channel. Additionally, we also extend previous results to consider mappings towards infinite-dimensional spaces. We show that, for each system, every such representation can be expressed as the composition of two maps that are completely characterized by their action on states and on the identity (equivalently, on effects) for that system. Our results apply to all complex-valued quasiprobability representations of any finite-dimensional, tomographically-local generalized probabilistic theory, with finite-dimensional quantum theory serving as a paradigmatic example. In the quantum case, the maps' action on states and effects corresponds to choices of frames and dual frames for the representation. This work offers a unified mathematical framework for analyzing complex-valued quasiprobability representations in generalized probabilistic theories.