arXiv:2610.32030
Can Spontaneous Time-Translation Symmetry Breaking Be Quantized Without Explicit Branches?
Partha Nandi
Abstract
Can classically branched dynamics associated with spontaneous time-translation-symmetry breaking be quantized without explicitly retaining the branches of the Hamiltonian? We investigate this question using a reduced phase space. formulation in which the Hamiltonian is single-valued, while the critical structure of the classical Legendre map is encoded in a singular, momentum-dependent symplectic geometry. Quantization of the reduced Poisson algebra yields a deformed position-momentum commutator whose singularities determine distinct regular momentum sectors. Using the positive measure induced by the reduced symplectic structure, we identify a bounded central sector and two unbounded outer sectors. In the central sector, states with vanishing mean momentum obey a nonzero lower bound on position uncertainty, subject to the operator-domain assumptions of the representation. We further identify a possible field-theoretic connection with k-essence, where nonlinear scalar-field kinetics can produce finite-velocity degeneracies of the Legendre map. The relationship between the resulting reduced quantum description and branch-matching quantization remains unresolved and requires a comparison of the corresponding Hilbert spaces and operator domains.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether classical dynamics with a branched Hamiltonian, arising from a noninvertible momentum–velocity relation, can be quantized without explicitly retaining Hamiltonian branches. It studies the stabilized kinetic Lagrangian $L=m\dot y^2/2-\beta m^3\dot y^4/4+\beta'^2m^5\dot y^6/6-V(y)$. Using mechanical momentum $p=m\dot y$ makes the energy single-valued while transferring the Legendre-map degeneracies into the reduced bracket $\{y,p\}=1/D(p)$, where $D(p)=1-3\beta p^2+5\beta'^2p^4$. Quantization adopts $[\hat y,\hat p]=i\hbar/D(\hat p)$. When $\beta/\beta'>2\sqrt5/3$, four singular momenta $\pm p_\pm$ separate five regular intervals. The chosen positive-measure representation, using $D(p)\,dp$, retains the bounded central interval and two unbounded outer intervals. Transforming to $q=p-\beta p^3+\beta'^2p^5$ gives $\hat y=i\hbar\partial_q$. Standard derivative-operator domain analysis yields self-adjoint position extensions on the central interval but none on either outer half-line individually. Robertson’s inequality and bounded momentum support imply $\Delta y>\hbar/(2p_-)$ for the specified zero-mean-momentum states on a suitable common domain. For $\beta=2\beta'$, this becomes $\Delta y>(\hbar/2)\sqrt{5\beta/2}$. The bound is conditional, not shown optimal or attainable, and is not a universal minimal length. Excluding the other intervals is a representation choice. Global self-adjoint dynamics, sector matching, and equivalence with branch-resolved quantization remain unresolved; the differential expressions agree locally. A polynomial $k$-essence example exhibits analogous Legendre-map degeneracies, but no constrained gravitational reduction or corresponding quantum theory is established.
Error found: Section II.B incorrectly identifies ±p_+ as global ground states whenever β/β′>2√5/3, whereas they lie strictly below the static minimum only when β/β′>√(80/27), with static and moving minima degenerate at equality.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- The manuscript has 16 pages, 3 figures, and 1 table