Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.32030

Can Spontaneous Time-Translation Symmetry Breaking Be Quantized Without Explicit Branches?

Partha Nandi

hep-thgr-qcmath-phquant-phSubmitted Oct 23, 2026• Announced Oct 26, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Can classically branched dynamics associated with spontaneous time-translation-symmetry breaking be quantized without explicitly retaining the branches of the Hamiltonian? We investigate this question using a reduced phase space. formulation in which the Hamiltonian is single-valued, while the critical structure of the classical Legendre map is encoded in a singular, momentum-dependent symplectic geometry. Quantization of the reduced Poisson algebra yields a deformed position-momentum commutator whose singularities determine distinct regular momentum sectors. Using the positive measure induced by the reduced symplectic structure, we identify a bounded central sector and two unbounded outer sectors. In the central sector, states with vanishing mean momentum obey a nonzero lower bound on position uncertainty, subject to the operator-domain assumptions of the representation. We further identify a possible field-theoretic connection with k-essence, where nonlinear scalar-field kinetics can produce finite-velocity degeneracies of the Legendre map. The relationship between the resulting reduced quantum description and branch-matching quantization remains unresolved and requires a comparison of the corresponding Hilbert spaces and operator domains.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether classical dynamics with a branched Hamiltonian, arising from a noninvertible momentum–velocity relation, can be quantized without explicitly retaining Hamiltonian branches. It studies the stabilized kinetic Lagrangian $L=m\dot y^2/2-\beta m^3\dot y^4/4+\beta'^2m^5\dot y^6/6-V(y)$. Using mechanical momentum $p=m\dot y$ makes the energy single-valued while transferring the Legendre-map degeneracies into the reduced bracket $\{y,p\}=1/D(p)$, where $D(p)=1-3\beta p^2+5\beta'^2p^4$. Quantization adopts $[\hat y,\hat p]=i\hbar/D(\hat p)$. When $\beta/\beta'>2\sqrt5/3$, four singular momenta $\pm p_\pm$ separate five regular intervals. The chosen positive-measure representation, using $D(p)\,dp$, retains the bounded central interval and two unbounded outer intervals. Transforming to $q=p-\beta p^3+\beta'^2p^5$ gives $\hat y=i\hbar\partial_q$. Standard derivative-operator domain analysis yields self-adjoint position extensions on the central interval but none on either outer half-line individually. Robertson’s inequality and bounded momentum support imply $\Delta y>\hbar/(2p_-)$ for the specified zero-mean-momentum states on a suitable common domain. For $\beta=2\beta'$, this becomes $\Delta y>(\hbar/2)\sqrt{5\beta/2}$. The bound is conditional, not shown optimal or attainable, and is not a universal minimal length. Excluding the other intervals is a representation choice. Global self-adjoint dynamics, sector matching, and equivalence with branch-resolved quantization remain unresolved; the differential expressions agree locally. A polynomial $k$-essence example exhibits analogous Legendre-map degeneracies, but no constrained gravitational reduction or corresponding quantum theory is established.

Likely largely AI-generatedIncrementalMissing comparisonStrong assumptions

Error found: Section II.B incorrectly identifies ±p_+ as global ground states whenever β/β′>2√5/3, whereas they lie strictly below the static minimum only when β/β′>√(80/27), with static and moving minima degenerate at equality.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
The manuscript has 16 pages, 3 figures, and 1 table

Related papers

The classical limit of Schrödinger operators in the framework of Berezin quantization and spontaneous symmetry breaking as an emergent phenomenon

Valter Moretti, Christiaan J. F. van de Ven

The algebraic properties of a strict deformation quantization are analyzed on the classical phase space [Formula: see text]. The corresponding quantization maps enable us to take the limit for [Formula: see text] of a suitable sequence of algebraic vector states induced by [Formula: see text]-dependent eigenvectors of several quantum models, in which the sequence converges to a probability measure on [Formula: see text], defining a classical algebraic state. The observables are here represented in terms of a Berezin quantization map which associates classical observables (functions on the phase space) to quantum observables (elements of [Formula: see text] algebras) parametrized by [Formula: see text]. The existence of this classical limit is in particular proved for ground states of a wide class of Schrödinger operators, where the classical limiting state is obtained in terms of a Haar integral. The support of the classical state (a probability measure on the phase space) is included in certain orbits in [Formula: see text] depending on the symmetry of the potential. In addition, since this [Formula: see text]-algebraic approach allows for both quantum and classical theories, it is highly suitable to study the theoretical concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) as an emergent phenomenon when passing from the quantum realm to the classical world by switching off [Formula: see text]. To this end, a detailed mathematical description is outlined and it is shown how this algebraic approach sheds new light on spontaneous symmetry breaking in several physical models.

arXiv:2103.11914•International Journal of Geometric Methods in Modern Physics•Nov 30, 2021•10 citations

SYMMETRIES AND QUANTIZATION: STRUCTURE OF THE STATE SPACE

P. P. Divakaran

This paper is concerned with the relationship between the group G of all symmetries of an unconstrained dynamical system and the space of its quantum states. The chief aim is to establish the validity of the claim that "quantizing a system" means deciding what G is and determining all projective unitary representations of G. The mathematical tool suited to this purpose is the theory of central extensions of an arbitrary group G by the circle group T (and the closely related cohomology group H2 (G, T)). The fundamental structural property is that there is a universal state space [Formula: see text] embedding all states, a unitary representation space of the universal central extension [Formula: see text] of G, on which the Pontryagin dual H2 (G, T)⋆ of H2 (G, T) operates as a group of su-perselection rules, so that the superselection sectors are [Formula: see text] and observables are self-adjoint operators Vh → Vh. This leads to a classification of time-evolution operators respecting the symmetries by H2 (G, T) and a general understanding of "anomalies" as arising from a mismatch of sectors to which symmetry transformations and time-evolution refer. For the special case of a Lie group G of symmetries, [Formula: see text] of G coincides with [Formula: see text] the universal covering group, if G is semisimple. More generally, depending on whether or not G is semisimple and/or simply connected, inequivalent quantizations are of topological, algebraic or "mixed" origin; in the algebraic case, the relationship between anomalous conservation laws and invariant dynamics is explicitly given. Illustrative examples worked out include the Euclidean group E (d) and the (connected) Poincaré group P (d, 1) for arbitrary spatial dimension d and the discrete groups (Z/N)2 and Z2 appropriate for planar square crystals — in particular, the absence of "fractional" angular momentum in the plane is established and the difficulties specific to (2,1)-dimensional quantum field theories precisely formulated. The paper concludes by noting that a number of ambiguities generally supposed to affect traditional procedures of quantization resolve themselves satisfactorily in this approach. Mathematically, the paper is self-contained as far as the concepts and results are concerned; occasionally, proofs of well-known facts are reworked when they serve to illustrate the value of the symmetry point of view. The theory of universal central extensions of groups, including important special cases, is treated in detail in an appendix by M. S. Raghunathan, in view of its significance for quantization and the absence of a similar account in the literature.

Reviews in Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1994•9 citations

Notes on phase space quantization

Jukka Kiukas, PEKKA J. LAHTI, Kari Ylinen

We consider questions related to a quantization scheme in which a classical variable f:Ω\to R on a phase space Ωis associated with a semispectral measure E^f, such that the moment operators of E^f are required to be of the form Γ(f^k), with Γa suitable mapping from the set of classical variables to the set of (not necessarily bounded) operators in some Hilbert space. In particular, we investigate the situation where the map Γis implemented by the operator integral with respect to some fixed positive operator measure. The phase space Ωis first taken to be an abstract measurable space, then a locally compact unimodular group, and finally R^2, where we determine explicitly the relevant operators Γ(f^k) for certain variables f, in the case where the quantization map Γis implemented by a translation covariant positive operator measure. In addition, we consider the question under what conditions a positive operator measure is projection valued.

arXiv:quant-ph/0601009•Jan 2, 2006•1 citation

Minimal length scale in quantum mechanics from a deformation quantization perspective

Ziemowit Domański

Abstract We develop a deformation quantization approach to quantum mechanics that exhibits a nonzero minimal uncertainty in position through the modification of commutation relations for the operators of position and momentum. Deformation quantization is a method of quantizing a classical Hamiltonian system by suitably deforming the Poisson algebra of the system. The developed theory of deformation quantization is non-formal. An appropriate integral formula for the star-product is introduced, along with a suitable space of functions on which the star-product is well defined. A C*-algebra of observables and a space of states are constructed. Moreover, an operator representation in momentum space is presented. Finally, an example of states of maximal localization is given in terms of generalized Wigner functions.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Dec 1, 2024•0 citations

Phase space quantization and the operator moment problem

Jukka Kiukas, PEKKA J. LAHTI, Kari Ylinen

We consider questions related to a quantization scheme in which a classical variable f:Ω→R on a phase space Ω is associated with a (preferably unique) semispectral measure Ef, such that the moment operators of Ef are required to be of the form Γ(fk), with Γ a suitable mapping from the set of classical variables to the set of (not necessarily bounded) operators in the Hilbert space of the quantum system. In particular, we investigate the situation where the map Γ is implemented by the operator integral with respect to some fixed positive operator measure. The phase space Ω is first taken to be an abstract measurable space, then a locally compact unimodular group, and finally R2, where we determine explicitly the relevant operators Γ(fk) for certain variables f, in the case where the quantization map Γ is implemented by a translation covariant positive operator measure. In addition, we consider the question under what conditions a positive operator measure is projection valued.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 2006•22 citations

Branched Quantization

Alfred D. Shapere, Frank A. Wilczek

We propose a method for quantization of Lagrangians for which the Hamiltonian, as a function of momentum, is a branched function, possibly with cusps. Appropriate boundary conditions, which we identify, ensure unitary time evolution. In special cases a dual (canonical) transformation maps the problem into a problem of quantum mechanics on singular spaces, which we also develop. Several possible applications are indicated.

arXiv:1207.2677•Physical Review Letters•Nov 13, 2012•43 citations
Can classically branched dynamics associated with spontaneous time-translation-symmetry breaking be quantized without explicitly retaining the branches of the Hamiltonian? We investigate this question using a reduced phase space. formulation in which the Hamiltonian is single-valued, while the critical structure of the classical Legendre map is encoded in a singular, momentum-dependent symplectic geometry. Quantization of the reduced Poisson algebra yields a deformed position-momentum commutator whose singularities determine distinct regular momentum sectors. Using the positive measure induced by the reduced symplectic structure, we identify a bounded central sector and two unbounded outer sectors. In the central sector, states with vanishing mean momentum obey a nonzero lower bound on position uncertainty, subject to the operator-domain assumptions of the representation. We further identify a possible field-theoretic connection with k-essence, where nonlinear scalar-field kinetics can produce finite-velocity degeneracies of the Legendre map. The relationship between the resulting reduced quantum description and branch-matching quantization remains unresolved and requires a comparison of the corresponding Hilbert spaces and operator domains.
The paper asks whether classical dynamics with a branched Hamiltonian, arising from a noninvertible momentum–velocity relation, can be quantized without explicitly retaining Hamiltonian branches. It studies the stabilized kinetic Lagrangian L=my˙2/2−βm3y˙4/4+β′2m5y˙6/6−V(y)L=m\dot y^2/2-\beta m^3\dot y^4/4+\beta'^2m^5\dot y^6/6-V(y)L=my˙​2/2−βm3y˙​4/4+β′2m5y˙​6/6−V(y). Using mechanical momentum p=my˙p=m\dot yp=my˙​ makes the energy single-valued while transferring the Legendre-map degeneracies into the reduced bracket {y,p}=1/D(p)\{y,p\}=1/D(p){y,p}=1/D(p), where D(p)=1−3βp2+5β′2p4D(p)=1-3\beta p^2+5\beta'^2p^4D(p)=1−3βp2+5β′2p4.
Quantization adopts [y^,p^]=iℏ/D(p^)[\hat y,\hat p]=i\hbar/D(\hat p)[y^​,p^​]=iℏ/D(p^​). When β/β′>25/3\beta/\beta'>2\sqrt5/3β/β′>25​/3, four singular momenta ±p±\pm p_\pm±p±​ separate five regular intervals. The chosen positive-measure representation, using D(p) dpD(p)\,dpD(p)dp, retains the bounded central interval and two unbounded outer intervals. Transforming to q=p−βp3+β′2p5q=p-\beta p^3+\beta'^2p^5q=p−βp3+β′2p5 gives y^=iℏ∂q\hat y=i\hbar\partial_qy^​=iℏ∂q​. Standard derivative-operator domain analysis yields self-adjoint position extensions on the central interval but none on either outer half-line individually. Robertson’s inequality and bounded momentum support imply Δy>ℏ/(2p−)\Delta y>\hbar/(2p_-)Δy>ℏ/(2p−​) for the specified zero-mean-momentum states on a suitable common domain. For β=2β′\beta=2\beta'β=2β′, this becomes Δy>(ℏ/2)5β/2\Delta y>(\hbar/2)\sqrt{5\beta/2}Δy>(ℏ/2)5β/2​.
The bound is conditional, not shown optimal or attainable, and is not a universal minimal length. Excluding the other intervals is a representation choice. Global self-adjoint dynamics, sector matching, and equivalence with branch-resolved quantization remain unresolved; the differential expressions agree locally. A polynomial kkk-essence example exhibits analogous Legendre-map degeneracies, but no constrained gravitational reduction or corresponding quantum theory is established.
The algebraic properties of a strict deformation quantization are analyzed on the classical phase space [Formula: see text]. The corresponding quantization maps enable us to take the limit for [Formula: see text] of a suitable sequence of algebraic vector states induced by [Formula: see text]-dependent eigenvectors of several quantum models, in which the sequence converges to a probability measure on [Formula: see text], defining a classical algebraic state. The observables are here represented in terms of a Berezin quantization map which associates classical observables (functions on the phase space) to quantum observables (elements of [Formula: see text] algebras) parametrized by [Formula: see text]. The existence of this classical limit is in particular proved for ground states of a wide class of Schrödinger operators, where the classical limiting state is obtained in terms of a Haar integral. The support of the classical state (a probability measure on the phase space) is included in certain orbits in [Formula: see text] depending on the symmetry of the potential. In addition, since this [Formula: see text]-algebraic approach allows for both quantum and classical theories, it is highly suitable to study the theoretical concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking (SSB) as an emergent phenomenon when passing from the quantum realm to the classical world by switching off [Formula: see text]. To this end, a detailed mathematical description is outlined and it is shown how this algebraic approach sheds new light on spontaneous symmetry breaking in several physical models.
This paper is concerned with the relationship between the group G of all symmetries of an unconstrained dynamical system and the space of its quantum states. The chief aim is to establish the validity of the claim that "quantizing a system" means deciding what G is and determining all projective unitary representations of G. The mathematical tool suited to this purpose is the theory of central extensions of an arbitrary group G by the circle group T (and the closely related cohomology group H2 (G, T)). The fundamental structural property is that there is a universal state space [Formula: see text] embedding all states, a unitary representation space of the universal central extension [Formula: see text] of G, on which the Pontryagin dual H2 (G, T)⋆ of H2 (G, T) operates as a group of su-perselection rules, so that the superselection sectors are [Formula: see text] and observables are self-adjoint operators Vh → Vh. This leads to a classification of time-evolution operators respecting the symmetries by H2 (G, T) and a general understanding of "anomalies" as arising from a mismatch of sectors to which symmetry transformations and time-evolution refer. For the special case of a Lie group G of symmetries, [Formula: see text] of G coincides with [Formula: see text] the universal covering group, if G is semisimple. More generally, depending on whether or not G is semisimple and/or simply connected, inequivalent quantizations are of topological, algebraic or "mixed" origin; in the algebraic case, the relationship between anomalous conservation laws and invariant dynamics is explicitly given. Illustrative examples worked out include the Euclidean group E (d) and the (connected) Poincaré group P (d, 1) for arbitrary spatial dimension d and the discrete groups (Z/N)2 and Z2 appropriate for planar square crystals — in particular, the absence of "fractional" angular momentum in the plane is established and the difficulties specific to (2,1)-dimensional quantum field theories precisely formulated. The paper concludes by noting that a number of ambiguities generally supposed to affect traditional procedures of quantization resolve themselves satisfactorily in this approach. Mathematically, the paper is self-contained as far as the concepts and results are concerned; occasionally, proofs of well-known facts are reworked when they serve to illustrate the value of the symmetry point of view. The theory of universal central extensions of groups, including important special cases, is treated in detail in an appendix by M. S. Raghunathan, in view of its significance for quantization and the absence of a similar account in the literature.
We consider questions related to a quantization scheme in which a classical variable f:Ω\to R on a phase space Ωis associated with a semispectral measure E^f, such that the moment operators of E^f are required to be of the form Γ(f^k), with Γa suitable mapping from the set of classical variables to the set of (not necessarily bounded) operators in some Hilbert space. In particular, we investigate the situation where the map Γis implemented by the operator integral with respect to some fixed positive operator measure. The phase space Ωis first taken to be an abstract measurable space, then a locally compact unimodular group, and finally R^2, where we determine explicitly the relevant operators Γ(f^k) for certain variables f, in the case where the quantization map Γis implemented by a translation covariant positive operator measure. In addition, we consider the question under what conditions a positive operator measure is projection valued.
Abstract We develop a deformation quantization approach to quantum mechanics that exhibits a nonzero minimal uncertainty in position through the modification of commutation relations for the operators of position and momentum. Deformation quantization is a method of quantizing a classical Hamiltonian system by suitably deforming the Poisson algebra of the system. The developed theory of deformation quantization is non-formal. An appropriate integral formula for the star-product is introduced, along with a suitable space of functions on which the star-product is well defined. A C*-algebra of observables and a space of states are constructed. Moreover, an operator representation in momentum space is presented. Finally, an example of states of maximal localization is given in terms of generalized Wigner functions.
We consider questions related to a quantization scheme in which a classical variable f:Ω→R on a phase space Ω is associated with a (preferably unique) semispectral measure Ef, such that the moment operators of Ef are required to be of the form Γ(fk), with Γ a suitable mapping from the set of classical variables to the set of (not necessarily bounded) operators in the Hilbert space of the quantum system. In particular, we investigate the situation where the map Γ is implemented by the operator integral with respect to some fixed positive operator measure. The phase space Ω is first taken to be an abstract measurable space, then a locally compact unimodular group, and finally R2, where we determine explicitly the relevant operators Γ(fk) for certain variables f, in the case where the quantization map Γ is implemented by a translation covariant positive operator measure. In addition, we consider the question under what conditions a positive operator measure is projection valued.