arXiv:2610.30618
Coherence and imaginarity of qubit states under vanishing Bargmann invariants
Hao-Fan Wang, Lin Chen
Abstract
Set coherence and set imaginarity are two important quantum resources defined by sets of states. We investigate tuples of qubit states under vanishing higher-order Bargmann invariants and show that their set coherence and set imaginarity are each related to whether they contain a pair of orthogonal states. Specifically, when the relevant higher-order Bargmann invariants vanish, the tuple contains a pair of orthogonal states if and only if removing some state makes the remaining tuple incoherent. Moreover, when maximally mixed states are excluded, the same vanishing conditions imply that the tuple is imaginarity-free if and only if it contains a pair of orthogonal states. As a consequence, under these conditions, a tuple of single-qubit states has imaginarity precisely when every tuple obtained by deleting one of its states is coherent.
AI Summary
The paper asks how vanishing higher-order Bargmann invariants constrain set coherence and set imaginarity of tuples of single-qubit states. Set incoherence means simultaneous unitary diagonalizability; imaginarity-freedom means that all states can be made real by a common unitary. For $n\geq4$, under specified vanishing conditions on $\operatorname{Tr}(\rho_{\sigma(1)}\cdots\rho_{\sigma(n)})$, it proves that a tuple contains an orthogonal pair, $\rho_i\rho_j=0$, if and only if deleting some state leaves an incoherent tuple. For $n=4$, three fourth-order traces must vanish. For $n=5$, the condition uses the 12 even permutations fixing the first label; for $n\geq6$, it uses all $(n-1)!$ permutations fixing that label. Under the full permutation condition, and excluding maximally mixed states, imaginarity-freedom is also equivalent to containing an orthogonal pair. Consequently, imaginarity is equivalent both to positive overlap for every pair and to coherence of every one-state-deleted tuple. The proofs use explicit qubit matrix calculations, Bloch-vector geometry, commutator identities, and induction. In particular, set imaginarity corresponds to Bloch vectors spanning three dimensions. Examples illustrate the equivalences and show why excluding maximally mixed states is necessary for the imaginarity result. The results concern exact vanishing conditions and qubits. The discussion leaves open whether fewer invariants suffice—particularly scenarios based on alternating groups—and whether analogous coherence–imaginarity equivalences hold in higher dimensions. Although direct invariant measurements are proposed as tomography-free witnesses, no finite-precision robustness bounds are supplied.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.