We prove that for every 3-player (3-prover) game
G with value less than one, whose query distribution has the support
S={(1,0,0),(0,1,0),(0,0,1)} of hamming weight one vectors, the value of the
n-fold parallel repetition
G⊗n decays polynomially fast to zero; that is, there is a constant
c=c(G)>0 such that the value of the game
G⊗n is at most
n−c. Following the recent work of Girish, Holmgren, Mittal, Raz and Zhan (STOC 2022), our result is the missing piece that implies a similar bound for a much more general class of multiplayer games: For
every 3-player game
G over
binary questions and
arbitrary answer lengths, with value less than 1, there is a constant
c=c(G)>0 such that the value of the game
G⊗n is at most
n−c. Our proof technique is new and requires many new ideas. For example, we make use of the Level-
k inequalities from Boolean Fourier Analysis, which, to the best of our knowledge, have not been explored in this context prior to our work.
The behavior of games repeated in parallel, when played with quantumly entangled players, has received much attention in recent years. Quantum analogues of Raz's classical parallel repetition theorem have been proved for many special classes of games. However, for general entangled games no parallel repetition theorem was known. We prove that the entangled value of a two-player game G repeated n times in parallel is at most c_G*n^{-1/4}*log(n) for a constant c_G depending on G, provided that the entangled value of G is less than 1. In particular, this gives the first proof that the entangled value of a parallel repeated game must converge to 0 for all games whose entangled value is less than 1. Central to our proof is a combination of both classical and quantum correlated sampling.
In a two-player game, two cooperating but non communicating players, Alice and Bob, receive inputs taken from a probability distribution. Each of them produces an output and they win the game if they satisfy some predicate on their inputs/outputs. The entangled value
ω∗(G) of a game
G is the maximum probability that Alice and Bob can win the game if they are allowed to share an entangled state prior to receiving their inputs. The
n-fold parallel repetition
Gn of
G consists of
n instances of
G where Alice and Bob receive all the inputs at the same time and must produce all the outputs at the same time. They win
Gn if they win each instance of
G. Recently, there has been a series of works showing parallel repetition with exponential decay for projection games [DSV13], games on the uniform distribution [CS14] and for free games, i.e. games on a product distribution [JPY13]. This article is meant to be a follow up of [CS14], where we improve and simplify several parts of our previous paper. Our main result is that for any free game
G with value
ω∗(G)=1−ε, we have
ω∗(Gn)≤(1−ε2)Ω(log(l)n) where
l is the size of the output set of the game. This result improves on both the results in [JPY13] and [CS14]. The framework we use can also be extended to free projection games. We show that for a free projection game
G with value
ω∗(G)=1−ε, we have
ω∗(Gn)≤(1−ε)Ω(n).
We study the behavior of the entangled value of two-player one-round projection games under parallel repetition. We show that for any projection game G of entangled value 1 - εc)k), for some universal constant c ≥ 1. Previously parallel repetition with an exponential decay in k was only known for the case of XOR and unique games. To prove the theorem we extend an analytical framework recently introduced by Dinur and Steurer for the study of the classical value of projection games under parallel repetition. Our proof, as theirs, relies on the introduction of a simple relaxation of the entangled value that is perfectly multiplicative. The main technical component of the proof consists in showing that the relaxed value remains tightly connected to the entangled value, thereby establishing the parallel repetition theorem. More generally, we obtain results on the behavior of the entangled value under products of arbitrary (not necessarily identical) projection games. Relating our relaxed value to the entangled value is done by giving an algorithm for converting a relaxed variant of quantum strategies that we call “vector quantum strategy” to a quantum strategy. The algorithm is considerably simpler in case the bipartite distribution of questions in the game has good expansion properties. When this is not the case, rounding relies on a quantum analogue of Holenstein's correlated sampling lemma which may be of independent interest. Our “quantum correlated sampling lemma” generalizes results of van Dam and Hayden on universal embezzlement to the following approximate scenario: two isolated parties, given classical descriptions of arbitrary bipartite states |ψ〉, |φ〉 respectively such that |ψ〉 ≈ |φ〉, are able to locally generate a joint entangled state|Ψ〉 ≈ |ψ〉 ≈ |φ〉 using an initial entangled state that is independent of their inputs.
A two-player game is played by cooperating players who are not allowed to communicate. A referee asks the players questions sampled from some known distribution and decides whether they win or not based on a known predicate of the questions and the players' answers. The parallel repetition of the game is the game in which the referee samples n independent pairs of questions and sends the corresponding questions to the players simultaneously. If the players cannot win the original game with probability better than
(1−ϵ), what's the best they can do in the repeated game? We improve earlier results of [R. Raz, SIAM J. Comput., 27 (1998), pp. 763–803] and [T. Holenstein, Theory Comput., 5 (2009), pp. 141–172], who showed that the players cannot win all copies in the repeated game with probability better than
(1−ϵ/2)Ω(nϵ2/c) (here c is the length of the answers in the game), in the following ways: (i) We show that the probability of winning all copies is
(1−ϵ/2)Ω(ϵn) as long as the game is a “projection game,” the type of game most commonly used in hardness of approximation results. (ii) We prove a concentration bound for parallel repetition (of general games) showing that for any constant
0<δ<ϵ, the probability that the players win a
(1−ϵ+δ) fraction of the games in the parallel repetition is at most
exp(−Ωϵ(δ3n/c)) (here the constant may depend on
ϵ); our result has applications to testing Bell inequalities, since it implies that the parallel repetition of the CHSH game can be used to get an experiment that has a very large classical versus quantum gap. Our first bound is independent of the answer length and has a better dependence on
ϵ. By the recent work of Raz [Proceedings of the
49th Annual IEEE Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science, 2008, pp. 369–373], this bound is tight. Our bound gives a generic way to improve the soundness of a probabilistically checkable proof (PCP), in a way that is independent of the answer length of the PCP. Using it, for every k, one can convert any q query PCP with answer length c, size
sc, and soundness
(1−ϵ) into a two-query PCP with answer length
ck, size
O(ck(2s)k), and soundness
(1−ϵ/2q)Ω(ϵk/q). Another consequence of our bound is that the unique games conjecture of Khot [Proceedings of the
34th Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing, 2002, pp. 767–775] can now be shown to be equivalent to the following a priori weaker conjecture: There is an unbounded increasing function
f:R+→R+ such that for every
ϵ>0, there exists an alphabet size
M(ϵ) for which it is NP-hard to distinguish a unique game with alphabet size M in which a
(1−ϵ2) fraction of the constraints can be satisfied from one in which a
(1−ϵf(1/ϵ)) fraction of the constraints can be satisfied.