arXiv:2610.30266
Discrete time liquids
Zuo Wang, Paul M. Schindler, Marin Bukov, Marios H. Michael
Abstract
Discrete time crystals exhibit robust subharmonic oscillations, spontaneously breaking the discrete time-translation symmetry of a periodic drive. Since their emergence, the question of whether other types of temporal many-body order can exist has attracted considerable attention. Here we identify discrete time liquids -- a new form of spatiotemporal order characterized by short-range temporal coherence as a result of time-solitons. We study a two-dimensional spin system coupled to a finite-temperature cavity, whose fluctuations provide a noisy, approximately periodic drive with only finite temporal coherence. Remarkably, the spins nevertheless form a metastable state with robust period-doubled dynamics over an extended parameter regime. Unlike a time crystal, this state has only finite temporal coherence: individual trajectories stochastically switch between the two symmetry-related temporal configurations of the period-doubled response. We identify these switches as time-solitons: topological defects in temporal order that preserve local period doubling while destroying long-range temporal coherence, thereby producing the time liquid state. We propose a minimal model which reproduces the distribution of temporal correlations of the many-body system, suggesting a general description of the time liquid as a time crystal with a finite density of time-solitons. Because these solitons can occur at arbitrary times, ensemble averaging restores continuous time-translation symmetry, raising the intriguing possibility that discrete time liquids can exist in thermal equilibrium.
AI Summary
Can a many-body system sustain subharmonic dynamics when its effective drive has only finite temporal coherence? This paper studies a two-dimensional classical Ising spin lattice with a transverse field, both modulated out of phase by a thermally fluctuating, damped harmonic oscillator. There is no imposed periodic drive. Numerical simulations use $100\times100$ spins, $10^4$ oscillator periods and typically 100 noise realizations. At intermediate noise temperatures, the spins exhibit metastable period doubling; weaker noise leaves approximately free precession, while stronger noise destroys the response. When the oscillator coherence time $\tau_{\rm cav}=2/\gamma$ is short, trajectories repeatedly switch between the two subharmonic phases while retaining local period doubling until spatial order decays. These switches are termed time-solitons, and the resulting finite-coherence regime a discrete time liquid. A stochastic sign-switching model, with an exponential decay envelope, reproduces the distribution of integrated single-trajectory responses after matching two measured timescales. It gives $\tau_{\rm ens}^{-1}=2n_{\rm sol}+\tau_{\rm th}^{-1}$; numerically, $\tau_{\rm ens}\simeq\tau_{\rm cav}$ when $\tau_{\rm cav}\ll\tau_{\rm th}$. The demonstrated regime is classical and prethermal, not an equilibrium phase. Spin backaction is omitted from the main calculations; supplementary tests show that it reshapes the drive, but its effect on the regime diagram remains unresolved. Regime boundaries use operational thresholds, with acknowledged cutoff sensitivity rather than established sharp transitions. Experimental implementations require engineering modulation of both interaction and field. Quantum realizations, universality classes and equilibrium time liquids remain proposed directions.
Error found: The claim that ensemble averaging restores continuous time-translation symmetry is not established: the demonstrated metastable process retains absolute-time dependence through its decaying envelope. The reported ordering window keeps T_bath/T_0 fixed with T_0 proportional to L^2, so it does not establish a noise-induced ordered regime at fixed physical bath temperature in the thermodynamic limit.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 8 pages main + 9 pages supplement, 4 figures main + 10 figures supplement