Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.30071

Inaccessibility of the Cosmological Singularity to Quantum Probes

Vishnulal Cheriyodathillathu, Saurya Das, Soumen Basak, Tanmay Patil

gr-qchep-thquant-phSubmitted Oct 21, 2026• Announced Oct 22, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We propose an operational resolution of the FLRW big bang singularity using quantum probes satisfying a curvature coupled Klein-Gordon equation. Applying the Madelung-Bohm decomposition of a Klein-Gordon field on a classical near-singularity FLRW background, we show that the induced conformal geometry renders curvature invariants finite and makes past directed causal geodesics complete. The classical big bang surface is therefore inaccessible to this class of quantum probes in finite effective proper time, while the underlying FLRW spacetime remains singular.

AI Summary

Can quantum probes reach the classical FLRW big-bang singularity? This paper studies an operational, probe-dependent notion of singularity avoidance without modifying the background geometry. It considers homogeneous Klein–Gordon test fields with curvature couplings $\xi R+\eta\ell_P^2K$, where $K$ is the background Kretschmann scalar and $\eta>0$, on a near-singularity FLRW branch $a(t)\propto t^q$, $0<q\leq1$. A Madelung–Bohm decomposition defines phase-flow trajectories and an effective metric $\tilde g_{\mu\nu}=\Omega^2g_{\mu\nu}$, with $\Omega^2=\mathcal M^2/m^2$. For a selected asymptotic solution, the dominant $K\propto t^{-4}$ coupling gives field amplitude $\mathcal R\propto t^{1-3q/2}$, phase proportional to $\pm1/t$, and $\Omega^2\propto t^{-4}$. Nonzero conserved phase flux ensures $\mathcal M^2>0$ in the homogeneous sector. More generally, for $\Omega^2\propto t^{-n}$, the effective curvature scalars are finite and both timelike proper-time and null affine-parameter integrals toward $t=0$ diverge when $n\geq2$. The selected branch therefore places the classical singular surface at an infinite effective distance, with $\tilde a\to\infty$, rather than producing a classical bounce. The conclusion is restricted to the specified coupling, homogeneous nonzero-flux probes, and selected asymptotic branch; it does not establish positivity for arbitrary inhomogeneous fields. The background remains singular. Backreaction is neglected: rescaling the field suppresses its stress tensor without changing the effective metric on any fixed cutoff region, but does not guarantee uniformly negligible backreaction for one fixed nonzero probe as $t\to0$.

Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsOverclaims

Error found: The abstract omits that the effective geometry is established for selected homogeneous Klein–Gordon configurations with nonzero conserved phase flux, rather than arbitrary quantum probes. The abstract leaves implicit the positive Kretschmann coupling, selected asymptotic branch, and decelerating power-law background on which the demonstrated regularity and completeness depend.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
5 pages

Related papers

Quantum resolution of the Schwarzschild singularity

Vishnulal Cheriyodathillathu, Tanmay Patil, Saurya Das +1 more

We revisit the Schwarzschild singularity in a semiclassical setting where the background geometry is classical and quantum effects enter through Bohmian (quantal) trajectories associated with a Klein Gordon wave packet. Using the Madelung-Bohm decomposition of the Klein Gordon wavefunction, we show that the quantum-modified motion is equivalent to geodesic motion in an effective metric conformally related to Schwarzschild, with a conformal factor fixed by the wavefunction amplitude. Solving the wavefunction equation near $r\to 0$ determines this factor and yields finite curvature invariants, in suitable coordinates the interior extends smoothly and the effective spacetime is geodesically complete. This suggests that quantum dynamics on a fixed classical background can regularize the Schwarzschild singularity without a full theory of quantum gravity.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2605.13508•May 14, 2026

Singularity Resolution in Quantum Cosmology via Page-Wootters Formalism

Vishal, Malay K. Nandy

We investigate the problem of classical big bang singularity in a plane-symmetric Bianchi type-I universe within the Wheeler-DeWitt (WDW) framework of quantum gravity. To address the problem of time, we employ the Page-Wootters formalism, which provides a relational notion of dynamics by conditioning the global state on a clock subsystem. Using Misner variables, the WDW equation assumes a Klein-Gordon (KG) type form. Its general solution is constructed as a Gaussian superposition of momentum eigenstates, resulting in an entangled global state between the clock and the remaining subsystem. Within this relational framework, we construct conditional states and obtain the corresponding probability density consistent with the KG-type inner product. The resulting conditional probability density vanishes in the limit of zero volume for all clock values, indicating quantum resolution of the classical singularity. We further show that positivity of the probability density imposes constraints on the admissible clock values, which depend on the parameters of the Gaussian wavepacket. These results highlight the essential role of quantum correlations in the emergence of relational dynamics, and demonstrate that the Page-Wootters formalism provides a consistent and nonsingular probabilistic description of quantum cosmology.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2605.06093•May 8, 2026

Consistent probabilities in perfect fluid quantum universes

Clécio R. Bom, Nelson Pinto-Neto, Grasiele Santos

Recently it has been claimed that the Wheeler--DeWitt quantization of gravity is unable to avoid cosmological singularities. However, in order to make this assertion, one must specify the underlying interpretation of quantum mechanics which has been adopted. For instance, several nonsingular models were obtained in Wheeler--DeWitt quantum cosmology in the framework of the de Broglie--Bohm quantum theory. Conversely, there are specific situations where the singularity cannot be avoided in the framework of the consistent histories approach to quantum mechanics. In these specific situations, the matter content is described by a scalar field, and the Wheeler--DeWitt equation looks like a Klein--Gordon equation. The aim of this work is to study a possible singular behavior of quantum cosmological models in which the matter content is described by a hydrodynamical perfect fluid, where the resulting wave equation is a genuine Schr\"odinger equation. In this case, it is shown that the conclusions of the consistent histories and the de Broglie--Bohm approaches coincide in the quantum cosmological models where the curvature of the spatial sections is not positive definite, namely, that the cosmological singularities are eliminated. In the case of positive spatial curvature, the family of histories is no longer consistent, and no conclusion can be given in this framework.

arXiv:1308.5210•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jan 21, 2014•1 citation

A Model for Singularity-Free Spacetime and Emergent Gravity

Low, Dunstan

General relativity predicts spacetime singularities where curvature diverges, while quantummechanics describes a probabilistic reality. We propose a model that unifies these domains bypositing that spacetime curvature is an emergent property of quantum state reduction. Themodel is based on a Collapse-Curvature Correspondence: R = −8πGρC , where the Ricciscalar R is proportional to the local collapse density ρC , defined as the rate of quantum-to-classical transitions. We argue that in causally isolated regions—such as black hole coresor the pre-Big Bang state—no measurement-induced collapse can occur, forcing ρC = 0 andconsequently R = 0. This naturally resolves curvature singularities without requiring quantumgravity. The framework reinterprets gravity as the geometric record of quantum actualizationand time as a procedural variable emerging from collapse progression, dτ = k dC. The modelis falsifiable through its unique predictions for experiments like BMV/QGEM, which shoulddetect no gravity-mediated entanglement prior to collapse.

•Nov 8, 2025•0 citations

A reasonable resolution for spacetime singularities and the origin of the quantum world

Haixin Cao

It is argued that the meaning of spacetime singularities, such as Big Bang cosmological or black hole ones, is nothing else than indicating that the physical world behaves in the causal or predictable way not to be the truly basic manifestation. But rather, this is only an emergent phenomena arising through that unknown fundamental laws, underlying the behavior of the physical world in the way without being in nature understood in term of the predictability, are no longer revealed significantly and thus hidden appropriately. If the causally physical world is emergent rather than being fundamental, what is the nature of the physical world? and how could the physical world behaving in the causal or predictable way be emerged from? In this paper, we would like to answer these two questions based on studying the behavior of an absolutely physical entity. Moreover, we show that the quantum world can be understood as an intermediate stage, in which physical effects originated fundamentally from are taken into account, between the fundamental and emergent pictures.

•Sep 8, 2016•0 citations

Entangled quantum clocks as operational probes of spacetime curvature

Ivana Đorđević, Aleksandra Gočanin, Dragoljub Gočanin

Building on the framework developed by Perche [Phys. Rev. D 106, 025018 (2022)], we study two localized nonrelativistic quantum particles propagating along timelike geodesics in a curved spacetime background. Each particle is coupled to a quantum clock that operationally records the time spent in a prescribed spatial region. We compute the covariance of the resulting time observables for separable and entangled two-particle states, comparing flat and curved backgrounds. We then reformulate the protocol as a Bell-like experiment and show that the Bell parameter can acquire a curvature-induced correction. In particular, a protocol calibrated to saturate the classical bound in flat spacetime can be driven above this bound in curved spacetime for entangled states. We focus on two-dimensional curved backgrounds in which the local tidal term induces an effective harmonic potential in the Fermi-frame description. Our results show that spacetime curvature can modify operationally defined quantum correlations and suggest entangled quantum clocks as probes of spacetime curvature.

quant-pharXiv:2607.05715•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 8, 2026•0 citations
We propose an operational resolution of the FLRW big bang singularity using quantum probes satisfying a curvature coupled Klein-Gordon equation. Applying the Madelung-Bohm decomposition of a Klein-Gordon field on a classical near-singularity FLRW background, we show that the induced conformal geometry renders curvature invariants finite and makes past directed causal geodesics complete. The classical big bang surface is therefore inaccessible to this class of quantum probes in finite effective proper time, while the underlying FLRW spacetime remains singular.
Can quantum probes reach the classical FLRW big-bang singularity? This paper studies an operational, probe-dependent notion of singularity avoidance without modifying the background geometry. It considers homogeneous Klein–Gordon test fields with curvature couplings ξR+ηℓP2K\xi R+\eta\ell_P^2KξR+ηℓP2​K, where KKK is the background Kretschmann scalar and η>0\eta>0η>0, on a near-singularity FLRW branch a(t)∝tqa(t)\propto t^qa(t)∝tq, 0<q≤10<q\leq10<q≤1.
A Madelung–Bohm decomposition defines phase-flow trajectories and an effective metric g~μν=Ω2gμν\tilde g_{\mu\nu}=\Omega^2g_{\mu\nu}g~​μν​=Ω2gμν​, with Ω2=M2/m2\Omega^2=\mathcal M^2/m^2Ω2=M2/m2. For a selected asymptotic solution, the dominant K∝t−4K\propto t^{-4}K∝t−4 coupling gives field amplitude R∝t1−3q/2\mathcal R\propto t^{1-3q/2}R∝t1−3q/2, phase proportional to ±1/t\pm1/t±1/t, and Ω2∝t−4\Omega^2\propto t^{-4}Ω2∝t−4. Nonzero conserved phase flux ensures M2>0\mathcal M^2>0M2>0 in the homogeneous sector. More generally, for Ω2∝t−n\Omega^2\propto t^{-n}Ω2∝t−n, the effective curvature scalars are finite and both timelike proper-time and null affine-parameter integrals toward t=0t=0t=0 diverge when n≥2n\geq2n≥2. The selected branch therefore places the classical singular surface at an infinite effective distance, with a~→∞\tilde a\to\inftya~→∞, rather than producing a classical bounce.
The conclusion is restricted to the specified coupling, homogeneous nonzero-flux probes, and selected asymptotic branch; it does not establish positivity for arbitrary inhomogeneous fields. The background remains singular. Backreaction is neglected: rescaling the field suppresses its stress tensor without changing the effective metric on any fixed cutoff region, but does not guarantee uniformly negligible backreaction for one fixed nonzero probe as t→0t\to0t→0.
We revisit the Schwarzschild singularity in a semiclassical setting where the background geometry is classical and quantum effects enter through Bohmian (quantal) trajectories associated with a Klein Gordon wave packet. Using the Madelung-Bohm decomposition of the Klein Gordon wavefunction, we show that the quantum-modified motion is equivalent to geodesic motion in an effective metric conformally related to Schwarzschild, with a conformal factor fixed by the wavefunction amplitude. Solving the wavefunction equation near r→0r\to 0r→0 determines this factor and yields finite curvature invariants, in suitable coordinates the interior extends smoothly and the effective spacetime is geodesically complete. This suggests that quantum dynamics on a fixed classical background can regularize the Schwarzschild singularity without a full theory of quantum gravity.
We investigate the problem of classical big bang singularity in a plane-symmetric Bianchi type-I universe within the Wheeler-DeWitt (WDW) framework of quantum gravity. To address the problem of time, we employ the Page-Wootters formalism, which provides a relational notion of dynamics by conditioning the global state on a clock subsystem. Using Misner variables, the WDW equation assumes a Klein-Gordon (KG) type form. Its general solution is constructed as a Gaussian superposition of momentum eigenstates, resulting in an entangled global state between the clock and the remaining subsystem. Within this relational framework, we construct conditional states and obtain the corresponding probability density consistent with the KG-type inner product. The resulting conditional probability density vanishes in the limit of zero volume for all clock values, indicating quantum resolution of the classical singularity. We further show that positivity of the probability density imposes constraints on the admissible clock values, which depend on the parameters of the Gaussian wavepacket. These results highlight the essential role of quantum correlations in the emergence of relational dynamics, and demonstrate that the Page-Wootters formalism provides a consistent and nonsingular probabilistic description of quantum cosmology.
Recently it has been claimed that the Wheeler--DeWitt quantization of gravity is unable to avoid cosmological singularities. However, in order to make this assertion, one must specify the underlying interpretation of quantum mechanics which has been adopted. For instance, several nonsingular models were obtained in Wheeler--DeWitt quantum cosmology in the framework of the de Broglie--Bohm quantum theory. Conversely, there are specific situations where the singularity cannot be avoided in the framework of the consistent histories approach to quantum mechanics. In these specific situations, the matter content is described by a scalar field, and the Wheeler--DeWitt equation looks like a Klein--Gordon equation. The aim of this work is to study a possible singular behavior of quantum cosmological models in which the matter content is described by a hydrodynamical perfect fluid, where the resulting wave equation is a genuine Schr\"odinger equation. In this case, it is shown that the conclusions of the consistent histories and the de Broglie--Bohm approaches coincide in the quantum cosmological models where the curvature of the spatial sections is not positive definite, namely, that the cosmological singularities are eliminated. In the case of positive spatial curvature, the family of histories is no longer consistent, and no conclusion can be given in this framework.
General relativity predicts spacetime singularities where curvature diverges, while quantummechanics describes a probabilistic reality. We propose a model that unifies these domains bypositing that spacetime curvature is an emergent property of quantum state reduction. Themodel is based on a Collapse-Curvature Correspondence: R = −8πGρC , where the Ricciscalar R is proportional to the local collapse density ρC , defined as the rate of quantum-to-classical transitions. We argue that in causally isolated regions—such as black hole coresor the pre-Big Bang state—no measurement-induced collapse can occur, forcing ρC = 0 andconsequently R = 0. This naturally resolves curvature singularities without requiring quantumgravity. The framework reinterprets gravity as the geometric record of quantum actualizationand time as a procedural variable emerging from collapse progression, dτ = k dC. The modelis falsifiable through its unique predictions for experiments like BMV/QGEM, which shoulddetect no gravity-mediated entanglement prior to collapse.
It is argued that the meaning of spacetime singularities, such as Big Bang cosmological or black hole ones, is nothing else than indicating that the physical world behaves in the causal or predictable way not to be the truly basic manifestation. But rather, this is only an emergent phenomena arising through that unknown fundamental laws, underlying the behavior of the physical world in the way without being in nature understood in term of the predictability, are no longer revealed significantly and thus hidden appropriately. If the causally physical world is emergent rather than being fundamental, what is the nature of the physical world? and how could the physical world behaving in the causal or predictable way be emerged from? In this paper, we would like to answer these two questions based on studying the behavior of an absolutely physical entity. Moreover, we show that the quantum world can be understood as an intermediate stage, in which physical effects originated fundamentally from are taken into account, between the fundamental and emergent pictures.
Building on the framework developed by Perche [Phys. Rev. D 106, 025018 (2022)], we study two localized nonrelativistic quantum particles propagating along timelike geodesics in a curved spacetime background. Each particle is coupled to a quantum clock that operationally records the time spent in a prescribed spatial region. We compute the covariance of the resulting time observables for separable and entangled two-particle states, comparing flat and curved backgrounds. We then reformulate the protocol as a Bell-like experiment and show that the Bell parameter can acquire a curvature-induced correction. In particular, a protocol calibrated to saturate the classical bound in flat spacetime can be driven above this bound in curved spacetime for entangled states. We focus on two-dimensional curved backgrounds in which the local tidal term induces an effective harmonic potential in the Fermi-frame description. Our results show that spacetime curvature can modify operationally defined quantum correlations and suggest entangled quantum clocks as probes of spacetime curvature.