Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.29397

The Lévy wave packet and fractional uncertainty relations

Zi-Xuan Li, Xiao-Dong Li, Towe Wang

math-phquant-phSubmitted Oct 21, 2026• Announced Oct 22, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This work revisits the debate on fractional uncertainty relations that arose a decade ago and tries to settle it. After a careful study of the position-momentum uncertainty product of the Lévy wave packet, a novel lower bound is proposed for uncertainty relations in fractional quantum mechanics. This bound is nearly linear in the Lévy index and is satisfied by exact, calculable solutions available in the literature.

AI Summary

The paper revisits a disputed position–momentum uncertainty relation in fractional quantum mechanics, where the kinetic energy is proportional to $|p|^\alpha$, with $1<\alpha\leq2$. It examines whether the proposed bound $\langle|\Delta x|^\mu\rangle^{1/\mu}\langle|\Delta p|^\mu\rangle^{1/\mu}\geq\hbar/(2\alpha)^{1/\mu}$ holds for Lévy wave packets. For the initial-time wave packet, analytical expansions near $\alpha=1$ extend a previously identified boundary counterexample into the allowed region $\alpha>1$. The calculation identifies an invalid estimate in the original derivation. Expansions near $\alpha=2$ and numerical integration across the interval characterize the product $\Pi_L$ as $\mu\to\alpha^-$: it interpolates almost linearly between $\hbar/\pi$ and $\hbar/2$. Numerical results show violations of the original bound throughout the interior interval. A proposed replacement starts with the endpoint interpolation $\Pi_1=\hbar[2+(\pi-2)(\alpha-1)]/(2\pi)$. This also slightly exceeds the wave-packet product near $\alpha=2$. Adding $0.079(\alpha-1)(\alpha-2)(\alpha-1.94)$ inside the brackets gives a refined candidate bound that remains below the computed wave-packet values, with a reported maximum relative discrepancy of approximately $0.01\%$, versus $0.4\%$ for the linear interpolation. Numerical tests of three infinite-square-well states and the delta-well bound state yield products above the proposed bound. The replacement is supported by wave-packet calculations and selected examples, not a proof for arbitrary states. Stated open issues include deriving a first-principles bound, testing additional potentials, and experimental verification in fractional-dynamics simulators.

Some signs of AI-generated textOverclaimsIncrementalStrong assumptionsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The proposed universal uncertainty bound is inferred from a Lévy-packet family and selected stationary states without an argument establishing a lower bound over all admissible states. The linear uncertainty inequality (newfur1) is violated near alpha = 2 by the paper's own Lévy packet, as the paper explicitly acknowledges. The cubic expression (newfur3) approximates the Lévy-packet uncertainty product, but its reported numerical accuracy does not establish a state-independent inequality. Admissible Gaussian initial states violate both proposed lower bounds for alpha sufficiently close to 1 from above. The epsilon coefficient in (Hup) is inconsistent with the exact Gaussian uncertainty product at alpha = 2.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
9 pages, 4 figures

Related papers

Uncertainty Relations for Nonsimultaneous Measurements

Jean-Marc Lévy-Leblond

The usual Heisenberg uncertainty relations are generalized to the case of nonsimultaneous measurements of position and momentum. The product of the corresponding uncertainties is bounded from below by a quantity depending on the dynamics of the system (the potential), and which may be lower than ħ/2 and even vanish. The case of two successive measurements of momentum and position is also treated, and one recovers the standard phenomenon of spreading of the wave packet. Whereas the case of an arbitrary potential can only be treated to lowest orders in the lime delay, a complete solution is given for the harmonic oscillator.

American Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 1972•4 citations

A Minimal Uncertainty Product for One Dimensional Semiclassical Wave Packets

George A. Hagedorn

Although real, normalized Gaussian wave packets minimize the product of position and momentum uncertainties, generic complex normalized Gaussian wave packets do not. We prove they minimize an alternative product of uncertainties that correspond to variables that are phase space rotations of position and momentum.

arXiv:1301.5956•Proceedings of symposia in pure mathematics•Jan 1, 2013•3 citations

Comment on “Quantum reciprocity relations for fluctuations of position and momentum”

Iwo Białynicki‐Birula

The authors of this paper [M. Pandit et al., Phys. Rev. A 100, 012131 (2019)] proposed an alternative formulation of the uncertainty relation in quantum mechanics in terms of the Lipschitz constants. They evaluated these constants in various cases and decided that the product of the square roots of Lipschitz constants for position and momentum probability distributions is bounded below by $0.3/\ensuremath{\hbar}$. In this comment, I invalidate this claim by giving an example of wave functions for which the value of the product of the Lipschitz constants for position and momentum does not obey this bound and tends to zero.

Physical Review A•Oct 28, 2019•1 citation

Uncertainty Relations: Curiosities and Inconsistencies

Krzysztof Urbanowski

Analyzing general uncertainty relations one can find that there can exist such pairs of non-commuting observables A and B and such vectors that the lower bound for the product of standard deviations ΔA and ΔB calculated for these vectors is zero: ΔA·ΔB≥0. Here we discuss examples of such cases and some other inconsistencies which can be found performing a rigorous analysis of the uncertainty relations in some special cases. As an illustration of such cases matrices (2×2) and (3×3) and the position–momentum uncertainty relation for a quantum particle in the box are considered. The status of the uncertainty relation in PT–symmetric quantum theory and the problems associated with it are also studied.

arXiv:2010.08339•Symmetry•Oct 6, 2020•3 citations

On fractional uncertainty: a dyadic approach

Hugo Aimar, P. G. Bolcatto, Ivana Gómez

The use of Haar wavelet analysis, instead of classical trigonometric analysis, provides inequalities which can be regarded as Heisenberg-type inequalities associated to fractional order quantum mechanics. The aim of this paper is to introduce and prove some of these lower order uncertainty estimates.

Applicable Analysis•Jun 21, 2019•1 citation

On Fractional Schrödinger Equation

P. Rozmej, Bartosz Bandrowski

In the note, recent efforts to derive fractional quantum mechanics are recalled.Some applications of a fractional approach to the Schrödinger equation are discussed as well.

Computational Methods in Science and Technology•Jan 1, 2010•29 citations
This work revisits the debate on fractional uncertainty relations that arose a decade ago and tries to settle it. After a careful study of the position-momentum uncertainty product of the Lévy wave packet, a novel lower bound is proposed for uncertainty relations in fractional quantum mechanics. This bound is nearly linear in the Lévy index and is satisfied by exact, calculable solutions available in the literature.
The paper revisits a disputed position–momentum uncertainty relation in fractional quantum mechanics, where the kinetic energy is proportional to ∣p∣α|p|^\alpha∣p∣α, with 1<α≤21<\alpha\leq21<α≤2. It examines whether the proposed bound ⟨∣Δx∣μ⟩1/μ⟨∣Δp∣μ⟩1/μ≥ℏ/(2α)1/μ\langle|\Delta x|^\mu\rangle^{1/\mu}\langle|\Delta p|^\mu\rangle^{1/\mu}\geq\hbar/(2\alpha)^{1/\mu}⟨∣Δx∣μ⟩1/μ⟨∣Δp∣μ⟩1/μ≥ℏ/(2α)1/μ holds for Lévy wave packets.
For the initial-time wave packet, analytical expansions near α=1\alpha=1α=1 extend a previously identified boundary counterexample into the allowed region α>1\alpha>1α>1. The calculation identifies an invalid estimate in the original derivation. Expansions near α=2\alpha=2α=2 and numerical integration across the interval characterize the product ΠL\Pi_LΠL​ as μ→α−\mu\to\alpha^-μ→α−: it interpolates almost linearly between ℏ/π\hbar/\piℏ/π and ℏ/2\hbar/2ℏ/2. Numerical results show violations of the original bound throughout the interior interval.
A proposed replacement starts with the endpoint interpolation Π1=ℏ[2+(π−2)(α−1)]/(2π)\Pi_1=\hbar[2+(\pi-2)(\alpha-1)]/(2\pi)Π1​=ℏ[2+(π−2)(α−1)]/(2π). This also slightly exceeds the wave-packet product near α=2\alpha=2α=2. Adding 0.079(α−1)(α−2)(α−1.94)0.079(\alpha-1)(\alpha-2)(\alpha-1.94)0.079(α−1)(α−2)(α−1.94) inside the brackets gives a refined candidate bound that remains below the computed wave-packet values, with a reported maximum relative discrepancy of approximately 0.01%0.01\%0.01%, versus 0.4%0.4\%0.4% for the linear interpolation. Numerical tests of three infinite-square-well states and the delta-well bound state yield products above the proposed bound.
The replacement is supported by wave-packet calculations and selected examples, not a proof for arbitrary states. Stated open issues include deriving a first-principles bound, testing additional potentials, and experimental verification in fractional-dynamics simulators.
The usual Heisenberg uncertainty relations are generalized to the case of nonsimultaneous measurements of position and momentum. The product of the corresponding uncertainties is bounded from below by a quantity depending on the dynamics of the system (the potential), and which may be lower than ħ/2 and even vanish. The case of two successive measurements of momentum and position is also treated, and one recovers the standard phenomenon of spreading of the wave packet. Whereas the case of an arbitrary potential can only be treated to lowest orders in the lime delay, a complete solution is given for the harmonic oscillator.
The authors of this paper [M. Pandit et al., Phys. Rev. A 100, 012131 (2019)] proposed an alternative formulation of the uncertainty relation in quantum mechanics in terms of the Lipschitz constants. They evaluated these constants in various cases and decided that the product of the square roots of Lipschitz constants for position and momentum probability distributions is bounded below by $0.3/\ensuremath{\hbar}$. In this comment, I invalidate this claim by giving an example of wave functions for which the value of the product of the Lipschitz constants for position and momentum does not obey this bound and tends to zero.
Analyzing general uncertainty relations one can find that there can exist such pairs of non-commuting observables A and B and such vectors that the lower bound for the product of standard deviations ΔA and ΔB calculated for these vectors is zero: ΔA·ΔB≥0. Here we discuss examples of such cases and some other inconsistencies which can be found performing a rigorous analysis of the uncertainty relations in some special cases. As an illustration of such cases matrices (2×2) and (3×3) and the position–momentum uncertainty relation for a quantum particle in the box are considered. The status of the uncertainty relation in PT–symmetric quantum theory and the problems associated with it are also studied.