arXiv:2610.28852
The Prevalence of Straight Shots in Control Space for Reaching Optimal Quantum Performance
Yiyou Chen, Gabriele Herr, Herschel Rabitz
Abstract
Gradient-based algorithms are often applied to identify an optimal control for maximizing a quantum objective functional by following a steepest ascent path to the top of the control landscape. In contrast, this paper explores straight shots through control space where movement along such a path corresponds to a less demanding monotonic complete climb up the landscape for the optimal objective value. Existing studies of control landscapes have revealed the presence of straight shots, but identifying them required computationally intensive stochastic methods. In this paper, we introduce a non-stochastic straight-shot search algorithm (STSA) that identifies a large class of straight shots. We apply STSA to numerically generate more than 10,000 distinct straight-shot optimization paths and analyze their statistical distribution for each of the objectives of (i) state-to-state transitions, (ii) general observables, and (iii) unitary transformation generation. The results show a decrease in the nearest-neighbor distances among straight shots as the sample size increases, suggesting their prevalence in control space. We further conjecture that the starting locations of the straight-shot pathways on a landscape level set may form connected neighborhoods, motivating future investigation into their underlying topological structure. The present paper focuses on the use of STSA for locating massive numbers of straight solutions. However, the STSA is not a high-efficiency algorithm in its present form, but the discovered prevalence of control straight shots leaves open future advances to accelerate the discovery of straight shots as optimal controls.
AI Summary
The paper asks how to locate straight paths through quantum-control space along which an objective increases monotonically from a prescribed low-fidelity level set to near-optimal performance. Unlike straight steepest-ascent trajectories, these paths need only remain monotonic; their fixed direction is the objective gradient at the starting control. A deterministic straight-shot search algorithm (STSA) adjusts the starting control within the bottom level set using D-MORPH. Each iteration evaluates the first maximum reached along the initial-gradient ray, then uses endpoint gradients and a starting-point Hessian to increase this maximum. The projected update guarantees nondecreasing endpoint performance where the ray-maximum objective is differentiable. The construction covers state transfer, observable maximization, and unitary synthesis. The reported numerical results use a four-level closed system with 400 time intervals and state-transfer fidelities $0.01$ and $0.99$ as the bottom and top thresholds. STSA found qualifying paths in all 10,000 runs; 33 runs encountered discontinuities requiring careful numerical treatment. Mean starting-control displacement was $1.31$, versus $2.93$ for a random-walk search, and mean straight-shot length was $5.15$. Decreasing nearest-neighbor distances with increasing sample size motivate conjectures about prevalence and connected neighborhoods, rather than establish these properties. STSA remains substantially more expensive than ordinary steepest ascent. Global success is not guaranteed, particularly near nondifferentiable ray maxima. Similar behavior is reported for tighter thresholds and the other two objectives, but their numerical results are not displayed; the detailed evidence is confined to one four-level model.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's per-objective sample counts and statistical analyses are not documented by the displayed results, which cover 10,000 state-transfer runs and leave the other objectives' results unshown. Successful searches from a restricted initialization family for one four-level system do not establish how prevalent straight-shot starting points are on the bottom level set. The concluding definition omits the initial-gradient direction restriction imposed by the formal definition and used by STSA. Decreasing nearest-neighbor distances with increasing sample size occur even for thin or disconnected sampling supports, so the reported trend does not establish prevalence or connected neighborhoods. Approximately Gaussian nearest-neighbor-distance histograms do not establish that the sampled controls are relatively uniformly distributed.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 14 pages, 10 figures