Quantum Simulation of the Static Yukawa Model via Effective Particles on a Trapped-Ion Quantum Simulator
Qingfeng Wang, Christopher G. Yale, Edward C. Tortorici, Brian K. McFarland, Daniel Lobser, Melissa C. Revelle, Andrew J. Landahl, Susan M. Clark, Peter J. Love
quant-phSubmitted Oct 20, 2026• Announced Oct 21, 2026• 2 citations
Trapped-ion, neutral-atom, and circuit QED quantum computers naturally enable coupled qubit-boson simulations. Boson-fermion interactions arise in quantum field theory, where renormalization is required to obtain finite results. We study one of the simplest examples of a coupled fermion-boson system, the static Yukawa model, on the QSCOUT trapped-ion system. We use similarity renormalization to express the same physics in terms of effective particles described by different values of the renormalization parameter $s$. This enables us to map data taken in the window of bosonic occupancy that is experimentally accessible to larger occupancies of distinct effective particles. We use this to study strongly coupled, high-occupancy regimes despite limited readout ranges. Using a trapped-ion qubit-boson device on Sandia National Laboratories' QSCOUT platform, we demonstrate the time evolution of the static Yukawa model.
AI Summary
The paper investigates whether similarity-renormalized effective particles can bring bosonic occupations within a trapped-ion simulator’s readout range while allowing recovery of the original model’s occupation. The setting is the exactly solvable static Yukawa model: a single bosonic mode coupled to a conserved fermion number.
In the one-fermion sector, the renormalization group procedure for effective particles reduces the coupling to $g_s=g e^{-s}$, using units $E_{\mathrm b}=E_{\mathrm f}=E_{\mathrm I}=1$. The evolution is compiled exactly into a phase, rotation, and displacement; for occupation measurements, only the displacement is needed. Experiments use a shared motional mode and two ancilla ions on QSCOUT. Occupations are reconstructed by fitting probe-qubit blue-sideband oscillations, with bootstrap error bars quantifying shot noise.
Time, coupling, and flow-parameter scans are compared with the vacuum-initialized prediction $\langle N\rangle_{\mathcal H}=4g^2e^{-2s}\sin^2(t/2)$. Readout becomes unreliable around 10–15 quanta. At $g=3$ and $t=\pi$, increasing $s$ lowers the predicted occupation from 36 into the readable range; measurements track the prediction for $s\gtrsim0.4$. Bare occupations follow through multiplication by $e^{2s}$. Examples yielding 64 and 100 are reinterpretations of an in-range measurement, not independent measurements at stronger couplings.
The stated limitations include amplified recovery uncertainty, a motional-heating floor, systematic hardware offsets, and the absence of computational advantage for this solvable benchmark. Generalization requires implementable renormalized dynamics and tractable observable recovery, neither established here for models with nonclosed operator flows or several running couplings.
Little sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptions
Error found: The paper interprets vacuum-initialized evolutions under different renormalized Hamiltonians as effective-particle descriptions of the same evolving state, but these correspond to different initial states in the original frame; consequently, its zero-physical-boson interpretation at infinite flow does not describe the original bare-vacuum quench.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
Trapped-ion, neutral-atom, and circuit QED quantum computers naturally enable coupled qubit-boson simulations. Boson-fermion interactions arise in quantum field theory, where renormalization is required to obtain finite results. We study one of the simplest examples of a coupled fermion-boson system, the static Yukawa model, on the QSCOUT trapped-ion system. We use similarity renormalization to express the same physics in terms of effective particles described by different values of the renormalization parameter s. This enables us to map data taken in the window of bosonic occupancy that is experimentally accessible to larger occupancies of distinct effective particles. We use this to study strongly coupled, high-occupancy regimes despite limited readout ranges. Using a trapped-ion qubit-boson device on Sandia National Laboratories' QSCOUT platform, we demonstrate the time evolution of the static Yukawa model.
The paper investigates whether similarity-renormalized effective particles can bring bosonic occupations within a trapped-ion simulator’s readout range while allowing recovery of the original model’s occupation. The setting is the exactly solvable static Yukawa model: a single bosonic mode coupled to a conserved fermion number.
In the one-fermion sector, the renormalization group procedure for effective particles reduces the coupling to gs=ge−s, using units Eb=Ef=EI=1. The evolution is compiled exactly into a phase, rotation, and displacement; for occupation measurements, only the displacement is needed. Experiments use a shared motional mode and two ancilla ions on QSCOUT. Occupations are reconstructed by fitting probe-qubit blue-sideband oscillations, with bootstrap error bars quantifying shot noise.
Time, coupling, and flow-parameter scans are compared with the vacuum-initialized prediction ⟨N⟩H=4g2e−2ssin2(t/2). Readout becomes unreliable around 10–15 quanta. At g=3 and t=π, increasing s lowers the predicted occupation from 36 into the readable range; measurements track the prediction for s≳0.4. Bare occupations follow through multiplication by e2s. Examples yielding 64 and 100 are reinterpretations of an in-range measurement, not independent measurements at stronger couplings.
The stated limitations include amplified recovery uncertainty, a motional-heating floor, systematic hardware offsets, and the absence of computational advantage for this solvable benchmark. Generalization requires implementable renormalized dynamics and tractable observable recovery, neither established here for models with nonclosed operator flows or several running couplings.
Real-time quantum simulation of field theories offers access to scattering and decay dynamics, circumventing the limitations of Euclidean lattice methods. However, representing bosonic fields on qubits requires a finite-dimensional approximation and can entail costly multi-qubit operations. Hybrid qubit-qumode architectures avoid this by encoding bosonic fields directly in oscillators. We formulate scattering in the (1+1)-dimensional Yukawa theory for such a device, with staggered fermions on qubits and the scalar on qumodes. Trapped ions are a natural candidate, with the fermions on the internal states of the ions and the scalar on their collective motion, so that the Yukawa coupling becomes a native spin-dependent displacement. Emulating the device with tensor networks, we study the decay of a single scalar particle and fermion-antifermion scattering around the resonance region, using observables that can be measured on the device natively. We compare the results with those obtained using lattice perturbation theory. The emulation is able to resolve corrections beyond the Dyson summation of the one-loop self-energy.
Universal digital quantum computers are able to approximate any Hamiltonian evolution as a digital quantum circuit consisting of discrete time steps. Strongly interacting physics models, for example in high-energy physics or materials science, make this a challenging task for near-term devices as they place a high demand on the quantum resources required [1]. One alternative is analog quantum simulation where the native evolution of a quantum system can be tailored to mimic that of the model of interest. While more efficient at specific problems, there are limits on the types of evolution available and on the observables that can be measured. In this conference paper we present first results towards unifying these two concepts in a trapped-ion experiment. Trapped atomic ions are one of the most advanced experimental platforms for both analog quantum simulation and digital quantum computing. Typically, the internal spin degrees of freedom are used qubits or for the simulation of spin models. The harmonic oscillator modes given by the motion of the ions in the trap are only employed transiently to create quantum gates or spin-spin interactions. However, these motional modes constitute a large Hilbert space themselves and present a bosonic degree of freedom, which is costly to model with qubits. Many systems of interest, for example Lattice gauge theories, require both spin and boson degrees of freedom. It was recently shown that they can be encoded more efficiently using the harmonic oscillator modes directly [2].
Key to solving many societally relevant problems in materials science, quantum chemistry, and nuclear physics is understanding their fundamental microscopic quantum behavior. All of these problems can be phrased as fermionic (e.g., electrons, quarks) and bosonic particles (e.g., lattice vibrations, photons) interacting with each other. However, solving these systems of strongly interacting fermions and bosons is out of reach for classical computers and also non-error-corrected qubit-only quantum computers. In this paper, we introduce a hybrid qubit and bosonic-oscillator quantum-simulation framework, which is so efficient that it could simulate some of these strongly correlated problems even without error correction. Specifically, we leverage the available universal bosonic gate set with O ( 1 ) operations per gate as a function of the bosonic cutoff. This enables our framework to provide exact decompositions of higher-order fermion-boson interactions, including notoriously challenging terms such as ( 2 + 1 ) D gauge theories. We show how to compile dynamics, ancilla-free partial error detection, nonlocal observable measurements, and ground-state energy estimation using both qubit-boson variational quantum eigensolvers and quantum signal processing. We introduce a “post-qubit quantum advantage” experiment which is out of reach for both near-term qubit-only quantum computers and classical computers. We justify this proposal by estimating bosonic gate fidelities through high–boson-occupation Lindblad simulation and by comparing to qubit-only algorithms. For the latter, we develop a new qubit-based algorithm for simulating a beam splitter with a boson number cutoff N max , which scales as O ˜ ( N max 1 + o ( 1 ) ) , asymptotically outperforming previously known qubit methods. However, to reach the same circuit fidelity as qubit-boson hardware with 99.9% per-gate fidelity, a qubit quantum computer using the best-known method would still need fidelities of at least 99.9999%, likely requiring substantial error correction. Our framework can be used in superconducting hardware, which we focus on, as well as trapped-ion and neutral-atom hardware. This work establishes digital hybrid qubit-boson quantum simulation as a promising and advantageous method for solving the many challenging, strongly correlated, fermion-boson models of relevance to science and technology.
Abstract Elementary quantum mechanics proposes that a closed physical system consistently evolves in a reversible manner. However, control and readout necessitate the coupling of the quantum system to the external environment, subjecting it to relaxation and decoherence. Consequently, system-environment interactions are indispensable for simulating physically significant theories. A broad spectrum of physical systems in condensed-matter and high-energy physics, vibrational spectroscopy, and circuit and cavity QED necessitates the incorporation of bosonic degrees of freedom, such as phonons, photons, and gluons, into optimized fermion algorithms for near-future quantum simulations. In particular, when a quantum system is surrounded by an external environment, its basic physics can usually be simplified to a spin or fermionic system interacting with bosonic modes. Nevertheless, troublesome factors such as the magnitude of the bosonic degrees of freedom typically complicate the direct quantum simulation of these interacting models, necessitating the consideration of a comprehensive plan. This strategy should specifically include a suitable fermion/boson-to-qubit mapping scheme to encode sufficiently large yet manageable bosonic modes, and a method for truncating and/or downfolding the Hamiltonian to the defined subspace for performing an approximate but highly accurate simulation, guided by rigorous error analysis. In this pedagogical tutorial review, we aim to provide such an exhaustive strategy, focusing on encoding and simulating certain bosonic-related model Hamiltonians, inclusive of their static properties and time evolutions. Specifically, we emphasize two aspects: (1) the discussion of recently developed quantum algorithms for these interacting models and the construction of effective Hamiltonians, and (2) a detailed analysis regarding a tightened error bound for truncating the bosonic modes for a class of fermion-boson interacting Hamiltonians.
We analyze the efficiency of quantum simulations of fermionic and bosonic models in trapped ions. In particular, we study the optimal time of entangling gates and the required number of total elementary gates. Furthermore, we exemplify these estimations in the light of quantum simulations of quantum field theories, condensed-matter physics, and quantum chemistry. Finally, we show that trapped-ion technologies are a suitable platform for implementing quantum simulations involving interacting fermionic and bosonic modes, paving the way for overcoming classical computers in the near future. PACS Codes: 03.67.Ac, 03.67.Lx, 37.10.Ty.
The quantum simulation of magnetism in trapped-ion systems makes use of the crystal vibrations to mediate pairwise interactions between spins, which are encoded in the internal electronic states of the ions, and measured in experiments that probe the real-time dynamics. These interactions can be accounted for by a long-wavelength relativistic theory, where the phonons are described by a coarse-grained Klein-Gordon field ϕ(x) locally coupled to the spins that acts as a carrier, leading to an analogue of pion-mediated Yukawa interactions. In the vicinity of a structural transition of the ion crystal, one must go beyond the Klein-Gordon fields, and include additional λϕ4 terms responsible for phonon-phonon scattering. This leads to quantum effects that can be expressed by Feynman loop integrals that modify the range of the Yukawa-type spin interactions; an effect that could be used to probe the underlying fixed point of this quantum field theory (QFT). Unfortunately, the rigidity of the trapped-ion crystal makes it challenging to observe genuine quantum effects, such as the flow of the critical point with the quartic coupling λ . We hereby show that thermal effects, which can be controlled by laser cooling, can unveil this flow through the appearance of thermal masses in interacting QFTs. We perform self-consistent calculations that resum certain Feynman diagrams and, additionally, go beyond mean-field theory to predict how measurements on the trapped-ion spin system can probe key properties of the λϕ4 QFT.