arXiv:2610.28415
Chaos and scrambling in anisotropic Dicke and Rabi models
Long-Jie Li, Li-Li Gao, Zi-Cheng Liu, Zi-Min Li, Murray T. Batchelor
Abstract
Identifying the quantum signatures of classical chaos remains a central question in quantum physics, and quantum scrambling provides a new perspective on this correspondence. We study two distinct limits of the same model to examine how the correspondence between chaos and scrambling changes across different regimes. The thermodynamic-limit anisotropic Dicke model exhibits a close correspondence between chaos and scrambling, whereas this correspondence breaks down in the large-frequency-ratio limit of the anisotropic Rabi model (ARM). The contrasting chaotic behavior in the two limits originates from the different numbers of classical degrees of freedom, whereas their similar scrambling behavior stems from eigenstate delocalization. This implies that, in the large-frequency-ratio limit, eigenstate delocalization alone is insufficient to qualify the ARM as a classically chaotic model. This finding suggests that identifying chaos in quantum systems requires jointly considering the classical degrees of freedom and eigenstate delocalization.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether scrambling diagnoses chaos in two semiclassical limits of anisotropic light–matter models: the Dicke model as $N\to\infty$ and the single-qubit Rabi model as $\eta=\Delta/\omega\to\infty$. It compares their adiabatic energy surfaces, densities of states, classical dynamics, parity-resolved spectral statistics, thermal out-of-time-order correlators (OTOCs), and bare-basis eigenstate participation ratios. The limits share the lowest adiabatic surface and superradiant-transition boundary, but retain different classical degrees of freedom. The Dicke model has two canonical pairs and supports mixed regular–chaotic energy shells; adiabatic qubit elimination leaves the Rabi model with one canonical pair and no chaotic sea. Analytical density-of-states calculations, compared with exact diagonalization, give logarithmic saddle-point divergences for Rabi, versus divergences in the first derivative for Dicke. Dicke spectra exhibit GOE-like correlations, while Rabi spectra do not: one Rabi sample has mean spacing ratio $0.654$, above the GOE value $0.536$, yet its spacing distribution contains a prominent regular-ladder peak. At matched reduced temperature $\beta N\Delta=1$, long-time photon-number OTOC signals increase strongly in both models and track thermally averaged participation-ratio maps. Thus enhanced OTOCs and bare-basis delocalization need not imply classical-like chaos. The plateau is expressed as an eigenvector functional under a nonresonance assumption. The conclusions concern these specific limits, basis, and probe. The participation-ratio connection is established through matching numerical patterns, not a general quantitative relation. Exact resonances require additional plateau terms, and near-degenerate gaps can delay dephasing beyond finite observation times.
Central claim may not hold: The attribution of similar scrambling to eigenstate delocalization exceeds the demonstrated map correlation, because participation ratios do not determine the probe matrix elements governing the OTOC plateau. Although the limiting classical dynamics is analytically supported, the full coupling-plane correspondence involving scrambling and delocalization is demonstrated only at finite parameters without an established limiting extrapolation.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 12 pages, 7 figures