arXiv:2610.27856 · Optical Switching and Networking
Atmospheric channel model for QKD over satellite megaconstellations
Sergio Gándara Gándara, Javier Vecino-Peñas, Ana Fernández-Vilas, Manuel Fernández-Veiga, Rebeca P. Díaz-Redondo
Abstract
Atmospheric turbulence and channel loss represent the primary limiting factors in ground-to-satellite quantum communication systems, yet their joint impact remains insufficiently characterized across diverse operational conditions. In this work, we develop a comprehensive and open atmospheric channel model for quantum optical links along ground-to-satellite paths, integrating altitude-dependent molecular and aerosol absorptions. The model is validated with available data from missions such as Micius and Hispasat, including a secondary viability assessment for a hypothetical Starlink-based quantum communication network, where we evaluate the predicted channel behavior in terms of single-photon transmittance and power balance, alongside the channel capacity of the link for uplink and downlink exclusively. Our comparative analysis demonstrates the ability of our channel model to predict real data under simple atmospheric behavior assumptions, which offer practical guidelines for the design and optimization of future quantum satellite missions.
AI Summary
The paper addresses how simplified atmospheric-channel modeling can estimate the feasibility of satellite QKD across orbital altitudes, wavelengths, and link geometries. It combines piecewise pressure and temperature profiles, a pressure-dependent refractive index, empirical absorption spectra, Rayleigh scattering, Fresnel transmission, Gaussian-beam propagation, and an optical link budget. Applications include Micius-like LEO links, the proposed Hispasat GEO mission, and a hypothetical Starlink-based quantum network. Model predictions are compared with published Micius loss estimates and with Hispasat design requirements. For Micius, predicted atmospheric losses are approximately $3$ dB, versus reported values of $3$–$8$ dB; predicted atmospheric transmittance is $0.46$–$0.50$, versus $0.16$–$0.50$. Total predicted losses are approximately $27$–$30$ dB with Micius-specific parameters, compared with reported losses of $31$–$39$ dB. Link-capacity estimates apply the pure-loss PLOB bound, $C(T)=-\log_2(1-T)$. NetSquid simulations of an E91 entanglement-distribution scenario at $500$ km altitude and $810$ nm, using 200 repetitions per sampled geometry, yield reported secure key rates of $0.20$–$0.35$ bit/s and QBERs of approximately $0.75$–$1.08\%$. The stated emphasis is simplicity rather than detailed atmospheric fidelity. Simulations assume unobstructed weather conditions, neglect or simplify pointing and tracking errors and other loss mechanisms, use a fixed depolarization rate of $8$ Hz, and hold satellite positions static during key-block transmission. The paper acknowledges optimistic loss predictions and says precise agreement requires additional modeled effects. The Starlink assessment assumes Micius-like optical hardware rather than existing quantum infrastructure.
Central claim may not hold: The claimed mission validation exceeds the evidence: Hispasat is compared with project requirements rather than observations, while the Micius comparison shows appreciable discrepancies and is acknowledged to lack precise predictive accuracy. The advertised comprehensive turbulence and altitude-dependent aerosol treatment is not established by the supplied model, which lacks a specified turbulence propagation calculation and an identifiable aerosol extinction profile. The surface-index formula gives n = 1.015 at 1000 nm, overestimating ordinary atmospheric-air refractivity by approximately 56 times. The Rayleigh quantity defined by integrating cross-section times molecular number density is dimensionless optical depth, but is subsequently used as an inverse-length attenuation coefficient. The explanation that downlink atmospheric absorption is weaker because the atmosphere occurs at the end of the path conflicts with reciprocal absorption through the same atmospheric column.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 11 pages, 11 figures