Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.27462

Systematic Truncated Wigner Approximation for Open Spin Systems Reveals Long-Range Order Far from Equilibrium

Igor Timofeev, Dawid A. Hryniuk, Marzena H. Szymańska

quant-phcond-mat.quant-gasSubmitted Oct 20, 2026• Announced Oct 21, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Long-range interactions can protect dissipative order against fluctuations, but determining when they do so in two dimensions remains out of reach for existing many-body methods. We develop a continuous SU(2)-covariant truncated-Wigner framework that maps the problem onto stochastic dynamics with one Bloch sphere per site. Derived systematically from the exact Stratonovich-Weyl evolution of the Lindblad equation, it generates both drift and reservoir noise for arbitrary spin $S$. Benchmarks against exact and tensor-network calculations validate its description of non-equilibrium dynamics and steady states. Applied to 400-site two-dimensional dissipative anisotropic XY lattices, our method reveals physics missed by mean-field and perturbative approaches: vortex-antivortex proliferation destroys the predicted staggered-XY phase for nearest-neighbour coupling, whereas algebraically decaying interactions stabilize an extended $\mathbb{Z}_2$-ordered phase. We obtain the first beyond-mean-field steady-state phase diagram of the long-range interacting model, revealing reentrant loss of order at strong coupling and closure of the ordered region beyond $α\approx 3.5$. Our new method provides a scalable route to strongly correlated driven-dissipative systems with long-range interactions, higher-dimensional geometries, spin-boson couplings, and spins beyond one half, relevant to modern experiments with magnetic atoms and polar molecules in optical lattices and tweezer arrays.

AI Summary

The paper addresses how to simulate correlated steady states of two-dimensional dissipative spin lattices with long-range interactions, and whether those interactions stabilize order absent for nearest-neighbour coupling. It derives a continuous SU(2)-covariant truncated-Wigner approximation from the Stratonovich–Weyl representation of Lindblad dynamics. Expanding the spin star product through second order in $\epsilon=(2S+1)^{-1}$ gives Hamiltonian and dissipative drift plus reservoir diffusion, represented by stochastic trajectories with two coordinates per spin. The construction accommodates arbitrary $S$; stochastic sampling requires positive-semidefinite diffusion. Benchmarks include exact dissipative Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick dynamics and published iPEPO results for the nearest-neighbour anisotropic XY model. Reported steady-state magnetization errors are approximately $2\%$ for $S=10$, $15\%$ for $S=1/2$ in the single-spin benchmark, and up to $10\%$ relative to iPEPO for the lattice. On $20\times20$ lattices, nearest-neighbour simulations show exponentially decaying correlations and vortex–antivortex proliferation, consistent with suppression of mean-field staggered-XY order. For interactions $r^{-\alpha}$, a finite-system correlation map indicates an extended $\mathbb{Z}_2$-ordered region: at $\alpha=3$, it spans roughly $0.5\lesssim J/\Gamma\lesssim2$, with reentrant disorder at stronger coupling. No ordered region is resolved above $\alpha\approx3.5$. The approximation improves with increasing spin and cannot exactly represent negative steady-state Wigner distributions through positive trajectory densities. Signed initial-state sampling becomes impractical for large lattices. The long-range phase map uses 30 trajectories per point at finite time and size; the reported correlation crossover is plausibly affected by finite size.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptionsMissing comparison

Central claim may not hold: The claimed long-range ordered phase is inferred from a normalized collective correlator on one 20×20 lattice without finite-size scaling establishing a nonzero thermodynamic order parameter. The abstract's closure near α≈3.5 is stronger than the body's finding that no ordered region is resolved above that exponent at the accessible system size. The reported algebraically decaying correlations do not establish the nonzero asymptotic correlation limit required for true long-range order. The spin-1/2 long-range phase boundaries lack independent benchmarking or truncation-error control, despite appreciable discrepancies in the supplied benchmarks.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Path integral approach to the truncated Wigner approximation of driven-dissipative spins

Viktoria Noel, Michael Fleischhauer, Igor Lesanovsky

Phase-space approaches such as the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) provide an efficient semiclassical framework for performing approximate simulations of the dynamics of open quantum many-body systems outside the reach of exact numerical methods but beyond the mean-field level. For bosonic systems, TWA is known to be equivalent to a Keldysh path-integral formulation truncated at second order in the so-called quantum fluctuations. This semiclassical approach provides an alternative transparent route towards approximate stochastic equations of motion, which can be efficiently solved. Here we establish the corresponding path-integral formulation for interacting open spin-$1/2$ systems using the continuous $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ phase space. We show, in particular, that a consistent treatment of dissipation requires correctly mapping operator products onto the curved spin phase space, leading to stochastic equations that coincide with those obtained from the continuous TWA formulation and thus reproduce the exact dynamics of a single dissipative spin. Our results provide a unified field-theoretic foundation for the TWA to dissipative spin dynamics and offer a systematic starting point for extensions beyond the semiclassical approximation.

quant-pharXiv:2607.26029•Jul 29, 2026•6 citations

Vortex formation and dynamics in two-dimensional driven-dissipative condensates

F. Hebenstreit

We investigate the real-time evolution of lattice bosons in two spatial dimensions whose dynamics is governed by a Markovian quantum master equation. We employ the Wigner-Weyl phase space quantization and derive the functional integral for open quantum many-body systems that determines the time evolution of the Wigner function. Using the truncated Wigner approximation, in which quantum fluctuations are only taken into account in the initial state whereas the dynamics is governed by classical evolution equations, we study the buildup of long-range correlations due to the action of non-Hermitean quantum jump operators that constitute a mechanism for dissipative cooling. Starting from an initially disordered state corresponding to a vortex condensate, the dissipative process results in the annihilation of vortex-antivortex pairs and the establishment of quasi-long-range order at late times. We observe that a finite vortex density survives the cooling process, which disagrees with the analytically constructed vortex-free Bose-Einstein condensate at asymptotic times. This indicates that quantum fluctuations beyond the truncated Wigner approximation need to be included to fully capture the physics of dissipative Bose-Einstein condensation.

arXiv:1607.06923•Physical Review A•Dec 16, 2016•4 citations

Hybrid discrete-continuous truncated Wigner approximation for driven, dissipative spin systems

Christopher D. Mink, David Petrosyan, Michael Fleischhauer

We present a systematic approach for the semiclassical treatment of many-body dynamics of interacting, open spin systems. Our approach overcomes some of the shortcomings of the recently developed discrete truncated Wigner approximation (DTWA) based on Monte Carlo sampling in a discrete phase space that improves the classical treatment by accounting for lowest-order quantum fluctuations. We provide a rigorous derivation of the DTWA by embedding it in a continuous phase space, thereby introducing a hybrid discrete-continuous truncated Wigner approximation . We derive a set of operator-differential mappings that yield an exact equation of motion (EOM) for the continuous SU(2) Wigner function of spins. The standard DTWA is then recovered by a systematic neglection of specific terms in this exact EOM. The hybrid approach permits us to determine the validity conditions and to gain a detailed understanding of the quality of the approximation, paving the way for systematic improvements. Furthermore, we show that the continuous embedding allows for a straightforward extension of the method to open spin systems subject to dephasing, losses, and incoherent drive, while preserving the key advantages of the discrete approach, such as a positive definite Wigner distribution of typical initial states. We derive exact stochastic differential equations for processes which cannot be described by the standard DTWA due to the presence of nonclassical noise. We illustrate our approach by applying it to the dissipative dynamics of Rydberg excitation of one-dimensional arrays of laser-driven atoms and compare it to exact results for small systems.

arXiv:2203.17120•Physical Review Research•Nov 28, 2022•33 citations

Discrete-phase-space method for driven-dissipative dynamics of strongly interacting bosons in optical lattices

Kazuma Nagao, Ippei Danshita, Seiji Yunoki

We develop a discrete truncated Wigner method to analyze the real-time evolution of dissipative $\mathrm{SU}(\mathcal{N})$ spin systems coupled with a Markovian environment. This semiclassical approach is not only numerically efficient but also particularly capable of accurately capturing local loss processes due to its local linearity in the dynamical equations. We apply the method to a state-of-the-art experiment involving an analog quantum simulator of a three-dimensional dissipative Bose-Hubbard model in a strongly interacting regime. Our numerical results show good agreement with experimental data, specifically capturing the continuous quantum Zeno effect in the dynamics subjected to a gradual change of the ratio between the hopping amplitude and the onsite interaction across the superfluid Mott insulator crossover. Furthermore, we present comparative analyses with the continuous truncated Wigner method, derived as an effective Fokker-Planck equation for $\mathrm{SU}(\mathcal{N})$ classical spin variables, showing that the discrete method outperforms the continuous one in simulating the long-time dynamics of SU(2) and SU(3) spin models. The discrete phase-space framework offers a versatile and powerful tool for exploring a wide range of open quantum many-body systems in dimensions higher than one dimension, where numerically exact methods are impractical due to the exponential growth of the Hilbert-space dimension.

arXiv:2307.16170•Physical Review A•Dec 11, 2024•6 citations

Dynamics of correlations in two-dimensional quantum spin models with long-range interactions: a phase-space Monte-Carlo study

Johannes Schachenmayer, Alexander Pikovski, A M Rey

Interacting quantum spin models are remarkably useful for describing different types of physical, chemical, and biological systems.Significant understanding of their equilibrium properties has been achieved to date, especially for the case of spin models with short-range couplings.However, progress toward the development of a comparable understanding in long-range interacting models, in particular out-of-equilibrium, remains limited.In a recent work, we proposed a semiclassical numerical method to study spin models, the discrete truncated Wigner approximation (DTWA), and demonstrated its capability to correctly capture the dynamics of one-and two-point correlations in one-dimensional (1D) systems.Here we go one step forward and use the DTWA method to study the dynamics of correlations in two-dimensional (2D) systems with many spins and different types of long-range couplings, in regimes where other numerical methods are generally unreliable.We compute spatial and time-dependent correlations for spin-couplings that decay with distance as a power-law and determine the velocity at which correlations propagate through the system.Sharp changes in the behavior of those velocities are found as a function of the power-law decay exponent.Our predictions are relevant for a broad range of systems including solid state materials, atom-photon systems and ultracold gases of polar molecules, trapped ions, Rydberg, and magnetic atoms.We validate the DTWA predictions for small 2D systems and 1D systems, but ultimately, in the spirt of quantum simulation, experiments will be needed to confirm our predictions for large 2D systems.

arXiv:1501.06593•New Journal of Physics•Jun 10, 2015•67 citations

Phase-space methods for simulating the dissipative many-body dynamics of collective spin systems

Julian Huber, Peter Kirton, Peter Rabl

We describe an efficient numerical method for simulating the dynamics and steady states of collective spin systems in the presence of dephasing and decay. The method is based on the Schwinger boson representation of spin operators and uses an extension of the truncated Wigner approximation to map the exact open system dynamics onto stochastic differential equations for the corresponding phase space distribution. This approach is most effective in the limit of very large spin quantum numbers, where exact numerical simulations and other approximation methods are no longer applicable. We benchmark this numerical technique for known superradiant decay and spin-squeezing processes and illustrate its application for the simulation of non-equilibrium phase transitions in dissipative spin lattice models.

arXiv:2011.10049•SciPost Physics•Feb 22, 2021•48 citations
Long-range interactions can protect dissipative order against fluctuations, but determining when they do so in two dimensions remains out of reach for existing many-body methods. We develop a continuous SU(2)-covariant truncated-Wigner framework that maps the problem onto stochastic dynamics with one Bloch sphere per site. Derived systematically from the exact Stratonovich-Weyl evolution of the Lindblad equation, it generates both drift and reservoir noise for arbitrary spin SSS. Benchmarks against exact and tensor-network calculations validate its description of non-equilibrium dynamics and steady states. Applied to 400-site two-dimensional dissipative anisotropic XY lattices, our method reveals physics missed by mean-field and perturbative approaches: vortex-antivortex proliferation destroys the predicted staggered-XY phase for nearest-neighbour coupling, whereas algebraically decaying interactions stabilize an extended Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-ordered phase. We obtain the first beyond-mean-field steady-state phase diagram of the long-range interacting model, revealing reentrant loss of order at strong coupling and closure of the ordered region beyond α≈3.5α\approx 3.5α≈3.5. Our new method provides a scalable route to strongly correlated driven-dissipative systems with long-range interactions, higher-dimensional geometries, spin-boson couplings, and spins beyond one half, relevant to modern experiments with magnetic atoms and polar molecules in optical lattices and tweezer arrays.
The paper addresses how to simulate correlated steady states of two-dimensional dissipative spin lattices with long-range interactions, and whether those interactions stabilize order absent for nearest-neighbour coupling.
It derives a continuous SU(2)-covariant truncated-Wigner approximation from the Stratonovich–Weyl representation of Lindblad dynamics. Expanding the spin star product through second order in ϵ=(2S+1)−1\epsilon=(2S+1)^{-1}ϵ=(2S+1)−1 gives Hamiltonian and dissipative drift plus reservoir diffusion, represented by stochastic trajectories with two coordinates per spin. The construction accommodates arbitrary SSS; stochastic sampling requires positive-semidefinite diffusion.
Benchmarks include exact dissipative Lipkin–Meshkov–Glick dynamics and published iPEPO results for the nearest-neighbour anisotropic XY model. Reported steady-state magnetization errors are approximately 2%2\%2% for S=10S=10S=10, 15%15\%15% for S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2 in the single-spin benchmark, and up to 10%10\%10% relative to iPEPO for the lattice. On 20×2020\times2020×20 lattices, nearest-neighbour simulations show exponentially decaying correlations and vortex–antivortex proliferation, consistent with suppression of mean-field staggered-XY order. For interactions r−αr^{-\alpha}r−α, a finite-system correlation map indicates an extended Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​-ordered region: at α=3\alpha=3α=3, it spans roughly 0.5≲J/Γ≲20.5\lesssim J/\Gamma\lesssim20.5≲J/Γ≲2, with reentrant disorder at stronger coupling. No ordered region is resolved above α≈3.5\alpha\approx3.5α≈3.5.
The approximation improves with increasing spin and cannot exactly represent negative steady-state Wigner distributions through positive trajectory densities. Signed initial-state sampling becomes impractical for large lattices. The long-range phase map uses 30 trajectories per point at finite time and size; the reported correlation crossover is plausibly affected by finite size.
Phase-space approaches such as the truncated Wigner approximation (TWA) provide an efficient semiclassical framework for performing approximate simulations of the dynamics of open quantum many-body systems outside the reach of exact numerical methods but beyond the mean-field level. For bosonic systems, TWA is known to be equivalent to a Keldysh path-integral formulation truncated at second order in the so-called quantum fluctuations. This semiclassical approach provides an alternative transparent route towards approximate stochastic equations of motion, which can be efficiently solved. Here we establish the corresponding path-integral formulation for interacting open spin-1/21/21/2 systems using the continuous SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2)SU(2) phase space. We show, in particular, that a consistent treatment of dissipation requires correctly mapping operator products onto the curved spin phase space, leading to stochastic equations that coincide with those obtained from the continuous TWA formulation and thus reproduce the exact dynamics of a single dissipative spin. Our results provide a unified field-theoretic foundation for the TWA to dissipative spin dynamics and offer a systematic starting point for extensions beyond the semiclassical approximation.
We investigate the real-time evolution of lattice bosons in two spatial dimensions whose dynamics is governed by a Markovian quantum master equation. We employ the Wigner-Weyl phase space quantization and derive the functional integral for open quantum many-body systems that determines the time evolution of the Wigner function. Using the truncated Wigner approximation, in which quantum fluctuations are only taken into account in the initial state whereas the dynamics is governed by classical evolution equations, we study the buildup of long-range correlations due to the action of non-Hermitean quantum jump operators that constitute a mechanism for dissipative cooling. Starting from an initially disordered state corresponding to a vortex condensate, the dissipative process results in the annihilation of vortex-antivortex pairs and the establishment of quasi-long-range order at late times. We observe that a finite vortex density survives the cooling process, which disagrees with the analytically constructed vortex-free Bose-Einstein condensate at asymptotic times. This indicates that quantum fluctuations beyond the truncated Wigner approximation need to be included to fully capture the physics of dissipative Bose-Einstein condensation.
We present a systematic approach for the semiclassical treatment of many-body dynamics of interacting, open spin systems. Our approach overcomes some of the shortcomings of the recently developed discrete truncated Wigner approximation (DTWA) based on Monte Carlo sampling in a discrete phase space that improves the classical treatment by accounting for lowest-order quantum fluctuations. We provide a rigorous derivation of the DTWA by embedding it in a continuous phase space, thereby introducing a hybrid discrete-continuous truncated Wigner approximation . We derive a set of operator-differential mappings that yield an exact equation of motion (EOM) for the continuous SU(2) Wigner function of spins. The standard DTWA is then recovered by a systematic neglection of specific terms in this exact EOM. The hybrid approach permits us to determine the validity conditions and to gain a detailed understanding of the quality of the approximation, paving the way for systematic improvements. Furthermore, we show that the continuous embedding allows for a straightforward extension of the method to open spin systems subject to dephasing, losses, and incoherent drive, while preserving the key advantages of the discrete approach, such as a positive definite Wigner distribution of typical initial states. We derive exact stochastic differential equations for processes which cannot be described by the standard DTWA due to the presence of nonclassical noise. We illustrate our approach by applying it to the dissipative dynamics of Rydberg excitation of one-dimensional arrays of laser-driven atoms and compare it to exact results for small systems.
We develop a discrete truncated Wigner method to analyze the real-time evolution of dissipative SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(\mathcal{N})SU(N) spin systems coupled with a Markovian environment. This semiclassical approach is not only numerically efficient but also particularly capable of accurately capturing local loss processes due to its local linearity in the dynamical equations. We apply the method to a state-of-the-art experiment involving an analog quantum simulator of a three-dimensional dissipative Bose-Hubbard model in a strongly interacting regime. Our numerical results show good agreement with experimental data, specifically capturing the continuous quantum Zeno effect in the dynamics subjected to a gradual change of the ratio between the hopping amplitude and the onsite interaction across the superfluid Mott insulator crossover. Furthermore, we present comparative analyses with the continuous truncated Wigner method, derived as an effective Fokker-Planck equation for SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(\mathcal{N})SU(N) classical spin variables, showing that the discrete method outperforms the continuous one in simulating the long-time dynamics of SU(2) and SU(3) spin models. The discrete phase-space framework offers a versatile and powerful tool for exploring a wide range of open quantum many-body systems in dimensions higher than one dimension, where numerically exact methods are impractical due to the exponential growth of the Hilbert-space dimension.
Interacting quantum spin models are remarkably useful for describing different types of physical, chemical, and biological systems.Significant understanding of their equilibrium properties has been achieved to date, especially for the case of spin models with short-range couplings.However, progress toward the development of a comparable understanding in long-range interacting models, in particular out-of-equilibrium, remains limited.In a recent work, we proposed a semiclassical numerical method to study spin models, the discrete truncated Wigner approximation (DTWA), and demonstrated its capability to correctly capture the dynamics of one-and two-point correlations in one-dimensional (1D) systems.Here we go one step forward and use the DTWA method to study the dynamics of correlations in two-dimensional (2D) systems with many spins and different types of long-range couplings, in regimes where other numerical methods are generally unreliable.We compute spatial and time-dependent correlations for spin-couplings that decay with distance as a power-law and determine the velocity at which correlations propagate through the system.Sharp changes in the behavior of those velocities are found as a function of the power-law decay exponent.Our predictions are relevant for a broad range of systems including solid state materials, atom-photon systems and ultracold gases of polar molecules, trapped ions, Rydberg, and magnetic atoms.We validate the DTWA predictions for small 2D systems and 1D systems, but ultimately, in the spirt of quantum simulation, experiments will be needed to confirm our predictions for large 2D systems.
We describe an efficient numerical method for simulating the dynamics and steady states of collective spin systems in the presence of dephasing and decay. The method is based on the Schwinger boson representation of spin operators and uses an extension of the truncated Wigner approximation to map the exact open system dynamics onto stochastic differential equations for the corresponding phase space distribution. This approach is most effective in the limit of very large spin quantum numbers, where exact numerical simulations and other approximation methods are no longer applicable. We benchmark this numerical technique for known superradiant decay and spin-squeezing processes and illustrate its application for the simulation of non-equilibrium phase transitions in dissipative spin lattice models.