arXiv:2610.27338
Assignment maps for arbitrary reduced quantum dynamics
James Fullwood, Weixiang Ye
Abstract
Given an open quantum system $S$ with environment $E$, we establish a one-to-one correspondence between completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps from $S$ to $E$ and assignment maps initializing the composite system $SE$ in a possibly correlated state prior to unitary evolution. We show that every possible joint state $ρ_{SE}$ can be realized by such assignment maps, which are inherently Hermiticity-preserving and trace-preserving (HPTP). While these maps sacrifice global positivity, we derive a simple necessary and sufficient condition for any local state of $S$ to belong to their domain of validity. Furthermore, we prove that the geometry of this domain is governed by the joint state assigned to the maximally mixed input, ensuring that a non-zero volume of admissible local states can readily coexist with initial system-environment entanglement. Finally, we provide an operational protocol for witnessing such limits of validity.
AI Summary
The paper addresses linear, consistent assignment maps for open-system dynamics with initially correlated system–environment states. It retains Hermiticity and trace preservation while allowing nonpositive outputs outside a restricted domain of system inputs. For finite-dimensional systems, it constructs a canonical family $\mathcal A_{\mathcal E}=(\mathrm{id}\otimes T\circ\mathcal E)\circ\mathcal B$, where $\mathcal E:S'\to E$ is CPTP and $\mathcal B$ is the canonical virtual broadcasting map. Using an existing partial-transpose theorem, it shows that every joint state can be realized by some member of this family. A Choi-matrix argument establishes a bijection between channels, this canonical family, and reference states $R=\mathcal A_{\mathcal E}(I/d_S)$ with maximally mixed system marginal—not arbitrary assignment maps. The identity $\mathcal A_{\mathcal E}(\rho)=\frac{d_S}{2}\{\rho\otimes I,R\}$ gives a necessary and sufficient positivity test. Block-matrix positivity shows that the domain’s affine hull is determined by $[\rho\otimes I,\Pi_R]=0$, where $\Pi_R$ projects onto the support of $R$; an operator-norm bound guarantees a neighborhood of the maximally mixed state within that hull. Qubit domains have affine dimension $0$, $1$, or $3$. For a qubit depolarizing channel of strength $p$, the domain is a Bloch ball of radius $\sqrt{p(4-3p)}/(2-p)$, asymptotically $\sqrt p$; the reference state remains entangled for $p<2/3$. Validity is restricted to compatible preparations and can collapse to a singleton. The proposed boundary witness uses a joint projective measurement after joint evolution, with its projector determined by a boundary assigned state’s kernel.
the authors utilized Google Gemini for language refinement, and as an interactive tool for the exploration of analytical methods and mathematical derivations.
Error found: The operational section incorrectly claims that every reference state other than a pure maximally entangled state gives a nonzero-volume validity domain; a mixed, perfectly classically correlated two-qubit reference state has only a line segment of valid inputs. The operational witness does not necessarily have strictly positive probability before the boundary, because its selected boundary-state kernel vector may also lie in the reference state's kernel, making the probability identically zero.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 5 pages, no figures