arXiv:2610.27335
Shot Allocation Strategies in Debugging Quantum Circuits
Era Thaqi, Coco Gong, Margaret Martonosi
Abstract
Debugging quantum programs remains challenging due to the nature of quantum measurement. As quantum algorithms and systems scale, it is increasingly crucial to develop rigorous debugging and verification approaches. Statistical assertion-based debugging validates quantum program behavior through repeated circuit execution and statistical hypothesis testing, but existing frameworks treat shot count as a fixed input parameter, leaving the problem of optimal shot allocation across multiple mid-circuit assertions unexplored. To improve debugging efficiency by making better use of given shot counts, this paper proposes and evaluates four shot allocation strategies within the QDB quantum debugger implemented within the CUDA-Q framework. These allocation approaches: equal split, static weight allocation, adaptive entropy routing, and sequential retirement, use statistical approaches to test whether qubits have expected state characteristics at different points in execution. We evaluate these allocation strategies on different circuits, under both noise-free and depolarizing noise conditions. We show how adaptive strategies use shots efficiently by concentrating them on assertions with high uncertainty. This substantially reduces total shot usage while maintaining comparable debugging confidence.
AI Summary
The paper studies how to distribute a fixed total shot budget $B$ across multiple statistical assertion checkpoints in quantum-circuit debugging. It considers assertions about classical outcomes, uniform measurement distributions, and independence between registers, implemented in the QDB debugger within CUDA-Q. Four allocation strategies are compared: equal allocation of $B/m$ shots to each of $m$ checkpoints; fixed type-based weights of 10%, 40%, and 50% for classical, uniform, and product assertions; adaptive routing after an initial probe using 10% of the budget; and sequential allocation in small batches, retiring assertions once their outcomes are statistically decisive. Adaptive routing scores checkpoints using empirical entropy, entropy deficit relative to uniformity, or deviation from the entropy identity for independent registers. Evaluation covers four circuit benchmarks under noiseless and depolarizing-noise conditions, measuring wasted shots, false-positive rates, and detection power for inserted bugs. The reported improvement in detection power is up to 13%. Sequential retirement is reported to give the lowest wasted-shot counts and, under noise, the lowest false-positive rates. These conclusions are based on empirical comparisons rather than analytical allocation bounds. The experiments distinguish readily detected structural bugs from subtle distributional biases. An initialization bug involving $R_y(0.024)$ requires substantially more sampling, whereas omission of a final Hadamard layer in a Bernstein–Vazirani circuit is detected at low shot counts. The text provides no detailed numerical false-positive rates, statistical guarantees for adaptive stopping, or hardware evaluation.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's claim of substantially fewer total shots at comparable confidence is not established by the body's qualitative fixed-budget and wasted-shot comparisons. The supplied figure contains no plotted results, and no numerical comparison substantiates the claimed improvement of up to 13% in bug-detection power. The entropy-routing scores quantify empirical violations rather than statistical uncertainty, potentially prioritizing obvious violations over subtle, difficult-to-detect bugs. The paper does not specify decision thresholds, a retirement rule with sequential error control, or numerical false-positive results sufficient to verify its confidence and reliability claims. A p-value of 1 or exact finite-sample agreement does not eliminate statistical ambiguity or justify accepting an assertion as validated, contrary to the paper's explanation of decisiveness.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 2 pages,1 figure, IEEE Quantum Week Poster Session