arXiv:2610.27223
Comparative Optical Spectroscopy of Er$^{3+}$, Tm$^{3+}$, and Eu$^{3+}$ Molecular Complexes at Cryogenic Temperature
Farhad Rasekh, Sahil, Arsalan Mansourzadeh, Diogo Alves Gálico, David Hunger, Muralee Murugesu, Daniel Oblak
Abstract
Rare-earth molecular complexes are attracting increasing interest for quantum information applications because of their structural flexibility and chemical tunability. Here, we compare the cryogenic optical properties of Er$^{3+}$, Tm$^{3+}$, and Eu$^{3+}$ complexes in the same ligand environment. Optical spectroscopy shows differing behavior across the three systems: spectral hole burning is observed in the Eu$^{3+}$ complex, whereas no measurable hole is detected in the Er$^{3+}$ and Tm$^{3+}$ complexes. We measure laser-induced local heating and rethermalization in the Er$^{3+}$ and Tm$^{3+}$ powder-like samples, observing strong local heating and slow thermal relaxation in the cold-plate cryostat. The recovery occurs over several seconds and, for some Er$^{3+}$ excitation conditions, extends over tens of seconds. The comparison across the three ions nevertheless suggests that heating alone is unlikely to account for the full contrast. Rather, the different behaviors of Eu$^{3+}$, Tm$^{3+}$, and Er$^{3+}$ point to ion-dependent relaxation and decoherence processes associated with their electronic level structure and coupling to the molecular environment. Temperature-dependent linewidth and line-shift measurements are further consistent with phonon-mediated broadening through coupling to crystal-field levels.
AI Summary
The paper asks how rare-earth ion identity and thermalization affect cryogenic optical spectroscopy in isostructural $[\mathrm{Ln}(acac)_3(phen)]$ molecular complexes, comparing Er$^{3+}$, Tm$^{3+}$, and Eu$^{3+}$. Measurements include absorption, photoluminescence, fluorescence lifetimes, spectral hole burning (SHB), and optical-depth transients used to infer laser-induced heating. Eu$^{3+}$ exhibits persistent spectral holes approximately $11$ MHz wide, giving an upper bound on the optical homogeneous linewidth of $\Gamma_h\lesssim5.7$ MHz. Hole recovery is biexponential, with components of $154\pm140$ ms and $8.08\pm1.10$ s, weighted approximately 16% and 84%. Its optical lifetime is $733\,\mu\mathrm{s}$. No measurable SHB is found in Er$^{3+}$ or Tm$^{3+}$ across concentrations of 1–100% and magnetic fields up to 3 T. Their concentrated-sample inhomogeneous linewidths are approximately 40 and 64 GHz, respectively. Er$^{3+}$ absorption and emission resolve the ground- and excited-manifold crystal-field structure; its $0.884\,\mu\mathrm{s}$ optical lifetime indicates strong nonradiative quenching. Post-pump absorption transients reveal local heating and seconds-scale rethermalization. Temperature-dependent linewidths and line shifts are fitted with phonon-coupling models. The thermal analysis suggests that heating alone does not explain absent SHB under low-power burning conditions; ion-dependent shelving, relaxation, and spectral diffusion remain possible explanations. The comparison uses different cryogenic environments: a helium bath for Eu$^{3+}$ and a cold-plate setup for Er$^{3+}$/Tm$^{3+}$. Shelving branching ratios and lifetimes are not determined, and the proposed decoherence mechanisms are not isolated. Er$^{3+}$ thermometry neglects temperature-dependent broadening, making its largest inferred temperatures upper bounds; several phonon-fit parameters are poorly constrained.
Error found: The supplied main text does not independently establish negligible heating during the SHB burn sequences, instead relying on effective-heating maps in separate Supporting Information. The Eu spectral-hole width is reported inconsistently as 10.76 ± 0.18 MHz in the figure caption and 11.40 ± 0.04 MHz in the text. The apparently same Tm thermal-recovery measurement is reported as 2.39 ± 0.21 s in the results and 2.0 ± 0.2 s in the conclusion. The conclusion incorrectly infers that any undetected Er spectral hole must be gigahertz-broadened and uses this to suggest a very large homogeneous linewidth, although inadequate shelving or rapid shelving-state relaxation could instead explain non-detection.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 14 pages and 5 figures