arXiv:2610.26859
Boundary-Sensitive Quantum Order on Non-Amenable Lattices
Xingzhi Wang, Zohar Nussinov, Gerardo Ortiz
Abstract
We show that quantum systems on non-amenable lattices, whose boundaries constitute an extensive fraction of the system, host novel forms of bulk ordering with no Euclidean counterpart. Combining boundary-retaining iDMRG with an exact symmetry-fixing duality, we investigate $p<5$ state clock models on the coordination-3 infinite Cayley tree. We find that between the ordered and disordered phases lies an emergent intermediate phase with bulk order induced by an arbitrarily weak boundary field rather than by conventional spontaneous symmetry-breaking. This establishes boundary-sensitive order as a distinct quantum ordering mechanism defying Landau's spontaneous symmetry-breaking paradigm. The intermediate phase realizes a bulk-boundary correspondence in which the unpolarized boundary selects a specific ordered bulk state.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether quantum spin systems on non-amenable lattices exhibit an intermediate regime where an arbitrarily weak boundary field induces bulk order, while the zero-field symmetric state remains disordered. It studies ferromagnetic transverse-field $p$-state clock models on the coordination-3 Cayley tree, whose boundary remains an extensive fraction of its volume. Boundary-retaining infinite-system DMRG is combined with an exact bond-algebraic duality that restricts the zero-field calculation to the ground-state $\mathbb Z_p$ symmetry sector. Ordering in this symmetric state is diagnosed through long-distance correlations, represented by strings in the dual model, rather than through a symmetry-breaking expectation value. Writing $K=J/h$, the calculations find intermediate boundary-sensitive regimes between $K_{c1}\simeq0.448$ and $K_{c2}\simeq0.535$ for $p=2$, and between $0.549$ and $0.612$ for $p=3$. The lower Ising transition is continuous, with fitted exponent $\beta\simeq0.50$; its upper transition and both three-state transitions are discontinuous. The $p=4$ model maps exactly to two decoupled Ising models. Ising magnetization profiles show boundary perturbations reaching arbitrarily deep into the intermediate regime, although the boundary polarization vanishes as the applied field tends to zero. The phase diagrams are numerical, using retained subtree dimensions $\chi=16$ and $18$. Reported bulk convergence is $10^{-4}$ away from a narrow region around the upper transition. Calculations are restricted to coordination three; larger coordination is computationally costly. Extension to lattices with loops requires additional gauge constraints, while continuous symmetries and itinerant systems remain open directions.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract extends the unpolarized-boundary conclusion across the studied clock models, but boundary-polarization calculations establish it only for p=2 and, through the exact mapping, p=4, not p=3. The paper's disordered symmetric free-boundary state does not exclude spontaneous symmetry breaking, because its ordered boundary-selected thermodynamic limits themselves provide symmetry-breaking infinite-volume ground states.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 10 pages