Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.26689

Measurement-efficient energy estimator for quantum chemistry of photodynamic materials

Connor Lenihan, Kripa Panchagnula, Luca Erhart, Jem Guhit, Carlo A. Gaggioli, Gabriel Greene-Diniz, Gabriel Laude, Megan Cerys Rowe, Fabian Finger, Pranav Kalidindi, Enrico Rinaldi, Mikko Muuronen, Chandrika Mulakala, Thomas M. Soini, Elvira Shishenina, David Muñoz Ramo, David Zsolt Manrique

quant-phphysics.chem-phSubmitted Oct 19, 2026• Announced Oct 20, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Accurate modelling of chemical reaction rates requires precise correlated energy differences. Quantum computing offers a potential route to their determination, but extracting energies from quantum-prepared states can demand prohibitive sampling. We demonstrate measurement-efficient correlated energy estimation using an electronically challenging H$_2$DBB--Ru model derived from a Ru-functionalized hafnium metal-organic framework relevant to radiodynamic and photodynamic therapies. The mixed estimator combines a quantum-prepared target with sparse multiconfiguration references and recovers ground-state corrections using magnitude-only compute-uncompute measurements. Analytical variance estimates predict 1.6 mHa precision with a few hundred shots, about 100 times fewer than the single-determinant formulation and three orders of magnitude fewer than optimized Hamiltonian-term sampling. With approximate targets, it reaches comparable accuracy using simpler state preparation than direct expectation-value estimation. Emulator and trapped-ion experiments on Quantinuum Helios validate the approach up to (10,10), including a 50-qubit circuit combining AI-assisted state preparation with error detection, providing a measurement-efficient route to correlated energy differences for challenging chemical problems.

AI Summary

The paper addresses the sampling cost of extracting correlated electronic energies from quantum-prepared states. It extends quantum mixed estimation to sparse multiconfiguration references, decomposing $H|\Phi\rangle=E_\Phi|\Phi\rangle+r_\Phi|\Lambda\rangle$. For an exact ground state within the reference’s symmetry sector, the correction has a known negative sign, allowing $E=E_\Phi-r_\Phi\sqrt{p_\Lambda/p_\Phi}$ to be reconstructed from magnitude-only compute–uncompute measurements rather than signed overlaps or Hamiltonian-term sampling. Analytical covariance calculations, finite-shot simulations, and trapped-ion experiments compare overlap protocols and reference sizes. In the high-quality-reference regime, compute–uncompute requires approximately $r_\Phi^2/(4\epsilon^2)$ shots. For a Ru-containing molecular benchmark, an eight-determinant reference gives an idealized requirement of about 400 shots for 1.6 mHa standard error: roughly 100 times fewer than single-determinant classical-shadow estimation and 1700 times fewer than the optimized qubit-wise-commuting Pauli baseline. Approximate-target tests also find reduced preparation requirements; in the (10,10) active space, mixed estimation reaches the accuracy criterion with 23–27 target determinants versus 96 or more for expectation values. Hardware tests reach (10,10), using 20 data qubits and up to 50 total qubits with parity detection. With 10,000 submitted shots per geometry, individual-energy standard errors are 1.66–1.73 mHa, but absolute errors across reported tests reach 13 mHa. Noise cancellation is conditional, and parity checks do not consistently improve energy differences. Targets and reference supports use classical benchmarks; approximate targets and residual truncation introduce bias, active-space energies are unconverged, and neither converged reaction rates nor quantum advantage is established.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedStrong assumptionsMissing comparison
We used large-language-model agents within a human-supervised iterative search to explore target- and residual-state truncations together with their compiled circuit implementations.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
89 pages total: 35-page main article and 54-page Supplementary Information; 31 figures and 8 tables

Related papers

Ground-state energy estimation of the water molecule on a trapped-ion quantum computer

Yunseong Nam, Jwo-Sy Chen, Neal C. Pisenti +24 more

Abstract Quantum computing leverages the quantum resources of superposition and entanglement to efficiently solve computational problems considered intractable for classical computers. Examples include calculating molecular and nuclear structure, simulating strongly interacting electron systems, and modeling aspects of material function. While substantial theoretical advances have been made in mapping these problems to quantum algorithms, there remains a large gap between the resource requirements for solving such problems and the capabilities of currently available quantum hardware. Bridging this gap will require a co-design approach, where the expression of algorithms is developed in conjunction with the hardware itself to optimize execution. Here we describe an extensible co-design framework for solving chemistry problems on a trapped-ion quantum computer and apply it to estimating the ground-state energy of the water molecule using the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) method. The controllability of the trapped-ion quantum computer enables robust energy estimates using the prepared VQE ansatz states. The systematic and statistical errors are comparable to the chemical accuracy, which is the target threshold necessary for predicting the rates of chemical reaction dynamics, without resorting to any error mitigation techniques based on Richardson extrapolation.

arXiv:1902.10171•npj Quantum Information•Apr 3, 2020•386 citations

Ground-State Energy Estimation of HeH$^{+}$, ArH$^{+}$, and H$_2$O via Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization

Jubin Park, Chae-Hyun Yoon, Minkyu Lee +1 more

Accurate ground-state energies are essential for understanding molecular structure, chemical bonding, and reaction energetics in quantum chemistry. In this work, we investigate the ground-state properties of the molecular systems HeH$^+$, ArH$^+$, and H$_2$O using Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization (SQD), a hybrid quantum-classical framework designed for near-term quantum devices. Unlike variational approaches such as VQE, which require deep parameterized circuits and repeated expectation-value measurements, SQD reconstructs a low-energy determinant subspace directly from measured bitstrings. For the present calculations, bitstrings were generated on IBM quantum hardware using shallow local unitary cluster Jastrow (LUCJ) circuits whose parameters were constructed from the $t_1$ and $t_2$ amplitudes of coupled-cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) calculations based on restricted Hartree--Fock (RHF) references. From these samples, we compute ground-state potential-energy curves of HeH$^+$, ArH$^+$, and H$_2$O with the 6-31G and cc-pVDZ basis sets. For all three systems, the SQD results obtained with the cc-pVDZ basis closely follow the corresponding same-basis CCSD energies and reproduce the equilibrium-region trends of the potential-energy curves. HeH$^+$ and ArH$^+$ were chosen as simple yet astrophysically important molecular-ion benchmarks, while H$_2$O was included as a representative polyatomic molecule to assess the applicability of SQD beyond diatomic ionic systems. At the adopted equilibrium geometries, the deviations from the same-active-space CASCI references are 0.00, 2.51, and 6.34 mHa for HeH$^+$, ArH$^+$, and H$_2$O, respectively. These results demonstrate the feasibility of hardware-assisted SQD for the present benchmark systems and motivate further studies of its accuracy and computational scaling for larger molecular active spaces.

arXiv:2608.06415•Aug 5, 2026•0 citations

Ground State Energy via Adiabatic Evolution and Phase Measurement for a Molecular Hamiltonian on an Ion-Trap Quantum Computer

Ludwig Nützel, Michael J. Hartmann, Henrik Dreyer +1 more

Estimating molecular ground-state energies is a central application of quantum computing, requiring both the preparation of accurate quantum states and efficient energy readout. Understanding the effect of hardware noise on these experiments is crucial to distinguish errors that have low impact, errors that can be mitigated, and errors that must be reduced at the hardware level. We ran a state preparation and energy measurement protocol on an ion-trap quantum computer, without any non-scalable off-loading of computational tasks to classical computers, and show that leakage errors are the main obstacle to chemical accuracy. More specifically, we apply adiabatic state preparation to prepare the ground state of a six-qubit encoding of the H3+ molecule and extract its energy using a noise-resilient variant of iterative quantum phase estimation. Our results improve upon the classical Hartree-Fock energy. Analyzing the effect of hardware noise on the result, we find that while coherent and incoherent noise have little influence, the hardware results are mainly impacted by leakage errors. Absent leakage errors, noisy numerical simulations show that with our experimental settings we would have achieved close to chemical accuracy, even shot noise included. These insights highlight the importance of targeting leakage suppression in future algorithm and hardware development.

quant-pharXiv:2512.14415•Quantum Science and Technology•Dec 17, 2025•3 citations

Quantum expectation-value estimation by computational basis sampling

Masaya Kohda, Ryosuke Imai, Keita Kanno +3 more

Measuring expectation values of observables is an essential ingredient in variational quantum algorithms. A practical obstacle is the necessity of a large number of measurements for statistical convergence to meet requirements of precision, such as chemical accuracy in the application to quantum chemistry computations. Here we propose an algorithm to estimate the expectation value based on its approximate expression as a weighted sum of classically tractable matrix elements with some modulation, where the weight and modulation factors are evaluated by sampling appropriately prepared quantum states in the computational basis on quantum computers. Each of those states is prepared by applying a unitary transformation consisting of at most $N$ CNOT gates, where $N$ is the number of qubits, to a target quantum state whose expectation value is evaluated. Our algorithm is expected to require fewer measurements than conventional methods for a required statistical precision of the expectation value when the target quantum state is concentrated in particular computational basis states. We provide numerical comparisons of our method with existing ones for measuring electronic ground-state energies (expectation values of electronic Hamiltonians for the lowest-energy states) of various small molecules. Numerical results show that our method can reduce the numbers of measurements to obtain the ground-state energies for a targeted precision by several orders of magnitudes for molecules whose ground states are concentrated. Our results provide another route to measure expectation values of observables, which could accelerate the variational quantum algorithms.

arXiv:2112.07416•Physical Review Research•Sep 2, 2022•38 citations

Solving an industrially relevant quantum chemistry problem on quantum hardware

Ludwig Nützel, Alexander Gresch, Lukas Hehn +10 more

Abstract Quantum chemical calculations are among the most promising applications for quantum computing. Implementations of dedicated quantum algorithms on available quantum hardware were so far, however, mostly limited to comparatively simple systems without strong correlations. As such, they can also be addressed by classically efficient single-reference methods. Here we calculate the lowest energy eigenvalue of active space Hamiltonians of industrially relevant and strongly correlated metal chelates on trapped ion quantum hardware, and integrate the results into a typical industrial quantum chemical workflow to arrive at chemically meaningful properties. We are able to achieve chemical accuracy by training a variational quantum algorithm on quantum hardware, followed by a classical diagonalization in the subspace of states measured as outputs of the quantum circuit. This approach is particularly measurement-efficient, requiring 600 single-shot measurements per cost function evaluation on a ten qubit system, and allows for efficient post-processing to handle erroneous runs.

arXiv:2408.10801•Quantum Science and Technology•Dec 13, 2024•18 citations

Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory Calculations of Low-lying States of Complex Chemical Systems with Quantum Computers

Zhanou Liu, Yuhao Chen, Yingjin Ma +2 more

Accurately describing strong electron correlation in complex systems remains a prominent challenge in computational chemistry as near-term quantum algorithms treating total correlation often require prohibitively deep circuits. Here we present a hybrid strategy combining the Variational Quantum Eigensolver with Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory to efficiently decouple correlation effects. This approach confines static correlation to a compact multireference quantum state while recovering dynamic correlation through a classical on-top density functional using reduced-density information. By enabling self-consistent orbital optimization, the method significantly reduces quantum resource overheads without sacrificing physical rigor. We demonstrate chemical accuracy on standard benchmarks by reproducing C$_2$ equilibrium bond lengths and benzene excitation energies with mean absolute errors of 0.006 Å and 0.048 eV respectively. Most notably, for the strongly correlated Cr$_2$ dimer requiring a large complete active space (48e, 42o), the framework yields a bound potential-energy curve and recovers qualitative dissociation behavior despite realistic hardware noise. These results establish that separating correlation types provides a practical route to reliable predictions on near-term quantum hardware.

arXiv:2602.10435•Feb 11, 2026•0 citations
Accurate modelling of chemical reaction rates requires precise correlated energy differences. Quantum computing offers a potential route to their determination, but extracting energies from quantum-prepared states can demand prohibitive sampling. We demonstrate measurement-efficient correlated energy estimation using an electronically challenging H2_22​DBB--Ru model derived from a Ru-functionalized hafnium metal-organic framework relevant to radiodynamic and photodynamic therapies. The mixed estimator combines a quantum-prepared target with sparse multiconfiguration references and recovers ground-state corrections using magnitude-only compute-uncompute measurements. Analytical variance estimates predict 1.6 mHa precision with a few hundred shots, about 100 times fewer than the single-determinant formulation and three orders of magnitude fewer than optimized Hamiltonian-term sampling. With approximate targets, it reaches comparable accuracy using simpler state preparation than direct expectation-value estimation. Emulator and trapped-ion experiments on Quantinuum Helios validate the approach up to (10,10), including a 50-qubit circuit combining AI-assisted state preparation with error detection, providing a measurement-efficient route to correlated energy differences for challenging chemical problems.
The paper addresses the sampling cost of extracting correlated electronic energies from quantum-prepared states. It extends quantum mixed estimation to sparse multiconfiguration references, decomposing H∣Φ⟩=EΦ∣Φ⟩+rΦ∣Λ⟩H|\Phi\rangle=E_\Phi|\Phi\rangle+r_\Phi|\Lambda\rangleH∣Φ⟩=EΦ​∣Φ⟩+rΦ​∣Λ⟩. For an exact ground state within the reference’s symmetry sector, the correction has a known negative sign, allowing E=EΦ−rΦpΛ/pΦE=E_\Phi-r_\Phi\sqrt{p_\Lambda/p_\Phi}E=EΦ​−rΦ​pΛ​/pΦ​​ to be reconstructed from magnitude-only compute–uncompute measurements rather than signed overlaps or Hamiltonian-term sampling.
Analytical covariance calculations, finite-shot simulations, and trapped-ion experiments compare overlap protocols and reference sizes. In the high-quality-reference regime, compute–uncompute requires approximately rΦ2/(4ϵ2)r_\Phi^2/(4\epsilon^2)rΦ2​/(4ϵ2) shots. For a Ru-containing molecular benchmark, an eight-determinant reference gives an idealized requirement of about 400 shots for 1.6 mHa standard error: roughly 100 times fewer than single-determinant classical-shadow estimation and 1700 times fewer than the optimized qubit-wise-commuting Pauli baseline. Approximate-target tests also find reduced preparation requirements; in the (10,10) active space, mixed estimation reaches the accuracy criterion with 23–27 target determinants versus 96 or more for expectation values.
Hardware tests reach (10,10), using 20 data qubits and up to 50 total qubits with parity detection. With 10,000 submitted shots per geometry, individual-energy standard errors are 1.66–1.73 mHa, but absolute errors across reported tests reach 13 mHa. Noise cancellation is conditional, and parity checks do not consistently improve energy differences. Targets and reference supports use classical benchmarks; approximate targets and residual truncation introduce bias, active-space energies are unconverged, and neither converged reaction rates nor quantum advantage is established.
Abstract Quantum computing leverages the quantum resources of superposition and entanglement to efficiently solve computational problems considered intractable for classical computers. Examples include calculating molecular and nuclear structure, simulating strongly interacting electron systems, and modeling aspects of material function. While substantial theoretical advances have been made in mapping these problems to quantum algorithms, there remains a large gap between the resource requirements for solving such problems and the capabilities of currently available quantum hardware. Bridging this gap will require a co-design approach, where the expression of algorithms is developed in conjunction with the hardware itself to optimize execution. Here we describe an extensible co-design framework for solving chemistry problems on a trapped-ion quantum computer and apply it to estimating the ground-state energy of the water molecule using the variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) method. The controllability of the trapped-ion quantum computer enables robust energy estimates using the prepared VQE ansatz states. The systematic and statistical errors are comparable to the chemical accuracy, which is the target threshold necessary for predicting the rates of chemical reaction dynamics, without resorting to any error mitigation techniques based on Richardson extrapolation.
Ground-State Energy Estimation of HeH+^{+}+, ArH+^{+}+, and H2_22​O via Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization
Accurate ground-state energies are essential for understanding molecular structure, chemical bonding, and reaction energetics in quantum chemistry. In this work, we investigate the ground-state properties of the molecular systems HeH+^++, ArH+^++, and H2_22​O using Sample-Based Quantum Diagonalization (SQD), a hybrid quantum-classical framework designed for near-term quantum devices. Unlike variational approaches such as VQE, which require deep parameterized circuits and repeated expectation-value measurements, SQD reconstructs a low-energy determinant subspace directly from measured bitstrings. For the present calculations, bitstrings were generated on IBM quantum hardware using shallow local unitary cluster Jastrow (LUCJ) circuits whose parameters were constructed from the t1t_1t1​ and t2t_2t2​ amplitudes of coupled-cluster singles and doubles (CCSD) calculations based on restricted Hartree--Fock (RHF) references. From these samples, we compute ground-state potential-energy curves of HeH+^++, ArH+^++, and H2_22​O with the 6-31G and cc-pVDZ basis sets. For all three systems, the SQD results obtained with the cc-pVDZ basis closely follow the corresponding same-basis CCSD energies and reproduce the equilibrium-region trends of the potential-energy curves. HeH+^++ and ArH+^++ were chosen as simple yet astrophysically important molecular-ion benchmarks, while H2_22​O was included as a representative polyatomic molecule to assess the applicability of SQD beyond diatomic ionic systems. At the adopted equilibrium geometries, the deviations from the same-active-space CASCI references are 0.00, 2.51, and 6.34 mHa for HeH+^++, ArH+^++, and H2_22​O, respectively. These results demonstrate the feasibility of hardware-assisted SQD for the present benchmark systems and motivate further studies of its accuracy and computational scaling for larger molecular active spaces.
Estimating molecular ground-state energies is a central application of quantum computing, requiring both the preparation of accurate quantum states and efficient energy readout. Understanding the effect of hardware noise on these experiments is crucial to distinguish errors that have low impact, errors that can be mitigated, and errors that must be reduced at the hardware level. We ran a state preparation and energy measurement protocol on an ion-trap quantum computer, without any non-scalable off-loading of computational tasks to classical computers, and show that leakage errors are the main obstacle to chemical accuracy. More specifically, we apply adiabatic state preparation to prepare the ground state of a six-qubit encoding of the H3+ molecule and extract its energy using a noise-resilient variant of iterative quantum phase estimation. Our results improve upon the classical Hartree-Fock energy. Analyzing the effect of hardware noise on the result, we find that while coherent and incoherent noise have little influence, the hardware results are mainly impacted by leakage errors. Absent leakage errors, noisy numerical simulations show that with our experimental settings we would have achieved close to chemical accuracy, even shot noise included. These insights highlight the importance of targeting leakage suppression in future algorithm and hardware development.
Measuring expectation values of observables is an essential ingredient in variational quantum algorithms. A practical obstacle is the necessity of a large number of measurements for statistical convergence to meet requirements of precision, such as chemical accuracy in the application to quantum chemistry computations. Here we propose an algorithm to estimate the expectation value based on its approximate expression as a weighted sum of classically tractable matrix elements with some modulation, where the weight and modulation factors are evaluated by sampling appropriately prepared quantum states in the computational basis on quantum computers. Each of those states is prepared by applying a unitary transformation consisting of at most NNN CNOT gates, where NNN is the number of qubits, to a target quantum state whose expectation value is evaluated. Our algorithm is expected to require fewer measurements than conventional methods for a required statistical precision of the expectation value when the target quantum state is concentrated in particular computational basis states. We provide numerical comparisons of our method with existing ones for measuring electronic ground-state energies (expectation values of electronic Hamiltonians for the lowest-energy states) of various small molecules. Numerical results show that our method can reduce the numbers of measurements to obtain the ground-state energies for a targeted precision by several orders of magnitudes for molecules whose ground states are concentrated. Our results provide another route to measure expectation values of observables, which could accelerate the variational quantum algorithms.
Abstract Quantum chemical calculations are among the most promising applications for quantum computing. Implementations of dedicated quantum algorithms on available quantum hardware were so far, however, mostly limited to comparatively simple systems without strong correlations. As such, they can also be addressed by classically efficient single-reference methods. Here we calculate the lowest energy eigenvalue of active space Hamiltonians of industrially relevant and strongly correlated metal chelates on trapped ion quantum hardware, and integrate the results into a typical industrial quantum chemical workflow to arrive at chemically meaningful properties. We are able to achieve chemical accuracy by training a variational quantum algorithm on quantum hardware, followed by a classical diagonalization in the subspace of states measured as outputs of the quantum circuit. This approach is particularly measurement-efficient, requiring 600 single-shot measurements per cost function evaluation on a ten qubit system, and allows for efficient post-processing to handle erroneous runs.
Accurately describing strong electron correlation in complex systems remains a prominent challenge in computational chemistry as near-term quantum algorithms treating total correlation often require prohibitively deep circuits. Here we present a hybrid strategy combining the Variational Quantum Eigensolver with Multiconfiguration Pair-Density Functional Theory to efficiently decouple correlation effects. This approach confines static correlation to a compact multireference quantum state while recovering dynamic correlation through a classical on-top density functional using reduced-density information. By enabling self-consistent orbital optimization, the method significantly reduces quantum resource overheads without sacrificing physical rigor. We demonstrate chemical accuracy on standard benchmarks by reproducing C2_22​ equilibrium bond lengths and benzene excitation energies with mean absolute errors of 0.006 Å and 0.048 eV respectively. Most notably, for the strongly correlated Cr2_22​ dimer requiring a large complete active space (48e, 42o), the framework yields a bound potential-energy curve and recovers qualitative dissociation behavior despite realistic hardware noise. These results establish that separating correlation types provides a practical route to reliable predictions on near-term quantum hardware.