Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.26603

Beyond Fidelity: Resolving Errors in Photonic Seed State Generation

Sara Bartolucci, Patrick Birchall, Jacob Bulmer, Sam Gartenstein, Mihir Pant, Terry Rudolph, Chris Sparrow, Andrzej Veitia

quant-phSubmitted Oct 19, 2026• Announced Oct 20, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

An important aspect of many linear optical quantum computing architectures is probabilistically generating small dual-rail qubit entangled states, or seed states. While many schemes to achieve this have been discovered, attention has been primarily focused on minimizing input resources and maximizing success probability rather than establishing a detailed understanding of linear-optical error performance. In this work, we develop a framework for resolving sensitivities to physically distinct errors in linear optical state generation, allowing us to identify precise ways in which these errors affect the properties of the output state. We use this framework to identify seed state generators in which destructive many-photon interference prevents detector loss and detector noise from causing a falsely successful heralding event. We show that this effect suppresses errors, for example cutting the effective loss on the output of particular Bell state generators in half relative to a standard scheme. We also present a new Bell state generator in which both detector loss and detector noise do not affect the quality of the output Bell state to first order, and a 4GHZ generator with >75% higher success probability than a standard circuit. In addition we provide some useful identities, bounds and invariants for studying linear optical seed state generation.

AI Summary

The paper asks how physical errors in heralded linear-optical seed-state generation translate into logical errors and leakage, and when circuit structure can suppress false heralding. It develops a subspace-resolved description tracking correlated vacuum, multiphoton, Pauli and distinguishability errors, with response coefficients giving their leading-order probabilities conditioned on successful detection. Channel-commutation identities relate input errors to detector errors and unavoidable output errors. In particular, $c_{L_{\rm in}\to(V,I,\ldots)}=1+c_{L_{\rm det}\to(V,I,\ldots)}\geq1$. When every interferometer input contains one photon, corresponding multiphoton and combined addition–loss Pauli-response bounds are $3/2$ and $1/4$, respectively. Calculations propagate error-modified Fock states or detector POVMs through each circuit and project the heralded outputs onto the chosen subspaces. Many-photon interference can eliminate detection patterns adjacent to successful patterns, preventing first-order detector loss or noise from falsely heralding success. A new six-photon Bell generator has both protections and succeeds with probability $1/18$; detector-loss protection halves leading-order single-qubit vacuum leakage from input loss relative to the standard generator. Other circuits convert detector errors into correlated leakage detectable by subsequent fusions. A twelve-photon ballistic four-qubit GHZ generator succeeds with probability $10/729$, over 75% above the $1/128$ benchmark, with detector-loss errors leaking all four qubits. An example shows that seed-state fidelity can reverse circuit rankings relative to fidelity after fusion. The analysis is primarily leading order, excludes internal interferometer imperfections and unbalanced internal loss, and uses a two-internal-mode distinguishability model. Subspace probabilities omit coherences and intra-subspace structure; their use as a reduced state representation requires additional assumptions or twirling.

No sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
18+24 pages, 13 figures

Related papers

Limits of heralded photonic Bell-state generation in the presence of loss

Kevin J. Randles, Manuel H. Muñoz-Arias, Mohan Sarovar

High-quality entangled states of photons underlie quantum information science (QIS) applications across communication, sensing, and computing. In many discrete-variable photonic QIS architectures, large application-ready states (e.g., cluster states, repeater graph states) are constructed via fusion measurements on small entangled seed states, of which Bell states are the fundamental example. The quality of seed-state generation therefore sets a baseline for application performance, making it crucial to understand this process under realistic error mechanisms, particularly in integrated photonics experiments. In this work, we analyze five heralded schemes for generating event-ready photonic Bell states, contrasting their heralding probabilities, fidelities, and error robustness. We develop a hierarchy of error models, progressing from an analytically tractable lumped-loss model to realistic heralded single-photon sources with multiphoton emission errors and finally to integrated frequency-bin implementations with architecture-dependent loss. Across these models, we find that schemes based on higher-order multiphoton interference provide superior fidelity robustness in low-loss implementations, while lower-photon-number schemes can be preferable when probabilistic sources or lossy beamsplitters dominate the resource cost. Our results provide design guidance for integrated discrete-variable quantum photonics, with particular relevance for frequency-bin architectures where active beamsplitter loss can determine the optimal resource-state-generation strategy.

quant-pharXiv:2608.01549•Aug 4, 2026•2 citations

Loss and distinguishability effects in heralded entangled state generation with Gaussian resources

Yun-Long Cao, Xiao-Ye Xu, Wiwittawin Sukmas +2 more

The effects of optical loss and photon distinguishability on the heralded generation of entangled states based on Gaussian resources are quantitatively investigated. By incorporating mode-dependent loss and the statistical characteristics of partially distinguishable photons into a phase-space representation, an efficient numerical framework is established to optimize target-state fidelity and success probability, with a specific focus on the enhancement triggered by non-Gaussian operations such as photon addition and subtraction. The numerical optimization results indicate that a non-vacuum post-selection strategy within a dual-rail encoding framework, combined with the simultaneous tuning of squeezing parameters and the interferometer network, effectively suppresses vacuum noise, enabling the generation of high-fidelity Bell, GHZ, and W states under realistic experimental constraints. The results show that introducing non-Gaussian operations can successfully enhance the state generation performance under realistic imperfections analogous to the enhancements observed under ideal conditions. This study demonstrates that experimental imperfections primarily scale down the success probability rather than fundamentally compromising the state fidelity, providing practical design guidelines for scalable state engineering on integrated photonic platforms.

quant-pharXiv:2607.23048•Jul 28, 2026•0 citations

Errors in heralded circuits for linear optical entanglement generation

Reece D. Shaw, Alex E. Jones, Patrick Yard +1 more

The heralded generation of entangled states underpins many photonic quantum technologies. As quantum error correction thresholds are determined by underlying physical noise mechanisms, a detailed and faithful characterization of resource states is required. Non-computational leakage, e.g. more than one photon occupying a dual-rail encoded qubit, is an error not captured by standard forms of state tomography, which postselect on photons remaining in the computational subspace. Here we use the continuous-variable (CV) formalism and first quantized state representation to develop a simulation framework that reconstructs photonic quantum states in the presence of partial distinguishability and resulting non-computational leakage errors. Using these tools, we analyze a variety of Bell state generation circuits and find that the five photon discrete Fourier transform (DFT) Bell state generation scheme [Phys Rev. Lett. 126 23054 (2021)] is most robust to such errors for near-ideal photons. Through characterization of a photonic entangling gate, we demonstrate how leakage errors prevent a modular characterization of concatenated gates using current tomographical procedures. Our work is a necessary step in revealing the true noise models that must be addressed in fault-tolerant photonic quantum computing architectures.

arXiv:2305.08452•May 15, 2023•10 citations

Creation of Entangled Photonic States Using Linear Optics

Sara Bartolucci, Patrick M. Birchall, Mercedes Gimeno-Segovia +7 more

Using only linear optical elements, the creation of dual-rail photonic entangled states is inherently probabilistic. Known entanglement generation schemes have low success probabilities, requiring large-scale multiplexing to achieve near-deterministic operation of quantum information processing protocols. In this paper, we introduce multiple techniques and methods to generate photonic entangled states with high probability, which have the potential to reduce the footprint of Linear Optical Quantum Computing (LOQC) architectures drastically. Most notably, we are showing how to improve Bell state preparation from four single photons to up to p=2/3, boost Type-I fusion to 75% with a dual-rail Bell state ancilla and improve Type-II fusion beyond the limits of Bell state discrimination.

arXiv:2106.13825•Jun 25, 2021•81 citations

Ghost unitaries for loss-resilient photonic resource-state generation

Kevin J. Randles, Manuel H. Muñoz-Arias, Kevin Thompson

Entangled few-photon states, such as Bell and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, are central resources for discrete-variable photonic quantum information processing. In many architectures, these states are generated probabilistically by first heralding single photons from biphoton sources and then interfering them in linear-optical circuits. In this work, we show that the entanglement structure of said biphoton sources can be directly exploited for noise-engineering to deliver higher quality resource states. Using the transpose identity of multi-mode squeezed vacuum states, we introduce "ghost-unitary" implementations in which the target resource-generation interferometer is applied to the heralding modes rather than to the delivered resource modes. When the dominant imperfection is interferometric loss, this relocation converts direct amplitude damping of the output into false-positive heralding events that require both higher-pair emission and photon loss. In the low-squeezing regime, these events are parametrically suppressed, yielding higher-fidelity conditional resource states. We analyze this mechanism for single-qubit states, two-photon NOON states, Bell states, and a family of $n$-qubit GHZ states, as well as for single-qubit teleportation and type-I-fusion-based resource growth. Across these examples, we delineate finite parameter regimes in which ghost-unitary implementations outperform direct implementations, with particular relevance to frequency-bin photonics where active linear-optical transformations can be relatively lossy. We also prove that, in the setting considered here, the direct implementation of the $n$-GHZ family delivers identically damped outputs: equivalent to the ideal state followed by uniform amplitude damping. This extends the known $n=2,3$ cases and provides a structural result of independent interest for photonic quantum information processing.

quant-pharXiv:2610.17300•Oct 14, 2026•0 citations

Generating entanglement with linear optics

Stasja Stanisic, Noah Linden, Ashley Montanaro +1 more

Entanglement is the basic building block of linear optical quantum computation, and as such understanding how to generate it in detail is of great importance for optical architectures. We prove that Bell states cannot be generated using only three photons in the dual-rail encoding, and give strong numerical evidence for the optimality of the existing four photon schemes. In a setup with a single photon in each input mode, we find a fundamental limit on the possible entanglement between a single mode Alice and arbitrary Bob. We investigate and compare other setups aimed at characterizing entanglement in settings more general than dual-rail encoding. The results draw attention to the trade-off between the entanglement a state has and the probability of postselecting that state, which can give surprising constant bounds on entanglement even with increasing numbers of photons.

arXiv:1702.05209•Physical Review A•Oct 26, 2017•27 citations
An important aspect of many linear optical quantum computing architectures is probabilistically generating small dual-rail qubit entangled states, or seed states. While many schemes to achieve this have been discovered, attention has been primarily focused on minimizing input resources and maximizing success probability rather than establishing a detailed understanding of linear-optical error performance. In this work, we develop a framework for resolving sensitivities to physically distinct errors in linear optical state generation, allowing us to identify precise ways in which these errors affect the properties of the output state. We use this framework to identify seed state generators in which destructive many-photon interference prevents detector loss and detector noise from causing a falsely successful heralding event. We show that this effect suppresses errors, for example cutting the effective loss on the output of particular Bell state generators in half relative to a standard scheme. We also present a new Bell state generator in which both detector loss and detector noise do not affect the quality of the output Bell state to first order, and a 4GHZ generator with >75% higher success probability than a standard circuit. In addition we provide some useful identities, bounds and invariants for studying linear optical seed state generation.
The paper asks how physical errors in heralded linear-optical seed-state generation translate into logical errors and leakage, and when circuit structure can suppress false heralding. It develops a subspace-resolved description tracking correlated vacuum, multiphoton, Pauli and distinguishability errors, with response coefficients giving their leading-order probabilities conditioned on successful detection.
Channel-commutation identities relate input errors to detector errors and unavoidable output errors. In particular, cLin→(V,I,…)=1+cLdet→(V,I,…)≥1c_{L_{\rm in}\to(V,I,\ldots)}=1+c_{L_{\rm det}\to(V,I,\ldots)}\geq1cLin​→(V,I,…)​=1+cLdet​→(V,I,…)​≥1. When every interferometer input contains one photon, corresponding multiphoton and combined addition–loss Pauli-response bounds are 3/23/23/2 and 1/41/41/4, respectively. Calculations propagate error-modified Fock states or detector POVMs through each circuit and project the heralded outputs onto the chosen subspaces.
Many-photon interference can eliminate detection patterns adjacent to successful patterns, preventing first-order detector loss or noise from falsely heralding success. A new six-photon Bell generator has both protections and succeeds with probability 1/181/181/18; detector-loss protection halves leading-order single-qubit vacuum leakage from input loss relative to the standard generator. Other circuits convert detector errors into correlated leakage detectable by subsequent fusions. A twelve-photon ballistic four-qubit GHZ generator succeeds with probability 10/72910/72910/729, over 75% above the 1/1281/1281/128 benchmark, with detector-loss errors leaking all four qubits. An example shows that seed-state fidelity can reverse circuit rankings relative to fidelity after fusion.
The analysis is primarily leading order, excludes internal interferometer imperfections and unbalanced internal loss, and uses a two-internal-mode distinguishability model. Subspace probabilities omit coherences and intra-subspace structure; their use as a reduced state representation requires additional assumptions or twirling.
High-quality entangled states of photons underlie quantum information science (QIS) applications across communication, sensing, and computing. In many discrete-variable photonic QIS architectures, large application-ready states (e.g., cluster states, repeater graph states) are constructed via fusion measurements on small entangled seed states, of which Bell states are the fundamental example. The quality of seed-state generation therefore sets a baseline for application performance, making it crucial to understand this process under realistic error mechanisms, particularly in integrated photonics experiments. In this work, we analyze five heralded schemes for generating event-ready photonic Bell states, contrasting their heralding probabilities, fidelities, and error robustness. We develop a hierarchy of error models, progressing from an analytically tractable lumped-loss model to realistic heralded single-photon sources with multiphoton emission errors and finally to integrated frequency-bin implementations with architecture-dependent loss. Across these models, we find that schemes based on higher-order multiphoton interference provide superior fidelity robustness in low-loss implementations, while lower-photon-number schemes can be preferable when probabilistic sources or lossy beamsplitters dominate the resource cost. Our results provide design guidance for integrated discrete-variable quantum photonics, with particular relevance for frequency-bin architectures where active beamsplitter loss can determine the optimal resource-state-generation strategy.
The effects of optical loss and photon distinguishability on the heralded generation of entangled states based on Gaussian resources are quantitatively investigated. By incorporating mode-dependent loss and the statistical characteristics of partially distinguishable photons into a phase-space representation, an efficient numerical framework is established to optimize target-state fidelity and success probability, with a specific focus on the enhancement triggered by non-Gaussian operations such as photon addition and subtraction. The numerical optimization results indicate that a non-vacuum post-selection strategy within a dual-rail encoding framework, combined with the simultaneous tuning of squeezing parameters and the interferometer network, effectively suppresses vacuum noise, enabling the generation of high-fidelity Bell, GHZ, and W states under realistic experimental constraints. The results show that introducing non-Gaussian operations can successfully enhance the state generation performance under realistic imperfections analogous to the enhancements observed under ideal conditions. This study demonstrates that experimental imperfections primarily scale down the success probability rather than fundamentally compromising the state fidelity, providing practical design guidelines for scalable state engineering on integrated photonic platforms.
The heralded generation of entangled states underpins many photonic quantum technologies. As quantum error correction thresholds are determined by underlying physical noise mechanisms, a detailed and faithful characterization of resource states is required. Non-computational leakage, e.g. more than one photon occupying a dual-rail encoded qubit, is an error not captured by standard forms of state tomography, which postselect on photons remaining in the computational subspace. Here we use the continuous-variable (CV) formalism and first quantized state representation to develop a simulation framework that reconstructs photonic quantum states in the presence of partial distinguishability and resulting non-computational leakage errors. Using these tools, we analyze a variety of Bell state generation circuits and find that the five photon discrete Fourier transform (DFT) Bell state generation scheme [Phys Rev. Lett. 126 23054 (2021)] is most robust to such errors for near-ideal photons. Through characterization of a photonic entangling gate, we demonstrate how leakage errors prevent a modular characterization of concatenated gates using current tomographical procedures. Our work is a necessary step in revealing the true noise models that must be addressed in fault-tolerant photonic quantum computing architectures.
Using only linear optical elements, the creation of dual-rail photonic entangled states is inherently probabilistic. Known entanglement generation schemes have low success probabilities, requiring large-scale multiplexing to achieve near-deterministic operation of quantum information processing protocols. In this paper, we introduce multiple techniques and methods to generate photonic entangled states with high probability, which have the potential to reduce the footprint of Linear Optical Quantum Computing (LOQC) architectures drastically. Most notably, we are showing how to improve Bell state preparation from four single photons to up to p=2/3, boost Type-I fusion to 75% with a dual-rail Bell state ancilla and improve Type-II fusion beyond the limits of Bell state discrimination.
Entangled few-photon states, such as Bell and Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, are central resources for discrete-variable photonic quantum information processing. In many architectures, these states are generated probabilistically by first heralding single photons from biphoton sources and then interfering them in linear-optical circuits. In this work, we show that the entanglement structure of said biphoton sources can be directly exploited for noise-engineering to deliver higher quality resource states. Using the transpose identity of multi-mode squeezed vacuum states, we introduce "ghost-unitary" implementations in which the target resource-generation interferometer is applied to the heralding modes rather than to the delivered resource modes. When the dominant imperfection is interferometric loss, this relocation converts direct amplitude damping of the output into false-positive heralding events that require both higher-pair emission and photon loss. In the low-squeezing regime, these events are parametrically suppressed, yielding higher-fidelity conditional resource states. We analyze this mechanism for single-qubit states, two-photon NOON states, Bell states, and a family of nnn-qubit GHZ states, as well as for single-qubit teleportation and type-I-fusion-based resource growth. Across these examples, we delineate finite parameter regimes in which ghost-unitary implementations outperform direct implementations, with particular relevance to frequency-bin photonics where active linear-optical transformations can be relatively lossy. We also prove that, in the setting considered here, the direct implementation of the nnn-GHZ family delivers identically damped outputs: equivalent to the ideal state followed by uniform amplitude damping. This extends the known n=2,3n=2,3n=2,3 cases and provides a structural result of independent interest for photonic quantum information processing.
Entanglement is the basic building block of linear optical quantum computation, and as such understanding how to generate it in detail is of great importance for optical architectures. We prove that Bell states cannot be generated using only three photons in the dual-rail encoding, and give strong numerical evidence for the optimality of the existing four photon schemes. In a setup with a single photon in each input mode, we find a fundamental limit on the possible entanglement between a single mode Alice and arbitrary Bob. We investigate and compare other setups aimed at characterizing entanglement in settings more general than dual-rail encoding. The results draw attention to the trade-off between the entanglement a state has and the probability of postselecting that state, which can give surprising constant bounds on entanglement even with increasing numbers of photons.