arXiv:2610.25685
Subsystem quantum Rényi-Bhattacharyya distance in 2D CFTs and its holographic applications
Yihao Wang, Jiaju Zhang
Abstract
We develop a systematic method to compute the subsystem fidelity and Rényi fidelity in two-dimensional conformal field theories (CFTs) from the operator product expansion of twist operators, and apply it to the subsystem quantum Bhattacharyya distance (BD) and Rényi-Bhattacharyya distance (RBD). We validate the method against exact results in the free massless fermion and boson theories, and then use it to compute the BD and RBD in holographic CFTs between two heavy primary states, between two thermal states, and between a heavy primary state and a thermal state. When the two states differ in their classical, order-$c$ data, the distances are of order $c$, and the states are distinguishable already at the level of classical gravity; when the leading data coincide, the distances are of order $1/c$ at every order of the short interval expansion, so that the distinguishability becomes a perturbative quantum gravity effect. For a heavy primary state and its thermal counterpart, the leading contribution to the BD appears at order $\ell^8$ and is of order $c^0$, whereas the RBD is generically of order $c$, in line with the earlier finding that a heavy primary state and a thermal state share the same order-$c$ entanglement entropy but have different order-$c$ Rényi entropies in the short interval expansion.
AI Summary
The paper studies how well states of a two-dimensional CFT can be distinguished on a short interval, using the Bhattacharyya distance $B=-\log F$ and its Rényi extension $B_p=-\log F_p$, where $F_p=\operatorname{tr}[(\rho\sigma)^p]/\sqrt{\operatorname{tr}\rho^{2p}\operatorname{tr}\sigma^{2p}}$ and $B=B_{1/2}$. It extends the twist-operator OPE calculation of subsystem fidelity to Rényi fidelity by organizing replica sums over alternating states. Short-interval expansions are computed through $\ell^8$, including a mixed three-quasiprimary contribution. Checks reproduce expansions of known exact results for ground and excited states in free massless fermion and boson theories. For holographic CFTs, retaining the vacuum conformal family, the calculations compare two heavy primary states, two thermal states, and an energy-matched heavy primary–thermal pair. Energy differences of order $c$, or temperature differences of order one, give distances of order $c$. Heavy-state energy differences of order one and inverse-temperature differences of order $1/c$ instead give order-$1/c$ distances at the computed interval orders. For the matched primary–thermal pair, $B$ first appears at $\ell^8$ and scales as $c^0$. Generic $B_p$ instead has an order-$c$ contribution proportional to $(1-4p^2)^2$, which vanishes at $p=1/2$. The analysis assumes translationally invariant states and short intervals; the holographic results omit non-vacuum conformal families and do not establish all-interval behavior. Including non-vacuum contributions, treating descendant states, and clarifying the role of KdV charges and generalized Gibbs ensembles are identified as further directions.
from which one can use Seed-2.1-Pro and obtain the general expressions
Central claim may not hold: The claim of 1/c scaling at every short-interval order exceeds the demonstrated expansion through ℓ⁸ and lacks an all-orders argument. The abstract presents scaling statements for subsystem distances that the calculations establish only after restricting to the vacuum conformal family, without bounding non-vacuum contributions. The advertised universal mixed-operator coefficient lacks a general derivation of its replica continuation, although its integer-dimensional formulas and the coefficient needed for the applications withstand independent checking.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 20 pages, no figure