Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.24857

Where should we look for the deviation from quantum mechanics?

Jerome Nicolas, Albert Schwarz

quant-phhep-exhep-thmath-phSubmitted Oct 17, 2026• Announced Oct 20, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We argue that the experimental measurement of the lifetime and decay law of metastable helium is a promising way to find a deviation from quantum mechanics. We analyze the decay of the metastable state for a quartic deformation of quantum mechanics. We find that the absolute change of the mean lifetime can be significant even if the modification is small. We show that, in the Wigner--Weisskopf approximation, the deviation from the exponential law in the modified theory can occur on time scales comparable with the lifetime.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether long-lived metastable helium can test nonlinear deviations from quantum mechanics through its lifetime and decay curve. It studies the $2\,{}^3S_1\to1\,{}^1S_0$ magnetic-dipole transition, whose reported lifetime is $7870(510)$ s, using a rotating-wave atom–photon model with an added quartic Hamiltonian term $A_1n_1^2$, where $n_1$ is the excited-state probability. Photon dynamics and the transition magnetic moment remain unchanged. Eliminating the photon amplitudes gives an exact nonlinear memory equation within this model. A short-memory, Wigner–Weisskopf reduction yields $\dot x=-\Gamma(x)x$, with $\Gamma(x)=2\pi J(\omega_0+2A_1x/\hbar)$. For a locally cubic spectral density and $\varepsilon=|A_1|/\Delta E\ll1$, the mean survival time satisfies $\tau_{\rm mean}/\tau_0=1-3A_1/\Delta E+O(\varepsilon^2)$. The logarithmic decay rate changes from $\Gamma_0[1+6A_1/\Delta E+O(\varepsilon^2)]$ toward $\Gamma_0$, producing nonexponentiality on the lifetime timescale. However, comparison with an ordinary atom at the corrected stationary gap $\Delta E+A_1$ removes the first-order mean-lifetime difference; the curve-shape change remains. The predictions require a smooth reservoir, short memory, and validity of the local spectral-density approximation across the shifted resonance range. No quantitative memory-error bound for helium is supplied. A long lifetime increases the absolute, not fractional, mean-lifetime change. Ordinary collision and boundary losses can mimic nonexponential decay; the proposed rate–mean relation is not a unique deformation signature. The framework also leaves prescriptions for multiple atoms, mixtures, and measurements unspecified.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalStrong assumptionsMissing comparisonOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The advertised first-order mean-lifetime shift depends on comparing at the undeformed gap; comparison with an ordinary atom at the corrected stationary gap removes that shift to first order, although the decay-shape change remains. The paper does not quantitatively establish that helium's long lifetime improves sensitivity to the deformation, since the fractional lifetime shift is not enhanced and experimental precision and backgrounds are not assessed. The cited short-window experiment probes the reduced initial rate rather than the mean survival time, and ordinary one- and two-body losses can mimic the first-order predicted decay curve for a nonnegative population-dependent rate correction.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
11 pages

Related papers

Oscillations in the Decay Law: A Possible Quantum Mechanical Explanation of the Anomaly in the Experiment at the GSI Facility

Francesco Giacosa, Giuseppe Pagliara

We study the deviations from the usual exponential decay law for quantum mechanical systems. We show that simple and physically motivated deviations from the Breit-Wigner energy distribution of the unstable state are sufficient to generate peculiar deviations from the exponential decay law. Denoting with $p(t)$ the survival probability, its derivative $h(t)$ shows typically an oscillating behavior on top of the usual exponential function. We argue that this can be a viable explanation of the observed experimental results at GSI Darmstadt, where the function $h(t)$ has been experimentally measured for electron capture decays of Hydrogen-like ions. Moreover, if our interpretation is correct, we predict that by measuring $h(t)$ at times close to the initial one, the number of decays per second rapidly drops to zero.

arXiv:1110.1669•Quantum Matter•Feb 1, 2013•31 citations

DEVIATION FROM THE EXPONENTIAL DECAY LAW IN RELATIVISTIC QUANTUM FIELD THEORY: THE EXAMPLE OF STRONGLY DECAYING PARTICLES

Francesco Giacosa, Giuseppe Pagliara

We show that a short-time regime, in which a deviation from the exponential decay law occurs, exists also in the framework of a superrenormalizable relativistic quantum field theory. This, in turn, implies the possibility of a quantum Zeno effect also for elementary decays. The attention is then focused on the typical order of magnitude of strong decay rates of mesons: for these particles, strong deviations from the exponential decay law are present during a period of time comparable with their mean lifetime. As a concrete example, the case of the ρ meson is studied.

arXiv:1005.4817•Modern Physics Letters A•Sep 5, 2011•39 citations

Nonexponential decay at late times and a different Zeno paradox

Jay Lawrence

The decay profile of a metastable quantum state decaying in isolation is predicted to depart from exponential behaviour after many lifetimes, and in typical cases to adopt algebraic behaviour as the late-time limit. The effect of environmental interactions, including measurement, is quite different from that of the familiar Zeno (and anti-Zeno) effects that have been observed at very early times. Instead of arresting the decay (or hastening it), the late-time interactions tend to enforce the exponential decay law, without substantially changing the decay constant intrinsic to the isolated system. The experimental challenge is to prevent these interactions and observe the crossover to the nonexponential regime.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Aug 1, 2002•12 citations

Non-exponential decay in Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Field Theory

Francesco Giacosa

We describe some salient features as well as some recent developments concerning short-time deviations from the exponential decay law in the context of Quantum Mechanics by using the Lee Hamiltonian approach and Quantum Field Theory by using relativistic Lagrangians. In particular, the case in which two decay channels are present is analyzed: the ratio of decay probability densities, which is a constant equal to the ratio of decay widths in the exponential limit, shows in general sizable fluctuations which persist also at long times.

arXiv:1312.3315•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Oct 10, 2014•4 citations

Decay law of unstable states

Jan Mostowski, K. Wódkiewicz

An outline of the Wigner-Weisskopf theory of unstable states is presented. Numerical analysis of the decay law is given, deviations from the exponential decay law are studied in some detail. The interpretation of the nonexponential decay law is also briefly discussed. (auth)

•Jan 1, 1973•1 citation

Influence of the measurement on the decay law: the bang-bang case

Francesco Giacosa, Giuseppe Pagliara

After reviewing the description of an unstable state in the framework of nonrelativistic Quantum Mechanics (QM) and relativistic Quantum Field Theory (QFT), we consider the effect of pulsed, ideal measurements repeated at equal time intervals on the lifetime of an unstable system. In particular, we investigate the case in which the ‘bare’ survival probability is an exact exponential (a very good approximation in both QM and QFT), but the measurement apparatus can detect the decay products only in a certain energy range. We show that the Quantum Zeno Effect can occur in this framework as well.

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2015•2 citations
We argue that the experimental measurement of the lifetime and decay law of metastable helium is a promising way to find a deviation from quantum mechanics. We analyze the decay of the metastable state for a quartic deformation of quantum mechanics. We find that the absolute change of the mean lifetime can be significant even if the modification is small. We show that, in the Wigner--Weisskopf approximation, the deviation from the exponential law in the modified theory can occur on time scales comparable with the lifetime.
The paper asks whether long-lived metastable helium can test nonlinear deviations from quantum mechanics through its lifetime and decay curve. It studies the 2 3S1→1 1S02\,{}^3S_1\to1\,{}^1S_023S1​→11S0​ magnetic-dipole transition, whose reported lifetime is 7870(510)7870(510)7870(510) s, using a rotating-wave atom–photon model with an added quartic Hamiltonian term A1n12A_1n_1^2A1​n12​, where n1n_1n1​ is the excited-state probability. Photon dynamics and the transition magnetic moment remain unchanged.
Eliminating the photon amplitudes gives an exact nonlinear memory equation within this model. A short-memory, Wigner–Weisskopf reduction yields x˙=−Γ(x)x\dot x=-\Gamma(x)xx˙=−Γ(x)x, with Γ(x)=2πJ(ω0+2A1x/ℏ)\Gamma(x)=2\pi J(\omega_0+2A_1x/\hbar)Γ(x)=2πJ(ω0​+2A1​x/ℏ). For a locally cubic spectral density and ε=∣A1∣/ΔE≪1\varepsilon=|A_1|/\Delta E\ll1ε=∣A1​∣/ΔE≪1, the mean survival time satisfies τmean/τ0=1−3A1/ΔE+O(ε2)\tau_{\rm mean}/\tau_0=1-3A_1/\Delta E+O(\varepsilon^2)τmean​/τ0​=1−3A1​/ΔE+O(ε2). The logarithmic decay rate changes from Γ0[1+6A1/ΔE+O(ε2)]\Gamma_0[1+6A_1/\Delta E+O(\varepsilon^2)]Γ0​[1+6A1​/ΔE+O(ε2)] toward Γ0\Gamma_0Γ0​, producing nonexponentiality on the lifetime timescale. However, comparison with an ordinary atom at the corrected stationary gap ΔE+A1\Delta E+A_1ΔE+A1​ removes the first-order mean-lifetime difference; the curve-shape change remains.
The predictions require a smooth reservoir, short memory, and validity of the local spectral-density approximation across the shifted resonance range. No quantitative memory-error bound for helium is supplied. A long lifetime increases the absolute, not fractional, mean-lifetime change. Ordinary collision and boundary losses can mimic nonexponential decay; the proposed rate–mean relation is not a unique deformation signature. The framework also leaves prescriptions for multiple atoms, mixtures, and measurements unspecified.
We study the deviations from the usual exponential decay law for quantum mechanical systems. We show that simple and physically motivated deviations from the Breit-Wigner energy distribution of the unstable state are sufficient to generate peculiar deviations from the exponential decay law. Denoting with p(t)p(t)p(t) the survival probability, its derivative h(t)h(t)h(t) shows typically an oscillating behavior on top of the usual exponential function. We argue that this can be a viable explanation of the observed experimental results at GSI Darmstadt, where the function h(t)h(t)h(t) has been experimentally measured for electron capture decays of Hydrogen-like ions. Moreover, if our interpretation is correct, we predict that by measuring h(t)h(t)h(t) at times close to the initial one, the number of decays per second rapidly drops to zero.
We show that a short-time regime, in which a deviation from the exponential decay law occurs, exists also in the framework of a superrenormalizable relativistic quantum field theory. This, in turn, implies the possibility of a quantum Zeno effect also for elementary decays. The attention is then focused on the typical order of magnitude of strong decay rates of mesons: for these particles, strong deviations from the exponential decay law are present during a period of time comparable with their mean lifetime. As a concrete example, the case of the ρ meson is studied.
The decay profile of a metastable quantum state decaying in isolation is predicted to depart from exponential behaviour after many lifetimes, and in typical cases to adopt algebraic behaviour as the late-time limit. The effect of environmental interactions, including measurement, is quite different from that of the familiar Zeno (and anti-Zeno) effects that have been observed at very early times. Instead of arresting the decay (or hastening it), the late-time interactions tend to enforce the exponential decay law, without substantially changing the decay constant intrinsic to the isolated system. The experimental challenge is to prevent these interactions and observe the crossover to the nonexponential regime.
We describe some salient features as well as some recent developments concerning short-time deviations from the exponential decay law in the context of Quantum Mechanics by using the Lee Hamiltonian approach and Quantum Field Theory by using relativistic Lagrangians. In particular, the case in which two decay channels are present is analyzed: the ratio of decay probability densities, which is a constant equal to the ratio of decay widths in the exponential limit, shows in general sizable fluctuations which persist also at long times.
After reviewing the description of an unstable state in the framework of nonrelativistic Quantum Mechanics (QM) and relativistic Quantum Field Theory (QFT), we consider the effect of pulsed, ideal measurements repeated at equal time intervals on the lifetime of an unstable system. In particular, we investigate the case in which the ‘bare’ survival probability is an exact exponential (a very good approximation in both QM and QFT), but the measurement apparatus can detect the decay products only in a certain energy range. We show that the Quantum Zeno Effect can occur in this framework as well.