Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.24440

Certifying Nonlocal Spin Quantum Entanglement from Local Tunneling Spectra

Payman Kazemikhah, Ruolun Zhang, Xiangyu Luo, Byunghoon Kim, Yu-Peng Zhu, Md. Shafayat Hossain, M. Zahid Hasan

quant-phcond-mat.str-elphysics.app-phSubmitted Oct 17, 2026• Announced Oct 20, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum entanglement is intrinsically nonlocal, whereas tunneling spectroscopy measures one site at a time. We show that this apparent mismatch can be overcome: local tunneling spectra can certify spin entanglement without coherent control or absolute intensity calibration. An exact spin sum rule turns the high-bias conductance into an internal normalization, allowing the inelastic spin-flip weight to place a lower bound on the local quantum Fisher information. Total-spin conservation then fixes the otherwise inaccessible intersite fluctuation, converting two local spectra into a bound on a collective entanglement witness. We incorporate coupling to the substrate through a spectroscopic bound on spin leakage, while a hierarchy of thresholds distinguishes entanglement between the spins from entanglement with their environment. Including instrumental broadening and noise, the resulting certificate holds at a stated confidence level. These results establish a route for extracting nonlocal quantum information from equilibrium local spectroscopy.

AI Summary

Can equilibrium, site-resolved tunneling spectra certify entanglement between two spins without coherent control or absolute intensity calibration? This paper combines the thermal susceptibility–quantum Fisher information (QFI) relation with a fixed-spin spectral sum rule. Normalizing inelastic spectral weight by the high-bias conductance gives $D_i^{\rm low}\le D_i$, with ideal-data ratio $D_i/[1+r^2/S(S+1)]$, where $r$ is the spin-conserving/exchange tunneling-amplitude ratio. For a dimer, the staggered, three-axis QFI satisfies $W=2(D_1+D_2)-\epsilon$, where $\epsilon$ is the QFI of the cluster’s total spin. For spin-$1/2$, thresholds $W>4$, $6$, and $8$ respectively exclude full separability, separability into spins with private environments, and separability of the reduced two-spin state. The last gives concurrence $C\ge(W-8)/4$. For an isolated antiferromagnetic dimer, $W>8$ requires $T<0.377J$ with ideal exchange-only tunneling; at low temperature, calibration-free certification requires the inelastic step to exceed two-thirds of the plateau. Nonnegative spectral inversion is formulated as linear programming with instrumental-kernel enclosures and simultaneous noise tolerances. Synthetic spectra, exact diagonalization and numerical renormalization-group calculations test the bounds and substrate effects. Certification assumes identified fixed local moments, weak equilibrium tunneling, and bounded temperature and instrumental parameters. Substrate leakage is estimated from linewidths using perturbation theory and numerical correction factors dependent on bath geometry; conservativeness with measured linewidths beyond leading order remains an expectation, not a demonstrated bound. Local spectra cannot distinguish hidden screening partners, and larger clusters generally require intersite information.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptions

Central claim may not hold: The linewidth-to-leakage prescription is a perturbative and numerically supported estimate, not the established upper bound required for a rigorous substrate-corrected entanglement certificate. The stated statistical confidence controls spectral measurement noise only conditional on a valid leakage upper bound, which the measured-linewidth prescription does not establish. The claim that the required assumptions can all be checked through spectral compatibility is overstated, since the paper itself exhibits indistinguishable local spectra requiring independent cluster identification. For U/t = 16, the Hubbard-dimer double occupancy per site is approximately 0.746%, not the main text's 1.5%, making its use of d inconsistent with the supplement.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Imaging spin entanglement with a scanning tunneling microscope

J. C. G. Henriques, B. Viña-Bausá, I. Brihuega +1 more

Artificial spin arrays assembled on surfaces enable atomic-scale studies of quantum correlations. Here we establish a hierarchy of connections between spin inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) and entanglement in spin-$1/2$ systems. We first show that the number of spectroscopically active transitions in a spin-$1/2$ dimer serves as an entanglement witness. Using the leading-order tunneling conductance for the tip placed on spin $i$, $dI(i)/dV$, we then relate spectral moments $\mathcal{M}^{(n)}(i)=\int V^n(d^2I(i)/dV^2)\,dV$ to quantum correlations. The zeroth moment probes the one-tangle in systems with a gapped, nondegenerate ground state. For rotationally invariant Heisenberg systems, the first moment yields thermal spin correlators $\langle\boldsymbol S(i)\cdot\boldsymbol S(j)\rangle$, enabling reconstruction of nearest-neighbor concurrence and spatial imaging of entanglement in spin chains. It also provides access to the internal energy and magnetic specific heat, both usable as entanglement witnesses. Applying this approach to experimental IETS data from nanographene spin chains, we find good agreement with theory. We further discuss how the second moment probes longer-range correlations and the inverse moment relates to local spin susceptibility. For spin-$1/2$ trimers, we connect inter-multiplet inelastic spectral weight to genuine tripartite entanglement quantified by the concurrence fill. Finally, we reconcile the local character of IETS with its sensitivity to nonlocal entanglement through an analogy with digital quantum circuits, where Hamiltonian evolution implements multiqubit operations. These results establish IETS as a tool for quantifying and imaging entanglement in engineered on-surface spin systems.

arXiv:2611.10946•Nov 7, 2026•0 citations

Witnessing entanglement with nonlocal operation

Weidong Li

The certification of entanglement is a vital task in quantum technology. To theoretically quantify and experimentally detect entanglement of many qubits, we suggest to identify quantum entanglement by measuring the statistical response of a quantum system to an arbitrary nonlocal parametric evolution. Our suggestion does not basing on the tomographic reconstruction of the quantum state, or the realization of witness operators. The protocol requires two collective settings for any number of parties and is robust against noise and decoherence occurring after the implementation of the parametric transformation. The bounds for witnessing quantum entanglement with strength of nonlocal interaction are shown with the help of Ising nonlocal Hamiltonian. Furthermore to illustrate its user friendliness we demonstrate multipartite entanglement in different experiments with ions and photons by analyzing published data on fidelity visibilities and variances of collective observables.

Quantum Information and Measurement (QIM)•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Quantum nonlocality via local contextuality with qubit-qubit entanglement

Debashis Saha, Adán Cabello, Sujit K. Choudhary +1 more

Quantum nonlocality can be revealed ``via local contextuality'' in qudit-qudit entangled systems with $d>2$, that is, through the violation of inequalities containing Alice-Bob correlations that admit a local description, and Alice-Alice correlations (between the results of sequences of measurements on Alice's subsystem) that admit a local (but contextual) description. A fundamental question to understand the respective roles of entanglement and local contextuality is whether nonlocality via local contextuality exists when the parties have only qubit-qubit entanglement. Here we respond affirmatively to this question. This result further clarifies the connection between contextuality and nonlocality and opens the door for observing nonlocality via local contextuality in actual experiments.

arXiv:1507.08480•Physical Review A•Apr 28, 2016•6 citations

Multipartite entanglement hidden in vector-chiral correlations of spin-1/2 chains

Tokuro Shimokawa

Characterizing entanglement in quantum materials through experimentally accessible observables remains a central challenge. Quantum Fisher information associated with sums of one-site spin operators provides one route by linking entanglement to measurable magnetic response functions. Extending this approach to local composite observables requires new entanglement bounds. Here we establish a rigorous bound for the total nearest-neighbour vector chirality of periodic spin-$1/2$ chains with an even number of sites. The quantum Fisher information per spin cannot exceed $k+1$ for any $k$-producible state, so exceeding this bound certifies entanglement depth of at least $k+1$. Combining infinite density-matrix renormalization group and thermal pure quantum-state calculations, we demonstrate multipartite entanglement encoded in vector-chiral correlations at zero and finite temperatures in an extended $J_1$-$J_2$ XXZ chain. The spin-current coupling between vector chirality and electric polarization offers, in principle, access to this witness through dielectric loss spectroscopy in multiferroic magnets, extending entanglement diagnostics beyond dipolar spin correlations.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2609.39258•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Transport-Noise Witnesses of Electronic Multipartite Entanglement

Shuhan Ding, Prakash Sharma, Zecheng Shen +3 more

Entanglement among particles is a defining feature of strongly correlated quantum materials, distinguishing them from conventional metals and semiconductors. The ability to certify intrinsic entanglement among interacting electrons in solid-state materials is important not only for classifying quantum states of matter, but also for developing material-based quantum technologies. Here, we introduce a transport-based protocol for witnessing multipartite entangled electronic states, based on the equilibrium noise spectrum as an experimentally accessible observable. The appropriately integrated, symmetrized, and projected current noise obeys an upper bound that can be derived from microscopic model parameters and is invariant with respect to the choice of electronic basis. We benchmark this framework in several paradigmatic systems, including twisted bilayer graphene, twisted bilayer MoTe$_2$, and Hubbard models, certifying entanglement in the fractional Chern insulating state. The method extends recently developed scattering-based entanglement witnesses to ultralow-temperature materials, where conventional spectroscopic probes are inaccessible but candidate entangled states are expected to arise.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2608.16028•Aug 18, 2026•0 citations

Bell-certified retardance polarimetry from CHSH correlators

Juan Sumaya-Martinez

Bell--CHSH measurements with polarization-entangled photons are usually reported only as nonlocality witnesses. Here we show that, for retardance sensing, the same coincidence data can also provide a quantitative metrological certificate. For a local birefringent phase $\phi$ encoded on one photon, we derive the classical Fisher information directly from experimentally accessible CHSH correlators $E_{xy}(\phi)$ and obtain an explicit lower bound in terms of the measured correlators and the phase slope $S'(\phi)$ of the Bell parameter. In the unbiased-marginal two-qubit regime, this leads to a dual-use result: the canonical CHSH analyzer settings are simultaneously Bell-optimal and Fisher-optimal, saturating the quantum Fisher information for retardance estimation. We further show that the certificate remains informative under visibility loss, finite counts, and moderate departure from the Bell-violation threshold, so useful retardance sensitivity can persist even when nonlocality certification is weak or absent. Relative to tomography-based entangled-photon polarimetry, the method converts a standard Bell-calibration run into a sensitivity statement with rigorous lower confidence bounds using only coincidence correlators. The scheme is implementable with standard SPDC sources, wave plates, and polarizing beam splitters.

•May 7, 2026•0 citations
Quantum entanglement is intrinsically nonlocal, whereas tunneling spectroscopy measures one site at a time. We show that this apparent mismatch can be overcome: local tunneling spectra can certify spin entanglement without coherent control or absolute intensity calibration. An exact spin sum rule turns the high-bias conductance into an internal normalization, allowing the inelastic spin-flip weight to place a lower bound on the local quantum Fisher information. Total-spin conservation then fixes the otherwise inaccessible intersite fluctuation, converting two local spectra into a bound on a collective entanglement witness. We incorporate coupling to the substrate through a spectroscopic bound on spin leakage, while a hierarchy of thresholds distinguishes entanglement between the spins from entanglement with their environment. Including instrumental broadening and noise, the resulting certificate holds at a stated confidence level. These results establish a route for extracting nonlocal quantum information from equilibrium local spectroscopy.
Can equilibrium, site-resolved tunneling spectra certify entanglement between two spins without coherent control or absolute intensity calibration? This paper combines the thermal susceptibility–quantum Fisher information (QFI) relation with a fixed-spin spectral sum rule. Normalizing inelastic spectral weight by the high-bias conductance gives Dilow≤DiD_i^{\rm low}\le D_iDilow​≤Di​, with ideal-data ratio Di/[1+r2/S(S+1)]D_i/[1+r^2/S(S+1)]Di​/[1+r2/S(S+1)], where rrr is the spin-conserving/exchange tunneling-amplitude ratio.
For a dimer, the staggered, three-axis QFI satisfies W=2(D1+D2)−ϵW=2(D_1+D_2)-\epsilonW=2(D1​+D2​)−ϵ, where ϵ\epsilonϵ is the QFI of the cluster’s total spin. For spin-1/21/21/2, thresholds W>4W>4W>4, 666, and 888 respectively exclude full separability, separability into spins with private environments, and separability of the reduced two-spin state. The last gives concurrence C≥(W−8)/4C\ge(W-8)/4C≥(W−8)/4. For an isolated antiferromagnetic dimer, W>8W>8W>8 requires T<0.377JT<0.377JT<0.377J with ideal exchange-only tunneling; at low temperature, calibration-free certification requires the inelastic step to exceed two-thirds of the plateau.
Nonnegative spectral inversion is formulated as linear programming with instrumental-kernel enclosures and simultaneous noise tolerances. Synthetic spectra, exact diagonalization and numerical renormalization-group calculations test the bounds and substrate effects.
Certification assumes identified fixed local moments, weak equilibrium tunneling, and bounded temperature and instrumental parameters. Substrate leakage is estimated from linewidths using perturbation theory and numerical correction factors dependent on bath geometry; conservativeness with measured linewidths beyond leading order remains an expectation, not a demonstrated bound. Local spectra cannot distinguish hidden screening partners, and larger clusters generally require intersite information.
Artificial spin arrays assembled on surfaces enable atomic-scale studies of quantum correlations. Here we establish a hierarchy of connections between spin inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) and entanglement in spin-1/21/21/2 systems. We first show that the number of spectroscopically active transitions in a spin-1/21/21/2 dimer serves as an entanglement witness. Using the leading-order tunneling conductance for the tip placed on spin iii, dI(i)/dVdI(i)/dVdI(i)/dV, we then relate spectral moments M(n)(i)=∫Vn(d2I(i)/dV2) dV\mathcal{M}^{(n)}(i)=\int V^n(d^2I(i)/dV^2)\,dVM(n)(i)=∫Vn(d2I(i)/dV2)dV to quantum correlations. The zeroth moment probes the one-tangle in systems with a gapped, nondegenerate ground state. For rotationally invariant Heisenberg systems, the first moment yields thermal spin correlators ⟨S(i)⋅S(j)⟩\langle\boldsymbol S(i)\cdot\boldsymbol S(j)\rangle⟨S(i)⋅S(j)⟩, enabling reconstruction of nearest-neighbor concurrence and spatial imaging of entanglement in spin chains. It also provides access to the internal energy and magnetic specific heat, both usable as entanglement witnesses. Applying this approach to experimental IETS data from nanographene spin chains, we find good agreement with theory. We further discuss how the second moment probes longer-range correlations and the inverse moment relates to local spin susceptibility. For spin-1/21/21/2 trimers, we connect inter-multiplet inelastic spectral weight to genuine tripartite entanglement quantified by the concurrence fill. Finally, we reconcile the local character of IETS with its sensitivity to nonlocal entanglement through an analogy with digital quantum circuits, where Hamiltonian evolution implements multiqubit operations. These results establish IETS as a tool for quantifying and imaging entanglement in engineered on-surface spin systems.
The certification of entanglement is a vital task in quantum technology. To theoretically quantify and experimentally detect entanglement of many qubits, we suggest to identify quantum entanglement by measuring the statistical response of a quantum system to an arbitrary nonlocal parametric evolution. Our suggestion does not basing on the tomographic reconstruction of the quantum state, or the realization of witness operators. The protocol requires two collective settings for any number of parties and is robust against noise and decoherence occurring after the implementation of the parametric transformation. The bounds for witnessing quantum entanglement with strength of nonlocal interaction are shown with the help of Ising nonlocal Hamiltonian. Furthermore to illustrate its user friendliness we demonstrate multipartite entanglement in different experiments with ions and photons by analyzing published data on fidelity visibilities and variances of collective observables.
Quantum nonlocality can be revealed ``via local contextuality'' in qudit-qudit entangled systems with d>2d>2d>2, that is, through the violation of inequalities containing Alice-Bob correlations that admit a local description, and Alice-Alice correlations (between the results of sequences of measurements on Alice's subsystem) that admit a local (but contextual) description. A fundamental question to understand the respective roles of entanglement and local contextuality is whether nonlocality via local contextuality exists when the parties have only qubit-qubit entanglement. Here we respond affirmatively to this question. This result further clarifies the connection between contextuality and nonlocality and opens the door for observing nonlocality via local contextuality in actual experiments.
Characterizing entanglement in quantum materials through experimentally accessible observables remains a central challenge. Quantum Fisher information associated with sums of one-site spin operators provides one route by linking entanglement to measurable magnetic response functions. Extending this approach to local composite observables requires new entanglement bounds. Here we establish a rigorous bound for the total nearest-neighbour vector chirality of periodic spin-1/21/21/2 chains with an even number of sites. The quantum Fisher information per spin cannot exceed k+1k+1k+1 for any kkk-producible state, so exceeding this bound certifies entanglement depth of at least k+1k+1k+1. Combining infinite density-matrix renormalization group and thermal pure quantum-state calculations, we demonstrate multipartite entanglement encoded in vector-chiral correlations at zero and finite temperatures in an extended J1J_1J1​-J2J_2J2​ XXZ chain. The spin-current coupling between vector chirality and electric polarization offers, in principle, access to this witness through dielectric loss spectroscopy in multiferroic magnets, extending entanglement diagnostics beyond dipolar spin correlations.
Entanglement among particles is a defining feature of strongly correlated quantum materials, distinguishing them from conventional metals and semiconductors. The ability to certify intrinsic entanglement among interacting electrons in solid-state materials is important not only for classifying quantum states of matter, but also for developing material-based quantum technologies. Here, we introduce a transport-based protocol for witnessing multipartite entangled electronic states, based on the equilibrium noise spectrum as an experimentally accessible observable. The appropriately integrated, symmetrized, and projected current noise obeys an upper bound that can be derived from microscopic model parameters and is invariant with respect to the choice of electronic basis. We benchmark this framework in several paradigmatic systems, including twisted bilayer graphene, twisted bilayer MoTe2_22​, and Hubbard models, certifying entanglement in the fractional Chern insulating state. The method extends recently developed scattering-based entanglement witnesses to ultralow-temperature materials, where conventional spectroscopic probes are inaccessible but candidate entangled states are expected to arise.
Bell--CHSH measurements with polarization-entangled photons are usually reported only as nonlocality witnesses. Here we show that, for retardance sensing, the same coincidence data can also provide a quantitative metrological certificate. For a local birefringent phase ϕ\phiϕ encoded on one photon, we derive the classical Fisher information directly from experimentally accessible CHSH correlators Exy(ϕ)E_{xy}(\phi)Exy​(ϕ) and obtain an explicit lower bound in terms of the measured correlators and the phase slope S′(ϕ)S'(\phi)S′(ϕ) of the Bell parameter. In the unbiased-marginal two-qubit regime, this leads to a dual-use result: the canonical CHSH analyzer settings are simultaneously Bell-optimal and Fisher-optimal, saturating the quantum Fisher information for retardance estimation. We further show that the certificate remains informative under visibility loss, finite counts, and moderate departure from the Bell-violation threshold, so useful retardance sensitivity can persist even when nonlocality certification is weak or absent. Relative to tomography-based entangled-photon polarimetry, the method converts a standard Bell-calibration run into a sensitivity statement with rigorous lower confidence bounds using only coincidence correlators. The scheme is implementable with standard SPDC sources, wave plates, and polarizing beam splitters.