Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.24196 · EPJ Quantum Technology

Nonlocality as a Benchmarking Tool for Quantum Processors

Andrés Camilo Granda Arango, Carla Sophie Rieger, Carlo Cuccu, Giuseppe Sergioli, Luigi Iapichino, Tobias Valentin Bauer, Roberto Giuntini, Federico Hernán Holik

quant-phSubmitted Oct 16, 2026• Announced Oct 20, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Benchmarking quantum processors is a central task in every roadmap aimed at quantum advantage. Here, we discuss a benchmarking protocol based on the violation of the Svetlichny inequality, which is designed to simulate genuine multipartite nonlocality. We compare it with Mermin's inequality, and present the results of applying this framework to two different quantum processing units -the superconducting system Garnet (from IQM) and the ion-trap system Marmot (from AQT), testing different families of quantum circuits for three to five qubits under identical experimental conditions. We also run simultaneous triplet tests across the full register, including a comparison between GHZ and linear cluster states, to probe how Svetlichny-inequality violations depend on qubit location and calibration. Our results demonstrate that tests based on genuine multipartite nonlocality provide a powerful tool to characterize the collective performance of quantum devices and to guide their calibration and optimization.

AI Summary

The paper examines whether Svetlichny-inequality tests can benchmark collective processor performance more stringently than Mermin tests. It extends an existing protocol using GHZ states, Clifford circuits, and Clifford+$T$ circuits on superconducting Garnet and trapped-ion Marmot processors, principally with 3–5 qubits. Measurement directions are optimized numerically for ideal states, then the corresponding correlations are reconstructed experimentally. Random-circuit experiments select low-depth representatives across ideal violation ranges rather than executing the full sampled ensemble. The Svetlichny hybrid-local bound is $2^{N-1}$, with quantum maximum $2^{N-1}\sqrt{2}$. For GHZ states, Garnet yields $4.39\pm0.10$, $7.72\pm0.09$, and $12.3\pm0.50$ for 3, 4, and 5 qubits, respectively: only the three-qubit result exceeds its bound. Marmot yields $5.39\pm0.05$, $9.83\pm0.26$, and $18.68\pm0.74$, exceeding all three bounds. Both devices retain Mermin violations through five qubits. These values summarize 20 repetitions; uncertainties are standard deviations. Depolarizing-noise simulations show that the fraction of circuits retaining Svetlichny violations decreases faster than for Mermin violations, alongside a comparison with Grover-search success. Additional three-qubit tests resolve location- and time-dependent performance on Garnet. Simultaneous tests on four disjoint Marmot triplets show similar performance across triplets but greater dispersion than isolated tests. Stated limitations include the absence of spacelike-separated measurements, precluding loophole-free nonlocality certification; unequal shot counts between platforms; exponential measurement resources; and the fact that failure to violate Svetlichny does not exclude genuine multipartite nonlocality detectable by other inequalities.

Some signs of AI-generated textIncrementalOverclaimsMissing comparison

Error found: The abstract's assertion of identical experimental conditions overlooks the tenfold difference in shots per circuit between Garnet and Marmot. The explanation that Svetlichny violations disappear because higher-order correlations degrade preferentially is unsupported: both operators contain full N-party correlators, and the GHZ data exhibit nearly equal fractional attenuation with different violation thresholds. The claim that random circuits make the benchmark unbiased overlooks explicit selection for ideal violations, shallow circuits, and low entangling-gate counts. Several reported normalized violation ratios have signs inconsistent with their definition, and that definition does not preserve the stated sign interpretation for states whose ideal expectation is below the classical bound.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Journal reference
EPJ Quantum Technology, 2026
Comments
23 pages, 14 figures, 5 tables

Related papers

Generalized Svetlichny Inequalities as a Cross-Platform Benchmark for Quantum Processors

Andrés Camilo Granda Arango, Giuseppe Sergioli, Luigi Iapichino +3 more

A cross-platform benchmark should be device-independent yet sensitive to imperfections accumulated during execution. Building on prior work, we formulate and validate a protocol through demonstrations based on generalized Svetlichny inequality violations (a simulation, rather than a loophole-free certification, of multipartite nonlocality) for larger subsystem sizes. We apply it unchanged to three processors, the trapped-ion Marmot and IBEX Q1 (both manufactured by AQT) and the superconducting Euro-Q-Exa System 1 (IQM), using identical GHZ-state circuits with fixed theoretical measurement settings from N=2 to N=10 qubits. Both trapped-ion processors sustain violations up to ten qubits, while the superconducting processor loses them beyond six qubits under unmitigated (raw) conditions; readout-error mitigation recovers violations up to eight qubits, with a substantial fraction of the degradation attributable to measurement imperfections. These processors provide a heterogeneous testbed for validating the protocol's cross-platform applicability and discriminating power, demonstrating its practicality as a common framework for assessing collective quantum performance.

quant-pharXiv:2610.24213•Oct 20, 2026•0 citations

Distribution of nonlocality on quantum random circuits

Andrés Camilo Granda Arango, Federico Holik, Roberto Giuntini +2 more

In this work we explore how different types of resources are distributed among the states generated by quantum random circuits. We focus on multipartite nonlocality, but we also analyze quantum correlations by appealing to different entanglement and nonclassicality measures. We analyze the violation of Mermin and Svetlichny inequalities in order to get a glance at the distribution of nonlocality and genuine multipartite nonlocality. Next, we compare universal vs nonuniversal sets of gates, to gain insight into the problem of explaining quantum advantage. By comparing the results obtained with ideal (noiseless) vs noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, we lay the basis of a certification protocol, which aims to quantify how robust is the resources distribution among the states that a given device can generate. We have implemented our nonlocality-based benchmark on actual quantum processors with different architectures, in order to assess up to which point they are capable of reproducing the ideal results.

arXiv:2405.01650•Physical Review A•Oct 23, 2025•3 citations

Cross-Platform Benchmarking of GHZ-State Generation in Quantum Processors via Cloud Services

Sergio Hernández, Unai Aseguinolaza, David Aguirre +10 more

Quantum computing has rapidly evolved into a diverse ecosystem of hardware platforms that differ in their underlying technologies and operational characteristics. Consequently, benchmarking has become essential for identifying the strengths of quantum processors, comparing their performance, and enabling informed decisions when selecting the most appropriate quantum computing platform for specific applications. In this work, we benchmark nine commercially accessible quantum processors from five vendors, spanning superconducting and trapped-ion technologies, using the multipartite entanglement benchmark from the QuSquare suite. All experiments were performed through remote cloud-access services, with the default compilation of each provider and without error mitigation, reflecting the performance experienced by end users. The benchmark estimates the fidelity of Greenberger--Horne--Zeilinger (GHZ) states by direct fidelity estimation and searches for the largest GHZ state whose fidelity is compatible, within the statistical error, with the genuine multipartite entanglement (GME) threshold $F=1/2$. Our results reveal a substantial gap between the total number of physical qubits available on a processor and the size of the largest GHZ state passing the benchmark: the best superconducting processors reach $N^*=27$ and $N^*=24$ qubits, less than a quarter of their registers, whereas the 12-qubit trapped-ion processor passes with its full register. We further show that median calibration data are poor predictors of the benchmark outcome, and that the reported sizes depend strongly on the statistical decision rule: requiring certified GME reduces the number of devices that succeed at any tested size from nine to four. These results provide a baseline for future cross-platform benchmarking of quantum processors.

arXiv:2611.14114•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations

Experimental demonstration of genuine multipartite quantum nonlocality without shared reference frames

Zhao Wang, Chao Zhang, Yun‐Feng Huang +3 more

Multipartite quantum nonlocality is an important diagnostic tool and resource for both researches in fundamental quantum mechanics and applications in quantum information protocols. Shared reference frames among all parties are usually required for experimentally observing quantum nonlocality, which is not possible in many circumstances. Previous results have shown violations of bipartite Bell inequalities with approaching unit probability, without shared reference frames. Here we experimentally demonstrate genuine multipartite quantum nonlocality without shared reference frames, using the Svetlichny inequality. A significant violation probability of 0.58 is observed with a high-fidelity three-photon Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state. Furthermore, when there is one shared axis among all the parties, which is the usual case in fiber-optic or earth-satellite links, the experimental results demonstrate the genuine three-partite nonlocality with certainty. Our experiment will be helpful for applications in multipartite quantum communication protocols.

Physical Review A•Mar 21, 2016•7 citations

Svetlichny’s inequality and genuine tripartite nonlocality in three-qubit pure states

Ashok Ajoy, Pranaw Rungta

The violation of the Svetlichny's inequality (SI) [Phys. Rev. D 35, 3066 (1987)] is sufficient but not necessary for genuine tripartite nonlocal correlations. Here we quantify the relationship between tripartite entanglement and the maximum expectation value of the Svetlichny operator (which is bounded from above by the inequality) for the two inequivalent subclasses of pure three-qubit states: the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) class and the $W$ class. We show that the maximum for the GHZ-class states reduces to Mermin's inequality [Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1838 (1990)] modulo a constant factor, and although it is a function of the three tangle and the residual concurrence, large numbers of states do not violate the inequality. We further show that by design SI is more suitable as a measure of genuine tripartite nonlocality between the three qubits in the $W$-class states, and the maximum is a certain function of the bipartite entanglement (the concurrence) of the three reduced states, and only when their sum attains a certain threshold value do they violate the inequality.

arXiv:0901.0368•Physical Review A•May 24, 2010•52 citations

Network nonlocality with tripartite entangled sources

Sudip Chakrabarty, Amit Kundu

Quantum networks are built from independent sources, and their nonlocality has mostly been studied with sources that emit bipartite entangled states. A source of three entangled qubits is richer, since its nonlocality can be tested by the Mermin or the more demanding Svetlichny inequality. We ask how network nonlocality relates to these two single-source notions and find that the answer depends on the wiring. When two central nodes without inputs share every source, Bell-state measurements turn every Svetlichny violation into a network violation, and even all entangled generalised Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states violate the network inequality. When a single central node is shared, the relation reverses, and a network violation requires a Mermin violation of the source. With more sources, the maximal violation depends on whether their number is even or odd, and we give tight bounds for both cases. These results show that the way multipartite sources are wired decides which kind of nonlocality a network inherits.

quant-pharXiv:2610.35838•Oct 27, 2026•0 citations
Benchmarking quantum processors is a central task in every roadmap aimed at quantum advantage. Here, we discuss a benchmarking protocol based on the violation of the Svetlichny inequality, which is designed to simulate genuine multipartite nonlocality. We compare it with Mermin's inequality, and present the results of applying this framework to two different quantum processing units -the superconducting system Garnet (from IQM) and the ion-trap system Marmot (from AQT), testing different families of quantum circuits for three to five qubits under identical experimental conditions. We also run simultaneous triplet tests across the full register, including a comparison between GHZ and linear cluster states, to probe how Svetlichny-inequality violations depend on qubit location and calibration. Our results demonstrate that tests based on genuine multipartite nonlocality provide a powerful tool to characterize the collective performance of quantum devices and to guide their calibration and optimization.
The paper examines whether Svetlichny-inequality tests can benchmark collective processor performance more stringently than Mermin tests. It extends an existing protocol using GHZ states, Clifford circuits, and Clifford+TTT circuits on superconducting Garnet and trapped-ion Marmot processors, principally with 3–5 qubits. Measurement directions are optimized numerically for ideal states, then the corresponding correlations are reconstructed experimentally. Random-circuit experiments select low-depth representatives across ideal violation ranges rather than executing the full sampled ensemble.
The Svetlichny hybrid-local bound is 2N−12^{N-1}2N−1, with quantum maximum 2N−122^{N-1}\sqrt{2}2N−12​. For GHZ states, Garnet yields 4.39±0.104.39\pm0.104.39±0.10, 7.72±0.097.72\pm0.097.72±0.09, and 12.3±0.5012.3\pm0.5012.3±0.50 for 3, 4, and 5 qubits, respectively: only the three-qubit result exceeds its bound. Marmot yields 5.39±0.055.39\pm0.055.39±0.05, 9.83±0.269.83\pm0.269.83±0.26, and 18.68±0.7418.68\pm0.7418.68±0.74, exceeding all three bounds. Both devices retain Mermin violations through five qubits. These values summarize 20 repetitions; uncertainties are standard deviations. Depolarizing-noise simulations show that the fraction of circuits retaining Svetlichny violations decreases faster than for Mermin violations, alongside a comparison with Grover-search success.
Additional three-qubit tests resolve location- and time-dependent performance on Garnet. Simultaneous tests on four disjoint Marmot triplets show similar performance across triplets but greater dispersion than isolated tests. Stated limitations include the absence of spacelike-separated measurements, precluding loophole-free nonlocality certification; unequal shot counts between platforms; exponential measurement resources; and the fact that failure to violate Svetlichny does not exclude genuine multipartite nonlocality detectable by other inequalities.
A cross-platform benchmark should be device-independent yet sensitive to imperfections accumulated during execution. Building on prior work, we formulate and validate a protocol through demonstrations based on generalized Svetlichny inequality violations (a simulation, rather than a loophole-free certification, of multipartite nonlocality) for larger subsystem sizes. We apply it unchanged to three processors, the trapped-ion Marmot and IBEX Q1 (both manufactured by AQT) and the superconducting Euro-Q-Exa System 1 (IQM), using identical GHZ-state circuits with fixed theoretical measurement settings from N=2 to N=10 qubits. Both trapped-ion processors sustain violations up to ten qubits, while the superconducting processor loses them beyond six qubits under unmitigated (raw) conditions; readout-error mitigation recovers violations up to eight qubits, with a substantial fraction of the degradation attributable to measurement imperfections. These processors provide a heterogeneous testbed for validating the protocol's cross-platform applicability and discriminating power, demonstrating its practicality as a common framework for assessing collective quantum performance.
In this work we explore how different types of resources are distributed among the states generated by quantum random circuits. We focus on multipartite nonlocality, but we also analyze quantum correlations by appealing to different entanglement and nonclassicality measures. We analyze the violation of Mermin and Svetlichny inequalities in order to get a glance at the distribution of nonlocality and genuine multipartite nonlocality. Next, we compare universal vs nonuniversal sets of gates, to gain insight into the problem of explaining quantum advantage. By comparing the results obtained with ideal (noiseless) vs noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, we lay the basis of a certification protocol, which aims to quantify how robust is the resources distribution among the states that a given device can generate. We have implemented our nonlocality-based benchmark on actual quantum processors with different architectures, in order to assess up to which point they are capable of reproducing the ideal results.
Quantum computing has rapidly evolved into a diverse ecosystem of hardware platforms that differ in their underlying technologies and operational characteristics. Consequently, benchmarking has become essential for identifying the strengths of quantum processors, comparing their performance, and enabling informed decisions when selecting the most appropriate quantum computing platform for specific applications. In this work, we benchmark nine commercially accessible quantum processors from five vendors, spanning superconducting and trapped-ion technologies, using the multipartite entanglement benchmark from the QuSquare suite. All experiments were performed through remote cloud-access services, with the default compilation of each provider and without error mitigation, reflecting the performance experienced by end users. The benchmark estimates the fidelity of Greenberger--Horne--Zeilinger (GHZ) states by direct fidelity estimation and searches for the largest GHZ state whose fidelity is compatible, within the statistical error, with the genuine multipartite entanglement (GME) threshold F=1/2F=1/2F=1/2. Our results reveal a substantial gap between the total number of physical qubits available on a processor and the size of the largest GHZ state passing the benchmark: the best superconducting processors reach N∗=27N^*=27N∗=27 and N∗=24N^*=24N∗=24 qubits, less than a quarter of their registers, whereas the 12-qubit trapped-ion processor passes with its full register. We further show that median calibration data are poor predictors of the benchmark outcome, and that the reported sizes depend strongly on the statistical decision rule: requiring certified GME reduces the number of devices that succeed at any tested size from nine to four. These results provide a baseline for future cross-platform benchmarking of quantum processors.
Multipartite quantum nonlocality is an important diagnostic tool and resource for both researches in fundamental quantum mechanics and applications in quantum information protocols. Shared reference frames among all parties are usually required for experimentally observing quantum nonlocality, which is not possible in many circumstances. Previous results have shown violations of bipartite Bell inequalities with approaching unit probability, without shared reference frames. Here we experimentally demonstrate genuine multipartite quantum nonlocality without shared reference frames, using the Svetlichny inequality. A significant violation probability of 0.58 is observed with a high-fidelity three-photon Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state. Furthermore, when there is one shared axis among all the parties, which is the usual case in fiber-optic or earth-satellite links, the experimental results demonstrate the genuine three-partite nonlocality with certainty. Our experiment will be helpful for applications in multipartite quantum communication protocols.
The violation of the Svetlichny's inequality (SI) [Phys. Rev. D 35, 3066 (1987)] is sufficient but not necessary for genuine tripartite nonlocal correlations. Here we quantify the relationship between tripartite entanglement and the maximum expectation value of the Svetlichny operator (which is bounded from above by the inequality) for the two inequivalent subclasses of pure three-qubit states: the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) class and the WWW class. We show that the maximum for the GHZ-class states reduces to Mermin's inequality [Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1838 (1990)] modulo a constant factor, and although it is a function of the three tangle and the residual concurrence, large numbers of states do not violate the inequality. We further show that by design SI is more suitable as a measure of genuine tripartite nonlocality between the three qubits in the WWW-class states, and the maximum is a certain function of the bipartite entanglement (the concurrence) of the three reduced states, and only when their sum attains a certain threshold value do they violate the inequality.
Quantum networks are built from independent sources, and their nonlocality has mostly been studied with sources that emit bipartite entangled states. A source of three entangled qubits is richer, since its nonlocality can be tested by the Mermin or the more demanding Svetlichny inequality. We ask how network nonlocality relates to these two single-source notions and find that the answer depends on the wiring. When two central nodes without inputs share every source, Bell-state measurements turn every Svetlichny violation into a network violation, and even all entangled generalised Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states violate the network inequality. When a single central node is shared, the relation reverses, and a network violation requires a Mermin violation of the source. With more sources, the maximal violation depends on whether their number is even or odd, and we give tight bounds for both cases. These results show that the way multipartite sources are wired decides which kind of nonlocality a network inherits.