Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.24154

Translation-Invariant Pure States with Exotic Half-Chain Factors

Ruizhi Liu, Jinmin Yi

quant-phmath-phmath.OASubmitted Oct 16, 2026• Announced Oct 20, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We construct translation-invariant pure quasifree fermionic states on the one-dimensional lattice whose half-chain von Neumann algebras are hyperfinite factors of type $\mathrm{II}_\infty$ or $\mathrm{III}_λ$ for any $0<λ\leq 1$. Via the Jordan-Wigner-Araki transformation, these yield translation-invariant pure spin-chain states with the same half-chain factors, demonstrating that such factors need not be of type I or III. Each state is the unique ground state of a gapless, translation-invariant parent Hamiltonian with superpolynomially decaying interactions. For any fixed factor type, the interval entanglement entropy can exhibit widely varying growth rates, from arbitrarily slow divergence to nearly power-law growth, showing that entropy scaling does not determine the factor type. In contrast, we prove that gauge-invariant quadratic Hamiltonians with finitely many flavours and exponentially decaying hopping exhibit a dichotomy: their ground states either satisfy an area law with a type I half-chain factor, or have logarithmic entropy growth with a type $\mathrm{III}_1$ factor. The counterexample was discovered with AI assistance.

AI Summary

The paper asks which von Neumann factor types can occur on a half-chain of a translation-invariant pure spin-chain state, and whether interval entropy growth determines that type. It constructs examples on $\bigotimes_{j\in\mathbb Z}M_{16}$ with hyperfinite half-chain factors of type $\mathrm{II}_\infty$ and $\mathrm{III}_\lambda$ for every $0<\lambda\le1$. The $\mathrm{II}_\infty$ example contradicts a previously claimed type I/type III dichotomy; the paper identifies a normality gap in that argument. The construction uses multicomponent pure gauge-invariant quasifree fermionic states. An infinite Blaschke product gives a Toeplitz isometry with an infinite-dimensional defect space, producing constant mixed covariance sectors whose mixing ratios determine the factor type. Blaschke zeros independently control entropy growth. Jordan–Wigner–Araki methods transfer purity, half-chain factors and interval entropies to spin chains. For each constructed type, entropy can grow as $\log\ell$, $\sqrt{\log\ell}$ or $\log\log\ell$, or diverge more slowly than any prescribed divergent nondecreasing function. Polynomially approaching zeros yield $c_\kappa\ell^{1/(\alpha+1)}\le S(\ell)\le C_\kappa\ell^{1/(\alpha+1)}\log\ell$ for $\alpha>1$. Each state has a unique gapless parent with superpolynomially decaying interactions, obtained by smoothing a flat-band parent at its singular momentum. For exponentially decaying quadratic hopping with finitely many flavours and no flat band at the Fermi energy, analyticity instead forces either type I with an area law or type $\mathrm{III}_1$ with $S(\ell)=\Theta(\log\ell)$, according to whether bands cross zero. Extending this dichotomy to interacting exponentially local chains remains conjectural; the polynomial-growth entropy bounds retain a logarithmic gap.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosed
Generative AI tools, including ChatGPT (GPT-5.6 Sol) and Claude Opus 5.5, were used extensively throughout the development of this work to explore mathematical arguments, suggest proof strategies, and assist in drafting and revising portions of the manuscript.

Error found: The abstract states the ground-state dichotomy for exponentially local quadratic Hamiltonians without excluding flat bands at the Fermi energy, although the zero Hamiltonian satisfies its stated assumptions and admits the constructed exotic states as ground states.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
45 pages, 3 figures

Related papers

Ground state entanglement in one-dimensional translationally invariant quantum systems

Sandy Irani

We examine whether it is possible for one-dimensional translationally invariant Hamiltonians to have ground states with a high degree of entanglement. We present a family of translationally invariant Hamiltonians {Hn} for the infinite chain. The spectral gap of Hn is Ω(1/poly(n)). Moreover, for any state in the ground space of Hn and any m, there are regions of size m with entanglement entropy Ω(min{m,n}). A similar construction yields translationally invariant Hamiltonians for finite chains that have unique ground states exhibiting high entanglement. The area law proven by Hastings [“An area law for one dimensional quantum systems,” J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. 2007 (08024)] gives a constant upper bound on the entanglement entropy for one-dimensional ground states that is independent of the size of the region but exponentially dependent on 1/Δ, where Δ is the spectral gap. This paper provides a lower bound, showing a family of Hamiltonians for which the entanglement entropy scales polynomially with 1/Δ. Previously, the best known such bound was logarithmic in 1/Δ.

arXiv:0901.1107•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 2010•45 citations

Entanglement entropy in quantum spin chains with broken reflection symmetry

Zoltán Kádár, Zoltán Zimborás

We investigate the entanglement entropy of a block of $L$ sites in quasifree translation-invariant spin chains concentrating on the effect of reflection-symmetry breaking. The Majorana two-point functions corresponding to the Jordan-Wigner transformed fermionic modes are determined in the most general case; from these, it follows that reflection symmetry in the ground state can only be broken if the model is quantum critical. The large $L$ asymptotics of the entropy are calculated analytically for general gauge-invariant models, which have, until now, been done only for the reflection-symmetric sector. Analytical results are also derived for certain nongauge-invariant models (e.g., for the Ising model with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction). We also study numerically finite chains of length $N$ with a nonreflection-symmetric Hamiltonian and report that the reflection symmetry of the entropy of the first $L$ spins is violated but the reflection-symmetric Calabrese-Cardy formula is recovered asymptotically. Furthermore, for noncritical reflection-symmetry-breaking Hamiltonians, we find an anomaly in the behavior of the saturation entropy as we approach the critical line. The paper also provides a concise but extensive review of the block-entropy asymptotics in translation-invariant quasifree spin chains with an analysis of the nearest-neighbor case and the enumeration of the yet unsolved parts of the quasifree landscape.

arXiv:1004.3112•Physical Review A•Sep 29, 2010•29 citations

Critical fermions are universal embezzlers

Lauritz van Luijk, Alexander Stottmeister, Henrik Wilming

Abstract Universal embezzlers are bipartite quantum systems from which any entangled state may be extracted to arbitrary precision using local operations while perturbing the system arbitrarily little. Here we show that a universal embezzler can be created by bipartitioning any local, translation-invariant, critical free-fermionic many-body system on a one-dimensional lattice. The same property holds for locally interacting spin chains that are dual to the critical fermionic models by the Jordan–Wigner transformation. Furthermore, for any finite error and any targeted entangled state, a finite length of the chain is sufficient to embezzle said state within the given error. Hence, universal embezzlement is not restricted to the thermodynamic limit. As well as establishing the ubiquity of universal embezzlers in many-body physics, on a technical level, our main result establishes that the half-chain observable algebras associated with ground-state sectors of the given models are type III1 factors.

arXiv:2406.11747•Nature Physics•May 27, 2025•10 citations

The von Neumann entropy asymptotics in multidimensional fermionic systems

Szilárd Farkas, Zoltán Zimborás

We study the von Neumann entropy asymptotics of pure translation-invariant quasifree states of d-dimensional fermionic systems. It is shown that the entropic area law is violated by all these states: apart from the trivial cases, the entropy of a cubic subsystem with edge length L cannot grow slower than Ld−1lnL. As for the upper bound of the entropy asymptotics, the zero-entropy-density property of these pure states is the only limit: it is proven that arbitrary fast sub-Ld entropy growth is achievable.

arXiv:0706.1805•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Oct 1, 2007•34 citations

Detailed balance and split property in quantum spin chain

Anilesh Mohari

In this exposition we investigate further the general methodology proposed in [Mo2] to study properties of the ground states of a translation invariant Hamiltonian for one lattice dimensional quantum spin chain A = ⊗ ZMd, where Md is the matrix of d × d complex matrices. We introduce a notion of quantum detailed balance [Mo1] for a translation invariant state on A and prove that such a pure state is uniformly mixing [BR,Ma2] if and only if the lattice space correlation functions decay exponentially. Furthermore we also prove that a pure lattice symmetric, translation and SU(2) gauge invariant state give rise to a canonical Popescu systems acting on a finite dimensional Hilbert space and thus the lattice space correlation functions of the pure state decay exponentially. As a consequence of these results we conclude that if the ground states for an integer spin SU(2) invariant (2s + 1 = d) detailed balanced Hamiltonian is unique then the state is split. In particular if the ground state for integer

arXiv:math-ph/0505035•May 11, 2005•3 citations

On the sharpness of the zero-entropy-density conjecture

S. Farkas, Zoltán Zimborás

The zero-entropy-density conjecture states that the entropy density defined as s≔limN→∞SN∕N vanishes for all translation-invariant pure states on the spin chain. Or equivalently, SN, the von Neumann entropy of such a state restricted to N consecutive spins, is sublinear. In this paper it is proved that this conjecture cannot be sharpened, i.e., translation-invariant states give rise to arbitrary fast sublinear entropy growth. The proof is constructive, and is based on a class of states derived from quasifree states on a CAR algebra. The question whether the entropy growth of pure quasifree states can be arbitrary fast sublinear was first raised by Fannes et al. [J. Math. Phys. 44, 6005 (2003)]. In addition to the main theorem it is also shown that the entropy asymptotics of all pure shift-invariant nontrivial quasifree states is at least logarithmic.

arXiv:math-ph/0507022•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2005•20 citations
We construct translation-invariant pure quasifree fermionic states on the one-dimensional lattice whose half-chain von Neumann algebras are hyperfinite factors of type II∞\mathrm{II}_\inftyII∞​ or IIIλ\mathrm{III}_λIIIλ​ for any 0<λ≤10<λ\leq 10<λ≤1. Via the Jordan-Wigner-Araki transformation, these yield translation-invariant pure spin-chain states with the same half-chain factors, demonstrating that such factors need not be of type I or III. Each state is the unique ground state of a gapless, translation-invariant parent Hamiltonian with superpolynomially decaying interactions. For any fixed factor type, the interval entanglement entropy can exhibit widely varying growth rates, from arbitrarily slow divergence to nearly power-law growth, showing that entropy scaling does not determine the factor type. In contrast, we prove that gauge-invariant quadratic Hamiltonians with finitely many flavours and exponentially decaying hopping exhibit a dichotomy: their ground states either satisfy an area law with a type I half-chain factor, or have logarithmic entropy growth with a type III1\mathrm{III}_1III1​ factor. The counterexample was discovered with AI assistance.
The paper asks which von Neumann factor types can occur on a half-chain of a translation-invariant pure spin-chain state, and whether interval entropy growth determines that type. It constructs examples on ⨂j∈ZM16\bigotimes_{j\in\mathbb Z}M_{16}⨂j∈Z​M16​ with hyperfinite half-chain factors of type II∞\mathrm{II}_\inftyII∞​ and IIIλ\mathrm{III}_\lambdaIIIλ​ for every 0<λ≤10<\lambda\le10<λ≤1. The II∞\mathrm{II}_\inftyII∞​ example contradicts a previously claimed type I/type III dichotomy; the paper identifies a normality gap in that argument.
The construction uses multicomponent pure gauge-invariant quasifree fermionic states. An infinite Blaschke product gives a Toeplitz isometry with an infinite-dimensional defect space, producing constant mixed covariance sectors whose mixing ratios determine the factor type. Blaschke zeros independently control entropy growth. Jordan–Wigner–Araki methods transfer purity, half-chain factors and interval entropies to spin chains.
For each constructed type, entropy can grow as log⁡ℓ\log\elllogℓ, log⁡ℓ\sqrt{\log\ell}logℓ​ or log⁡log⁡ℓ\log\log\ellloglogℓ, or diverge more slowly than any prescribed divergent nondecreasing function. Polynomially approaching zeros yield cκℓ1/(α+1)≤S(ℓ)≤Cκℓ1/(α+1)log⁡ℓc_\kappa\ell^{1/(\alpha+1)}\le S(\ell)\le C_\kappa\ell^{1/(\alpha+1)}\log\ellcκ​ℓ1/(α+1)≤S(ℓ)≤Cκ​ℓ1/(α+1)logℓ for α>1\alpha>1α>1. Each state has a unique gapless parent with superpolynomially decaying interactions, obtained by smoothing a flat-band parent at its singular momentum.
For exponentially decaying quadratic hopping with finitely many flavours and no flat band at the Fermi energy, analyticity instead forces either type I with an area law or type III1\mathrm{III}_1III1​ with S(ℓ)=Θ(log⁡ℓ)S(\ell)=\Theta(\log\ell)S(ℓ)=Θ(logℓ), according to whether bands cross zero. Extending this dichotomy to interacting exponentially local chains remains conjectural; the polynomial-growth entropy bounds retain a logarithmic gap.
We examine whether it is possible for one-dimensional translationally invariant Hamiltonians to have ground states with a high degree of entanglement. We present a family of translationally invariant Hamiltonians {Hn} for the infinite chain. The spectral gap of Hn is Ω(1/poly(n)). Moreover, for any state in the ground space of Hn and any m, there are regions of size m with entanglement entropy Ω(min{m,n}). A similar construction yields translationally invariant Hamiltonians for finite chains that have unique ground states exhibiting high entanglement. The area law proven by Hastings [“An area law for one dimensional quantum systems,” J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. 2007 (08024)] gives a constant upper bound on the entanglement entropy for one-dimensional ground states that is independent of the size of the region but exponentially dependent on 1/Δ, where Δ is the spectral gap. This paper provides a lower bound, showing a family of Hamiltonians for which the entanglement entropy scales polynomially with 1/Δ. Previously, the best known such bound was logarithmic in 1/Δ.
We investigate the entanglement entropy of a block of LLL sites in quasifree translation-invariant spin chains concentrating on the effect of reflection-symmetry breaking. The Majorana two-point functions corresponding to the Jordan-Wigner transformed fermionic modes are determined in the most general case; from these, it follows that reflection symmetry in the ground state can only be broken if the model is quantum critical. The large LLL asymptotics of the entropy are calculated analytically for general gauge-invariant models, which have, until now, been done only for the reflection-symmetric sector. Analytical results are also derived for certain nongauge-invariant models (e.g., for the Ising model with Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction). We also study numerically finite chains of length NNN with a nonreflection-symmetric Hamiltonian and report that the reflection symmetry of the entropy of the first LLL spins is violated but the reflection-symmetric Calabrese-Cardy formula is recovered asymptotically. Furthermore, for noncritical reflection-symmetry-breaking Hamiltonians, we find an anomaly in the behavior of the saturation entropy as we approach the critical line. The paper also provides a concise but extensive review of the block-entropy asymptotics in translation-invariant quasifree spin chains with an analysis of the nearest-neighbor case and the enumeration of the yet unsolved parts of the quasifree landscape.
Abstract Universal embezzlers are bipartite quantum systems from which any entangled state may be extracted to arbitrary precision using local operations while perturbing the system arbitrarily little. Here we show that a universal embezzler can be created by bipartitioning any local, translation-invariant, critical free-fermionic many-body system on a one-dimensional lattice. The same property holds for locally interacting spin chains that are dual to the critical fermionic models by the Jordan–Wigner transformation. Furthermore, for any finite error and any targeted entangled state, a finite length of the chain is sufficient to embezzle said state within the given error. Hence, universal embezzlement is not restricted to the thermodynamic limit. As well as establishing the ubiquity of universal embezzlers in many-body physics, on a technical level, our main result establishes that the half-chain observable algebras associated with ground-state sectors of the given models are type III1 factors.
We study the von Neumann entropy asymptotics of pure translation-invariant quasifree states of d-dimensional fermionic systems. It is shown that the entropic area law is violated by all these states: apart from the trivial cases, the entropy of a cubic subsystem with edge length L cannot grow slower than Ld−1lnL. As for the upper bound of the entropy asymptotics, the zero-entropy-density property of these pure states is the only limit: it is proven that arbitrary fast sub-Ld entropy growth is achievable.
In this exposition we investigate further the general methodology proposed in [Mo2] to study properties of the ground states of a translation invariant Hamiltonian for one lattice dimensional quantum spin chain A = ⊗ ZMd, where Md is the matrix of d × d complex matrices. We introduce a notion of quantum detailed balance [Mo1] for a translation invariant state on A and prove that such a pure state is uniformly mixing [BR,Ma2] if and only if the lattice space correlation functions decay exponentially. Furthermore we also prove that a pure lattice symmetric, translation and SU(2) gauge invariant state give rise to a canonical Popescu systems acting on a finite dimensional Hilbert space and thus the lattice space correlation functions of the pure state decay exponentially. As a consequence of these results we conclude that if the ground states for an integer spin SU(2) invariant (2s + 1 = d) detailed balanced Hamiltonian is unique then the state is split. In particular if the ground state for integer
The zero-entropy-density conjecture states that the entropy density defined as s≔limN→∞SN∕N vanishes for all translation-invariant pure states on the spin chain. Or equivalently, SN, the von Neumann entropy of such a state restricted to N consecutive spins, is sublinear. In this paper it is proved that this conjecture cannot be sharpened, i.e., translation-invariant states give rise to arbitrary fast sublinear entropy growth. The proof is constructive, and is based on a class of states derived from quasifree states on a CAR algebra. The question whether the entropy growth of pure quasifree states can be arbitrary fast sublinear was first raised by Fannes et al. [J. Math. Phys. 44, 6005 (2003)]. In addition to the main theorem it is also shown that the entropy asymptotics of all pure shift-invariant nontrivial quasifree states is at least logarithmic.