arXiv:2610.22489
Multi-Time States in Quantum and Operational Probabilistic Theories: An Axiomatic Framework
Kaumudibikash Goswami, Archana Barvar, Manabendra Nath Bera
Abstract
Quantum states over time were introduced, in part, to extend Bayesian probability to quantum theory and have since found applications across diverse areas, ranging from quantum causality and open-system dynamics to tests of macroscopic realism. While axiomatic characterizations of these states exist for Markovian dynamics, a general framework accommodating non-Markovian dynamics is still lacking. Moreover, extending this framework beyond quantum mechanics to general physical theories also remains elusive. In this work, we develop an axiomatic framework for multi-time states within a class of operational probabilistic theories (OPTs) that includes quantum mechanics as a special case. Based on three assumptions---compositionality, reconstructibility, and spatio-temporal marginal consistency---the framework accommodates both Markovian and non-Markovian dynamics, and provides sufficient conditions to certify signaling and temporal memory within OPT. As a concrete application of our OPT framework, we fully characterize the unique multi-time state in boxworld and develop a method for Bayesian retrodiction of physical transformations there. Our general framework is consistent with quantum theory, reproducing several existing results. In the non-Markovian quantum dynamics, we establish a correspondence between multi-time states and the process-matrix framework, and fully characterize the multi-time states compatible with general dynamics. This correspondence also lets us infer quantum causal models from multi-time states, and as a proof of principle, we propose a semidefinite program to infer causal order from quantum multi-time states. These results provide a unified framework for studying spatio-temporal states, causal relations, and Bayesian reasoning within OPTs, with implications for both fundamental and applied research.
AI Summary
The paper asks how states over time can be characterized axiomatically for non-Markovian dynamics and for theories beyond quantum mechanics. It works with finite-dimensional operational probabilistic theories (OPTs) satisfying causality and local tomography. Temporal states lie in the complex span of physical states and need not themselves be physical. Starting from marginal consistency, it imposes compositionality and reconstructibility through linear, generally nonphysical maps. These imply that Markov-compatible multi-time states are constructed by alternating dynamics with virtual broadcasting maps. An additional spatio-temporal marginal-consistency axiom extends the construction to joint system–environment dynamics followed by environmental discarding. In quantum theory, this yields $\tau=W*\bigotimes_n J(\mathcal C_{\mathrm{id}})$: a process tensor contracted with broadcasting-map Choi operators. The structure is fixed, but the broadcasting maps require further axioms. Applications include a sufficient signaling witness: for a semicausal bipartite channel, a specified temporal marginal must be a physical state; failure of physicality certifies signaling. A SWAP-based causal break turns this into a sufficient memory witness. A semidefinite feasibility formulation tests compatibility with a specified quantum causal order. For square-bit boxworld with maximal tensor product, covariance and classical consistency select a unique virtual broadcaster, enabling temporal-state and Bayesian-retrodiction constructions; the bipartite broadcaster factorizes. The process–state correspondence does not identify a unique underlying causal model. The causal-inference application is proof-of-principle, and the witnesses are sufficient rather than complete. Extensions beyond local tomography, universal uniqueness of broadcasting maps, quantum-versus-classical memory distinctions, and indefinite causal order remain open.
We used standard AI tools to polish the writing and improve styles. No conceptual or mathematical content was AI-generated.
Central claim may not hold: The claimed unique boxworld broadcasting map fails its defining classical-consistency axiom for the valid distinguishing measurement e=(e_x+e_y)/2 on the diagonal basis {rho_11,rho_00}, yielding -1/8 where the axiom requires zero.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 22+19 pages, 7+2 figures, comments welcome