Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.22097

Operational Limits of Gravity-Mediated Entanglement

Atta ur Rahman, Muhammad Noman, Ying-Jian Zhu, Jia-Xin Peng, Saeed Haddadi

quant-phgr-qcSubmitted Oct 15, 2026• Announced Oct 16, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Tests of gravity-mediated entanglement aim to determine whether two massive objects in spatial superposition can become entangled through their mutual gravitational interaction. In an ideal model, the two objects are often treated as pointlike branches, but real wave packets have a finite width and are also exposed to dephasing and residual non-gravitational forces. We study these effects in a two-branch gravitational cat-state model with Gaussian wave packets. The Newtonian interaction is averaged over the finite wave-packet width, and spatially correlated dephasing is included phenomenologically. We then ask a practical question: when does the generated state remain useful rather than merely entangled? To answer this, we examine Bell violation, teleportation fidelity, coherent information, Fisher information, and state distinguishability. We find finite parameter windows where the same state is Bell-nonlocal and teleportation-useful, but these windows shrink as the wave packets become broader or the dephasing becomes stronger. We also show that a residual electrostatic branch interaction can coherently cancel the gravitational nonlocal phase and strongly suppress the operational signal. The results identify finite-width and electrostatic tolerance boundaries that should be considered in future tests of gravity-mediated entanglement.

AI Summary

The paper asks when gravity-mediated entanglement remains operationally useful once finite wave-packet width, correlated dephasing, and residual electrostatic interactions are included. It models two masses as branch qubits initially in $|++\rangle$, with diagonal interaction phases obtained from the Gaussian-smeared Newtonian kernel $K(D,\sigma)=\operatorname{erf}[D/(2\sigma)]/D$ and phenomenological Gaussian local-phase noise. Direct evaluation of $4\times4$ density matrices gives concurrence, maximal CHSH violation, teleportation fidelity, coherent information, Fisher information, and state-discrimination measures. Finite-time parameter scans identify overlapping Bell-violating and teleportation-useful windows that shrink with increasing width or dephasing. For branch separation $\Delta x/d=0.8$ and dimensionless dephasing $\Gamma_0=0.018$, one sampled operating point gives $\mathcal B_{\max}=2.4956$ and $F_{\rm tel}=0.9263$. A coherent electrostatic contribution cancels the entangling phase at $\epsilon_{\rm canc}=-\Omega_G/\Omega_E$, producing a suppressed-usefulness band. Additional maps locate entangled states that fail the joint Bell, teleportation, and positive-coherent-information criterion. Discrimination against an electrostatic mimic calibrated at one width becomes possible when its width dependence differs from gravity’s; matching profiles remain exactly indistinguishable. The results are conditional on the effective orthogonal-branch model, chosen geometry, phenomenological noise and electrostatic profiles, and finite scan window $0.60\leq\tau\leq18$. Broad packets are treated as a stress test rather than a controlled treatment of branch overlap. The numerical boundaries and fitted robustness scaling lack grid-convergence extrapolation. Detector errors, calibration uncertainty, microscopic environmental dynamics, wave-packet evolution, and platform-level feasibility are excluded; the benchmark comparisons do not exclude general classical or hybrid gravity models.

Likely largely AI-generatedIncrementalSmall numerics onlyStrong assumptionsUnclear novelty

Error found: The metrology discussion overinterprets the loss of a Bell–teleportation-compatible estimation window as weakened gravitational-amplitude sensitivity, although the stated model makes QFI independent of electrostatic amplitude at fixed width and time and permits nonzero Pauli Fisher information at exact cancellation. The Fig. 2 discussion incorrectly describes its dephasing grid as having 120 points, whereas the table's 115-point grid is consistent with the reported representative value Gamma_0 = 0.0182.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
24 pages, 8 figures

Related papers

Testing non-classical gravitational phase dynamics under strong dephasing

Tianfeng Feng, Vlatko Vedral

Whether gravity must be quantum is often approached by asking whether two masses can become entangled through their mutual gravitational interaction. In practice, the weak interaction competes with environmental decoherence, so the final state may contain no entanglement even when the underlying gravitational phase remains coherent. We investigate what can still be learned from the dynamics in a dephased Bose--Marletto--Vedral setup. The dominant Newtonian effect for well-separated paths is an accumulated phase rather than transfer between interferometer arms, a regime motivated by matter-wave gravitational phase experiments and quantified here by wavepacket-overlap and deflection estimates. Keeping independently characterized local which-path dephasing fixed, we prove an exact finite-time distinction between the gravitational conditional-phase evolution and every passive stochastic local-phase model (induced by a classical mediator), including regimes where the chosen input remains separable at all times. The distinction survives, with a modified sensitivity, when the comparison is enlarged to population-preserving classical measurement and feedback through a diagonal PPT relaxation. These results identify an operational test of gravitational phase dynamics in the strong-dephasing regimes, conditional on explicit and physically motivated classical mediator models.

arXiv:2611.12229•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Gravitationally mediated entanglement of fermionic qubits: from static to dynamical limits

Moslem Zarei, Mehdi Abdi, N. Bartolo +1 more

Abstract We employ the quantum Boltzmann equation to analyze the gravitationally generated entanglement between two remote qubits by considering two explicit microscopic models. A graviton propagator is employed as the mediator of the interactions, while the qubits are considered in a spatial superposition state. Such a setup, in the case of any entanglement generation, could potentially offer experimental evidence for the quantization of gravity. By treating the qubits as spin-1/2 particles in wave packets, we establish that the entanglement arises from forward scattering processes involving graviton exchanges. In our study, we consider both static and dynamical limits of the propagator and show that only in the dynamical limit such entangled states can be generated. These effects are observed to be diminished as the wave packet size increases. Our findings sheds more light into the gravity mediated entanglement between two spin-1/2 particles.

arXiv:2510.20587•Quantum Science and Technology•May 28, 2026•1 citation

Newtonian Gravitational Phase, Plaquette Invariants, and Entanglement: An Operational Test of Gravity-Mediated Quantum Correlations

Cary Miller

This work presents an explicit Newtonian gravitational phase model for two masses placed in spatial superposition and demonstrates that the resulting phase structure produces a non-zero plaquette invariant. Numerical simulations show that the plaquette phase scales with branch separation, generates entanglement according to analytic mappings, and vanishes under loop-removal kill tests. These results provide a fully operational demonstration that Newtonian gravitational phase accumulation produces the non-factorable loop structure required for gravity-mediated entanglement.

•Feb 8, 2026•0 citations

Detecting gravitational decoherence with clocks: Limits on temporal resolution from a classical-channel model of gravity

Kiran E. Khosla, Natacha Altamirano

The notion of time is given a different footing in quantum mechanics and general relativity, treated as a parameter in the former and being an observer-dependent property in the latter. From an operational point of view time is simply the correlation between a system and a clock, where an idealized clock can be modeled as a two-level system. We investigate the dynamics of clocks interacting gravitationally by treating the gravitational interaction as a classical information channel. This model, known as the classical-channel gravity (CCG), postulates that gravity is mediated by a fundamentally classical force carrier and is therefore unable to entangle particles gravitationally. In particular, we focus on the decoherence rates and temporal resolution of arrays of $N$ clocks, showing how the minimum dephasing rate scales with $N$, and the spatial configuration. Furthermore, we consider the gravitational redshift between a clock and a massive particle and show that a classical-channel model of gravity predicts a finite-dephasing rate from the nonlocal interaction. In our model we obtain a fundamental limitation in time accuracy that is intrinsic to each clock.

arXiv:1611.09919•Physical Review A•May 17, 2017•18 citations

Photonic implementation of quantum gravity simulator

Emanuele Polino, Beatrice Polacchi, Davide Poderini +6 more

Detecting gravity-mediated entanglement can provide evidence that the gravitational field obeys quantum mechanics. We report the result of a simulation of the phenomenon using a photonic platform. The simulation tests the idea of probing the quantum nature of a variable by using it to mediate entanglement and yields theoretical and experimental insights, clarifying the operational tools needed for future gravitational experiments. We employ three methods to test the presence of entanglement: the Bell test, entanglement witness, and quantum state tomography. We also simulate the alternative scenario predicted by gravitational collapse models or due to imperfections in the experimental setup and use quantum state tomography to certify the absence of entanglement. The simulation reinforces two main lessons: (1) which path information must be first encoded and subsequently coherently erased from the gravitational field and (2) performing a Bell test leads to stronger conclusions, certifying the existence of gravity-mediated nonlocality.

arXiv:2207.01680•Advanced Photonics Nexus•May 22, 2024•12 citations

Newtonian Gravitational Curvature-Induced Entanglement Generation

Mughees Ahmad Khan, Asad Ali, M. I Hussain +2 more

We show that gravitational curvature can control the generation of nonlocal quantum correlations in a hybrid qubit-mechanical device. The tidal field of a nearby source mass modifies the susceptibility of a shared mechanical oscillator, thereby tuning an oscillator-mediated qubit-qubit interaction and the resulting entangling phase. An exact treatment of the dynamics reveals stroboscopic geometric gates whose accumulated phase is directly sensitive to gravitational curvature. Treating the curvature as an unknown parameter, we derive the ultimate quantum limit for its estimation and identify a parity-based measurement that saturates this bound. Solving the full master equation with the mechanical mode retained explicitly, we find that thermal occupation of the mediator suppresses entanglement between the closure times but is undone at each closure, exactly in the unitary limit for any initial mechanical temperature, so that ground-state cooling of the oscillator is not a prerequisite for the protocol. Mechanical damping and qubit dephasing behave differently: they leak branch information irreversibly to the environment, and it is the heating and dephasing rates, rather than the bath occupation alone, that limit the entanglement visibility and the number of usable interrogation loops. In contrast to gravity-mediated entanglement proposals, entanglement is generated by the mechanical oscillator while gravity acts solely as a classical control field. We quantify the achievable curvature parameters; all curvature dependencies are analytic, allowing for exact rescaling of the results. The scheme therefore demonstrates gravitational control of a quantum interaction and provides a route to curvature sensing based on a nonlocal two-qubit phase rather than on local phase measurements.

quant-pharXiv:2608.30075•Sep 1, 2026•0 citations
Tests of gravity-mediated entanglement aim to determine whether two massive objects in spatial superposition can become entangled through their mutual gravitational interaction. In an ideal model, the two objects are often treated as pointlike branches, but real wave packets have a finite width and are also exposed to dephasing and residual non-gravitational forces. We study these effects in a two-branch gravitational cat-state model with Gaussian wave packets. The Newtonian interaction is averaged over the finite wave-packet width, and spatially correlated dephasing is included phenomenologically. We then ask a practical question: when does the generated state remain useful rather than merely entangled? To answer this, we examine Bell violation, teleportation fidelity, coherent information, Fisher information, and state distinguishability. We find finite parameter windows where the same state is Bell-nonlocal and teleportation-useful, but these windows shrink as the wave packets become broader or the dephasing becomes stronger. We also show that a residual electrostatic branch interaction can coherently cancel the gravitational nonlocal phase and strongly suppress the operational signal. The results identify finite-width and electrostatic tolerance boundaries that should be considered in future tests of gravity-mediated entanglement.
The paper asks when gravity-mediated entanglement remains operationally useful once finite wave-packet width, correlated dephasing, and residual electrostatic interactions are included. It models two masses as branch qubits initially in ∣++⟩|++\rangle∣++⟩, with diagonal interaction phases obtained from the Gaussian-smeared Newtonian kernel K(D,σ)=erf⁡[D/(2σ)]/DK(D,\sigma)=\operatorname{erf}[D/(2\sigma)]/DK(D,σ)=erf[D/(2σ)]/D and phenomenological Gaussian local-phase noise. Direct evaluation of 4×44\times44×4 density matrices gives concurrence, maximal CHSH violation, teleportation fidelity, coherent information, Fisher information, and state-discrimination measures.
Finite-time parameter scans identify overlapping Bell-violating and teleportation-useful windows that shrink with increasing width or dephasing. For branch separation Δx/d=0.8\Delta x/d=0.8Δx/d=0.8 and dimensionless dephasing Γ0=0.018\Gamma_0=0.018Γ0​=0.018, one sampled operating point gives Bmax⁡=2.4956\mathcal B_{\max}=2.4956Bmax​=2.4956 and Ftel=0.9263F_{\rm tel}=0.9263Ftel​=0.9263. A coherent electrostatic contribution cancels the entangling phase at ϵcanc=−ΩG/ΩE\epsilon_{\rm canc}=-\Omega_G/\Omega_Eϵcanc​=−ΩG​/ΩE​, producing a suppressed-usefulness band. Additional maps locate entangled states that fail the joint Bell, teleportation, and positive-coherent-information criterion. Discrimination against an electrostatic mimic calibrated at one width becomes possible when its width dependence differs from gravity’s; matching profiles remain exactly indistinguishable.
The results are conditional on the effective orthogonal-branch model, chosen geometry, phenomenological noise and electrostatic profiles, and finite scan window 0.60≤τ≤180.60\leq\tau\leq180.60≤τ≤18. Broad packets are treated as a stress test rather than a controlled treatment of branch overlap. The numerical boundaries and fitted robustness scaling lack grid-convergence extrapolation. Detector errors, calibration uncertainty, microscopic environmental dynamics, wave-packet evolution, and platform-level feasibility are excluded; the benchmark comparisons do not exclude general classical or hybrid gravity models.
Whether gravity must be quantum is often approached by asking whether two masses can become entangled through their mutual gravitational interaction. In practice, the weak interaction competes with environmental decoherence, so the final state may contain no entanglement even when the underlying gravitational phase remains coherent. We investigate what can still be learned from the dynamics in a dephased Bose--Marletto--Vedral setup. The dominant Newtonian effect for well-separated paths is an accumulated phase rather than transfer between interferometer arms, a regime motivated by matter-wave gravitational phase experiments and quantified here by wavepacket-overlap and deflection estimates. Keeping independently characterized local which-path dephasing fixed, we prove an exact finite-time distinction between the gravitational conditional-phase evolution and every passive stochastic local-phase model (induced by a classical mediator), including regimes where the chosen input remains separable at all times. The distinction survives, with a modified sensitivity, when the comparison is enlarged to population-preserving classical measurement and feedback through a diagonal PPT relaxation. These results identify an operational test of gravitational phase dynamics in the strong-dephasing regimes, conditional on explicit and physically motivated classical mediator models.
Abstract We employ the quantum Boltzmann equation to analyze the gravitationally generated entanglement between two remote qubits by considering two explicit microscopic models. A graviton propagator is employed as the mediator of the interactions, while the qubits are considered in a spatial superposition state. Such a setup, in the case of any entanglement generation, could potentially offer experimental evidence for the quantization of gravity. By treating the qubits as spin-1/2 particles in wave packets, we establish that the entanglement arises from forward scattering processes involving graviton exchanges. In our study, we consider both static and dynamical limits of the propagator and show that only in the dynamical limit such entangled states can be generated. These effects are observed to be diminished as the wave packet size increases. Our findings sheds more light into the gravity mediated entanglement between two spin-1/2 particles.
This work presents an explicit Newtonian gravitational phase model for two masses placed in spatial superposition and demonstrates that the resulting phase structure produces a non-zero plaquette invariant. Numerical simulations show that the plaquette phase scales with branch separation, generates entanglement according to analytic mappings, and vanishes under loop-removal kill tests. These results provide a fully operational demonstration that Newtonian gravitational phase accumulation produces the non-factorable loop structure required for gravity-mediated entanglement.
The notion of time is given a different footing in quantum mechanics and general relativity, treated as a parameter in the former and being an observer-dependent property in the latter. From an operational point of view time is simply the correlation between a system and a clock, where an idealized clock can be modeled as a two-level system. We investigate the dynamics of clocks interacting gravitationally by treating the gravitational interaction as a classical information channel. This model, known as the classical-channel gravity (CCG), postulates that gravity is mediated by a fundamentally classical force carrier and is therefore unable to entangle particles gravitationally. In particular, we focus on the decoherence rates and temporal resolution of arrays of NNN clocks, showing how the minimum dephasing rate scales with NNN, and the spatial configuration. Furthermore, we consider the gravitational redshift between a clock and a massive particle and show that a classical-channel model of gravity predicts a finite-dephasing rate from the nonlocal interaction. In our model we obtain a fundamental limitation in time accuracy that is intrinsic to each clock.
Detecting gravity-mediated entanglement can provide evidence that the gravitational field obeys quantum mechanics. We report the result of a simulation of the phenomenon using a photonic platform. The simulation tests the idea of probing the quantum nature of a variable by using it to mediate entanglement and yields theoretical and experimental insights, clarifying the operational tools needed for future gravitational experiments. We employ three methods to test the presence of entanglement: the Bell test, entanglement witness, and quantum state tomography. We also simulate the alternative scenario predicted by gravitational collapse models or due to imperfections in the experimental setup and use quantum state tomography to certify the absence of entanglement. The simulation reinforces two main lessons: (1) which path information must be first encoded and subsequently coherently erased from the gravitational field and (2) performing a Bell test leads to stronger conclusions, certifying the existence of gravity-mediated nonlocality.
We show that gravitational curvature can control the generation of nonlocal quantum correlations in a hybrid qubit-mechanical device. The tidal field of a nearby source mass modifies the susceptibility of a shared mechanical oscillator, thereby tuning an oscillator-mediated qubit-qubit interaction and the resulting entangling phase. An exact treatment of the dynamics reveals stroboscopic geometric gates whose accumulated phase is directly sensitive to gravitational curvature. Treating the curvature as an unknown parameter, we derive the ultimate quantum limit for its estimation and identify a parity-based measurement that saturates this bound. Solving the full master equation with the mechanical mode retained explicitly, we find that thermal occupation of the mediator suppresses entanglement between the closure times but is undone at each closure, exactly in the unitary limit for any initial mechanical temperature, so that ground-state cooling of the oscillator is not a prerequisite for the protocol. Mechanical damping and qubit dephasing behave differently: they leak branch information irreversibly to the environment, and it is the heating and dephasing rates, rather than the bath occupation alone, that limit the entanglement visibility and the number of usable interrogation loops. In contrast to gravity-mediated entanglement proposals, entanglement is generated by the mechanical oscillator while gravity acts solely as a classical control field. We quantify the achievable curvature parameters; all curvature dependencies are analytic, allowing for exact rescaling of the results. The scheme therefore demonstrates gravitational control of a quantum interaction and provides a route to curvature sensing based on a nonlocal two-qubit phase rather than on local phase measurements.