Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.20846

Entanglement of superpositions in zero-energy subspace: insights from stabilizer theory

Konstantin Antipin, Richik Sengupta

quant-phSubmitted Oct 14, 2026• Announced Oct 16, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Exact zero-energy eigenstates built from entangled dimers have recently been found in a large class of spin Hamiltonians. While the individual states have a simple structure, their superpositions can have very different entanglement properties. In this work, we study these superpositions for geometrically local spin-1/2 chains with periodic boundary conditions. Using stabilizer theory and polynomial methods, we characterize the subspace they span and find the minimum entanglement entropy between two halves of the chain. For Hamiltonians generated by a single local Pauli interaction with noncommuting translates, this minimum obeys a volume law at fixed interaction range. The structure of the least-entangled superpositions also suggests further exact eigenstate constructions, including zero-energy states separable between the two halves of the chain and states at nonzero energies.

AI Summary

The paper asks how little half-chain entanglement can be obtained by superposing exact zero-energy states built from maximally entangled antipodal dimers in periodic spin-$1/2$ chains. It studies the span selected by termwise Pauli commutation/anticommutation constraints, rather than the entire zero-energy eigenspace. Valid Pauli strings form an affine binary constraint space. Using operator–state vectorization, the entropy optimization becomes a problem about density operators in a Pauli group algebra. A Clifford canonical form proves a lower bound valid for arbitrary superposition coefficients; maximal commuting stabilizer projectors attain it. If $\mathcal W$ is the symplectic span of the translated Hamiltonian generators, the exact minimum is $S_{\min}=\tfrac12[\dim\mathcal W-\dim(\mathcal W\cap\mathcal W^\perp)]$ bits. For a single finite-range Pauli generator, polynomial methods express this as $S_{\min}=\tfrac12[L-\deg\gcd(C(x),x^L-1)]$ on a $2L$-site ring. Noncommuting translates and fixed interaction range imply $S_{\min}=L/2-O(1)$, despite an exponentially large valid-state span. For the $XZ$ chain, $S_{\min}=\lfloor(L-1)/2\rfloor$; an equal-amplitude superposition instead has second Rényi entropy approximately $0.7284L$. Multiple generators are treated using polynomial invariant factors and can yield $L-O(1)$ minimum entropy. Additional dimer constructions produce exact zero- and nonzero-energy eigenstates, including half-chain-separable zero modes outside the antipodal span. Consequently, the bounds do not resolve the conjectured existence of area-law states in exponentially degenerate full nullspaces. Separability across the specified cut does not establish area laws for other cuts; general higher-spin and higher-dimensional optimization remains open.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedStrong assumptions
ChatGPT-6 Astra helped with calculations and proofs in Appendices~\ref{sec:appendix_mpo_purity}, \ref{app:thm_pol}, \ref{app:sec:sec:smith_form}.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
43 pages, 5 figures

Related papers

Exact Volume-Law Entangled Zero-Energy Eigenstates in a Large Class of Spin Models

Sashikanta Mohapatra, Sanjay Moudgalya, Ajit Coimbatore Balram

Exact solutions for excited states in nonintegrable quantum Hamiltonians have revealed novel dynamical phenomena that can occur in quantum many-body systems. This work proposes a method to analytically construct a specific set of volume-law entangled zero-energy exact excited eigenstates in a large class of spin Hamiltonians. In particular, we show that all spin chains that satisfy a simple set of conditions host exact volume law entangled zero-energy eigenstates in the middle of their spectra. Examples of physically relevant spin chains of this type include the transverse-field Ising model, PXP model, spin-S XY model, and spin-S Kitaev chain. Although these eigenstates are highly atypical in their structure, they are thermal with respect to local observables. Our framework also unifies many recent constructions of volume-law entangled eigenstates in the literature. Finally, we show that a similar construction also generalizes to spin models on graphs in arbitrary dimensions.

arXiv:2410.22773•Physical Review Letters•May 30, 2025•13 citations

Parent Hamiltonians for stabilizer quantum many-body scars

Shane Dooley

Quantum many-body scars (QMBS) have attracted considerable interest due to their role in weak ergodicity breaking in many-body systems. We present a general construction that embeds stabilizer states as QMBS of local Hamiltonians. The method relies on a notion of factorizability of Pauli strings on a lattice, which is used to convert stabilizer elements into local, few-body operators that annihilate the stabilizer state. This enables the systematic construction of parent Hamiltonians with zero-energy stabilizer QMBS typically near the middle of the spectrum. The method reproduces several known results in a unified framework, including recent examples of volume-law entangled QMBS, such as the ``rainbow'' QMBS and the entangled antipodal Bell pair state. We also apply the framework to construct examples of stabilizer QMBS with a more complex entanglement structure, such as the cluster state, the toric code state, and a volume-law entangled state we dub the antipodal toric code (ATC) state. Exact diagonalization confirms our results and reveal the stabilizer states as exact eigenstates of their parent Hamiltonian.

quant-pharXiv:2601.10805•Physical Review Letters•Jan 19, 2026•5 citations

Crosscap states with tunable entanglement as exact eigenstates of local spin chain Hamiltonians

Márton Mestyán, Balázs Pozsgay

Abstract It has been observed recently that various spin chain Hamiltonians admit special zero energy ‘crosscap’ eigenstates. These states are made up of maximally entangled Bell pairs prepared on antipodal sites of a periodic chain. We generalize the states by allowing the antipodal pairs to have non-maximal, tunable entanglement. We give sufficient conditions for such states to be exact zero energy eigenstates of a local Hamiltonian. The conditions are naturally satisfied in many models which have a global U (1) symmetry. These models include well known integrable models such as the XX model, the Bariev model, the folded XXZ model, and also a variety of non-integrable models. Using the zero-energy crosscap states we also derive a family of exact zero modes with sub-volume law entanglement.

arXiv:2503.15640•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 10, 2025•4 citations

Entanglement and the sign structure of quantum states

Tarun Grover, Matthew P. A. Fisher

Many-body quantum eigenstates of generic Hamiltonians at finite-energy density typically satisfy the ``volume law'' of entanglement entropy: the von Neumann entanglement entropy and the Renyi entropies for a subregion scale in proportion to its volume. Here we provide a connection between the volume law and the sign structure of eigenstates. In particular, we ask the following question: Can a positive wave function support a volume law entanglement? Remarkably, we find that a typical random positive wave function exhibits a constant law for Renyi entanglement entropies ${S}_{n}$ for $n>1$, despite arbitrary large-amplitude fluctuations. We also provide evidence that the modulus of the finite-energy density eigenstates of generic local Hamiltonians shows similar behavior.

arXiv:1412.3534•Physical Review A•Oct 8, 2015•36 citations

Exact Thermal Stabilizer Eigenstates at Infinite Temperature

Akihiro Hokkyo

Understanding how microscopic few-body interactions give rise to thermal behavior in isolated quantum many-body systems remains a central challenge in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics. While individual energy eigenstates are expected to reproduce thermal equilibrium values, analytic access to highly entangled thermal eigenstates of nonintegrable Hamiltonians remains scarce. In this Letter, we construct exact infinite-temperature eigenstates of generically nonintegrable two-body Hamiltonians using stabilizer states. These states can fully reproduce thermal expectation values for all spatially local observables, extending previously known Bell-pair-based constructions to a broader class. At the same time, we prove a sharp no-go theorem: stabilizer eigenstates of two-body Hamiltonians cannot satisfy microscopic thermal equilibrium for all four-body observables. This bound is tight, as we explicitly construct a translationally invariant Hamiltonian whose stabilizer eigenstate is thermal for all two-body and three-body observables as well as all spatially local observables. Our results suggest that reproducing higher-order thermal correlations requires nonstabilizer degrees of freedom, providing analytic insight into the interplay between interaction locality, microscopic thermal equilibrium, and quantum computational complexity.

quant-pharXiv:2601.16177•Jan 23, 2026•2 citations

Volume-law scaling for the entanglement entropy in spin-1/2 chains

Giuseppe Vitagliano, Arnau Riera, José Ignacio Latorre

Entanglement entropy obeys area law scaling for typical physical quantum systems. This may naively be argued to follow from the locality of interactions. We show that this is not the case by constructing an explicit simple spin chain Hamiltonian with nearest-neighbor interactions that presents an entanglement volume scaling law. This non-translational model is contrived to have couplings that force the accumulation of singlet bonds across the half-chain. This configuration of the couplings is suggested by real-space renormalization group arguments. Computation of the entanglement entropy is performed by mapping the system to free fermions and diagonalizing numerically its correlation matrix. An analytical relationship between the entanglement entropy and the Frobenius norm of the correlation matrix is also established. Our result is complementary to the known relationship between non-translational invariant, nearest-neighbor interacting Hamiltonians and quantum Merlin–Arthur (QMA)-complete problems.

arXiv:1003.1292•New Journal of Physics•Nov 26, 2010•142 citations
Exact zero-energy eigenstates built from entangled dimers have recently been found in a large class of spin Hamiltonians. While the individual states have a simple structure, their superpositions can have very different entanglement properties. In this work, we study these superpositions for geometrically local spin-1/2 chains with periodic boundary conditions. Using stabilizer theory and polynomial methods, we characterize the subspace they span and find the minimum entanglement entropy between two halves of the chain. For Hamiltonians generated by a single local Pauli interaction with noncommuting translates, this minimum obeys a volume law at fixed interaction range. The structure of the least-entangled superpositions also suggests further exact eigenstate constructions, including zero-energy states separable between the two halves of the chain and states at nonzero energies.
The paper asks how little half-chain entanglement can be obtained by superposing exact zero-energy states built from maximally entangled antipodal dimers in periodic spin-1/21/21/2 chains. It studies the span selected by termwise Pauli commutation/anticommutation constraints, rather than the entire zero-energy eigenspace.
Valid Pauli strings form an affine binary constraint space. Using operator–state vectorization, the entropy optimization becomes a problem about density operators in a Pauli group algebra. A Clifford canonical form proves a lower bound valid for arbitrary superposition coefficients; maximal commuting stabilizer projectors attain it. If W\mathcal WW is the symplectic span of the translated Hamiltonian generators, the exact minimum is Smin⁡=12[dim⁡W−dim⁡(W∩W⊥)]S_{\min}=\tfrac12[\dim\mathcal W-\dim(\mathcal W\cap\mathcal W^\perp)]Smin​=21​[dimW−dim(W∩W⊥)] bits.
For a single finite-range Pauli generator, polynomial methods express this as Smin⁡=12[L−deg⁡gcd⁡(C(x),xL−1)]S_{\min}=\tfrac12[L-\deg\gcd(C(x),x^L-1)]Smin​=21​[L−deggcd(C(x),xL−1)] on a 2L2L2L-site ring. Noncommuting translates and fixed interaction range imply Smin⁡=L/2−O(1)S_{\min}=L/2-O(1)Smin​=L/2−O(1), despite an exponentially large valid-state span. For the XZXZXZ chain, Smin⁡=⌊(L−1)/2⌋S_{\min}=\lfloor(L-1)/2\rfloorSmin​=⌊(L−1)/2⌋; an equal-amplitude superposition instead has second Rényi entropy approximately 0.7284L0.7284L0.7284L. Multiple generators are treated using polynomial invariant factors and can yield L−O(1)L-O(1)L−O(1) minimum entropy.
Additional dimer constructions produce exact zero- and nonzero-energy eigenstates, including half-chain-separable zero modes outside the antipodal span. Consequently, the bounds do not resolve the conjectured existence of area-law states in exponentially degenerate full nullspaces. Separability across the specified cut does not establish area laws for other cuts; general higher-spin and higher-dimensional optimization remains open.
Exact solutions for excited states in nonintegrable quantum Hamiltonians have revealed novel dynamical phenomena that can occur in quantum many-body systems. This work proposes a method to analytically construct a specific set of volume-law entangled zero-energy exact excited eigenstates in a large class of spin Hamiltonians. In particular, we show that all spin chains that satisfy a simple set of conditions host exact volume law entangled zero-energy eigenstates in the middle of their spectra. Examples of physically relevant spin chains of this type include the transverse-field Ising model, PXP model, spin-S XY model, and spin-S Kitaev chain. Although these eigenstates are highly atypical in their structure, they are thermal with respect to local observables. Our framework also unifies many recent constructions of volume-law entangled eigenstates in the literature. Finally, we show that a similar construction also generalizes to spin models on graphs in arbitrary dimensions.
Quantum many-body scars (QMBS) have attracted considerable interest due to their role in weak ergodicity breaking in many-body systems. We present a general construction that embeds stabilizer states as QMBS of local Hamiltonians. The method relies on a notion of factorizability of Pauli strings on a lattice, which is used to convert stabilizer elements into local, few-body operators that annihilate the stabilizer state. This enables the systematic construction of parent Hamiltonians with zero-energy stabilizer QMBS typically near the middle of the spectrum. The method reproduces several known results in a unified framework, including recent examples of volume-law entangled QMBS, such as the ``rainbow'' QMBS and the entangled antipodal Bell pair state. We also apply the framework to construct examples of stabilizer QMBS with a more complex entanglement structure, such as the cluster state, the toric code state, and a volume-law entangled state we dub the antipodal toric code (ATC) state. Exact diagonalization confirms our results and reveal the stabilizer states as exact eigenstates of their parent Hamiltonian.
Abstract It has been observed recently that various spin chain Hamiltonians admit special zero energy ‘crosscap’ eigenstates. These states are made up of maximally entangled Bell pairs prepared on antipodal sites of a periodic chain. We generalize the states by allowing the antipodal pairs to have non-maximal, tunable entanglement. We give sufficient conditions for such states to be exact zero energy eigenstates of a local Hamiltonian. The conditions are naturally satisfied in many models which have a global U (1) symmetry. These models include well known integrable models such as the XX model, the Bariev model, the folded XXZ model, and also a variety of non-integrable models. Using the zero-energy crosscap states we also derive a family of exact zero modes with sub-volume law entanglement.
Many-body quantum eigenstates of generic Hamiltonians at finite-energy density typically satisfy the ``volume law'' of entanglement entropy: the von Neumann entanglement entropy and the Renyi entropies for a subregion scale in proportion to its volume. Here we provide a connection between the volume law and the sign structure of eigenstates. In particular, we ask the following question: Can a positive wave function support a volume law entanglement? Remarkably, we find that a typical random positive wave function exhibits a constant law for Renyi entanglement entropies Sn{S}_{n}Sn​ for n>1n>1n>1, despite arbitrary large-amplitude fluctuations. We also provide evidence that the modulus of the finite-energy density eigenstates of generic local Hamiltonians shows similar behavior.
Understanding how microscopic few-body interactions give rise to thermal behavior in isolated quantum many-body systems remains a central challenge in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics. While individual energy eigenstates are expected to reproduce thermal equilibrium values, analytic access to highly entangled thermal eigenstates of nonintegrable Hamiltonians remains scarce. In this Letter, we construct exact infinite-temperature eigenstates of generically nonintegrable two-body Hamiltonians using stabilizer states. These states can fully reproduce thermal expectation values for all spatially local observables, extending previously known Bell-pair-based constructions to a broader class. At the same time, we prove a sharp no-go theorem: stabilizer eigenstates of two-body Hamiltonians cannot satisfy microscopic thermal equilibrium for all four-body observables. This bound is tight, as we explicitly construct a translationally invariant Hamiltonian whose stabilizer eigenstate is thermal for all two-body and three-body observables as well as all spatially local observables. Our results suggest that reproducing higher-order thermal correlations requires nonstabilizer degrees of freedom, providing analytic insight into the interplay between interaction locality, microscopic thermal equilibrium, and quantum computational complexity.
Entanglement entropy obeys area law scaling for typical physical quantum systems. This may naively be argued to follow from the locality of interactions. We show that this is not the case by constructing an explicit simple spin chain Hamiltonian with nearest-neighbor interactions that presents an entanglement volume scaling law. This non-translational model is contrived to have couplings that force the accumulation of singlet bonds across the half-chain. This configuration of the couplings is suggested by real-space renormalization group arguments. Computation of the entanglement entropy is performed by mapping the system to free fermions and diagonalizing numerically its correlation matrix. An analytical relationship between the entanglement entropy and the Frobenius norm of the correlation matrix is also established. Our result is complementary to the known relationship between non-translational invariant, nearest-neighbor interacting Hamiltonians and quantum Merlin–Arthur (QMA)-complete problems.