In the mid-1940s, the question of whether quantum mechanics could be supplemented by deterministic hidden variables resurfaced in a debate in ^textit{Nature}. I show that Erwin Schrödinger drafted a hitherto unpublished response to this controversy. In it, Schrödinger provided an explicit hidden-variable model, thereby showing that such models could not be ruled out. I reconstruct the historical context of this forgotten manuscript and publish here the first transcription and analysis. Importantly, Schrödinger's proposal should be understood as a proof of principle rather than as evidence of his commitment to determinism.
AI Summary
This historical study asks how objections to deterministic hidden-variable descriptions were challenged during the 1944–45 *Nature* debate over the “Collapse of Determinism,” and what an unpublished Schrödinger manuscript adds to that history. It reconstructs the exchange, provides the manuscript’s first full transcription, and analyzes its model and philosophical conclusions.
The manuscript counters Whittaker’s claimed impossibility of reproducing Malus’ law with hidden variables. A photon carries a uniformly distributed parameter $\lambda\in[0,1]$ and is transmitted through a polarizer at relative angle $\varphi$ precisely when $\lambda\geq\sin^2\varphi$, giving transmission probability $\cos^2\varphi$. After transmission, the deterministic update $\lambda'=(\lambda-\sin^2\varphi)/\cos^2\varphi$ restores a uniform distribution; an analogous update handles reflection. The analysis explains how this permits successive polarizers to reproduce the corresponding quantum probabilities. Comparison with Pelzer’s published 1944 construction identifies an equivalent single-polarizer model, but without an explicit deterministic update.
The historical conclusion is that Schrödinger’s construction was a proof of principle against an impossibility claim, not evidence of commitment to determinism. The manuscript explicitly favors indeterminism on broader philosophical grounds. Its scope is polarization statistics, not a general hidden-variable completion of quantum mechanics or a resolution of later locality constraints. The manuscript is undated, though references establish that it followed November 25, 1944. The suggestion that awareness of Pelzer’s work explains its nonpublication remains conjectural.
No sign of AI-generated text
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
Comments
5 pages + 1-page typescript o the unpublished manuscript by Schrödinger
In the mid-1940s, the question of whether quantum mechanics could be supplemented by deterministic hidden variables resurfaced in a debate in ^textit{Nature}. I show that Erwin Schrödinger drafted a hitherto unpublished response to this controversy. In it, Schrödinger provided an explicit hidden-variable model, thereby showing that such models could not be ruled out. I reconstruct the historical context of this forgotten manuscript and publish here the first transcription and analysis. Importantly, Schrödinger's proposal should be understood as a proof of principle rather than as evidence of his commitment to determinism.
This historical study asks how objections to deterministic hidden-variable descriptions were challenged during the 1944–45 Nature debate over the “Collapse of Determinism,” and what an unpublished Schrödinger manuscript adds to that history. It reconstructs the exchange, provides the manuscript’s first full transcription, and analyzes its model and philosophical conclusions.
The manuscript counters Whittaker’s claimed impossibility of reproducing Malus’ law with hidden variables. A photon carries a uniformly distributed parameter λ∈[0,1] and is transmitted through a polarizer at relative angle φ precisely when λ≥sin2φ, giving transmission probability cos2φ. After transmission, the deterministic update λ′=(λ−sin2φ)/cos2φ restores a uniform distribution; an analogous update handles reflection. The analysis explains how this permits successive polarizers to reproduce the corresponding quantum probabilities. Comparison with Pelzer’s published 1944 construction identifies an equivalent single-polarizer model, but without an explicit deterministic update.
The historical conclusion is that Schrödinger’s construction was a proof of principle against an impossibility claim, not evidence of commitment to determinism. The manuscript explicitly favors indeterminism on broader philosophical grounds. Its scope is polarization statistics, not a general hidden-variable completion of quantum mechanics or a resolution of later locality constraints. The manuscript is undated, though references establish that it followed November 25, 1944. The suggestion that awareness of Pelzer’s work explains its nonpublication remains conjectural.
This preprint re-examines the widespread belief that “Einstein was wrong about quantum mechanics.” While Einstein is often portrayed as rejecting quantum theory due to his criticism of its probabilistic interpretation, this simplified narrative does not accurately reflect his actual position or the historical context. The paper organizes Einstein’s original arguments, clarifies common misunderstandings—such as the misattribution that he “advocated hidden variables”—and reviews the development of Bell’s inequalities and their experimental tests. These experiments ruled out simple local hidden-variable models but did not fully resolve Einstein’s deeper concern: the possible incompleteness of quantum mechanics as a physical theory. By revisiting historical documents and theoretical developments, this work argues that Einstein’s critique was not a fundamental mistake but has been misinterpreted over time. The goal is to provide a more accurate understanding of the Einstein–Bohr debates and the conceptual foundations of quantum mechanics.
In the debate whether ‘hidden variables’ could exist underneath quantum probabilities, the ‘no hidden-variables’ position is at present favored. In this article I attempt to provide a more equilibrated verdict, by pointing towards the heuristic and explanatory power of the hidden-variables hypothesis, in particular in its deterministic form. I argue that this hypothesis can answer three foundational questions, whereas the opposing thesis (‘no hidden variables’) remains entirely silent for them. These questions are: 1) How to interpret probabilistic correlation ? (a question considered by Kolmogorov “one of the most important problems in the philosophy of the natural sciences”, and first analysed by Reichenbach); 2) How to interpret the Central Limit Theorem ?; and 3) Are there degrees of freedom that could unify quantum field theories and general relativity, and if so, can we (at least qualitatively) specify them ? It appears that only the hidden-variables hypothesis can provide coherent answers to these problems; answers which can be mathematically justified in the deterministic case. This suggests that the hidden-variables hypothesis should be considered a legitimate candidate as a guiding, unifying principle in the foundations of physics.
This paper argues that a European controversy over a 'mystical' hypothesis, one assigning the mind a role to play at the material level of reality, shaped much of the debate over the interpretation of the quantum equations. It traces back the controversy to the past two decades, beginning in the late 1920s—birth of quantum theory—and concluding with Erwin Schrodinger's lectures published as 'Mind and Matter'. Becoming aware of the issues at stake can help us understand the historical, philosophical and cultural background from which today's physics emerged.
Schrödinger's Hidden Variable: Resolving the 1944 "Collapse of Determinism" via the Discrete A4 Lattice
The recent archival recovery and transcription of Erwin Schrödinger's unpublished 1944–1945 manuscript, Collapse of Determinism (Del Santo, 2026), revealed that Schrödinger formulated an explicit, deterministic hidden-variable threshold (λ≥sin2θ) and post-measurement state-update rule (λ′=cos2θλ−sin2θ) to refute E. T. Whittaker's claim that Malus's Law precludes determinism in quantum optics. While Schrödinger's continuous 1D algebraic model was mathematically exact for sequential single-photon polarizers, it lacked a physical microscopic substrate and remained vulnerable to later Bell-type locality arguments. In this manuscript, we demonstrate that Schrödinger's 1944 continuous equations are the exact macroscopic continuum shadows of the discrete hardware of the Dynamic Needle Framework (DNF). Modeling the photon as an untethered 1D topological string (CK=0) traversing the projected 5-dimensional A4 quasicrystalline lattice over Q(5), we establish: Diophantine Quantization of λ: Rather than a continuous real variable requiring infinite information density, Schrödinger's hidden variable is strictly quantized over the finite 5D Hilbert flux capacity (Nflux=1325=40,074,642,432) of a macroscopic k=1 dodecahedral voxel: λn=Naligned/Nflux=1−ϵ(t). Driven by the irrational Golden Ratio phase residue ϵ(t)=2∣ϕN(t)−round(ϕN(t))∣, Weyl's Equidistribution Theorem guarantees that λn is strictly uniformly distributed on [0,1] with a discrete step resolution of Δλ=132−5≈2.495×10−11, recovering Malus's Law from pure number theory without probabilistic postulates. Trace-Preserving Integer Renormalization: At a polarizing boundary via Discrete Exterior Calculus (DEC), a discrete orientation state m partitions Nflux into orthogonal blocked modes N⊥(m) and parallel transmitted modes N∥(m)=Nflux−N⊥(m). When Naligned≥N⊥(m), the string pays the integer boundary toll N⊥(m) and renormalizes its remaining phase count against the restricted parallel pathway capacity to preserve unit trace under the Discrete Noether Theorem: λn′=Nflux−N⊥(m)Naligned−N⊥(m)⟶cos2θλn−sin2θ. Bypassing Bell's Theorem via the k=4 Protospace Colloid: Evaluating the DNF's recursive fractal spatial hierarchy (S=13220≈2.579×1042), we prove that at the 4th deflation step (k=4, 6.76×10−142 m), the Lucas nodal demand (L12=ϕ12+ϕ−12=322) exceeds the N=137.030 projection window limit, dissolving the spatial metric into the timeless, zero-metric protospace colloid where all entangled endpoints are universally adjacent (dproto(A,B)≡0). Routing Schrödinger's two-channel trace-preserving renormalization across a shared CK=0 protospace tether yields strictly unbiased local marginals (P(A=±1)=1/2, satisfying no-signaling) while transitioning the bipartite correlation from the classical local L1 taxicab bound (SL1=2) to the exact quadratic L2 quantum correlation E(θA,θB)=cos(2(θA−θB)), deterministically achieving Tsirelson's bound (SCHSH=22).