arXiv:2610.20258
Gaussian and Qubit Semigroup Dynamics beyond GKSL
Nadine Diesel, Charlotte Bäcker, Walter T. Strunz
Abstract
A well established approach to describe open quantum system dynamics is the celebrated Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad (GKSL) master equation. In this article we aim to shed light on semigroup dynamics that are not of this form. Such dynamics may appear in real physical systems describing asymptotic long-time dynamics. Thus, they correspond to semigroup dynamics applicable to a restricted set of initial states only. As a way of motivating our studies, first we review known results about the single-mode Gaussian Quantum Brownian motion channel and corresponding master equations. Next we discuss a conceptually simpler family of qubit semigroup generators and identify parameter regions of completely positive, merely positive, and non-positive dynamics. We then focus on the latter case to which we will refer to as restricted-positive, as the semigroup generator may well be physically meaningful when applied to a restricted set of admissible initial states.
AI Summary
The paper asks when time-independent open-system master equations outside GKSL form can describe valid dynamics on restricted sets of initial states. It reviews single-mode Gaussian quantum Brownian motion as motivation, then studies a two-parameter family of qubit semigroups. For damped single-mode Gaussian semigroups, the reviewed positivity and complete-positivity conditions coincide: the diffusion matrix must satisfy $D\succ0$ and $\det D\geq\gamma^2/4$. Quantum Brownian motion’s asymptotic generator instead has $D_{qq}=0$, violating these conditions. The proposed interpretation is that this generator acts only after an initial transient, on states already affected by an initial-slip map. That map also defines an admissible system–ancilla domain for restricted complete positivity. The qubit family has Bloch dynamics $\dot{\mathbf r}=\operatorname{diag}(-\alpha,-1,-1)\mathbf r+(0,0,\beta)^T$, with $\alpha>0$ and $|\beta|\leq1$. Complete positivity holds exactly when $(\alpha-1)^2+\beta^2\leq1$; positivity on the entire Bloch ball holds exactly when $\alpha\geq[1-\sqrt{1-\beta^2}]/2$. These boundaries follow from canonical decay rates and an inward-pointing velocity condition on pure states, respectively. Below the positivity boundary, the paper numerically characterizes the initial states remaining physical for all times; for $(\alpha,\beta)=(0.1,0.9)$, they occupy approximately $86.7\%$ of the Bloch-ball volume. A convexity construction proves positive-volume admissible domains for $|\beta|<1$. The Gaussian treatment largely reviews established results and uses asymptotic constant coefficients after the transient. The qubit analysis primarily concerns ordinary positivity; characterizing its restricted complete-positivity domain is explicitly left for future work.
Central claim may not hold: The defining qubit generator produces different Bloch dynamics from those analyzed, invalidating its stated positivity regions and positive-volume positivity domains unless its coefficients are corrected. The Brownian-motion argument treats asymptotic coefficient replacement as an exact finite-time factorization and therefore does not establish its claimed all-time positivity guarantee on the slip-map image.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.