Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.20132

A low-cost compact muon detector for millikelvin operation

Tengiz Ibrayev, Danish Khan, Alex Herscovics, Komal Kataruka, Matilda Lawton, Sandhya Sharma, Steven Waddy, Laura Manenti

physics.ins-dethep-exquant-phSubmitted Oct 14, 2026• Announced Oct 15, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Ionizing radiation produces correlated errors in superconducting qubits, posing some challenges to quantum error correction. In addition, it causes background events in other superconducting cryogenic devices, such as kinetic inductance detectors and superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors. Cosmic muons are a component of this background that can only be partly shielded against at ground level, but can be tagged by an independent detector inside the cryostat, so that the affected data can be vetoed, or the muon tags incorporated into error correction. We present a low-cost, compact muon detector consisting of two plastic scintillator modules, each read out by a silicon photomultiplier (SiPM), operated in coincidence. We characterize the SiPMs from room temperature down to 10 mK, including the breakdown and upper-limit voltages that define the operating bias range. Operated as a muon counter, the detector measures a coincidence rate that, as expected, is independent of temperature within uncertainties and agrees with analytical and Monte Carlo predictions. Below approximately 8 K, each muon event produces two pulses, one narrow and one broad, an effect that, to our knowledge, has not been reported before. Coincidences with an independent muon detector outside the cryostat confirm that muons are still counted reliably in this regime. By studying the appearance of double pulses as a function of temperature and magnetic field up to 4.5 T, we find a behavior consistent with the phase diagram of a type-II superconductor. This links the double pulses to a superconducting material in the SiPM, likely an adhesion layer or diffusion barrier introduced during manufacturing. The mechanism by which the superconducting state produces the second pulse is not yet understood.

AI Summary

Cosmic muons can generate correlated errors in superconducting qubits and backgrounds in other cryogenic superconducting devices. This paper investigates whether a compact scintillator–silicon-photomultiplier (SiPM) coincidence detector can reliably tag muons inside a dilution refrigerator. The detector uses two $14\times8\times8\,\mathrm{mm}^3$ plastic scintillators coupled to commercial SiPMs; the scintillators, sensors and PCBs together cost under USD 100. Measurements from room temperature to approximately $10\,\mathrm{mK}$ characterize the breakdown voltage and operational upper bias limit. Both vary non-monotonically at low temperature, defining a temperature-dependent operating window. Muon coincidence rates measured in two dilution refrigerators remain within 15% of their mean across temperatures and agree with analytical acceptance calculations and Geant4 simulations, including measured building attenuation. The analytical prediction is $8.1\pm1.4$ events per hour. Below approximately $8\,\mathrm{K}$, the sensor response splits into prompt narrow and delayed broad pulses. Temperature and magnetic-field scans up to $4.5\,\mathrm{T}$ show that suppressing this splitting follows a superconducting-like phase boundary, with fitted $T_c=8.05\pm0.08\,\mathrm{K}$ and extrapolated $B_{c2}(0)=8.1\pm0.5\,\mathrm{T}$. A forward-voltage transition near $8.08\,\mathrm{K}$ provides additional evidence for superconducting material within the SiPM. Timing remains usable: 152 fourfold coincidences with external detectors confirm muon detection despite splitting. The responsible material and pulse-generation mechanism remain unidentified, and extracting photon counts from split waveforms is unresolved. Operation alongside a qubit array and use of tags in error correction are left to future work.

No sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedIncremental
ChatGPT and Claude Code were used to correct grammar and typographical errors in the manuscript and to assist in searching the literature.

Error found: The Monte Carlo rate comparison uses room-temperature photon-detection efficiency and a fixed amplitude-per-photon conversion that are not validated for the millikelvin double-pulse response, so its quantitative acceptance prediction is conditional on those response assumptions.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

A Cryogenic Muon Tagging System Based on Kinetic Inductance Detectors for Superconducting Quantum Processors

Ambra Mariani, Laura Cardani, Mustafa Bal +16 more

Ionizing radiation has emerged as a potential limiting factor for superconducting quantum processors, inducing quasiparticle bursts and correlated errors that challenge fault-tolerant operation. Atmospheric muons are particularly problematic due to their high energy and penetration power, making passive shielding ineffective. Therefore, monitoring the real-time muon flux is crucial to guide the development of alternative error-correction or mitigation strategies. We present the design, simulation, and first operation of a cryogenic muon-tagging system based on Kinetic Inductance Detectors (KIDs), developed as a stand-alone cryogenic particle-tagging module for superconducting quantum processors. The system consists of two KIDs arranged in a vertical stack and operated at $\sim$20 mK. Monte Carlo simulations based on Geant4 guided the prototype design and provided reference expectations for muon-tagging efficiency and accidental coincidences due to ambient $γ$-rays. We observed a muon-induced coincidence rate among the top and bottom detectors of (192 $\pm$ 9)$\times10^{-3}$ events/s, in excellent agreement with the Monte Carlo prediction. The prototype achieves a muon-tagging efficiency of about 90% with negligible dead time. These results demonstrate the feasibility of operating a muon-tagging system at millikelvin temperatures and represent a key step toward the integration of cryogenic veto systems with multi-qubit chips to mitigate muon-induced errors.

quant-pharXiv:2512.10679•Quantum Science and Technology•Dec 12, 2025•2 citations

Superconducting qubit decoherence correlated with detected radiation events

A. R. Castelli, K. M. Beck, L. D. H. Alegria +6 more

Most quantum error correction (QEC) protocols for superconducting qubits assume spatially and temporally uncorrelated decoherence events; however, recent evidence suggests that cosmic radiation induces spatially correlated errors. We present a platform that sandwiches a superconducting transmon qubit between two microwave kinetic inductance detector (MKID) arrays, enabling real-time detection of radiation-induced phonon bursts. By synchronizing MKID event detection with single-shot measurements of qubit energy relaxation ($T_1$) and phase coherence ($T_2$), we observe statistically significant reductions in both $T_1$ and $T_2$-up to 30.5%-immediately following dual MKID events attributed to penetrating muons. Our findings directly link radiating events to correlated qubit decoherence. Furthermore, our experimental platform provides a foundation for systematic studies of radiation effects, the development of shielding and mitigation techniques, and the refinement of error-correction algorithms tailored to correlated noise sources.

quant-pharXiv:2512.18171•Physical Review Applied•Dec 23, 2025•3 citations

Synchronous detection of cosmic rays and correlated errors in superconducting qubit arrays

P. M. Harrington, M. Li, Max Hays +13 more

Quantum information processing at scale will require sufficiently stable and long-lived qubits, likely enabled by error-correction codes. Several recent superconducting-qubit experiments, however, reported observing intermittent spatiotemporally correlated errors that would be problematic for conventional codes, with ionizing radiation being a likely cause. Here, we directly measured the cosmic-ray contribution to spatiotemporally correlated qubit errors. We accomplished this by synchronously monitoring cosmic-ray detectors and qubit energy-relaxation dynamics of 10 transmon qubits distributed across a 5 × 5 × 0.35 mm3 silicon chip. Cosmic rays caused correlated errors at a rate of $$1/\left(592\begin{array}{c}+48\\ -41\end{array}\,{\rm{s}}\right)$$ , accounting for 17.1 ± 1.3% of all such events. Our qubits responded to essentially all of the cosmic rays and their secondary particles incident on the chip, consistent with the independently measured arrival flux. Moreover, we observed that the landscape of the superconducting gap in proximity to the Josephson junctions dramatically impacts the qubit response to cosmic rays. Given the practical difficulties associated with shielding cosmic rays, our results indicate the importance of radiation hardening—for example, superconducting gap engineering—to the realization of robust quantum error correction. Ionizing radiation from cosmic rays has been identified as a source of correlated errors in superconducting qubits, but a direct demonstration of this link has been lacking. Here the authors measure the coincidence between correlated errors and incident cosmic rays in a chip with 10 transmon qubits.

arXiv:2402.03208•Nature Communications•Jul 11, 2025•57 citations

Spectroscopic Measurements and Models of Energy Deposition in the Substrate of Quantum Circuits by Natural Ionizing Radiation

Joseph W. Fowler, Paul Szypryt, R. Bunker +16 more

Naturally occurring background radiation is a potential source of correlated decoherence events in superconducting qubits that will challenge error-correction schemes. In order to characterize the radiation environment in an unshielded laboratory representative of superconducting qubits’ environments, we performed broadband, spectroscopic measurements of background radiation events inside a millikelvin refrigerator. The spectrometer was designed to mimic the size and composition of a quantum circuit. Specifically, we measured the background radiation spectra in silicon substrates of two thicknesses, 500 and 1500 µm, and one area, 25 mm 2 . The observed spectra span energies from a few kilo-electron-volts up to nearly 10 MeV, are nearly featureless, and decrease in intensity by a factor of 40 000 between 100 keV and 3 MeV for the 500-µm substrate. We integrate the spectra to obtain the average event rates and deposited power levels. These quantities correspond to a rate of 0.023 events per second and a power of 4.9 keV s − 1 , when counting events that deposit at least 40 keV for the 500-µm-thick substrate. We find that the cryogenic measurements are in good agreement with predictions based on simple measurements of the terrestrial gamma-ray flux outside the refrigerator, published models of cosmic-ray fluxes, a crude model of the cryostat, and radiation-transport simulations. This model requires no free parameters to predict the background radiation spectra in the silicon substrates. The agreement between measurements and predictions demonstrates that the model we present can be used to assess the relative contributions of terrestrial and cosmic-ray sources to background radiation interactions in silicon substrates of varying thickness. These spectroscopic measurements are performed with a novel combination of superconducting microresonators located on micromachined silicon islands that define the interaction volume with background radiation. The resonators transduce deposited energy to a readily detectable electrical signal. Microresonator readout closely resembles dispersive superconducting qubit readout, so similar devices—with or without micromachined islands—are suitable for integration with superconducting quantum circuits as detectors for background radiation events. For our specific laboratory conditions, we find that gamma-ray emissions from radioisotopes are responsible for the majority of events that deposit E < 1 Me V . We present results demonstrating that the background radiation spectrum contains relevant contributions from cosmic-ray particles other than muons, particularly a tail of multi-mega-electron-volt events due to protons and neutrons. These observations suggest several paths to reducing the impact of background radiation on quantum circuits, supported by an empirically validated model for generating reliable predictions of radiation interactions with silicon substrates. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2404.10866•PRX Quantum•Nov 12, 2024•20 citations

A tunable coincidence counter based on superconducting nanowire cryotrons

Nai‐Tao Liu, Qingyuan Zhao, Y Huang +16 more

Single-photon coincidence counters are essential components in integrated quantum photonics, enabling efficient logic discrimination and real-time error correction at the chip level. However, monolithic integration at cryogenic temperature remains challenging. Here, we demonstrate a coincidence counter based on superconducting nanowire cryotrons (nTron). The circuit comprises five nTron devices, including delay gates, buffer gates, and an AND gate, achieving a maximum bias margin of 22% at a bit error rate (BER) of 10−5. Operating at 1 MHz, the counter exhibits a static power consumption of 282 nW and a dynamic power consumption of approximately 2 nW at a maximum operation frequency of 17 MHz. The coincidence time window is tunable, with a minimum width below 1 ns, and its position can be adjusted via bias currents. This design offers compatibility with superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors in fabrication and operation, supporting monolithic integration for scalable quantum photonic systems.

Applied Physics Letters•Jun 29, 2026•0 citations

Superconducting nanowire avalanche photodetectors

Sae Woo Nam, Brice Calkins, T. Gerritts +9 more

Superconducting devices offer the potential to perform at speeds and detection efficiencies higher than what is possible using conventional technologies (such as semiconducting avalanche photodiodes and photomultiplier tubs) for wavelengths from the ultraviolet to the mid-infrared. As a result, there has been increasing interest in using superconducting optical photon detectors in a variety of applications. There has been significant progress in using these types of detectors in areas of basic research such as quantum information science and quantum optics. These applications require detectors that have extremely low dark count rates, high count rates, and high quantum efficiency. I will begin by describing some of our earlier work on superconducting Transition-Edge Sensor (TES). In particular, I will describe some of the engineering involved in the cryogenic, electrical, and optical packaging so that these devices can be easily coupled into fiber-based optics. I will also describe our recent work on developing superconducting nanowire single photon detectors (SNSPD or SSPD). An SNSPD is an ultra-thin, ultra-narrow (nm scale) superconducting meander that is current biased just below its critical current density. When one or more photon is absorbed, a hot spot is formed that causes the superconductor to develop a resistance and consequently a voltage pulse. At NIST and JPL, we have been developing nanowire detectors using an amorphous alloy of tungsten-silicide. We will describe to construct systems using tungsten-silicide nanowires to achieve high detection efficiency (>90% at 1550nm). I will also describe our work to improve the performance of the device by fabricating multiple nanowires in an electrically parallel structure to implement a superconducting nanowire avalanche photodiode (SNAP)[1]. One example of this type of detector is shown in Fig 1. In this case, there are two tungsten silicide layers separated by a dielectric layer to optimize detection of light for any polarization[2]. In addition, progress on other types of SNAP detectors will be described to increase the signal size from a single photon, reduce the recovery time of the device, and to improve the jitter.

IEEE Photonics Conference•Sep 1, 2013•4 citations
Ionizing radiation produces correlated errors in superconducting qubits, posing some challenges to quantum error correction. In addition, it causes background events in other superconducting cryogenic devices, such as kinetic inductance detectors and superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors. Cosmic muons are a component of this background that can only be partly shielded against at ground level, but can be tagged by an independent detector inside the cryostat, so that the affected data can be vetoed, or the muon tags incorporated into error correction.
We present a low-cost, compact muon detector consisting of two plastic scintillator modules, each read out by a silicon photomultiplier (SiPM), operated in coincidence. We characterize the SiPMs from room temperature down to 10 mK, including the breakdown and upper-limit voltages that define the operating bias range. Operated as a muon counter, the detector measures a coincidence rate that, as expected, is independent of temperature within uncertainties and agrees with analytical and Monte Carlo predictions.
Below approximately 8 K, each muon event produces two pulses, one narrow and one broad, an effect that, to our knowledge, has not been reported before. Coincidences with an independent muon detector outside the cryostat confirm that muons are still counted reliably in this regime. By studying the appearance of double pulses as a function of temperature and magnetic field up to 4.5 T, we find a behavior consistent with the phase diagram of a type-II superconductor. This links the double pulses to a superconducting material in the SiPM, likely an adhesion layer or diffusion barrier introduced during manufacturing. The mechanism by which the superconducting state produces the second pulse is not yet understood.
Cosmic muons can generate correlated errors in superconducting qubits and backgrounds in other cryogenic superconducting devices. This paper investigates whether a compact scintillator–silicon-photomultiplier (SiPM) coincidence detector can reliably tag muons inside a dilution refrigerator.
The detector uses two 14×8×8 mm314\times8\times8\,\mathrm{mm}^314×8×8mm3 plastic scintillators coupled to commercial SiPMs; the scintillators, sensors and PCBs together cost under USD 100. Measurements from room temperature to approximately 10 mK10\,\mathrm{mK}10mK characterize the breakdown voltage and operational upper bias limit. Both vary non-monotonically at low temperature, defining a temperature-dependent operating window. Muon coincidence rates measured in two dilution refrigerators remain within 15% of their mean across temperatures and agree with analytical acceptance calculations and Geant4 simulations, including measured building attenuation. The analytical prediction is 8.1±1.48.1\pm1.48.1±1.4 events per hour.
Below approximately 8 K8\,\mathrm{K}8K, the sensor response splits into prompt narrow and delayed broad pulses. Temperature and magnetic-field scans up to 4.5 T4.5\,\mathrm{T}4.5T show that suppressing this splitting follows a superconducting-like phase boundary, with fitted Tc=8.05±0.08 KT_c=8.05\pm0.08\,\mathrm{K}Tc​=8.05±0.08K and extrapolated Bc2(0)=8.1±0.5 TB_{c2}(0)=8.1\pm0.5\,\mathrm{T}Bc2​(0)=8.1±0.5T. A forward-voltage transition near 8.08 K8.08\,\mathrm{K}8.08K provides additional evidence for superconducting material within the SiPM. Timing remains usable: 152 fourfold coincidences with external detectors confirm muon detection despite splitting.
The responsible material and pulse-generation mechanism remain unidentified, and extracting photon counts from split waveforms is unresolved. Operation alongside a qubit array and use of tags in error correction are left to future work.
Ionizing radiation has emerged as a potential limiting factor for superconducting quantum processors, inducing quasiparticle bursts and correlated errors that challenge fault-tolerant operation. Atmospheric muons are particularly problematic due to their high energy and penetration power, making passive shielding ineffective. Therefore, monitoring the real-time muon flux is crucial to guide the development of alternative error-correction or mitigation strategies. We present the design, simulation, and first operation of a cryogenic muon-tagging system based on Kinetic Inductance Detectors (KIDs), developed as a stand-alone cryogenic particle-tagging module for superconducting quantum processors. The system consists of two KIDs arranged in a vertical stack and operated at $\sim$20 mK. Monte Carlo simulations based on Geant4 guided the prototype design and provided reference expectations for muon-tagging efficiency and accidental coincidences due to ambient γγγ-rays. We observed a muon-induced coincidence rate among the top and bottom detectors of (192 ±\pm± 9)×10−3\times10^{-3}×10−3 events/s, in excellent agreement with the Monte Carlo prediction. The prototype achieves a muon-tagging efficiency of about 90% with negligible dead time. These results demonstrate the feasibility of operating a muon-tagging system at millikelvin temperatures and represent a key step toward the integration of cryogenic veto systems with multi-qubit chips to mitigate muon-induced errors.
Most quantum error correction (QEC) protocols for superconducting qubits assume spatially and temporally uncorrelated decoherence events; however, recent evidence suggests that cosmic radiation induces spatially correlated errors. We present a platform that sandwiches a superconducting transmon qubit between two microwave kinetic inductance detector (MKID) arrays, enabling real-time detection of radiation-induced phonon bursts. By synchronizing MKID event detection with single-shot measurements of qubit energy relaxation (T1T_1T1​) and phase coherence (T2T_2T2​), we observe statistically significant reductions in both T1T_1T1​ and T2T_2T2​-up to 30.5%-immediately following dual MKID events attributed to penetrating muons. Our findings directly link radiating events to correlated qubit decoherence. Furthermore, our experimental platform provides a foundation for systematic studies of radiation effects, the development of shielding and mitigation techniques, and the refinement of error-correction algorithms tailored to correlated noise sources.
Quantum information processing at scale will require sufficiently stable and long-lived qubits, likely enabled by error-correction codes. Several recent superconducting-qubit experiments, however, reported observing intermittent spatiotemporally correlated errors that would be problematic for conventional codes, with ionizing radiation being a likely cause. Here, we directly measured the cosmic-ray contribution to spatiotemporally correlated qubit errors. We accomplished this by synchronously monitoring cosmic-ray detectors and qubit energy-relaxation dynamics of 10 transmon qubits distributed across a 5 × 5 × 0.35 mm3 silicon chip. Cosmic rays caused correlated errors at a rate of 1/(592+48−41 s)1/\left(592\begin{array}{c}+48\\ -41\end{array}\,{\rm{s}}\right)1/(592+48−41​s) , accounting for 17.1 ± 1.3% of all such events. Our qubits responded to essentially all of the cosmic rays and their secondary particles incident on the chip, consistent with the independently measured arrival flux. Moreover, we observed that the landscape of the superconducting gap in proximity to the Josephson junctions dramatically impacts the qubit response to cosmic rays. Given the practical difficulties associated with shielding cosmic rays, our results indicate the importance of radiation hardening—for example, superconducting gap engineering—to the realization of robust quantum error correction. Ionizing radiation from cosmic rays has been identified as a source of correlated errors in superconducting qubits, but a direct demonstration of this link has been lacking. Here the authors measure the coincidence between correlated errors and incident cosmic rays in a chip with 10 transmon qubits.
Naturally occurring background radiation is a potential source of correlated decoherence events in superconducting qubits that will challenge error-correction schemes. In order to characterize the radiation environment in an unshielded laboratory representative of superconducting qubits’ environments, we performed broadband, spectroscopic measurements of background radiation events inside a millikelvin refrigerator. The spectrometer was designed to mimic the size and composition of a quantum circuit. Specifically, we measured the background radiation spectra in silicon substrates of two thicknesses, 500 and 1500 µm, and one area, 25 mm 2 . The observed spectra span energies from a few kilo-electron-volts up to nearly 10 MeV, are nearly featureless, and decrease in intensity by a factor of 40 000 between 100 keV and 3 MeV for the 500-µm substrate. We integrate the spectra to obtain the average event rates and deposited power levels. These quantities correspond to a rate of 0.023 events per second and a power of 4.9 keV s − 1 , when counting events that deposit at least 40 keV for the 500-µm-thick substrate. We find that the cryogenic measurements are in good agreement with predictions based on simple measurements of the terrestrial gamma-ray flux outside the refrigerator, published models of cosmic-ray fluxes, a crude model of the cryostat, and radiation-transport simulations. This model requires no free parameters to predict the background radiation spectra in the silicon substrates. The agreement between measurements and predictions demonstrates that the model we present can be used to assess the relative contributions of terrestrial and cosmic-ray sources to background radiation interactions in silicon substrates of varying thickness. These spectroscopic measurements are performed with a novel combination of superconducting microresonators located on micromachined silicon islands that define the interaction volume with background radiation. The resonators transduce deposited energy to a readily detectable electrical signal. Microresonator readout closely resembles dispersive superconducting qubit readout, so similar devices—with or without micromachined islands—are suitable for integration with superconducting quantum circuits as detectors for background radiation events. For our specific laboratory conditions, we find that gamma-ray emissions from radioisotopes are responsible for the majority of events that deposit E < 1 Me V . We present results demonstrating that the background radiation spectrum contains relevant contributions from cosmic-ray particles other than muons, particularly a tail of multi-mega-electron-volt events due to protons and neutrons. These observations suggest several paths to reducing the impact of background radiation on quantum circuits, supported by an empirically validated model for generating reliable predictions of radiation interactions with silicon substrates. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Single-photon coincidence counters are essential components in integrated quantum photonics, enabling efficient logic discrimination and real-time error correction at the chip level. However, monolithic integration at cryogenic temperature remains challenging. Here, we demonstrate a coincidence counter based on superconducting nanowire cryotrons (nTron). The circuit comprises five nTron devices, including delay gates, buffer gates, and an AND gate, achieving a maximum bias margin of 22% at a bit error rate (BER) of 10−5. Operating at 1 MHz, the counter exhibits a static power consumption of 282 nW and a dynamic power consumption of approximately 2 nW at a maximum operation frequency of 17 MHz. The coincidence time window is tunable, with a minimum width below 1 ns, and its position can be adjusted via bias currents. This design offers compatibility with superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors in fabrication and operation, supporting monolithic integration for scalable quantum photonic systems.
Superconducting devices offer the potential to perform at speeds and detection efficiencies higher than what is possible using conventional technologies (such as semiconducting avalanche photodiodes and photomultiplier tubs) for wavelengths from the ultraviolet to the mid-infrared. As a result, there has been increasing interest in using superconducting optical photon detectors in a variety of applications. There has been significant progress in using these types of detectors in areas of basic research such as quantum information science and quantum optics. These applications require detectors that have extremely low dark count rates, high count rates, and high quantum efficiency. I will begin by describing some of our earlier work on superconducting Transition-Edge Sensor (TES). In particular, I will describe some of the engineering involved in the cryogenic, electrical, and optical packaging so that these devices can be easily coupled into fiber-based optics. I will also describe our recent work on developing superconducting nanowire single photon detectors (SNSPD or SSPD). An SNSPD is an ultra-thin, ultra-narrow (nm scale) superconducting meander that is current biased just below its critical current density. When one or more photon is absorbed, a hot spot is formed that causes the superconductor to develop a resistance and consequently a voltage pulse. At NIST and JPL, we have been developing nanowire detectors using an amorphous alloy of tungsten-silicide. We will describe to construct systems using tungsten-silicide nanowires to achieve high detection efficiency (>90% at 1550nm). I will also describe our work to improve the performance of the device by fabricating multiple nanowires in an electrically parallel structure to implement a superconducting nanowire avalanche photodiode (SNAP)[1]. One example of this type of detector is shown in Fig 1. In this case, there are two tungsten silicide layers separated by a dielectric layer to optimize detection of light for any polarization[2]. In addition, progress on other types of SNAP detectors will be described to increase the signal size from a single photon, reduce the recovery time of the device, and to improve the jitter.