arXiv:2610.19304
Leakage benchmarking with decohering subgroups in the presence of preparation and measurement errors
Shawn Geller, Tongyu Zhao, Alex Kwiatkowski, Scott Glancy, Raymond W. Simmonds, Emanuel Knill
Abstract
A common problem with physical qubits is that the state can leak outside the computational subspace. To characterize the problem, it is desirable to measure both the leakage probability and the fidelity of gates inside the computational subspace. Randomized benchmarking is a readily accessible method for estimating average gate fidelities and can be modified to account for leakage. However, in the presence of state preparation and measurement errors (SPAM) there are parameter degeneracies, and fidelities and leakage become underdetermined. We study the example of qudits with any number of leakage levels under the assumption of gate-independent noise. We show that randomized benchmarking sequences with leakage level decoherence can be analyzed as a Markov process with noisy classical preparations and measurements. This result generalizes to randomized benchmarking with random gates from an arbitrary group that contains a phase-decohering subgroup. We characterize the parameter degeneracy in inferring the Markov process, preparations and measurements. Based on this characterization we develop a measurement and inference method taking advantage of known conservative bounds on SPAM to constrain fidelity, leakage and other parameters of the Markov process, state preparations and measurements. As part of our study, we experimentally implemented the measurement method for a qubit defined on the one-excitation subspace of two transmons, for which there are two leakage levels. We determined confidence intervals accounting for parameter degeneracy for a number of performance parameters of the system. For leakage and fidelity, we compare these intervals to those obtained for several conventional methods for leakage benchmarking.
AI Summary
Leakage randomized benchmarking can leave gate fidelity, leakage and seepage underdetermined when state preparation and measurement (SPAM) are unknown: distinct physical parameters can produce identical outcome probabilities. This paper develops decohering-subgroup randomized benchmarking (DSRB) to characterize that ambiguity and bound performance parameters using conservative SPAM constraints. For gate-independent noise and benchmarking groups containing a subgroup whose average dephases an orthogonal basis, the sequence-averaged experiment reduces to a classical Markov process with noisy preparations and measurements. The group need not be a unitary design. The paper characterizes the similarity-transformation gauge freedom, constructs an observable representation, and combines constrained maximum-likelihood inference with an outer approximation to the gauge-compatible parameter region. Statistical uncertainty is assessed by bootstrap resampling. An implementation uses a dual-rail qubit in two transmons, with two distinguishable leakage levels, two measurement settings and $4\times10^6$ trials. Assuming preparation and relevant measurement-identification probabilities are at least $0.8$, the reported gauge-inclusive $68\%$ intervals are $[0.00075,0.00138]$ for conditional gate error, $[0.00825,0.00895]$ for leakage to the ground state, and $[0.00148,0.00184]$ for leakage to the doubly excited state. Conventional benchmarking fits give higher conditional-error and lower total-leakage estimates on these data. The bounds retain nonzero width even with unlimited data. Gate-dependent noise is not covered, and leakage decoherence is assumed rather than actively enforced experimentally. Only 40 random sequences per configuration were repeated. Substantial model mismatch remains: the total fit statistic is $T^2=312.67$, versus an expected $30.33$ under the model, indicating systematic uncertainty not captured by the reported intervals.
Much of the description of the specific implementation in the appendix was initially generated by AI.
Error found: The reported experimental confidence intervals do not establish their nominal coverage for the physical device's leakage and fidelity because the fitted Markov model fails the paper's own goodness-of-fit check and systematic biases remain unquantified. The finite-grid gauge search does not establish guaranteed enclosure of all continuously admissible parameter values because the supplied method provides no certified control between grid points.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.