Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.19060

The cost of classically simulating quantum communication is as high as it could be

Riccardo Castellano, Pavel Sekatski, Nicolas Brunner

quant-phSubmitted Oct 13, 2026• Announced Oct 15, 2026• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A long-standing open question is to characterize the classical communication cost of simulating the correlations arising from measurements on finite-dimensional quantum systems. We consider this question in the prepare-and-measure scenario. First we construct a classical simulation model involving a finite average number of bits of one-way communication that simulates exactly the correlations arising from arbitrary $d$-dimensional quantum states and arbitrary measurements. Second, we show that no classical simulation protocol involving a finite average message dimension can exist for $d\geq 4$, hence strengthening a recent result of de Gois, Santos and Vieira. Our first result relies on a more general simulation theorem which can be applied to certain continuous variable (i.e. infinite-dimensional) quantum systems, and even beyond quantum theory, e.g. to generalized probabilistic theories. In particular, we show that multimode Gaussian states of bounded average energy and general Gaussian measurements admit an exact classical simulation with a finite expected number of bits. Overall, our results show that the classical simulation cost of quantum communication is essentially as high as it could be.

AI Summary

The paper asks how much one-way classical communication, assisted by unlimited shared randomness, is needed to reproduce exactly prepare-and-measure correlations for arbitrary qudit states and POVMs. It distinguishes worst-case alphabet size, expected alphabet size, and expected bit cost $\mathbb E[\log_2 D_\lambda]$, where the shared randomness determines the message alphabet. For $d\geq4$, every measurable exact simulation must have $\mathbb E[D_\lambda]=\infty$, strengthening the previously known impossibility of a bounded alphabet. Nevertheless, every finite-dimensional quantum system admits an exact simulation using $O(d\log d)$ expected bits, with communication tail $\Pr(\log_2D_\lambda\geq k)\leq C_d2^{-k/(2d-2)}$. The construction also yields one-way simulations of arbitrary bipartite finite-dimensional entangled-state correlations. The upper bound follows from a general theorem: polynomial covering growth under a measurement-dependent “mass deficit,” measuring probability mass not common to all inputs in a cell, suffices for finite expected communication. A geometrically distributed shared resolution selects a nested partition; recursive lower-envelope decoders recover the target distribution exactly. The lower bound extends an existing fixed-fidelity zero-slope argument using dominated convergence. Applications include deterministic approximate qudit simulation with $D(q\|p)\leq K_dN^{-1/(d-1)}$ for alphabet size $N$, and exact simulation of energy-bounded multimode Gaussian states under general-dyne and homodyne measurements, using $O(n^2\log E+n^2\log n)$ expected bits at large energy. Optimal expected-cost scaling and tail exponents remain open, as do multipartite one-way extensions and whether the Gaussian setting permits finite expected alphabet size.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosedOverclaims
ChatGPT Sol 5.6 and ChatGPT Astra 6.0 have contributed via extensive dialogues with the authors. This helped prove the statements, as well as identifying and correcting errors.

Error found: The discussion after the main simulation theorem claims O(d) expected bits for arbitrary bipartite Bell correlations, but the supplied protocol and conditional-state reduction establish only O(d log d).

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
11 pages of main, 11 of appendix. 1 figure

Related papers

Bounding Two-Way Average Communication Cost of Simulating Quantum Correlations

Kai-Siang Chen, Gelo Noel M. Tabia, Bo-An Tsai +2 more

Bell nonlocal correlations cannot be reproduced by local hidden-variable models without communication, making classical communication cost a natural quantitative measure of nonlocality. Although finite communication always suffices to simulate any correlation in a fixed finite Bell scenario, determining the minimum amount needed to (exactly) simulate any given nonlocal correlation remains challenging, especially in the average-cost setting. Here, we derive lower bounds on input-average communication cost from nonlocal games, allowing variable-length, fully interactive two-way protocols. When applied to parallel games, these bounds yield explicit finite quantum correlations for which the exact simulation cost exceeds any prescribed finite input-average communication budget. For $n$ parallel Magic-Square-winning correlations, we prove a lower bound of $n\log_2(3/2)$ bits and give a one-way communication protocol that attains this rate asymptotically. For the quantum correlation maximally winning the $n$-copy of the Clauser--Horne--Shimony--Holt nonlocal game, we obtain an input-average lower bound of approximately $0.04627n$ bits for exact simulation. Finally, we formulate a hierarchy of lower bounds and complementary upper bounds using deterministic correlations up to chosen communication costs. Both recover the exact input-average cost at their final levels, and if the bounds agree at lower levels, their common value yields the exact input-average cost without needing to consider all communication strategies.

quant-pharXiv:2610.04648•Oct 6, 2026•0 citations

Bounding the classical cost of simulating quantum behaviors in the prepare-and-measure scenario

Sebastian Schlösser, Matthias Kleinmann

We study the prepare-and-measure scenario in which Alice transmits a quantum system to Bob, who then performs a quantum measurement. The quantum state of the system is unknown to Bob, and the measurement is unknown to Alice. It has recently been shown that shared randomness and two bits of classical communication are necessary and sufficient to simulate the transmission of a qubit. We show that the communication cost can be reduced to an average of $1.89$ bits. We then study restricted sets of state preparations: First, for a restriction to real-valued qubit states, if the communication of a classical trit is sufficient, we show that the corresponding protocol must have a convoluted form. We then reduce the smallest qubit scenario requiring two bits of classical communication to only $6$ state preparations and $5$ measurements. For a qutrit, it is not known whether the communication cost is finite; we identify a scenario that requires at least $5$ classical messages, already for the simulation of the real qutrit. Finally, we develop a method for restricted sets of states, that allows us to lower bound the classical communication cost based solely on the set of quantum states.

quant-pharXiv:2603.01255•Mar 3, 2026•7 citations

Classical simulation of quantum entanglement without local hidden variables

Serge Massar, Dave Bacon, Nicolas J. Cerf +1 more

Recent work has extended Bell's theorem by quantifying the amount of communication required to simulate entangled quantum systems with classical information. The general scenario is that a bipartite measurement is given from a set of possibilities and the goal is to find a classical scheme that reproduces exactly the correlations that arise when an actual quantum system is measured. Previous results have shown that, using local hidden variables, a finite amount of communication suffices to simulate the correlations for a Bell state. We extend this in a number of ways. First, we show that, when the communication is merely required to be finite on average, Bell states can be simulated without any local hidden variables. More generally, we show that arbitrary positive operator valued measurements on systems of n Bell states can be simulated with ${O(n2}^{n})$ bits of communication on average (again, without local hidden variables). On the other hand, when the communication is required to be absolutely bounded, we show that a finite number of bits of local hidden variables is insufficient to simulate a Bell state. This latter result is based on an analysis of the nondeterministic communication complexity of the NOT-EQUAL function, which is constant in the quantum model and logarithmic in the classical model.

arXiv:quant-ph/0009088•Physical Review A•Apr 16, 2001•83 citations

Quantum communication and Bell nonlocality require infinite classical communication to simulate

Carlos de Gois, Thyago S. R. Santos, Carlos Vieira

A quantum system of any fixed dimension can be prepared in a continuum of states, yet it cannot be used to transmit an unlimited amount of classical information. Similarly, the correlations observed between measurement outcomes on separate parts of a shared quantum system can be stronger than classical correlations, but they cannot transmit information. These fundamental limitations suggest that the statistics observed from quantum communication and quantum correlations may admit a simulation using a finite amount of classical communication. This expectation is confirmed in the smallest nontrivial quantum dimension, with two classical bits being necessary and sufficient to exactly simulate qubit communication and all correlations between qubits. Despite significant efforts during the previous decades, this remained the only solved case. Here we resolve both problems for every quantum dimension. The solution reveals an unexpected qualitative transition starting at dimension four: no finite amount of classical communication can exactly simulate ququart communication nor all quantum correlations of two entangled ququarts, even with unlimited shared randomness. One might have expected this transition, if it existed, to appear already for qutrits. Instead, we construct an explicit protocol that exactly simulates qutrit communication using $357$ classical bits, and consequently, all correlations of two entangled qutrits.

quant-pharXiv:2609.04182•Sep 4, 2026•5 citations

Lower bound on the communication cost of simulating bipartite quantum correlations

Tamás Vértesi, Erika Bene

Suppose Alice and Bob share a maximally entangled state of any finite dimension and each perform two-outcome measurements on the respective part of the state. It is known, due to the recent result of Regev and Toner, that if a classical model is augmented with two bits of communication, then all the quantum correlations arising from these measurements can be reproduced. Here, we show that two bits of communication are in fact necessary for the perfect simulation. In particular, we prove that a pair of maximally entangled four-dimensional quantum systems cannot be simulated by a classical model augmented by only one bit of communication.

arXiv:0904.1390•Physical Review A•Dec 8, 2009•16 citations

Lower Bounds on the Communication Complexity of Binary Local Quantum Measurement Simulation

Adrian Kosowski, Markiewicz, Marcin

We consider the problem of the classical simulation of quantum measurements in the scenario of communication complexity. Regev and Toner (2007) have presented a 2-bit protocol which simulates one particular correlation function arising from binary projective quantum measurements on arbitrary state, and in particular does not preserve local averages. The question of simulating other correlation functions using a protocol with bounded communication, or preserving local averages, has been posed as an open one. Within this paper we resolve it in the negative: we show that any such protocol must have unbounded communication for some subset of executions. In particular, we show that for any protocol, there exist inputs for which the random variable describing the number of communicated bits has arbitrarily large variance.

arXiv:1310.2217•Oct 8, 2013•1 citation
A long-standing open question is to characterize the classical communication cost of simulating the correlations arising from measurements on finite-dimensional quantum systems. We consider this question in the prepare-and-measure scenario. First we construct a classical simulation model involving a finite average number of bits of one-way communication that simulates exactly the correlations arising from arbitrary ddd-dimensional quantum states and arbitrary measurements. Second, we show that no classical simulation protocol involving a finite average message dimension can exist for d≥4d\geq 4d≥4, hence strengthening a recent result of de Gois, Santos and Vieira. Our first result relies on a more general simulation theorem which can be applied to certain continuous variable (i.e. infinite-dimensional) quantum systems, and even beyond quantum theory, e.g. to generalized probabilistic theories. In particular, we show that multimode Gaussian states of bounded average energy and general Gaussian measurements admit an exact classical simulation with a finite expected number of bits. Overall, our results show that the classical simulation cost of quantum communication is essentially as high as it could be.
The paper asks how much one-way classical communication, assisted by unlimited shared randomness, is needed to reproduce exactly prepare-and-measure correlations for arbitrary qudit states and POVMs. It distinguishes worst-case alphabet size, expected alphabet size, and expected bit cost E[log⁡2Dλ]\mathbb E[\log_2 D_\lambda]E[log2​Dλ​], where the shared randomness determines the message alphabet.
For d≥4d\geq4d≥4, every measurable exact simulation must have E[Dλ]=∞\mathbb E[D_\lambda]=\inftyE[Dλ​]=∞, strengthening the previously known impossibility of a bounded alphabet. Nevertheless, every finite-dimensional quantum system admits an exact simulation using O(dlog⁡d)O(d\log d)O(dlogd) expected bits, with communication tail Pr⁡(log⁡2Dλ≥k)≤Cd2−k/(2d−2)\Pr(\log_2D_\lambda\geq k)\leq C_d2^{-k/(2d-2)}Pr(log2​Dλ​≥k)≤Cd​2−k/(2d−2). The construction also yields one-way simulations of arbitrary bipartite finite-dimensional entangled-state correlations.
The upper bound follows from a general theorem: polynomial covering growth under a measurement-dependent “mass deficit,” measuring probability mass not common to all inputs in a cell, suffices for finite expected communication. A geometrically distributed shared resolution selects a nested partition; recursive lower-envelope decoders recover the target distribution exactly. The lower bound extends an existing fixed-fidelity zero-slope argument using dominated convergence.
Applications include deterministic approximate qudit simulation with D(q∥p)≤KdN−1/(d−1)D(q\|p)\leq K_dN^{-1/(d-1)}D(q∥p)≤Kd​N−1/(d−1) for alphabet size NNN, and exact simulation of energy-bounded multimode Gaussian states under general-dyne and homodyne measurements, using O(n2log⁡E+n2log⁡n)O(n^2\log E+n^2\log n)O(n2logE+n2logn) expected bits at large energy. Optimal expected-cost scaling and tail exponents remain open, as do multipartite one-way extensions and whether the Gaussian setting permits finite expected alphabet size.
Bell nonlocal correlations cannot be reproduced by local hidden-variable models without communication, making classical communication cost a natural quantitative measure of nonlocality. Although finite communication always suffices to simulate any correlation in a fixed finite Bell scenario, determining the minimum amount needed to (exactly) simulate any given nonlocal correlation remains challenging, especially in the average-cost setting. Here, we derive lower bounds on input-average communication cost from nonlocal games, allowing variable-length, fully interactive two-way protocols. When applied to parallel games, these bounds yield explicit finite quantum correlations for which the exact simulation cost exceeds any prescribed finite input-average communication budget. For nnn parallel Magic-Square-winning correlations, we prove a lower bound of nlog⁡2(3/2)n\log_2(3/2)nlog2​(3/2) bits and give a one-way communication protocol that attains this rate asymptotically. For the quantum correlation maximally winning the nnn-copy of the Clauser--Horne--Shimony--Holt nonlocal game, we obtain an input-average lower bound of approximately 0.04627n0.04627n0.04627n bits for exact simulation. Finally, we formulate a hierarchy of lower bounds and complementary upper bounds using deterministic correlations up to chosen communication costs. Both recover the exact input-average cost at their final levels, and if the bounds agree at lower levels, their common value yields the exact input-average cost without needing to consider all communication strategies.
We study the prepare-and-measure scenario in which Alice transmits a quantum system to Bob, who then performs a quantum measurement. The quantum state of the system is unknown to Bob, and the measurement is unknown to Alice. It has recently been shown that shared randomness and two bits of classical communication are necessary and sufficient to simulate the transmission of a qubit. We show that the communication cost can be reduced to an average of 1.891.891.89 bits. We then study restricted sets of state preparations: First, for a restriction to real-valued qubit states, if the communication of a classical trit is sufficient, we show that the corresponding protocol must have a convoluted form. We then reduce the smallest qubit scenario requiring two bits of classical communication to only 666 state preparations and 555 measurements. For a qutrit, it is not known whether the communication cost is finite; we identify a scenario that requires at least 555 classical messages, already for the simulation of the real qutrit. Finally, we develop a method for restricted sets of states, that allows us to lower bound the classical communication cost based solely on the set of quantum states.
Recent work has extended Bell's theorem by quantifying the amount of communication required to simulate entangled quantum systems with classical information. The general scenario is that a bipartite measurement is given from a set of possibilities and the goal is to find a classical scheme that reproduces exactly the correlations that arise when an actual quantum system is measured. Previous results have shown that, using local hidden variables, a finite amount of communication suffices to simulate the correlations for a Bell state. We extend this in a number of ways. First, we show that, when the communication is merely required to be finite on average, Bell states can be simulated without any local hidden variables. More generally, we show that arbitrary positive operator valued measurements on systems of n Bell states can be simulated with O(n2n){O(n2}^{n})O(n2n) bits of communication on average (again, without local hidden variables). On the other hand, when the communication is required to be absolutely bounded, we show that a finite number of bits of local hidden variables is insufficient to simulate a Bell state. This latter result is based on an analysis of the nondeterministic communication complexity of the NOT-EQUAL function, which is constant in the quantum model and logarithmic in the classical model.
A quantum system of any fixed dimension can be prepared in a continuum of states, yet it cannot be used to transmit an unlimited amount of classical information. Similarly, the correlations observed between measurement outcomes on separate parts of a shared quantum system can be stronger than classical correlations, but they cannot transmit information. These fundamental limitations suggest that the statistics observed from quantum communication and quantum correlations may admit a simulation using a finite amount of classical communication. This expectation is confirmed in the smallest nontrivial quantum dimension, with two classical bits being necessary and sufficient to exactly simulate qubit communication and all correlations between qubits. Despite significant efforts during the previous decades, this remained the only solved case. Here we resolve both problems for every quantum dimension. The solution reveals an unexpected qualitative transition starting at dimension four: no finite amount of classical communication can exactly simulate ququart communication nor all quantum correlations of two entangled ququarts, even with unlimited shared randomness. One might have expected this transition, if it existed, to appear already for qutrits. Instead, we construct an explicit protocol that exactly simulates qutrit communication using 357357357 classical bits, and consequently, all correlations of two entangled qutrits.
Suppose Alice and Bob share a maximally entangled state of any finite dimension and each perform two-outcome measurements on the respective part of the state. It is known, due to the recent result of Regev and Toner, that if a classical model is augmented with two bits of communication, then all the quantum correlations arising from these measurements can be reproduced. Here, we show that two bits of communication are in fact necessary for the perfect simulation. In particular, we prove that a pair of maximally entangled four-dimensional quantum systems cannot be simulated by a classical model augmented by only one bit of communication.
We consider the problem of the classical simulation of quantum measurements in the scenario of communication complexity. Regev and Toner (2007) have presented a 2-bit protocol which simulates one particular correlation function arising from binary projective quantum measurements on arbitrary state, and in particular does not preserve local averages. The question of simulating other correlation functions using a protocol with bounded communication, or preserving local averages, has been posed as an open one. Within this paper we resolve it in the negative: we show that any such protocol must have unbounded communication for some subset of executions. In particular, we show that for any protocol, there exist inputs for which the random variable describing the number of communicated bits has arbitrarily large variance.