Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.19034

Logical gate set tomography

Piper C. Wysocki, Juan Gonzalez De Mendoza, Karl Mayer, Natalie C. Brown, Ciaran Ryan-Anderson, Jalan A. Ziyad, Jordan H. Hines, Daniel G. Hothem, Corey I. Ostrove, Timothy J. Proctor, Kevin C. Young, Robin J. Blume-Kohout, Charles H. Baldwin, Kenneth M. Rudinger

quant-phSubmitted Oct 13, 2026• Announced Oct 15, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum error correction (QEC) can strongly suppress noise, but predicting whether a computation succeeds requires understanding not only how much effective noise persists after QEC, but what form that noise takes. To thoroughly characterize this noise, we introduce logical gate set tomography (``logical GST''). Logical GST produces detailed representations of noisy logical operations that can be used to derive higher-level metrics, such as gate fidelity and diamond distance, and to test for non-Markovian and coherent logical errors. We use logical GST to obtain the first full, self-consistent characterization of a universal single-qubit logical gate set, implemented in the seven-qubit Steane code using Quantinuum System Model H1, a 20-qubit trapped-ion quantum processor. In the experimental data from H1, logical GST identified predominantly logical Pauli-stochastic errors, found no evidence of logical non-Markovianity, and detected weak potential signatures of coherent logical error. By contrast, higher-shot datasets generated with Quantinuum's detailed system emulator, identify mechanisms for weak but statistically significant logical non-Markovianity and strong evidence of coherent logical error. Finally, we use logical GST to perform error attribution with the system emulator, revealing how specific physical error sources shape logical error mechanisms.

AI Summary

Logical error rates alone do not determine how errors accumulate in fault-tolerant circuits. This paper adapts gate set tomography (GST) to encoded operations, estimating self-consistent logical channels while testing whether fixed Markovian channels and Pauli-stochastic noise adequately describe the data. The experimental demonstration characterizes logical preparation, measurement, idle, $H_L$, $S_L$, and magic-state-injected $T_L$ operations in the $\llbracket7,1,3\rrbracket$ Steane code on Quantinuum H1-1, using active correction. A compressed design uses 158 circuits with approximately 50 retained shots each, reaching 38 QEC cycles. Maximum-likelihood CPTP fits give entanglement infidelities of $(0.7\pm0.4)\%$, $(0.2\pm0.4)\%$, and $(1.2\pm1.5)\%$ for $H_L$, $S_L$, and $T_L$, respectively, with 95% intervals. Hardware data show no significant non-Markovianity or rejection of Pauli-stochastic noise, although individual coherent axis-misalignment parameters modestly improve fits. Emulator datasets use 931 circuits and 14,100 shots per circuit, independently toggling leakage and coherent memory errors. Likelihood tests detect strong departures from Pauli-stochastic noise when memory errors are enabled and weaker non-Markovianity, requiring unmodeled error below 1% of per-operation diamond-distance error. Logical over-rotations near $0.0015\pi$ are resolved for $S_L$, idle, and $T_L$; an independent logical Ramsey experiment corroborates the $S_L$ estimate. Automated model selection removes at least 22 of 43 observable parameters. Limitations include low hardware statistical power, emulator dependence, and implementation-specific distance-three behavior. The $T_L$ reconstruction conditions on post-selection acceptance. Mechanisms underlying emergent non-Markovianity remain unresolved, and Pauli-frame tracking could change the observed noise.

Little sign of AI-generated textAI use disclosed
the authors used AI-based tools to assist in generating code for analysis and visualization and to support manuscript outlining, drafting, and prose development.

Error found: The abstract's full-characterization claim omits that the reconstructed T_L operation is conditioned on successful injection and excludes rejected outcomes. The abstract overstates the identification of emergent logical non-Markovianity mechanisms relative to the appendix's explicitly tentative conclusions. The evidence-ratio equation has the wrong denominator sign under the paper's definition of kappa, although its reported values and interpretation use a positive ratio. The appendix's proposed explanation of residual T_L coherent error yields a symmetric stochastic-channel generator with no first-order Hamiltonian component, so its commutator rewriting does not establish the claimed coherent mechanism.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

A context-aware gate set tomography: Improving the self-consistent characterization of trapped-ion universal gate sets by leveraging non-Markovianity

Pablo Viñas, A. Bermudez

Abstract To progress in the characterization of noise for quantum computers, gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a self-consistent protocol that accurately estimates noisy gates, state preparations, and measurements. In its original incarnation, GST improves estimation precision by applying gates sequentially, assuming the noise yields fixed completely-positive and trace-preserving (CPTP) maps independent of prior gate history. This ‘Markovian’ assumption can conflict with experiments, where time-correlated noise may induce non-Markovian dynamics, or slow drifts and cumulative calibration errors introduce context dependence, causing CP-divisible maps to vary with circuit depth. In this work, we address this issue for trapped-ion devices with phonon-mediated two-qubit gates. Using detailed microscopic modeling of high-fidelity light-shift gates, we tailor GST to capture the main source of context dependence: motional degrees of freedom. Rather than invalidating GST, context dependence can be incorporated into the gate-set parametrization, reducing sampling cost. Our results identify a promising research avenue that might be applicable to other platforms where microscopic modeling can be incorporated: the development of a context-aware GST.

arXiv:2507.02542•npj Quantum Information•Jun 26, 2026•2 citations

Emergent Non-Markovianity in Logical Qubit Dynamics

Jalan A. Ziyad, Robin Blume-Kohout, Kenneth Rudinger

Logical qubits encoded in quantum error correcting codes can exhibit non-Markovian dynamical evolution, even when the underlying physical noise is Markovian. To understand this emergent non-Markovianity, we define a Markovianity condition appropriate to logical gate operations, and study it by relating logical operations to their physical implementation (operations on the data qubits into which the logical qubit is encoded). We apply our analysis to small quantum codes, and show that they exhibit non-Markovian dynamics even for very simple physical noise models. We show that non-Markovianity can emerge from Markovian physical operations if (and only if) the physical qubits are not necessarily returned to the code subspace after every round of QEC. In this situation, the syndrome qubits can act as a memory, mediating time correlations and enabling violation of the Markov condition. We quantify the emergent non-Markovianity in simple examples, and propose sufficient conditions for reliable use of gate-based characterization techniques like gate set tomography in early fault-tolerant quantum devices.

quant-pharXiv:2512.08893•Dec 10, 2025

Introduction to Quantum Gate Set Tomography

Greenbaum, Daniel

Quantum gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a promising method for the full characterization of quantum logic gates. In contrast to quantum process tomography (QPT), GST self-consistently and correctly accounts for state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors. It therefore provides significantly more accurate estimates than QPT as gate fidelities increase into the fault-tolerant regime. We give a detailed review of GST and provide a self-contained guide to its implementation. The method is presented in a step-by-step fashion and relevant mathematical background material is included. Our goal is to demonstrate the utility of GST as both an accurate characterization technique and a simple and effective diagnostic tool. As an illustration, we compare the output of GST and QPT using simulated example data for a single qubit. In agreement with the original literature, we find that coherent errors are poorly estimated by QPT near quantum error correction thresholds, while GST is accurate in this regime.

arXiv:1509.02921•Sep 9, 2015•273 citations

Non-Markovian quantum gate set tomography

Ze‐Tong Li, Congcong Zheng, Fanxu Meng +4 more

Abstract Engineering quantum devices requires reliable characterization of the quantum system, including qubits, quantum operations (also known as instruments) and the quantum noise. Recently, quantum gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a powerful technique for self-consistently describing quantum states, gates, and measurements. However, non-Markovian correlations between the quantum system and environment impact the reliability of GST. To address this, we propose a self-consistent operational framework called instrument set tomography (IST) for non-Markovian GST. Based on the stochastic quantum process, the instrument set describes instruments and system-environment (SE) correlations. We introduce a linear inversion IST (LIST) to describe instruments and SE correlations without physical constraints. The disharmony of linear relationships between instruments is detected. Furthermore, we propose a physically constrained statistical method based on the maximum likelihood estimation for IST (MLE-IST) with adjustable dimensions. MLE-IST shows significant flexibility in adapting to different types of devices, such as noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, by adjusting the model and constraints. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and necessity of simultaneously describing instruments and SE correlations. Specifically, the LIST and MLE-IST obtains significant improvement on average square error reduction in the imperfect implemented simulations by orders of −23.77 and −6.21, respectively, compared to their comparative methods. Remarkably, real-chip experiments indicate that a polynomial number of parameters with respect to the Markovian order are sufficient to characterize non-Markovian quantum noise in current NISQ devices. Consequently, IST provides an essential and self-consistent framework for characterizing, benchmarking, and developing quantum devices in terms of the instrument set.

arXiv:2307.14696•Quantum Science and Technology•Apr 11, 2024•10 citations

Robust, self-consistent, closed-form tomography of quantum logic gates on a trapped ion qubit

Robin Blume-Kohout, John King Gamble, Erik Nielsen +3 more

We introduce and demonstrate experimentally: (1) a framework called "gate set tomography" (GST) for self-consistently characterizing an entire set of quantum logic gates on a black-box quantum device; (2) an explicit closed-form protocol for linear-inversion gate set tomography (LGST), whose reliability is independent of pathologies such as local maxima of the likelihood; and (3) a simple protocol for objectively scoring the accuracy of a tomographic estimate without reference to target gates, based on how well it predicts a set of testing experiments. We use gate set tomography to characterize a set of Clifford-generating gates on a single trapped-ion qubit, and compare the performance of (i) standard process tomography; (ii) linear gate set tomography; and (iii) maximum likelihood gate set tomography.

arXiv:1310.4492•Oct 16, 2013•218 citations

Gate Set Tomography

Erik Nielsen, John King Gamble, Kenneth Rudinger +3 more

Gate set tomography (GST) is a protocol for detailed, predictive characterization of logic operations (gates) on quantum computing processors. Early versions of GST emerged around 2012-13, and since then it has been refined, demonstrated, and used in a large number of experiments. This paper presents the foundations of GST in comprehensive detail. The most important feature of GST, compared to older state and process tomography protocols, is that it is calibration-free . GST does not rely on pre-calibrated state preparations and measurements. Instead, it characterizes all the operations in a gate set simultaneously and self-consistently, relative to each other. Long sequence GST can estimate gates with very high precision and efficiency, achieving Heisenberg scaling in regimes of practical interest. In this paper, we cover GST's intellectual history, the techniques and experiments used to achieve its intended purpose, data analysis, gauge freedom and fixing, error bars, and the interpretation of gauge-fixed estimates of gate sets. Our focus is fundamental mathematical aspects of GST, rather than implementation details, but we touch on some of the foundational algorithmic tricks used in the pyGSTi implementation.

arXiv:2009.07301•Quantum•Oct 5, 2021•266 citations
Quantum error correction (QEC) can strongly suppress noise, but predicting whether a computation succeeds requires understanding not only how much effective noise persists after QEC, but what form that noise takes. To thoroughly characterize this noise, we introduce logical gate set tomography (``logical GST''). Logical GST produces detailed representations of noisy logical operations that can be used to derive higher-level metrics, such as gate fidelity and diamond distance, and to test for non-Markovian and coherent logical errors. We use logical GST to obtain the first full, self-consistent characterization of a universal single-qubit logical gate set, implemented in the seven-qubit Steane code using Quantinuum System Model H1, a 20-qubit trapped-ion quantum processor. In the experimental data from H1, logical GST identified predominantly logical Pauli-stochastic errors, found no evidence of logical non-Markovianity, and detected weak potential signatures of coherent logical error. By contrast, higher-shot datasets generated with Quantinuum's detailed system emulator, identify mechanisms for weak but statistically significant logical non-Markovianity and strong evidence of coherent logical error. Finally, we use logical GST to perform error attribution with the system emulator, revealing how specific physical error sources shape logical error mechanisms.
Logical error rates alone do not determine how errors accumulate in fault-tolerant circuits. This paper adapts gate set tomography (GST) to encoded operations, estimating self-consistent logical channels while testing whether fixed Markovian channels and Pauli-stochastic noise adequately describe the data.
The experimental demonstration characterizes logical preparation, measurement, idle, HLH_LHL​, SLS_LSL​, and magic-state-injected TLT_LTL​ operations in the ⟦7,1,3⟧\llbracket7,1,3\rrbracket[[7,1,3]] Steane code on Quantinuum H1-1, using active correction. A compressed design uses 158 circuits with approximately 50 retained shots each, reaching 38 QEC cycles. Maximum-likelihood CPTP fits give entanglement infidelities of (0.7±0.4)%(0.7\pm0.4)\%(0.7±0.4)%, (0.2±0.4)%(0.2\pm0.4)\%(0.2±0.4)%, and (1.2±1.5)%(1.2\pm1.5)\%(1.2±1.5)% for HLH_LHL​, SLS_LSL​, and TLT_LTL​, respectively, with 95% intervals. Hardware data show no significant non-Markovianity or rejection of Pauli-stochastic noise, although individual coherent axis-misalignment parameters modestly improve fits.
Emulator datasets use 931 circuits and 14,100 shots per circuit, independently toggling leakage and coherent memory errors. Likelihood tests detect strong departures from Pauli-stochastic noise when memory errors are enabled and weaker non-Markovianity, requiring unmodeled error below 1% of per-operation diamond-distance error. Logical over-rotations near 0.0015π0.0015\pi0.0015π are resolved for SLS_LSL​, idle, and TLT_LTL​; an independent logical Ramsey experiment corroborates the SLS_LSL​ estimate. Automated model selection removes at least 22 of 43 observable parameters.
Limitations include low hardware statistical power, emulator dependence, and implementation-specific distance-three behavior. The TLT_LTL​ reconstruction conditions on post-selection acceptance. Mechanisms underlying emergent non-Markovianity remain unresolved, and Pauli-frame tracking could change the observed noise.
Abstract To progress in the characterization of noise for quantum computers, gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a self-consistent protocol that accurately estimates noisy gates, state preparations, and measurements. In its original incarnation, GST improves estimation precision by applying gates sequentially, assuming the noise yields fixed completely-positive and trace-preserving (CPTP) maps independent of prior gate history. This ‘Markovian’ assumption can conflict with experiments, where time-correlated noise may induce non-Markovian dynamics, or slow drifts and cumulative calibration errors introduce context dependence, causing CP-divisible maps to vary with circuit depth. In this work, we address this issue for trapped-ion devices with phonon-mediated two-qubit gates. Using detailed microscopic modeling of high-fidelity light-shift gates, we tailor GST to capture the main source of context dependence: motional degrees of freedom. Rather than invalidating GST, context dependence can be incorporated into the gate-set parametrization, reducing sampling cost. Our results identify a promising research avenue that might be applicable to other platforms where microscopic modeling can be incorporated: the development of a context-aware GST.
Logical qubits encoded in quantum error correcting codes can exhibit non-Markovian dynamical evolution, even when the underlying physical noise is Markovian. To understand this emergent non-Markovianity, we define a Markovianity condition appropriate to logical gate operations, and study it by relating logical operations to their physical implementation (operations on the data qubits into which the logical qubit is encoded). We apply our analysis to small quantum codes, and show that they exhibit non-Markovian dynamics even for very simple physical noise models. We show that non-Markovianity can emerge from Markovian physical operations if (and only if) the physical qubits are not necessarily returned to the code subspace after every round of QEC. In this situation, the syndrome qubits can act as a memory, mediating time correlations and enabling violation of the Markov condition. We quantify the emergent non-Markovianity in simple examples, and propose sufficient conditions for reliable use of gate-based characterization techniques like gate set tomography in early fault-tolerant quantum devices.
Quantum gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a promising method for the full characterization of quantum logic gates. In contrast to quantum process tomography (QPT), GST self-consistently and correctly accounts for state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors. It therefore provides significantly more accurate estimates than QPT as gate fidelities increase into the fault-tolerant regime. We give a detailed review of GST and provide a self-contained guide to its implementation. The method is presented in a step-by-step fashion and relevant mathematical background material is included. Our goal is to demonstrate the utility of GST as both an accurate characterization technique and a simple and effective diagnostic tool. As an illustration, we compare the output of GST and QPT using simulated example data for a single qubit. In agreement with the original literature, we find that coherent errors are poorly estimated by QPT near quantum error correction thresholds, while GST is accurate in this regime.
Abstract Engineering quantum devices requires reliable characterization of the quantum system, including qubits, quantum operations (also known as instruments) and the quantum noise. Recently, quantum gate set tomography (GST) has emerged as a powerful technique for self-consistently describing quantum states, gates, and measurements. However, non-Markovian correlations between the quantum system and environment impact the reliability of GST. To address this, we propose a self-consistent operational framework called instrument set tomography (IST) for non-Markovian GST. Based on the stochastic quantum process, the instrument set describes instruments and system-environment (SE) correlations. We introduce a linear inversion IST (LIST) to describe instruments and SE correlations without physical constraints. The disharmony of linear relationships between instruments is detected. Furthermore, we propose a physically constrained statistical method based on the maximum likelihood estimation for IST (MLE-IST) with adjustable dimensions. MLE-IST shows significant flexibility in adapting to different types of devices, such as noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices, by adjusting the model and constraints. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness and necessity of simultaneously describing instruments and SE correlations. Specifically, the LIST and MLE-IST obtains significant improvement on average square error reduction in the imperfect implemented simulations by orders of −23.77 and −6.21, respectively, compared to their comparative methods. Remarkably, real-chip experiments indicate that a polynomial number of parameters with respect to the Markovian order are sufficient to characterize non-Markovian quantum noise in current NISQ devices. Consequently, IST provides an essential and self-consistent framework for characterizing, benchmarking, and developing quantum devices in terms of the instrument set.
We introduce and demonstrate experimentally: (1) a framework called "gate set tomography" (GST) for self-consistently characterizing an entire set of quantum logic gates on a black-box quantum device; (2) an explicit closed-form protocol for linear-inversion gate set tomography (LGST), whose reliability is independent of pathologies such as local maxima of the likelihood; and (3) a simple protocol for objectively scoring the accuracy of a tomographic estimate without reference to target gates, based on how well it predicts a set of testing experiments. We use gate set tomography to characterize a set of Clifford-generating gates on a single trapped-ion qubit, and compare the performance of (i) standard process tomography; (ii) linear gate set tomography; and (iii) maximum likelihood gate set tomography.
Gate set tomography (GST) is a protocol for detailed, predictive characterization of logic operations (gates) on quantum computing processors. Early versions of GST emerged around 2012-13, and since then it has been refined, demonstrated, and used in a large number of experiments. This paper presents the foundations of GST in comprehensive detail. The most important feature of GST, compared to older state and process tomography protocols, is that it is calibration-free . GST does not rely on pre-calibrated state preparations and measurements. Instead, it characterizes all the operations in a gate set simultaneously and self-consistently, relative to each other. Long sequence GST can estimate gates with very high precision and efficiency, achieving Heisenberg scaling in regimes of practical interest. In this paper, we cover GST's intellectual history, the techniques and experiments used to achieve its intended purpose, data analysis, gauge freedom and fixing, error bars, and the interpretation of gauge-fixed estimates of gate sets. Our focus is fundamental mathematical aspects of GST, rather than implementation details, but we touch on some of the foundational algorithmic tricks used in the pyGSTi implementation.