Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.18582

Can the system dynamics remain structurally non-Markovian while its experimentally accessible memory signatures disappear?

Sayan Sengupta, Anish Sharma, George Biswas, Anindya Biswas

quant-phSubmitted Oct 13, 2026• Announced Oct 14, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate how unresolved quasistatic disorder in system bath coupling affects non-Markovian dynamics in spin environments. The coupling is fixed within each experimental shot but varies between shots, so repeated shot tomography reconstructs a disorder averaged dynamical map. For a single spin bath with pure dephasing Ising interaction, disorder can drive a transition to CP-divisible dynamics for fixed bath preparations, with a critical strength set by bath polarization along the interaction axis. However, when the bath state fluctuates physically between shots, the averaged dynamics remain CP indivisible at any finite disorder strength. We extend these results analytically to inhomogeneously coupled pure dephasing baths of any number \(N\) of non-interacting spins. At any finite disorder strength, one unpolarized bath spin suffices to retain CP-indivisible dynamics, whereas a fully polarized bath yields Markovian (CP-divisible) dynamics. Dynamics with physically fluctuating bath states likewise remain non-Markovian (CP indivisible) at finite disorder for arbitrary \(N\) in the pure dephasing case. For anisotropic Heisenberg interactions, any nonzero transverse exchange eliminates the disorder driven transition to CP divisibility in a single spin bath. Exact diagonalization of anisotropic models with inhomogeneous couplings up to \(N=12\) reveals persistent trace distance revivals for fixed bath preparations, sampled Haar random preparations, and physically fluctuating bath states, showing that this effect of transverse exchange extends beyond a single bath spin. Increasing disorder still suppresses experimentally accessible revivals and can make memory effects unresolvable at finite measurement resolution even as the dynamics remain CP indivisible. Thus, transverse exchange and physical bath state fluctuations preserve dynamical indivisibility against unresolved coupling disorder.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether unresolved quasi-static coupling disorder can make finite-spin open-system dynamics CP-divisible, or merely hide observable memory signatures. Couplings remain fixed within each shot but vary between shots, so tomography reconstructs a disorder-averaged channel. It distinguishes fixed characterized bath states, fixed unknown states treated through an epistemic Haar average, and physically Haar-resampled bath states, equivalent to a maximally mixed bath. For a single-spin Ising dephasing bath with Gaussian coupling disorder, analytical decoherence functions and decay rates give a polarization-dependent CP-divisibility threshold: the critical ratio $\epsilon/|J_0|$ vanishes for $|m_z|=1$ and diverges at $m_z=0$. Physically resampled baths remain CP-indivisible at every finite disorder strength for nonzero mean coupling. Analytical extensions to product baths of arbitrary size $N$, with independent inhomogeneous Gaussian couplings, show that one longitudinally unpolarized spin with nonzero mean coupling suffices to preserve indivisibility; fully polarized baths are CP-divisible. For a single-spin anisotropic Heisenberg bath, trace-distance formulas establish persistent backflow for any nonzero transverse exchange at finite disorder. Intermediate-map Choi spectra also establish indivisibility for isotropic exchange. Exact diagonalization up to $N=12$ finds revivals for the tested many-spin exchange models and preparations. Revival-amplitude thresholds illustrate how finite measurement resolution can conceal these effects without restoring divisibility. The models omit intrinsic system and bath dynamics and bath–bath interactions. Many-spin exchange conclusions are numerical and parameter-limited; larger baths, thermodynamic limits, non-Gaussian disorder, correlated preparations, and initial system–environment correlations remain open extensions. Operational resolution thresholds are illustrative, not platform-specific noise floors.

Some signs of AI-generated textIncrementalUnclear noveltyStrong assumptionsPossible error

Error found: The abstract attributes protection of indivisibility to physical bath-state fluctuations without stating the essential Haar-resampling condition; fluctuating preparations with average polarization mz=1/2 instead yield a CP-divisible Ising channel at ε/|J0|=1. The abstract omits the nonzero-mean-coupling restriction: with zero mean coupling, its Haar-averaged dephasing and single-spin isotropic exchange channels are CP divisible at finite disorder. The persistent-N-spin pure-dephasing S2 paragraph incorrectly claims non-Markovianity for every fixed bath preparation, contradicting the CP-divisible fully polarized preparations given by its own S1 formula.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
The manuscript spans the first 22 pages and includes 18 figures, followed by the appendices in the remaining

Related papers

Non-Markovian amplitude damping in a central spin model with random couplings

Mehboob Rashid, Rayees A Malla, Saima Bashir +1 more

Abstract Non-Markovian dynamics is central to quantum information processing, as memory effects strongly influence coherence preservation, metrology, and communication. In this work, we investigate the role of stochastic system–bath couplings in shaping non-Markovian behavior of open quantum systems, using the central spin model within a time-convolutionless master equation framework. We show that the character of the reduced dynamics depends jointly on the intrinsic memory of the environment and on the structure of the system–environment interaction. In certain regimes, the dynamics simplify to pure dephasing, while in general both amplitude damping and dephasing contribute to the evolution. By employing two complementary measures: the Quantum Fisher Information (QFI) flow and the Breuer–Laine–Piilo (BLP) measure, we demonstrate that QFI flow may fail to witness memory effects in weak-coupling and near-resonant regimes, whereas the BLP measure still detects information backflow. Furthermore, external modulation of the interaction kernel produces qualitatively richer behavior, including irregular and frequency-dependent revivals of non-Markovianity. These results clarify the physical origin of memory effects, highlight the limitations of single-witness approaches, and suggest that stochasticity and modulation can be harnessed to engineer robust, noise-resilient quantum technologies.

arXiv:2509.12670•Physica Scripta•Sep 1, 2025•1 citation

Collision models for open quantum systems coupled to finite environments

Gyaneswar Bhoi, Anil Shaji

We study a system qubit repeatedly interacting with the same environmental qubit, with a reservoir acting on the environment between collisions via a completely positive, trace-preserving map. We show that complete suppression of system--environment correlations uniquely requires a full environmental reset, recovering a semi group dynamics with a time-independent Gorini--Kossakowski--Sudarshan--Lindblad generator, whereas a partial reset yields a continuous transition between Markovian and non-Markovian regimes governed by a single dimensionless relaxation parameter. For a resonant excitation-exchange interaction, we obtain exact closed-form expressions for the Bloch-vector dynamics for both a generalized depolarizing channel and a generalized amplitude-damping channel acting as the reservoir-induced map. Using the Breuer--Laine--Piilo measure and a Choi-matrix CP-divisibility witness, we identify three distinct dynamical regimes across the parameter space: CP-divisible Markovian dynamics, CP-indivisible but P-divisible dynamics, and non-P-divisible non-Markovian dynamics. The boundaries between these regimes, and the structural differences between uniform and anisotropic environmental relaxation, are characterized numerically.

quant-pharXiv:2606.14163•Jun 15, 2026•0 citations

Weak-coupling study of decoherence of a qubit in disordered magnetic environments

Emilio A. Winograd, Marcelo J. Rozenberg, R. Chitra

We study the decoherence of a qubit weakly coupled to frustrated spin baths. We focus on spin baths described by the classical Ising spin glass and the quantum random transverse Ising model which are known to have complex thermodynamic phase diagrams as a function of an external magnetic field and temperature. Using a combination of numerical and analytical methods, we show that for baths initially in thermal equilibrium, the resulting decoherence is highly sensitive to the nature of the coupling to the environment and is qualitatively different in different parts of the phase diagram. We find an unexpected strong non-Markovian decay of the coherence when the random transverse Ising model bath is prepared in an initial state characterized by a finite temperature paramagnet. This is contrary to the usual case of exponential decay (Markovian) expected for spin baths in finite temperature paramagnetic phases, thereby illustrating the importance of the underlying nontrivial dynamics of interacting quantum spinbaths.

arXiv:1007.2105•Physical Review B•Dec 31, 2009•7 citations

Indivisible quantum evolution of a driven open spin-SSS system

Hao, Xiang, Xuefen Xu, Xiaoqun Wang

Using a recently proposed measure for divisibility of a dynamical map, we study the non-Markovian character of a quantum evolution of a driven spin-$S$ system weakly coupled to a bosonic bath. The complete tomographic knowledge about the dynamics of the open system is obtained by the time-convolutionless master equation in the secular approximation. The derived equation can be applied to a wide range of spin-boson models with the Hermitian or non-Hermitian coupling operator in the system-environment interaction Hamiltonian. Besides the influence of the environmental spectral densities, the tunneling energy of the system Hamiltonian can affect the measure of quantum non-Markovianity. It is found that the non-Markovian feature of a dynamical map of a high-dimension spin system is noticeable in contrast to that of a low-dimension spin system.

arXiv:1208.1546•Aug 8, 2012•1 citation

Stability and dynamics of many-body localized systems coupled to a small bath

Shao-Hen Chiew, Jiangbin Gong, L. C. Kwek +1 more

It is known that strong disorder in closed quantum systems leads to many-body localization (MBL), and that this quantum phase can be destroyed by coupling to an infinitely large Markovian environment. However, the stability of the MBL phase is less clear when the system and environment are of finite and comparable size. Here, we study the stability and eventual localization properties of a disordered Heisenberg spin chain coupled to a finite environment, and extensively explore the effects of environment disorder, geometry, initial state, and system-bath coupling strength, using the steady-state value of magnetization as a probe. Focusing on nonequilibrium dynamics and steady-state properties, our results indicate that within system sizes amenable to exact diagonalization, a strongly localized system interacting in a junction configuration retains remnant information on its initial state at long times despite coupling to a finite ergodic environment. In contrast, in a ladder configuration, strong dependencies on the initial state and coupling strength are observed, which can lead to either the loss or retention of information. Finally, we highlight and discuss discrepancies that can arise when similar methodologies are employed to infer localization or thermalization, revealing the need for careful interpretation.

arXiv:2107.07710•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 12, 2023•4 citations

Effect of random interactions in spin baths on decoherence

S. Camalet, R. Chitra

We study the decoherence of a central spin-$1∕2$ induced by a spin bath with intrabath interactions. Since we are interested in the cumulative effect of interaction and disorder, we study baths comprising Ising spins with random ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions between the spins. Using the resolvent operator method which goes beyond the standard Born-Markov master equation approach, we show that, in the weak coupling regime, the decoherence of the central spin at all times is entirely determined by the local-field distribution or equivalently, the dynamical structure factor of the Ising bath. We present analytic results for the Ising spin chain bath at arbitrary temperature for different distributions of the intrabath interaction strengths. We find clear evidence of non-Markovian behavior in the low temperature regime. We also consider baths described by Ising models on higher-dimensional lattices. We find that interactions lead to a significant reduction of the decoherence. An important feature of interacting spin baths is the saturation of the asymptotic Markovian decay rate at high temperatures, as opposed to the conventional Ohmic boson bath.

arXiv:cond-mat/0610874•Physical Review B•Mar 29, 2007•31 citations
We investigate how unresolved quasistatic disorder in system bath coupling affects non-Markovian dynamics in spin environments. The coupling is fixed within each experimental shot but varies between shots, so repeated shot tomography reconstructs a disorder averaged dynamical map. For a single spin bath with pure dephasing Ising interaction, disorder can drive a transition to CP-divisible dynamics for fixed bath preparations, with a critical strength set by bath polarization along the interaction axis. However, when the bath state fluctuates physically between shots, the averaged dynamics remain CP indivisible at any finite disorder strength. We extend these results analytically to inhomogeneously coupled pure dephasing baths of any number (N) of non-interacting spins. At any finite disorder strength, one unpolarized bath spin suffices to retain CP-indivisible dynamics, whereas a fully polarized bath yields Markovian (CP-divisible) dynamics. Dynamics with physically fluctuating bath states likewise remain non-Markovian (CP indivisible) at finite disorder for arbitrary (N) in the pure dephasing case. For anisotropic Heisenberg interactions, any nonzero transverse exchange eliminates the disorder driven transition to CP divisibility in a single spin bath. Exact diagonalization of anisotropic models with inhomogeneous couplings up to (N=12) reveals persistent trace distance revivals for fixed bath preparations, sampled Haar random preparations, and physically fluctuating bath states, showing that this effect of transverse exchange extends beyond a single bath spin. Increasing disorder still suppresses experimentally accessible revivals and can make memory effects unresolvable at finite measurement resolution even as the dynamics remain CP indivisible. Thus, transverse exchange and physical bath state fluctuations preserve dynamical indivisibility against unresolved coupling disorder.
The paper asks whether unresolved quasi-static coupling disorder can make finite-spin open-system dynamics CP-divisible, or merely hide observable memory signatures. Couplings remain fixed within each shot but vary between shots, so tomography reconstructs a disorder-averaged channel. It distinguishes fixed characterized bath states, fixed unknown states treated through an epistemic Haar average, and physically Haar-resampled bath states, equivalent to a maximally mixed bath.
For a single-spin Ising dephasing bath with Gaussian coupling disorder, analytical decoherence functions and decay rates give a polarization-dependent CP-divisibility threshold: the critical ratio ϵ/∣J0∣\epsilon/|J_0|ϵ/∣J0​∣ vanishes for ∣mz∣=1|m_z|=1∣mz​∣=1 and diverges at mz=0m_z=0mz​=0. Physically resampled baths remain CP-indivisible at every finite disorder strength for nonzero mean coupling. Analytical extensions to product baths of arbitrary size NNN, with independent inhomogeneous Gaussian couplings, show that one longitudinally unpolarized spin with nonzero mean coupling suffices to preserve indivisibility; fully polarized baths are CP-divisible.
For a single-spin anisotropic Heisenberg bath, trace-distance formulas establish persistent backflow for any nonzero transverse exchange at finite disorder. Intermediate-map Choi spectra also establish indivisibility for isotropic exchange. Exact diagonalization up to N=12N=12N=12 finds revivals for the tested many-spin exchange models and preparations. Revival-amplitude thresholds illustrate how finite measurement resolution can conceal these effects without restoring divisibility.
The models omit intrinsic system and bath dynamics and bath–bath interactions. Many-spin exchange conclusions are numerical and parameter-limited; larger baths, thermodynamic limits, non-Gaussian disorder, correlated preparations, and initial system–environment correlations remain open extensions. Operational resolution thresholds are illustrative, not platform-specific noise floors.
Abstract Non-Markovian dynamics is central to quantum information processing, as memory effects strongly influence coherence preservation, metrology, and communication. In this work, we investigate the role of stochastic system–bath couplings in shaping non-Markovian behavior of open quantum systems, using the central spin model within a time-convolutionless master equation framework. We show that the character of the reduced dynamics depends jointly on the intrinsic memory of the environment and on the structure of the system–environment interaction. In certain regimes, the dynamics simplify to pure dephasing, while in general both amplitude damping and dephasing contribute to the evolution. By employing two complementary measures: the Quantum Fisher Information (QFI) flow and the Breuer–Laine–Piilo (BLP) measure, we demonstrate that QFI flow may fail to witness memory effects in weak-coupling and near-resonant regimes, whereas the BLP measure still detects information backflow. Furthermore, external modulation of the interaction kernel produces qualitatively richer behavior, including irregular and frequency-dependent revivals of non-Markovianity. These results clarify the physical origin of memory effects, highlight the limitations of single-witness approaches, and suggest that stochasticity and modulation can be harnessed to engineer robust, noise-resilient quantum technologies.
We study a system qubit repeatedly interacting with the same environmental qubit, with a reservoir acting on the environment between collisions via a completely positive, trace-preserving map. We show that complete suppression of system--environment correlations uniquely requires a full environmental reset, recovering a semi group dynamics with a time-independent Gorini--Kossakowski--Sudarshan--Lindblad generator, whereas a partial reset yields a continuous transition between Markovian and non-Markovian regimes governed by a single dimensionless relaxation parameter. For a resonant excitation-exchange interaction, we obtain exact closed-form expressions for the Bloch-vector dynamics for both a generalized depolarizing channel and a generalized amplitude-damping channel acting as the reservoir-induced map. Using the Breuer--Laine--Piilo measure and a Choi-matrix CP-divisibility witness, we identify three distinct dynamical regimes across the parameter space: CP-divisible Markovian dynamics, CP-indivisible but P-divisible dynamics, and non-P-divisible non-Markovian dynamics. The boundaries between these regimes, and the structural differences between uniform and anisotropic environmental relaxation, are characterized numerically.
We study the decoherence of a qubit weakly coupled to frustrated spin baths. We focus on spin baths described by the classical Ising spin glass and the quantum random transverse Ising model which are known to have complex thermodynamic phase diagrams as a function of an external magnetic field and temperature. Using a combination of numerical and analytical methods, we show that for baths initially in thermal equilibrium, the resulting decoherence is highly sensitive to the nature of the coupling to the environment and is qualitatively different in different parts of the phase diagram. We find an unexpected strong non-Markovian decay of the coherence when the random transverse Ising model bath is prepared in an initial state characterized by a finite temperature paramagnet. This is contrary to the usual case of exponential decay (Markovian) expected for spin baths in finite temperature paramagnetic phases, thereby illustrating the importance of the underlying nontrivial dynamics of interacting quantum spinbaths.
Using a recently proposed measure for divisibility of a dynamical map, we study the non-Markovian character of a quantum evolution of a driven spin-SSS system weakly coupled to a bosonic bath. The complete tomographic knowledge about the dynamics of the open system is obtained by the time-convolutionless master equation in the secular approximation. The derived equation can be applied to a wide range of spin-boson models with the Hermitian or non-Hermitian coupling operator in the system-environment interaction Hamiltonian. Besides the influence of the environmental spectral densities, the tunneling energy of the system Hamiltonian can affect the measure of quantum non-Markovianity. It is found that the non-Markovian feature of a dynamical map of a high-dimension spin system is noticeable in contrast to that of a low-dimension spin system.
It is known that strong disorder in closed quantum systems leads to many-body localization (MBL), and that this quantum phase can be destroyed by coupling to an infinitely large Markovian environment. However, the stability of the MBL phase is less clear when the system and environment are of finite and comparable size. Here, we study the stability and eventual localization properties of a disordered Heisenberg spin chain coupled to a finite environment, and extensively explore the effects of environment disorder, geometry, initial state, and system-bath coupling strength, using the steady-state value of magnetization as a probe. Focusing on nonequilibrium dynamics and steady-state properties, our results indicate that within system sizes amenable to exact diagonalization, a strongly localized system interacting in a junction configuration retains remnant information on its initial state at long times despite coupling to a finite ergodic environment. In contrast, in a ladder configuration, strong dependencies on the initial state and coupling strength are observed, which can lead to either the loss or retention of information. Finally, we highlight and discuss discrepancies that can arise when similar methodologies are employed to infer localization or thermalization, revealing the need for careful interpretation.
We study the decoherence of a central spin-1∕21∕21∕2 induced by a spin bath with intrabath interactions. Since we are interested in the cumulative effect of interaction and disorder, we study baths comprising Ising spins with random ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic interactions between the spins. Using the resolvent operator method which goes beyond the standard Born-Markov master equation approach, we show that, in the weak coupling regime, the decoherence of the central spin at all times is entirely determined by the local-field distribution or equivalently, the dynamical structure factor of the Ising bath. We present analytic results for the Ising spin chain bath at arbitrary temperature for different distributions of the intrabath interaction strengths. We find clear evidence of non-Markovian behavior in the low temperature regime. We also consider baths described by Ising models on higher-dimensional lattices. We find that interactions lead to a significant reduction of the decoherence. An important feature of interacting spin baths is the saturation of the asymptotic Markovian decay rate at high temperatures, as opposed to the conventional Ohmic boson bath.