arXiv:2610.18582
Can the system dynamics remain structurally non-Markovian while its experimentally accessible memory signatures disappear?
Sayan Sengupta, Anish Sharma, George Biswas, Anindya Biswas
Abstract
We investigate how unresolved quasistatic disorder in system bath coupling affects non-Markovian dynamics in spin environments. The coupling is fixed within each experimental shot but varies between shots, so repeated shot tomography reconstructs a disorder averaged dynamical map. For a single spin bath with pure dephasing Ising interaction, disorder can drive a transition to CP-divisible dynamics for fixed bath preparations, with a critical strength set by bath polarization along the interaction axis. However, when the bath state fluctuates physically between shots, the averaged dynamics remain CP indivisible at any finite disorder strength. We extend these results analytically to inhomogeneously coupled pure dephasing baths of any number \(N\) of non-interacting spins. At any finite disorder strength, one unpolarized bath spin suffices to retain CP-indivisible dynamics, whereas a fully polarized bath yields Markovian (CP-divisible) dynamics. Dynamics with physically fluctuating bath states likewise remain non-Markovian (CP indivisible) at finite disorder for arbitrary \(N\) in the pure dephasing case. For anisotropic Heisenberg interactions, any nonzero transverse exchange eliminates the disorder driven transition to CP divisibility in a single spin bath. Exact diagonalization of anisotropic models with inhomogeneous couplings up to \(N=12\) reveals persistent trace distance revivals for fixed bath preparations, sampled Haar random preparations, and physically fluctuating bath states, showing that this effect of transverse exchange extends beyond a single bath spin. Increasing disorder still suppresses experimentally accessible revivals and can make memory effects unresolvable at finite measurement resolution even as the dynamics remain CP indivisible. Thus, transverse exchange and physical bath state fluctuations preserve dynamical indivisibility against unresolved coupling disorder.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether unresolved quasi-static coupling disorder can make finite-spin open-system dynamics CP-divisible, or merely hide observable memory signatures. Couplings remain fixed within each shot but vary between shots, so tomography reconstructs a disorder-averaged channel. It distinguishes fixed characterized bath states, fixed unknown states treated through an epistemic Haar average, and physically Haar-resampled bath states, equivalent to a maximally mixed bath. For a single-spin Ising dephasing bath with Gaussian coupling disorder, analytical decoherence functions and decay rates give a polarization-dependent CP-divisibility threshold: the critical ratio $\epsilon/|J_0|$ vanishes for $|m_z|=1$ and diverges at $m_z=0$. Physically resampled baths remain CP-indivisible at every finite disorder strength for nonzero mean coupling. Analytical extensions to product baths of arbitrary size $N$, with independent inhomogeneous Gaussian couplings, show that one longitudinally unpolarized spin with nonzero mean coupling suffices to preserve indivisibility; fully polarized baths are CP-divisible. For a single-spin anisotropic Heisenberg bath, trace-distance formulas establish persistent backflow for any nonzero transverse exchange at finite disorder. Intermediate-map Choi spectra also establish indivisibility for isotropic exchange. Exact diagonalization up to $N=12$ finds revivals for the tested many-spin exchange models and preparations. Revival-amplitude thresholds illustrate how finite measurement resolution can conceal these effects without restoring divisibility. The models omit intrinsic system and bath dynamics and bath–bath interactions. Many-spin exchange conclusions are numerical and parameter-limited; larger baths, thermodynamic limits, non-Gaussian disorder, correlated preparations, and initial system–environment correlations remain open extensions. Operational resolution thresholds are illustrative, not platform-specific noise floors.
Error found: The abstract attributes protection of indivisibility to physical bath-state fluctuations without stating the essential Haar-resampling condition; fluctuating preparations with average polarization mz=1/2 instead yield a CP-divisible Ising channel at ε/|J0|=1. The abstract omits the nonzero-mean-coupling restriction: with zero mean coupling, its Haar-averaged dephasing and single-spin isotropic exchange channels are CP divisible at finite disorder. The persistent-N-spin pure-dephasing S2 paragraph incorrectly claims non-Markovianity for every fixed bath preparation, contradicting the CP-divisible fully polarized preparations given by its own S1 formula.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- The manuscript spans the first 22 pages and includes 18 figures, followed by the appendices in the remaining