arXiv:2610.16673
Euler's thirty-six officers need not all be entangled: real AME(4,6), families and classification
Palash Pandya
Abstract
Absolutely maximally entangled states of four six-level systems, AME$(4,6)$, are the quantum solutions of Euler's problem of the thirty-six officers. Until recently all reported solutions were complex, and it was conjectured that no real orthogonal 2-unitary matrix of order $36$ exists. We give real AME$(4,6)$ states with $60$ non-zero coefficients in $\{\pm1,\sqrt2\}/\sqrt{72}$. Of their thirty-six officers, $12$ are classical, as some must be whenever fewer than $72$ coefficients are non-zero. They lie in the $-1$ eigenspace of an order-$4$ local symmetry, and on their support the AME conditions become linear. We derive two closed-form families of AME$(4,6)$ states that meet at one of these states: a $10$-parameter family that is supported on $72$ basis states, and an $11$-parameter family on $60$ basis states. At each of its two ends the first family loses $12$ coefficients, and the AME states on the remaining $60$ basis states form an $11$-parameter family: the second family at one end, and an analogous family at the other. These two $60$-term families contain $4096$ real AME states up to diagonal local unitaries, $1024$ of which are limits of the first family. They fall into exactly $20$ classes under local unitaries and permutations of the parties, and we certify their separation with interval arithmetic.
AI Summary
The paper addresses whether an $\mathrm{AME}(4,6)$ state can have real coefficients, equivalently whether a real orthogonal 2-unitary matrix of order $36$ exists. It gives an explicit state with $60$ nonzero coefficients in $\{\pm1,\sqrt2\}/\sqrt{72}$, including $12$ classical officers and $24$ two-term entangled officers. Each of its three balanced reshapings decomposes into twelve $1\times1$ and twelve orthogonal $2\times2$ blocks, directly proving the AME property. The real-existence question is also reported as independently resolved in concurrent work. A search within an order-four local-symmetry eigenspace leads to supports on which the AME constraints reduce to linear equations for squared moduli and linear phase congruences. These yield two complex-conjugate $10$-parameter components on $72$ basis states, whose endpoints lie in two $11$-parameter families on $60$ basis states, modulo diagonal local unitaries. The two endpoint families contain $4096$ real states modulo diagonal local unitaries, with $1024$ accessible as limits from the $72$-term components. They form exactly $20$ classes under local unitaries and party permutations. Explicit transformations establish equivalences; Jacobian-spectrum invariants, certified using interval arithmetic, separate classes. The classification is restricted to these supports, not all real $\mathrm{AME}(4,6)$ states. Isolation of the real states and several deformation claims rely on numerical calculations. Global minimum support remains unresolved: the paper proves a lower bound of $38$, versus the demonstrated $60$. More generally, support size $s<72$ forces at least $72-s$ classical officers.
for generating the tables and figures from the data, and for drafting and editing the text.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 9 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables; gtihub repo is https://github.com/palashpandya/real-ame46