arXiv:2610.16267
Classical and Quantum Information Measures Characterizing Convertibility: An Axiomatic Approach
Frits Verhagen
Abstract
In this PhD thesis, we take an axiomatic approach to studying multivariate divergences, which are measures of the information content of a tuple of classical or quantum states. These divergences are studied in the context of large-sample and catalytic convertibility of tuples of states. This type of convertibility is characterized by the ordering of an axiomatically defined family of divergences. In this thesis, we identify this family of divergences explicitly for two scenarios, one classical and one quantum. In the classical setting, we show that the relevant divergences are certain generalizations of the bivariate Rényi divergences. Unlike previous studies, we do not require the distributions to have the same support, yielding interesting new divergences. In the quantum setting, we consider pairs of classical-quantum states with pure component states, and find that majorization is characterized by all $α$-$z$ relative entropies for $α<1$. This demonstrates the first operational interpretation of these relative entropies.
AI Summary
This thesis studies when one channel can simultaneously convert a tuple of classical or quantum states into another, either exactly on sufficiently many tensor copies or with a catalyst returned unchanged. It seeks additive, data-processing-monotone divergences that characterize these conversion orders. For finite classical experiments, it extends earlier equal-support results to distributions with nonempty common support, considering both unrestricted support relations and a distinguished distribution whose support contains the others. The resulting monotones are multivariate Rényi divergences supplemented by support-intersection-restricted quantities; the dominating-support case also requires higher-order Rényi and max-divergence constraints. Strict inequalities give sufficient conditions for exact large-sample and catalytic conversion, while conversion implies non-strict inequalities. Under additional input assumptions, non-strict inequalities characterize conversion to arbitrarily close perturbed targets. For pairs of classical–quantum states with pure conditional states, the corresponding characterization uses $\alpha$–$z$ relative entropies with $0<\alpha<1$ and $z>\max\{\alpha,1-\alpha\}$, providing an operational interpretation in this restricted setting. The analysis applies existing preordered-semiring comparison theorems after classifying monotone homomorphisms and derivations. It also derives optimal exact conversion rates as $\min_D D(P)/D(Q)$ and proves, in selected settings, that deleting any nonempty open parameter subset makes the monotone family insufficient. The results require restrictive power-universality conditions on inputs, often tied to support structure. Approximation concerns a perturbed single-copy target before tensoring, not directly vanishing global tensor-product error. General mixed quantum-state pairs, broader support patterns, and removal of power-universality assumptions remain open.
Central claim may not hold: The abstract's quantum parameter claim needs qualification because the demonstrated characterization concerns a restricted α–z parameter region, not arbitrary z with α<1. The abstract omits substantive power-universality hypotheses on source tuples that restrict the applicability of the large-sample characterizations.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- PhD thesis at the Centre for Quantum Technologies, National University of Singapore; contains corrections of some minor errors appearing in the published papers that this thesis is based on