Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.16018

Adaptive Entanglement Witnessing for Two-Qubit Systems

Lev Gruber, Ria Haapala, Elio Thadhani, Paco Navarro, Eritas Yang, Benjamin Hartley, Rebecca Verghese, Oscar Scholin, Isabel Godoy, Stuart Kerr, Brayden Mendoza, Alec Roberson, Theresa W. Lynn

quant-phSubmitted Oct 12, 2026• Announced Oct 13, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Entanglement witnesses are a key instrument in determining the entanglement of unknown bipartite qubit systems without requiring a full tomography. Riccardi et al. (2020) proposed a set of two-qubit witnesses, denoted $\{W^3\}$, which require a set of local measurements in three bases. In this work we propose an additional set of witnesses, denoted $\{W^5\}$, that build on $\{W^3\}$ and require measurements in two additional bases. We present an adaptive two-step method that uses the measurement results obtained for $\{W^3\}$ to select which $W^5$ to evaluate. We computationally demonstrate that our adaptive two-step protocol can identify 72% of entangled states generated according to the methods of Roik et al. (2021) while requiring measurements in only five of the nine bases needed for full quantum tomography. Additionally, we experimentally verify the behavior of both sets of witnesses using polarization-entangled photon pairs.

AI Summary

The paper studies adaptive entanglement detection for unknown two-qubit states using fewer local Pauli measurement settings than the nine required for full tomography. It starts from six previously proposed one-parameter witness families, $\{W^3\}$, evaluated using the $xx$, $yy$, and $zz$ settings, and derives analytic expressions for their minimized expectation values. Local rotations generate nine additional witness families, $\{W^5\}$, grouped into three triplets; each triplet requires two additional cross-axis settings. Six families admit analytic minimization, while three retain a two-parameter numerical optimization. The proposed protocol first tests $\{W^3\}$, then uses those measurement results to select one $W^5$ triplet, either through a rule based on the largest diagonal correlation magnitude or a five-hidden-layer neural network. On 16.8 million randomly generated entangled states, $W^3$ detects 33%, while the complete adaptive protocol detects 70% with the analytic rule and 72% with the network, using at most five settings. An oracle selecting a successful triplet whenever one exists would detect 79%; evaluating every triplet instead requires all nine settings. These percentages are specific to the sampled state ensemble. Polarization-entangled photon experiments demonstrate detection on selected pure and mixed states missed by $W^3$. A failed test remains inconclusive, and identical first-stage data can require different second-stage choices. Experimental deviations are attributed to residual decoherence and calibration offsets. Finite-statistics uncertainty and tradeoffs between measurement duration and additional settings are left for future study.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalMissing comparison

Error found: The analytic minimum reported for W5_1 is incorrect for the stated theta domain [0,pi/2], although extending that domain repairs the formula while retaining valid entanglement witnesses and the same measurement settings. The partially minimized W5_9 formula incorrectly uses S_xy twice in place of S_xz, introducing a correlator unavailable from that triplet's five measurement settings.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
11 pages, 6 figures

Related papers

Experimental witnessing for entangled states with limited local measurements

Gaoyan Zhu, Chengjie Zhang, Kunkun Wang +2 more

We experimentally demonstrate a method for detection of entanglement via construction of entanglement witnesses from a limited fixed set of local measurements ( M ). Such a method does not require a priori knowledge about the form of the entanglement witnesses. It is suitable for a scenario where a full state tomography is not available, but the only resource is a limited set of M . We demonstrate the method on pure two-qubit entangled states and mixed two-qubit entangled states, which emerge from photonic implementation of controllable quantum noisy channels. The states we select are motivated by realistic experimental conditions, and we confirm it works well for both cases. Furthermore, possible generalizations to higher-dimensional bipartite systems have been considered, which can potentially detect both decomposable and indecomposable entanglement witnesses. Our experimental results show perfect validity of the method, which indicates that even a limited set of local measurements can be used for quick entanglement detection and further provide a practical test bed for experiments with entanglement witnesses.

Photonics Research•Jun 30, 2022•6 citations

Entanglement quantification via weak measurements assisted by deep learning

Mu Yang, Xiao Ya, Ze-Yan Hao +9 more

Entanglement has been recognized as being crucial when implementing various quantum information tasks. Nevertheless, quantifying entanglement for an unknown quantum state requires nonphysical operations or post-processing measurement data. For example, evaluation methods via quantum state tomography require vast amounts of measurement data and likely estimation. Although a direct entanglement determination has been reported for the unknown pure state, it is still tricky for the mixed state. In this work, assisted by weak measurement and deep learning technology, we directly detect the entanglement (namely, the concurrence) of a class of two-photon polarization-entangled mixed states both theoretically and experimentally according to the local photon spatial distributions after weak measurement. In this way, the number of projective bases is much smaller than that required in quantum state tomography.

Photonics Research•Dec 11, 2023•4 citations

Accessible nonlinear entanglement witnesses

Juan Miguel Arrazola, Oleg Gittsovich, Norbert Lütkenhaus

Verification of entanglement is an important tool to characterize sources and devices for use in quantum computing and communication applications. In a vast majority of experiments entanglement witnesses (EWs) are used in order to prove the presence of entanglement in a quantum state. EWs can be constructed from available measurement results and do not require a reconstruction of the whole density matrix (full tomography), which is especially valuable for high-dimensional systems. We provide a method to construct accessible nonlinear EWs, which incorporate two important properties. First, they improve on linear EWs in the sense that each nonlinear EW detects more entangled states than its linear counterpart and therefore allows the verification of entanglement without critical dependence on having found the ``right'' linear witness. Second, they can be evaluated using exactly the same data as for the evaluation of the original linear witness. This allows a reanalysis of published experimental data to strengthen statements about entanglement verification without the requirement to perform additional measurements. These particular properties make the accessible nonlinear EWs attractive for the implementations in current experiments, for they can also enhance the statistical significance of the entanglement verification.

arXiv:1203.1239•Physical Review A•Jun 28, 2012•23 citations

A Universal Entanglement Witness Generator

Aiden R. Rosebush, Alexander C. B. Greenwood, Andi Shahaj +1 more

Entanglement witnesses are essential for certifying entanglement, yet constructing ones that are both noise-robust and economical in measurement settings remains challenging - particularly beyond qubits and for non-stabilizer ("magic") states. We present a machine-learning method that, given a target state and a user-specified number of measurement settings, generates an entanglement witness optimized for noise tolerance in the neighborhood of that state, requiring only local measurements. The approach is fully general, applying to multipartite qubit and qudit systems alike, including non-stabilizer states. For N qudits of dimension d, we train on the fully-separable eigenstates of each qudit's SU(d) generators to find a prototype witness, then tune the witness's bias term via gradient descent to maximize noise tolerance. Adversarial training further strengthens the witnesses, delivering greater noise tolerance with even fewer settings; critically, under this scheme the required training-set size becomes independent of system size. We package the entire pipeline as an automated script that, in every case we tested, produces witnesses surpassing all existing methods in noise tolerance and/or number of measurement settings. We demonstrate the method on Bell, GHZ, W, and hypergraph states, along with a range of qudit states, spanning 2-6 qubits, bipartite qudits up to d=10, and tripartite qutrits. Our witnesses achieve perfect accuracy across both physical experimental test states and large numerical sets of separable mixed states-including 30 million test states for a 3-qubit W-state witness and 10 million for a 4-qubit hypergraph-state witness-and we experimentally confirm the noise tolerance of Bell- and hypergraph state witnesses on both photonic and superconducting platforms, respectively.

quant-pharXiv:2608.07806•Aug 11, 2026•0 citations

Ultrafine Entanglement Witnessing

Farid Shähandeh, Martin Ringbauer, J. C. Loredo +1 more

Entanglement witnesses are invaluable for efficient quantum entanglement certification without the need for expensive quantum state tomography. Yet, standard entanglement witnessing requires multiple measurements and its bounds can be elusive as a result of experimental imperfections. Here, we introduce and demonstrate a novel procedure for entanglement detection which simply and seamlessly improves any standard witnessing procedure by using additional available information to tighten the witnessing bounds. Moreover, by relaxing the requirements on the witness operators, our method removes the general need for the difficult task of witness decomposition into local observables. We experimentally demonstrate entanglement detection with our approach using a separable test operator and a simple fixed measurement device for each agent. Finally, we show that the method can be generalized to higher-dimensional and multipartite cases with a complexity that scales linearly with the number of parties.

arXiv:1610.04244•Physical Review Letters•Mar 14, 2017•35 citations

Experimental Detection of Entanglement with Optimal-Witness Families

Jibo Dai, Yink Loong Len, Yong Siah Teo +2 more

We report an experiment in which one determines, with least tomographic effort, whether an unknown two-photon polarization state is entangled or separable. The method measures whole families of optimal entanglement witnesses. We introduce adaptive measurement schemes that greatly speed up the entanglement detection. The experiments are performed on states of different ranks, and we find good agreement with results from computer simulations.

arXiv:1402.5710•Physical Review Letters•Oct 21, 2014•23 citations
Entanglement witnesses are a key instrument in determining the entanglement of unknown bipartite qubit systems without requiring a full tomography. Riccardi et al. (2020) proposed a set of two-qubit witnesses, denoted {W3}\{W^3\}{W3}, which require a set of local measurements in three bases. In this work we propose an additional set of witnesses, denoted {W5}\{W^5\}{W5}, that build on {W3}\{W^3\}{W3} and require measurements in two additional bases. We present an adaptive two-step method that uses the measurement results obtained for {W3}\{W^3\}{W3} to select which W5W^5W5 to evaluate. We computationally demonstrate that our adaptive two-step protocol can identify 72% of entangled states generated according to the methods of Roik et al. (2021) while requiring measurements in only five of the nine bases needed for full quantum tomography. Additionally, we experimentally verify the behavior of both sets of witnesses using polarization-entangled photon pairs.
The paper studies adaptive entanglement detection for unknown two-qubit states using fewer local Pauli measurement settings than the nine required for full tomography. It starts from six previously proposed one-parameter witness families, {W3}\{W^3\}{W3}, evaluated using the xxxxxx, yyyyyy, and zzzzzz settings, and derives analytic expressions for their minimized expectation values. Local rotations generate nine additional witness families, {W5}\{W^5\}{W5}, grouped into three triplets; each triplet requires two additional cross-axis settings. Six families admit analytic minimization, while three retain a two-parameter numerical optimization.
The proposed protocol first tests {W3}\{W^3\}{W3}, then uses those measurement results to select one W5W^5W5 triplet, either through a rule based on the largest diagonal correlation magnitude or a five-hidden-layer neural network. On 16.8 million randomly generated entangled states, W3W^3W3 detects 33%, while the complete adaptive protocol detects 70% with the analytic rule and 72% with the network, using at most five settings. An oracle selecting a successful triplet whenever one exists would detect 79%; evaluating every triplet instead requires all nine settings. These percentages are specific to the sampled state ensemble.
Polarization-entangled photon experiments demonstrate detection on selected pure and mixed states missed by W3W^3W3. A failed test remains inconclusive, and identical first-stage data can require different second-stage choices. Experimental deviations are attributed to residual decoherence and calibration offsets. Finite-statistics uncertainty and tradeoffs between measurement duration and additional settings are left for future study.
We experimentally demonstrate a method for detection of entanglement via construction of entanglement witnesses from a limited fixed set of local measurements ( M ). Such a method does not require a priori knowledge about the form of the entanglement witnesses. It is suitable for a scenario where a full state tomography is not available, but the only resource is a limited set of M . We demonstrate the method on pure two-qubit entangled states and mixed two-qubit entangled states, which emerge from photonic implementation of controllable quantum noisy channels. The states we select are motivated by realistic experimental conditions, and we confirm it works well for both cases. Furthermore, possible generalizations to higher-dimensional bipartite systems have been considered, which can potentially detect both decomposable and indecomposable entanglement witnesses. Our experimental results show perfect validity of the method, which indicates that even a limited set of local measurements can be used for quick entanglement detection and further provide a practical test bed for experiments with entanglement witnesses.
Entanglement has been recognized as being crucial when implementing various quantum information tasks. Nevertheless, quantifying entanglement for an unknown quantum state requires nonphysical operations or post-processing measurement data. For example, evaluation methods via quantum state tomography require vast amounts of measurement data and likely estimation. Although a direct entanglement determination has been reported for the unknown pure state, it is still tricky for the mixed state. In this work, assisted by weak measurement and deep learning technology, we directly detect the entanglement (namely, the concurrence) of a class of two-photon polarization-entangled mixed states both theoretically and experimentally according to the local photon spatial distributions after weak measurement. In this way, the number of projective bases is much smaller than that required in quantum state tomography.
Verification of entanglement is an important tool to characterize sources and devices for use in quantum computing and communication applications. In a vast majority of experiments entanglement witnesses (EWs) are used in order to prove the presence of entanglement in a quantum state. EWs can be constructed from available measurement results and do not require a reconstruction of the whole density matrix (full tomography), which is especially valuable for high-dimensional systems. We provide a method to construct accessible nonlinear EWs, which incorporate two important properties. First, they improve on linear EWs in the sense that each nonlinear EW detects more entangled states than its linear counterpart and therefore allows the verification of entanglement without critical dependence on having found the ``right'' linear witness. Second, they can be evaluated using exactly the same data as for the evaluation of the original linear witness. This allows a reanalysis of published experimental data to strengthen statements about entanglement verification without the requirement to perform additional measurements. These particular properties make the accessible nonlinear EWs attractive for the implementations in current experiments, for they can also enhance the statistical significance of the entanglement verification.
Entanglement witnesses are essential for certifying entanglement, yet constructing ones that are both noise-robust and economical in measurement settings remains challenging - particularly beyond qubits and for non-stabilizer ("magic") states. We present a machine-learning method that, given a target state and a user-specified number of measurement settings, generates an entanglement witness optimized for noise tolerance in the neighborhood of that state, requiring only local measurements. The approach is fully general, applying to multipartite qubit and qudit systems alike, including non-stabilizer states. For N qudits of dimension d, we train on the fully-separable eigenstates of each qudit's SU(d) generators to find a prototype witness, then tune the witness's bias term via gradient descent to maximize noise tolerance. Adversarial training further strengthens the witnesses, delivering greater noise tolerance with even fewer settings; critically, under this scheme the required training-set size becomes independent of system size. We package the entire pipeline as an automated script that, in every case we tested, produces witnesses surpassing all existing methods in noise tolerance and/or number of measurement settings. We demonstrate the method on Bell, GHZ, W, and hypergraph states, along with a range of qudit states, spanning 2-6 qubits, bipartite qudits up to d=10, and tripartite qutrits. Our witnesses achieve perfect accuracy across both physical experimental test states and large numerical sets of separable mixed states-including 30 million test states for a 3-qubit W-state witness and 10 million for a 4-qubit hypergraph-state witness-and we experimentally confirm the noise tolerance of Bell- and hypergraph state witnesses on both photonic and superconducting platforms, respectively.
Entanglement witnesses are invaluable for efficient quantum entanglement certification without the need for expensive quantum state tomography. Yet, standard entanglement witnessing requires multiple measurements and its bounds can be elusive as a result of experimental imperfections. Here, we introduce and demonstrate a novel procedure for entanglement detection which simply and seamlessly improves any standard witnessing procedure by using additional available information to tighten the witnessing bounds. Moreover, by relaxing the requirements on the witness operators, our method removes the general need for the difficult task of witness decomposition into local observables. We experimentally demonstrate entanglement detection with our approach using a separable test operator and a simple fixed measurement device for each agent. Finally, we show that the method can be generalized to higher-dimensional and multipartite cases with a complexity that scales linearly with the number of parties.