arXiv:2610.16018
Adaptive Entanglement Witnessing for Two-Qubit Systems
Lev Gruber, Ria Haapala, Elio Thadhani, Paco Navarro, Eritas Yang, Benjamin Hartley, Rebecca Verghese, Oscar Scholin, Isabel Godoy, Stuart Kerr, Brayden Mendoza, Alec Roberson, Theresa W. Lynn
Abstract
Entanglement witnesses are a key instrument in determining the entanglement of unknown bipartite qubit systems without requiring a full tomography. Riccardi et al. (2020) proposed a set of two-qubit witnesses, denoted $\{W^3\}$, which require a set of local measurements in three bases. In this work we propose an additional set of witnesses, denoted $\{W^5\}$, that build on $\{W^3\}$ and require measurements in two additional bases. We present an adaptive two-step method that uses the measurement results obtained for $\{W^3\}$ to select which $W^5$ to evaluate. We computationally demonstrate that our adaptive two-step protocol can identify 72% of entangled states generated according to the methods of Roik et al. (2021) while requiring measurements in only five of the nine bases needed for full quantum tomography. Additionally, we experimentally verify the behavior of both sets of witnesses using polarization-entangled photon pairs.
AI Summary
The paper studies adaptive entanglement detection for unknown two-qubit states using fewer local Pauli measurement settings than the nine required for full tomography. It starts from six previously proposed one-parameter witness families, $\{W^3\}$, evaluated using the $xx$, $yy$, and $zz$ settings, and derives analytic expressions for their minimized expectation values. Local rotations generate nine additional witness families, $\{W^5\}$, grouped into three triplets; each triplet requires two additional cross-axis settings. Six families admit analytic minimization, while three retain a two-parameter numerical optimization. The proposed protocol first tests $\{W^3\}$, then uses those measurement results to select one $W^5$ triplet, either through a rule based on the largest diagonal correlation magnitude or a five-hidden-layer neural network. On 16.8 million randomly generated entangled states, $W^3$ detects 33%, while the complete adaptive protocol detects 70% with the analytic rule and 72% with the network, using at most five settings. An oracle selecting a successful triplet whenever one exists would detect 79%; evaluating every triplet instead requires all nine settings. These percentages are specific to the sampled state ensemble. Polarization-entangled photon experiments demonstrate detection on selected pure and mixed states missed by $W^3$. A failed test remains inconclusive, and identical first-stage data can require different second-stage choices. Experimental deviations are attributed to residual decoherence and calibration offsets. Finite-statistics uncertainty and tradeoffs between measurement duration and additional settings are left for future study.
Error found: The analytic minimum reported for W5_1 is incorrect for the stated theta domain [0,pi/2], although extending that domain repairs the formula while retaining valid entanglement witnesses and the same measurement settings. The partially minimized W5_9 formula incorrectly uses S_xy twice in place of S_xz, introducing a correlator unavailable from that triplet's five measurement settings.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 11 pages, 6 figures