Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.14788

Entanglement generation from degeneracy breaking of superradiant Liouvillian steady states by local operations

Adam Burgess, Erik M. Gauger

quant-phSubmitted Oct 10, 2026• Announced Oct 13, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Superradiance is a collective optical effect where emitters cooperatively radiate with a maximal intensity scaling proportional to the square of the number of emitters. Despite the superradiant cascade transitioning through highly entangled states, it has been shown that, for dynamics along the Dicke ladder, superradiance need not generate entanglement between the emitters. By contrast, we show how introducing incoherent local processes -- normally considered detrimental to both entanglement and superradiance -- can generate high levels of inter-emitter entanglement. We develop a general framework, using degenerate non-Hermitian perturbation theory, for the study of superradiant Liouvillian steady-state degeneracy breaking by these local operations from a few emitters up into the thermodynamic limit. From this, we are able to show that entanglement becomes ubiquitous in this regime and demonstrate its robustness against other forms of symmetric environmental noise. In the regime where pumping dominates, we find that population accumulates towards the maximally entangled minimal pseudo-spin states, corresponding to multi-emitter singlet states. This provides a deeper insight into many-body entanglement and the curious connection between local operations and entanglement generation.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether weak, independent incoherent processes can generate steady-state entanglement in an ensemble dominated by collective radiative decay, despite the absence of entanglement generation for superradiant decay from a fully inverted state along the maximal Dicke ladder. The model combines collective decay with permutation-symmetric local pumping, dephasing and independent decay. In the regime $\gamma_{P,D,I}\ll\gamma_o$, degenerate non-Hermitian perturbation theory projects the dynamics onto the dark states at the bottoms of the total-spin ladders. The resulting recurrence determines steady-state populations using $\lfloor N/2\rfloor+1$ variables. Comparisons with permutation-invariant master-equation calculations validate this approximation; representative 80-emitter cases have infidelities of order $10^{-4}$. Analytical partial-transpose calculations establish nonzero negativity across the $1:(N-1)$ partition for every non-ground-state mixture in this dark-state family. Weak pumping transfers population toward low-total-spin sectors. With pumping alone, over $99.9\%$ of the thermodynamic-limit population occupies the five lowest-total-spin levels, and the negativity approaches approximately $0.235$ for odd $N$ and $0.225$ for even $N$, versus the partition’s maximum of $1/2$. A separate large-$N$ approximation gives Gaussian excitation statistics when $r=\gamma_P/\gamma_I<1$, with mean $Nr/(1+r)$ and variance $Nr/(1+r)^2$; dephasing drops out at leading order. The treatment concerns perturbative steady states and assumes identical, permutation-symmetric emitters. Disorder is expected to reduce entanglement, and the Lindblad description may fail at very large emitter numbers. The entanglement measure probes one emitter versus the remainder, rather than establishing genuine multipartite entanglement.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptionsPossible errorOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The pumping-dominated thermodynamic entanglement result lacks uniform perturbative control: pumping out of a singlet scales as N gamma_P/2 while the ensuing collective relaxation rate is only 2 gamma_o, requiring an additional scaling condition or an explicit order of limits. The expanded negativity formula has the wrong sign in its p_{j-1} squared contribution and produces an imaginary result for the two-emitter singlet, although the preceding unexpanded formula gives the correct negativity. The supplement's displayed effective generator omits the negative diagonal loss contribution and therefore does not conserve probability as written.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Related papers

Extensive mixed-state entanglement in kinetically constrained superradiance

Lucas Winter, Jan Kumlin, Thomas Pohl +1 more

Dicke superradiance by an ensemble of quantum emitters produces a collective burst of radiation, but no entanglement in the mixed state of the emitters. We show that adding a local kinetic constraint between the emitters generates extensive mixed-state entanglement, while otherwise preserving all key features of Dicke superradiance. Specifically, for any local Boolean constraint, we analytically derive a lower bound for the emission rate which implies a peak intensity $\propto N^2$ and a peak time $\propto (\log N)/N$ with number of spins $N$. This effect enables the superradiantly accelerated preparation of entangled dark states. Hereby, Hilbert-space fragmentation of the Dicke ladder leads to an exponentially branching decay tree that generates a hierarchy of dark states. Importantly, these disconnected manifolds include exponentially many long-range entangled singlet dark states. The explored kinetic constraints and superradiant dynamics can be realized in neutral-atom arrays coupled to an optical cavity, and we suggest a simple and accessible witness to detect the predicted mixed-state entanglement in such experiments. Moreover, we show that entanglement generation is robust against atomic decay and collective dephasing, and should be observable under recently reported experimental conditions. Our results, thereby, offer a general framework and experimentally viable approach for the dissipative engineering of entangled dark states enhanced by superradiance.

quant-pharXiv:2605.16131•Physical Review Letters•May 18, 2026•4 citations

Observation of Superradiant Bursts in a Cascaded Quantum System

Christian Liedl, Felix Tebbenjohanns, Constanze Bach +3 more

We experimentally investigate the collective radiative decay of a fully inverted ensemble of two-level atoms for a chiral, i.e., propagation direction-dependent light-matter coupling. Despite a fundamentally different interaction Hamiltonian which has a reduced symmetry compared to the standard Dicke case of superradiance, we do observe a superradiant burst of light. The burst occurs above a threshold number of atoms, and its peak power scales faster with the number of atoms than in the case of free-space Dicke superradiance. We measure the first-order coherence of the burst and experimentally distinguish two regimes, one dominated by the coherence induced during the excitation process and the other governed by vacuum fluctuations. Our results shed light on the collective radiative dynamics of cascaded quantum many-body systems, i.e., systems in which each quantum emitter is only driven by light radiated by emitters that are upstream in the cascade. Our findings may turn out useful for generating multiphoton Fock states as a resource for quantum technologies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2211.08940•Physical Review X•Feb 16, 2024•68 citations

Kinetically constrained superradiance

Luis Fernando dos Prazeres, Hossein Hosseinabadi, Jamir Marino

We introduce kinetically constrained superradiance, a form of cooperative emission in which interactions imprint configuration-dependent energy shifts on optical transitions, splitting Dicke superradiance into multiple, frequency-resolved collective decay channels. Each channel selectively radiates from distinct many-body spin configurations, generating a hierarchy of dissipative time scales and sequential relaxation dynamics. Unlike conventional superradiance, where permutation symmetry enforces relaxation to a trivial steady state, configuration-selective emission can trap finite-momentum spin-wave excitations and stabilize long-lived entanglement. Remarkably, these correlations are generated purely by dissipation in the absence of entangling coherent dynamics. Our results point to modern superradiant experiments as scalable resources for dissipative engineering of correlated quantum states.

quant-pharXiv:2605.05343•May 8, 2026•6 citations

Cavity-mediated collective emission from steady-state subradiance

Kyu-Young Kim, Jinhee Lee, Woong Bae Jeon +5 more

Cooperative effects such as super(or sub)radiance in quantum systems arise from the interplay among quantum emitters. While bright superradiant states have been extensively studied and have yielded important insights into cooperative phenomena, subradiant states remain less explored due to their inherently dark state nature. However, subradiance holds significant potential as a valuable quantum resource exploiting long-lived and large-scale entanglement, which is a key for advancing quantum information technologies. Here, we demonstrate strong collective emission from a cavity-mediated steady-state subradiant state. In a tailored photonic environment with balanced cavity dissipation, emitter-field coupling strength, and incoherent pumping, two quantum dots coupled to a low-Q cavity exhibit a steady-state population in a subradiant state with a highly negative cooperativity parameter among the emitters. As a key signature of steady-state subradiance, the system shows strong photon bunching ( $${{{\rm{g}}}}^{\left(2\right)}\left(0\right) > 8$$ ) and suppressed single-photon decay (36 ns). Furthermore, we investigate that such collective interactions can be manipulated by controlling various system parameters, such as detuning and dephasing, supported by numerical simulations. Our approach to inducing cavity-mediated subradiance paves the way for generating and harnessing quantum correlations among quantum emitters via controlled dissipation. Subradiance is a cooperative effect in systems of quantum emitters, which is the opposite of superradiance, or enhanced emission, but has been less explored. Here, the authors demonstrate a steady-state subradiant state in a system of two InAs quantum dots coupled to a low-Q nanophotonic cavity.

arXiv:2412.09252•Nature Communications•Jul 9, 2025•10 citations

Scaling theory of decoherence in Dicke superradiance

Nico S. Bassler, Julian Lyne, Javier Cuerda

The survival of many-body coherence depends on the competition between correlation buildup and decoherence. In Dicke superradiance, collective emission builds up correlations, producing a peak intensity scaling as $N^2$ for $N$ emitters. We develop a scaling theory including local dephasing and spontaneous emission and obtain fully collective, partially collective, and independent-emitter scaling regimes. The boundary of the fully collective regime defines a continuous phase transition in a transient observable. Local decoherence can prevent $N^2$ scaling despite increasing $N$.

quant-pharXiv:2607.28034•Jul 31, 2026•1 citation

Steady-state spin order and superradiance beyond the Dicke limit

Silvia Cardenas-Lopez, Edgar Guardiola-Navarrete, Ana Asenjo-Garcia

Spontaneous collective decay in incoherently driven atomic ensembles can generate macroscopic coherence in the steady state, as exemplified by steady-state superradiance in single-mode cavities. Whether spontaneous order persists beyond the Dicke limit, where competing collective decay channels and light propagation might preclude an ordered phase, remains an open question. We address it by analyzing incoherently pumped atoms coupled to one-dimensional electromagnetic baths through two models: a ring cavity with two bright decay channels, and a bidirectional waveguide where propagation additionally induces Hamiltonian dipole-dipole interactions. We find that both systems sustain steady-state phase order with intensity scaling as $N^2$, but that the order takes two qualitatively distinct forms, neither described by a single macroscopic dipole. In the ring cavity, individual trajectories spontaneously break mirror symmetry, locking the atomic phases and the emitted field to one of two chiral orders. In the waveguide, coherent interactions instead enforce a phase-separated steady state in which the two chiral orders coexist, each dominating one end of the array. Our results show how competition and propagation shape emergent order beyond the Dicke limit.

quant-pharXiv:2511.10638•Physical Review Research•Nov 14, 2025•3 citations
Superradiance is a collective optical effect where emitters cooperatively radiate with a maximal intensity scaling proportional to the square of the number of emitters. Despite the superradiant cascade transitioning through highly entangled states, it has been shown that, for dynamics along the Dicke ladder, superradiance need not generate entanglement between the emitters. By contrast, we show how introducing incoherent local processes -- normally considered detrimental to both entanglement and superradiance -- can generate high levels of inter-emitter entanglement. We develop a general framework, using degenerate non-Hermitian perturbation theory, for the study of superradiant Liouvillian steady-state degeneracy breaking by these local operations from a few emitters up into the thermodynamic limit. From this, we are able to show that entanglement becomes ubiquitous in this regime and demonstrate its robustness against other forms of symmetric environmental noise. In the regime where pumping dominates, we find that population accumulates towards the maximally entangled minimal pseudo-spin states, corresponding to multi-emitter singlet states. This provides a deeper insight into many-body entanglement and the curious connection between local operations and entanglement generation.
The paper asks whether weak, independent incoherent processes can generate steady-state entanglement in an ensemble dominated by collective radiative decay, despite the absence of entanglement generation for superradiant decay from a fully inverted state along the maximal Dicke ladder.
The model combines collective decay with permutation-symmetric local pumping, dephasing and independent decay. In the regime γP,D,I≪γo\gamma_{P,D,I}\ll\gamma_oγP,D,I​≪γo​, degenerate non-Hermitian perturbation theory projects the dynamics onto the dark states at the bottoms of the total-spin ladders. The resulting recurrence determines steady-state populations using ⌊N/2⌋+1\lfloor N/2\rfloor+1⌊N/2⌋+1 variables. Comparisons with permutation-invariant master-equation calculations validate this approximation; representative 80-emitter cases have infidelities of order 10−410^{-4}10−4.
Analytical partial-transpose calculations establish nonzero negativity across the 1:(N−1)1:(N-1)1:(N−1) partition for every non-ground-state mixture in this dark-state family. Weak pumping transfers population toward low-total-spin sectors. With pumping alone, over 99.9%99.9\%99.9% of the thermodynamic-limit population occupies the five lowest-total-spin levels, and the negativity approaches approximately 0.2350.2350.235 for odd NNN and 0.2250.2250.225 for even NNN, versus the partition’s maximum of 1/21/21/2. A separate large-NNN approximation gives Gaussian excitation statistics when r=γP/γI<1r=\gamma_P/\gamma_I<1r=γP​/γI​<1, with mean Nr/(1+r)Nr/(1+r)Nr/(1+r) and variance Nr/(1+r)2Nr/(1+r)^2Nr/(1+r)2; dephasing drops out at leading order.
The treatment concerns perturbative steady states and assumes identical, permutation-symmetric emitters. Disorder is expected to reduce entanglement, and the Lindblad description may fail at very large emitter numbers. The entanglement measure probes one emitter versus the remainder, rather than establishing genuine multipartite entanglement.
Dicke superradiance by an ensemble of quantum emitters produces a collective burst of radiation, but no entanglement in the mixed state of the emitters. We show that adding a local kinetic constraint between the emitters generates extensive mixed-state entanglement, while otherwise preserving all key features of Dicke superradiance. Specifically, for any local Boolean constraint, we analytically derive a lower bound for the emission rate which implies a peak intensity ∝N2\propto N^2∝N2 and a peak time ∝(log⁡N)/N\propto (\log N)/N∝(logN)/N with number of spins NNN. This effect enables the superradiantly accelerated preparation of entangled dark states. Hereby, Hilbert-space fragmentation of the Dicke ladder leads to an exponentially branching decay tree that generates a hierarchy of dark states. Importantly, these disconnected manifolds include exponentially many long-range entangled singlet dark states. The explored kinetic constraints and superradiant dynamics can be realized in neutral-atom arrays coupled to an optical cavity, and we suggest a simple and accessible witness to detect the predicted mixed-state entanglement in such experiments. Moreover, we show that entanglement generation is robust against atomic decay and collective dephasing, and should be observable under recently reported experimental conditions. Our results, thereby, offer a general framework and experimentally viable approach for the dissipative engineering of entangled dark states enhanced by superradiance.
We experimentally investigate the collective radiative decay of a fully inverted ensemble of two-level atoms for a chiral, i.e., propagation direction-dependent light-matter coupling. Despite a fundamentally different interaction Hamiltonian which has a reduced symmetry compared to the standard Dicke case of superradiance, we do observe a superradiant burst of light. The burst occurs above a threshold number of atoms, and its peak power scales faster with the number of atoms than in the case of free-space Dicke superradiance. We measure the first-order coherence of the burst and experimentally distinguish two regimes, one dominated by the coherence induced during the excitation process and the other governed by vacuum fluctuations. Our results shed light on the collective radiative dynamics of cascaded quantum many-body systems, i.e., systems in which each quantum emitter is only driven by light radiated by emitters that are upstream in the cascade. Our findings may turn out useful for generating multiphoton Fock states as a resource for quantum technologies. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We introduce kinetically constrained superradiance, a form of cooperative emission in which interactions imprint configuration-dependent energy shifts on optical transitions, splitting Dicke superradiance into multiple, frequency-resolved collective decay channels. Each channel selectively radiates from distinct many-body spin configurations, generating a hierarchy of dissipative time scales and sequential relaxation dynamics. Unlike conventional superradiance, where permutation symmetry enforces relaxation to a trivial steady state, configuration-selective emission can trap finite-momentum spin-wave excitations and stabilize long-lived entanglement. Remarkably, these correlations are generated purely by dissipation in the absence of entangling coherent dynamics. Our results point to modern superradiant experiments as scalable resources for dissipative engineering of correlated quantum states.
Cooperative effects such as super(or sub)radiance in quantum systems arise from the interplay among quantum emitters. While bright superradiant states have been extensively studied and have yielded important insights into cooperative phenomena, subradiant states remain less explored due to their inherently dark state nature. However, subradiance holds significant potential as a valuable quantum resource exploiting long-lived and large-scale entanglement, which is a key for advancing quantum information technologies. Here, we demonstrate strong collective emission from a cavity-mediated steady-state subradiant state. In a tailored photonic environment with balanced cavity dissipation, emitter-field coupling strength, and incoherent pumping, two quantum dots coupled to a low-Q cavity exhibit a steady-state population in a subradiant state with a highly negative cooperativity parameter among the emitters. As a key signature of steady-state subradiance, the system shows strong photon bunching ( g(2)(0)>8{{{\rm{g}}}}^{\left(2\right)}\left(0\right) > 8g(2)(0)>8 ) and suppressed single-photon decay (36 ns). Furthermore, we investigate that such collective interactions can be manipulated by controlling various system parameters, such as detuning and dephasing, supported by numerical simulations. Our approach to inducing cavity-mediated subradiance paves the way for generating and harnessing quantum correlations among quantum emitters via controlled dissipation. Subradiance is a cooperative effect in systems of quantum emitters, which is the opposite of superradiance, or enhanced emission, but has been less explored. Here, the authors demonstrate a steady-state subradiant state in a system of two InAs quantum dots coupled to a low-Q nanophotonic cavity.
The survival of many-body coherence depends on the competition between correlation buildup and decoherence. In Dicke superradiance, collective emission builds up correlations, producing a peak intensity scaling as N2N^2N2 for NNN emitters. We develop a scaling theory including local dephasing and spontaneous emission and obtain fully collective, partially collective, and independent-emitter scaling regimes. The boundary of the fully collective regime defines a continuous phase transition in a transient observable. Local decoherence can prevent N2N^2N2 scaling despite increasing NNN.
Spontaneous collective decay in incoherently driven atomic ensembles can generate macroscopic coherence in the steady state, as exemplified by steady-state superradiance in single-mode cavities. Whether spontaneous order persists beyond the Dicke limit, where competing collective decay channels and light propagation might preclude an ordered phase, remains an open question. We address it by analyzing incoherently pumped atoms coupled to one-dimensional electromagnetic baths through two models: a ring cavity with two bright decay channels, and a bidirectional waveguide where propagation additionally induces Hamiltonian dipole-dipole interactions. We find that both systems sustain steady-state phase order with intensity scaling as N2N^2N2, but that the order takes two qualitatively distinct forms, neither described by a single macroscopic dipole. In the ring cavity, individual trajectories spontaneously break mirror symmetry, locking the atomic phases and the emitted field to one of two chiral orders. In the waveguide, coherent interactions instead enforce a phase-separated steady state in which the two chiral orders coexist, each dominating one end of the array. Our results show how competition and propagation shape emergent order beyond the Dicke limit.