Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.13802

Replica Transition at Measurement-Altered Ising Criticality

Kabir Khanna, Sara Murciano, Romain Vasseur

cond-mat.stat-mechquant-phSubmitted Oct 9, 2026• Announced Oct 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Performing measurements on gapless quantum ground states can give rise to new universal phenomena, whose origins remain poorly understood even for the paradigmatic Ising critical point. Replica methods offer a natural framework to study such post-measurement ensembles, with the replica limit $Q\to 1$ describing physical Born-averaged observables. Here we show that, for the monitored critical Ising chain, the replicated post-measurement ensemble of states itself undergoes a phase transition precisely at the physically relevant replica limit $Q \to 1$, preventing standard replica treatments. We use boundary conformal field theory (BCFT) methods to explain the underlying mechanism of this transition. Our methods yield a perturbative analytic calculation of the universal $O(1)$ constant in the Shannon entropy of the measurement record, previously known only numerically. We also apply our tools to study measurement-averaged spin correlators, providing a unified description of the universal properties of measurement outcomes and post-measurement states in the critical Ising chain.

AI Summary

The paper studies why the Born ensemble of order-parameter measurements on the critical Ising ground state lies at a replica transition at $Q=1$, and how to compute universal measurement-record entropies and post-measurement correlations there. The transition and Shannon-entropy constant were previously observed numerically; continuation from either neighboring replica phase does not recover the physical point. Folding $Q$ Ising replicas gives $2Q$ boundary theories. A simultaneous boundary-condition-changing insertion has scaling dimension $Q$: it destabilizes the aligned fixed boundary for $Q<1$, is irrelevant for $Q>1$, and is exactly marginal at $Q=1$. Boundary conformal field theory identifies the marginal family with the Ising defect line. Kraus completeness selects its defect-free point, with fugacity $\lambda_*=1/\pi$ and scattering angle $\theta_*=\pi/4$. The replica and thermodynamic limits therefore do not commute. An expansion over boundary-condition-changing insertions yields the universal constant in $S=\alpha L-s_{\rm eff}+\cdots$. Analytically, $s_{\rm eff}+\log 2=\theta_*^2-(\sqrt{3}/\pi)\theta_*^4+O(\theta_*^6)$; numerically evaluated higher orders approach the previously reported $s_{\rm eff}\simeq-0.254392$. The same framework predicts connected spin-correlation moments near the projective fixed point: $\mathcal C_k(x)\sim |x|^{-2k}$ for even $k$ and $|x|^{-2k-1/4}$ for odd $k$, including exponents $9/4$ and $4$ for the first two moments. The entropy calculation is perturbative rather than closed-form, and convergence of the angle expansion remains unproved. Extensions to other conformal theories are proposed but not established; identifying the relevant boundary operators in richer theories and treating higher dimensions remain open.

No sign of AI-generated text

Error found: The dimension-Q BCC argument establishes local instability of the ordered boundary for Q<1, but the paper does not establish from that argument the asserted global flow to the free boundary or exclude an intervening fixed point. The Shannon-entropy discussion incorrectly identifies lim_{Q→1}(1−Q)^{-1}log g_Q with s_eff, whereas its definition S=αL−s_eff requires that limit to equal −s_eff.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
22 pages, 2 figures

Related papers

Theory of Measurement-Altered Criticality

Kabir Khanna, Sara Murciano, Romain Vasseur

Local measurements can alter long-range correlations in gapless quantum matter. We propose a theory of weakly-monitored Tomonaga-Luttinger liquids, a broad class of quantum critical states in one dimension. In order to address the intrinsic randomness of the measurement record, we develop a replica instanton calculation to study Born-averaged observables. We find that when measurements are relevant, average correlators of density and phase fluctuations decay at long distances as universal power laws with logarithmic corrections, a feature we argue is peculiar to measurement-induced randomness. We characterize the full multifractal spectrum of moments of correlations functions, revealing broad, strongly non-gaussian fluctuations across the ensemble of post-measurement states. We support these analytic results with matrix-product-state calculations, and provide a general picture of measurement-altered criticality for ground states described by 1+1d conformal field theories. Our results establish that physical measurements alter critical quantum states in a manner that lies beyond both forced measurements and conventional critical scaling.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2608.05289•Aug 7, 2026•5 citations

Structure of Measurement-Induced Entanglement in Infinite-Randomness Critical States

Oliver Breach

The impact of projective measurements on a many-body quantum state is tightly linked to its underlying entanglement structure. Critical states are particularly sensitive, as long-range entanglement allows local measurements to have global consequences. This has been extensively studied in the context of critical states described by a conformal field theory (CFT), where measurements can alter critical properties in post-measurement quantities ('measurement-altered criticality') and induce long-range entanglement with universal features ('measurement-induced entanglement'). By contrast, little is known about the role of measurements on critical states with quenched disorder, which admit no CFT description. Here, we develop a theory of measurements on one-dimensional critical states governed by infinite-randomness fixed points (IRFPs), focusing on two closely related examples: the random XXZ chain and the random transverse-field Ising model. We show that the measurement-induced entanglement decays as a power-law with universal exponent $(3-\sqrt{5})/2$ in both models, and that the minimum number of measurements required to establish this entanglement obeys a universal scaling form. When only a finite density of measurements is made, we show that the critical properties of the state are remarkably robust: `measurement-altered criticality' is absent, with measurements either preserving the critical exponents, or destroying the criticality entirely. These results establish IRFPs as an analytically tractable arena for measurements on critical states, complementary to the CFT case. The outcome randomness that necessitates replica methods in clean systems becomes trivial at infinite randomness, with the universal response governed by the statistics induced by the quenched disorder.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2609.17670•Sep 17, 2026•1 citation

Measurement-Altered Quantum Criticality

Yue Liu

Measurements are usually introduced as probes of quantum systems, but they can also act as a powerful, intrinsically nonunitary control knob for manipulating quantum states. This thesis develops the theory, experimental realization, and detection of measurement-altered quantum criticality in one-dimension: the phenomenon where local measurements on critical wave functions reshape universal long-distance correlations, entanglement, and other scaling behaviors. We show that measurements generate defect or boundary perturbations in the underlying conformal field theory, producing new measurement-induced fixed points and new universal observables that are often invisible to the pristine theory. In transverse-field Ising chains, we design measurement-altered criticality protocols in which correlated ancillas are entangled with the critical system and then projectively measured. This setting shows that measurement basis, entangling gate, measurement outcome, and ancilla correlations can qualitatively change correlations in the system and induce outcome-dependent order-parameter condensation. We also develop nonstandard probes --- including higher moments and symmetry-resolved averages --- that retain nontrivial signatures of the post-measurement ensemble. These ideas are then connected to quantum information by studying imperfect teleportation of critical many-body wavefunctions. Teleportation errors can be reinterpreted as effective weak measurements acting on an otherwise faithfully teleported critical state. This perspective yields a classification of protocols in which imperfections either preserve universal correlations and entanglement scaling, continuously deform them, or destroy long-range entanglement while leaving altered power-law correlations behind. Measurement-altered criticality therefore becomes not only a fundamental phenomenon, but also a tool for understanding and optimizing noisy quantum-information protocols. We also broaden the framework to measurement-induced boundary physics. In a gapless parent of the one-dimensional cluster state, a single round of measurements can generate boundary conformal field theories with distinct universal properties. Rotating the measurement basis drives transitions between these boundary fixed points, producing measurement-induced boundary transitions that have no analogue in the descendant gapped cluster state. Extensions to tricritical Ising and three-state Potts criticality show that such transitions arise generally in 1+1D conformal field theories. Finally, the thesis addresses experimental access. We propose practical protocols for observing measurement-altered criticality in Rydberg atom arrays tuned to Ising and tricritical-Ising transitions, where projective measurements of selected atoms can controllably modify critical correlations with experimentally favorable post-selection probabilities. We also develop a post-selection-free framework for extracting nonlinear observables from raw measurement records using statistical learning. By recasting higher moments of conditioned observables as supervised learning objectives, the method replaces exponentially costly sector-by-sector postselection with regression whose sample complexity is controlled by decoder capacity. In critical Ising chains, linear, logistic, and convolutional decoders recover measurement-altered scaling and correlations from simulated unpostselected data. Together, these results establish measurements as a practical and universal route to engineering, diagnosing, and exploiting new forms of quantum critical behavior.

•Jun 5, 2026•0 citations

Measurement-Altered Ising Quantum Criticality

Sara Murciano, Pablo Sala, Yue Liu +2 more

Quantum critical systems constitute appealing platforms for exploring novel measurement-induced phenomena due to their innate sensitivity to perturbations.We study the impact of measurements on paradigmatic Ising quantum-critical chains using an explicit protocol, whereby correlated ancillae are entangled with the critical chain and then projectively measured.Using a perturbative analytic framework supported by extensive numerical simulations, we demonstrate that measurements can qualitatively alter critical correlations in a manner dependent on the choice of entangling gate, ancilla measurement basis, measurement outcome, and nature of ancilla correlations.We further show that measurement-altered Ising criticality can be pursued surprisingly efficiently in experiments featuring of order 100 qubits by postselecting for high-probability measurement outcomes or, in certain cases, by averaging observables separately over measurement outcomes residing in distinct symmetry sectors.Our framework naturally adapts to more exotic quantum-critical points and highlights opportunities for realization in noisy intermediate-scale quantum hardware and in Rydberg arrays.

arXiv:2302.04325•Physical Review X•Dec 5, 2023•63 citations

Nonlocality and entanglement in measured critical quantum Ising chains

Zack Weinstein, Rohith Sajith, Ehud Altman +1 more

We study the effects of measurements, performed with a finite density in space, on the ground state of the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising model at criticality. Local degrees of freedom in critical states exhibit long-range entanglement, and as a result, local measurements can have highly nonlocal effects. Our analytical investigation of correlations and entanglement in the ensemble of measured states is based on properties of the Ising conformal field theory (CFT), where measurements appear as $(1+0)$-dimensional defects in the $(1+1)$-dimensional Euclidean spacetime. So that we can verify our predictions using large-scale free-fermion numerics, we restrict ourselves to parity-symmetric measurements. To describe their averaged effects analytically we use a replica approach, and we show that the defect arising in the replica theory is an irrelevant perturbation to the Ising CFT. Strikingly, the asymptotic scalings of averaged correlations and entanglement entropy are therefore unchanged relative to the ground state. In contrast, the defect generated by postselecting on the most likely measurement outcomes is exactly marginal. We then find that the exponent governing postmeasurement order parameter correlations, as well as the ``effective central charge'' governing the scaling of entanglement entropy, vary continuously with the density of measurements in space. Our work establishes connections between the effects of measurements on many-body quantum states and of physical defects on low-energy equilibrium properties.

arXiv:2301.08268•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 22, 2023•49 citations

Phase transition in the Rényi-Shannon entropy of Luttinger liquids

Jean-Marie Stéphan, Grégoire Misguich, Vincent Pasquier

The R\'enyi-Shannon entropy allows extraction of some universal information about many-body wave functions. For a critical spin chain with central charge $c=1$, we show that it exhibits a phase transition at some value ${n}_{c}$ of the R\'enyi parameter $n$ which depends on the Luttinger parameter $R$. A replica-free formulation establishes a connection to boundary entropies in conformal field theory and reveals that the transition is triggered by a vertex operator which becomes relevant at the boundary. Our numerical results (XXZ and ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ spin chains) match the continuum limit prediction, confirming its universal character. The replica approach used in previous works turns out to be correct only for $n<{n}_{c}$. From the point of view of two-dimensional Rokhsar-Kivelson states, this transition reveals a singularity in the entanglement spectra.

arXiv:1104.2544•Physical Review B•Nov 28, 2011•95 citations
Performing measurements on gapless quantum ground states can give rise to new universal phenomena, whose origins remain poorly understood even for the paradigmatic Ising critical point. Replica methods offer a natural framework to study such post-measurement ensembles, with the replica limit Q→1Q\to 1Q→1 describing physical Born-averaged observables. Here we show that, for the monitored critical Ising chain, the replicated post-measurement ensemble of states itself undergoes a phase transition precisely at the physically relevant replica limit Q→1Q \to 1Q→1, preventing standard replica treatments. We use boundary conformal field theory (BCFT) methods to explain the underlying mechanism of this transition. Our methods yield a perturbative analytic calculation of the universal O(1)O(1)O(1) constant in the Shannon entropy of the measurement record, previously known only numerically. We also apply our tools to study measurement-averaged spin correlators, providing a unified description of the universal properties of measurement outcomes and post-measurement states in the critical Ising chain.
The paper studies why the Born ensemble of order-parameter measurements on the critical Ising ground state lies at a replica transition at Q=1Q=1Q=1, and how to compute universal measurement-record entropies and post-measurement correlations there. The transition and Shannon-entropy constant were previously observed numerically; continuation from either neighboring replica phase does not recover the physical point.
Folding QQQ Ising replicas gives 2Q2Q2Q boundary theories. A simultaneous boundary-condition-changing insertion has scaling dimension QQQ: it destabilizes the aligned fixed boundary for Q<1Q<1Q<1, is irrelevant for Q>1Q>1Q>1, and is exactly marginal at Q=1Q=1Q=1. Boundary conformal field theory identifies the marginal family with the Ising defect line. Kraus completeness selects its defect-free point, with fugacity λ∗=1/π\lambda_*=1/\piλ∗​=1/π and scattering angle θ∗=π/4\theta_*=\pi/4θ∗​=π/4. The replica and thermodynamic limits therefore do not commute.
An expansion over boundary-condition-changing insertions yields the universal constant in S=αL−seff+⋯S=\alpha L-s_{\rm eff}+\cdotsS=αL−seff​+⋯. Analytically, seff+log⁡2=θ∗2−(3/π)θ∗4+O(θ∗6)s_{\rm eff}+\log 2=\theta_*^2-(\sqrt{3}/\pi)\theta_*^4+O(\theta_*^6)seff​+log2=θ∗2​−(3​/π)θ∗4​+O(θ∗6​); numerically evaluated higher orders approach the previously reported seff≃−0.254392s_{\rm eff}\simeq-0.254392seff​≃−0.254392. The same framework predicts connected spin-correlation moments near the projective fixed point: Ck(x)∼∣x∣−2k\mathcal C_k(x)\sim |x|^{-2k}Ck​(x)∼∣x∣−2k for even kkk and ∣x∣−2k−1/4|x|^{-2k-1/4}∣x∣−2k−1/4 for odd kkk, including exponents 9/49/49/4 and 444 for the first two moments.
The entropy calculation is perturbative rather than closed-form, and convergence of the angle expansion remains unproved. Extensions to other conformal theories are proposed but not established; identifying the relevant boundary operators in richer theories and treating higher dimensions remain open.
Local measurements can alter long-range correlations in gapless quantum matter. We propose a theory of weakly-monitored Tomonaga-Luttinger liquids, a broad class of quantum critical states in one dimension. In order to address the intrinsic randomness of the measurement record, we develop a replica instanton calculation to study Born-averaged observables. We find that when measurements are relevant, average correlators of density and phase fluctuations decay at long distances as universal power laws with logarithmic corrections, a feature we argue is peculiar to measurement-induced randomness. We characterize the full multifractal spectrum of moments of correlations functions, revealing broad, strongly non-gaussian fluctuations across the ensemble of post-measurement states. We support these analytic results with matrix-product-state calculations, and provide a general picture of measurement-altered criticality for ground states described by 1+1d conformal field theories. Our results establish that physical measurements alter critical quantum states in a manner that lies beyond both forced measurements and conventional critical scaling.
The impact of projective measurements on a many-body quantum state is tightly linked to its underlying entanglement structure. Critical states are particularly sensitive, as long-range entanglement allows local measurements to have global consequences. This has been extensively studied in the context of critical states described by a conformal field theory (CFT), where measurements can alter critical properties in post-measurement quantities ('measurement-altered criticality') and induce long-range entanglement with universal features ('measurement-induced entanglement'). By contrast, little is known about the role of measurements on critical states with quenched disorder, which admit no CFT description. Here, we develop a theory of measurements on one-dimensional critical states governed by infinite-randomness fixed points (IRFPs), focusing on two closely related examples: the random XXZ chain and the random transverse-field Ising model. We show that the measurement-induced entanglement decays as a power-law with universal exponent (3−5)/2(3-\sqrt{5})/2(3−5​)/2 in both models, and that the minimum number of measurements required to establish this entanglement obeys a universal scaling form. When only a finite density of measurements is made, we show that the critical properties of the state are remarkably robust: `measurement-altered criticality' is absent, with measurements either preserving the critical exponents, or destroying the criticality entirely. These results establish IRFPs as an analytically tractable arena for measurements on critical states, complementary to the CFT case. The outcome randomness that necessitates replica methods in clean systems becomes trivial at infinite randomness, with the universal response governed by the statistics induced by the quenched disorder.
Measurements are usually introduced as probes of quantum systems, but they can also act as a powerful, intrinsically nonunitary control knob for manipulating quantum states. This thesis develops the theory, experimental realization, and detection of measurement-altered quantum criticality in one-dimension: the phenomenon where local measurements on critical wave functions reshape universal long-distance correlations, entanglement, and other scaling behaviors. We show that measurements generate defect or boundary perturbations in the underlying conformal field theory, producing new measurement-induced fixed points and new universal observables that are often invisible to the pristine theory. In transverse-field Ising chains, we design measurement-altered criticality protocols in which correlated ancillas are entangled with the critical system and then projectively measured. This setting shows that measurement basis, entangling gate, measurement outcome, and ancilla correlations can qualitatively change correlations in the system and induce outcome-dependent order-parameter condensation. We also develop nonstandard probes --- including higher moments and symmetry-resolved averages --- that retain nontrivial signatures of the post-measurement ensemble. These ideas are then connected to quantum information by studying imperfect teleportation of critical many-body wavefunctions. Teleportation errors can be reinterpreted as effective weak measurements acting on an otherwise faithfully teleported critical state. This perspective yields a classification of protocols in which imperfections either preserve universal correlations and entanglement scaling, continuously deform them, or destroy long-range entanglement while leaving altered power-law correlations behind. Measurement-altered criticality therefore becomes not only a fundamental phenomenon, but also a tool for understanding and optimizing noisy quantum-information protocols. We also broaden the framework to measurement-induced boundary physics. In a gapless parent of the one-dimensional cluster state, a single round of measurements can generate boundary conformal field theories with distinct universal properties. Rotating the measurement basis drives transitions between these boundary fixed points, producing measurement-induced boundary transitions that have no analogue in the descendant gapped cluster state. Extensions to tricritical Ising and three-state Potts criticality show that such transitions arise generally in 1+1D conformal field theories. Finally, the thesis addresses experimental access. We propose practical protocols for observing measurement-altered criticality in Rydberg atom arrays tuned to Ising and tricritical-Ising transitions, where projective measurements of selected atoms can controllably modify critical correlations with experimentally favorable post-selection probabilities. We also develop a post-selection-free framework for extracting nonlinear observables from raw measurement records using statistical learning. By recasting higher moments of conditioned observables as supervised learning objectives, the method replaces exponentially costly sector-by-sector postselection with regression whose sample complexity is controlled by decoder capacity. In critical Ising chains, linear, logistic, and convolutional decoders recover measurement-altered scaling and correlations from simulated unpostselected data. Together, these results establish measurements as a practical and universal route to engineering, diagnosing, and exploiting new forms of quantum critical behavior.
Quantum critical systems constitute appealing platforms for exploring novel measurement-induced phenomena due to their innate sensitivity to perturbations.We study the impact of measurements on paradigmatic Ising quantum-critical chains using an explicit protocol, whereby correlated ancillae are entangled with the critical chain and then projectively measured.Using a perturbative analytic framework supported by extensive numerical simulations, we demonstrate that measurements can qualitatively alter critical correlations in a manner dependent on the choice of entangling gate, ancilla measurement basis, measurement outcome, and nature of ancilla correlations.We further show that measurement-altered Ising criticality can be pursued surprisingly efficiently in experiments featuring of order 100 qubits by postselecting for high-probability measurement outcomes or, in certain cases, by averaging observables separately over measurement outcomes residing in distinct symmetry sectors.Our framework naturally adapts to more exotic quantum-critical points and highlights opportunities for realization in noisy intermediate-scale quantum hardware and in Rydberg arrays.
We study the effects of measurements, performed with a finite density in space, on the ground state of the one-dimensional transverse-field Ising model at criticality. Local degrees of freedom in critical states exhibit long-range entanglement, and as a result, local measurements can have highly nonlocal effects. Our analytical investigation of correlations and entanglement in the ensemble of measured states is based on properties of the Ising conformal field theory (CFT), where measurements appear as (1+0)(1+0)(1+0)-dimensional defects in the (1+1)(1+1)(1+1)-dimensional Euclidean spacetime. So that we can verify our predictions using large-scale free-fermion numerics, we restrict ourselves to parity-symmetric measurements. To describe their averaged effects analytically we use a replica approach, and we show that the defect arising in the replica theory is an irrelevant perturbation to the Ising CFT. Strikingly, the asymptotic scalings of averaged correlations and entanglement entropy are therefore unchanged relative to the ground state. In contrast, the defect generated by postselecting on the most likely measurement outcomes is exactly marginal. We then find that the exponent governing postmeasurement order parameter correlations, as well as the ``effective central charge'' governing the scaling of entanglement entropy, vary continuously with the density of measurements in space. Our work establishes connections between the effects of measurements on many-body quantum states and of physical defects on low-energy equilibrium properties.
The R\'enyi-Shannon entropy allows extraction of some universal information about many-body wave functions. For a critical spin chain with central charge c=1c=1c=1, we show that it exhibits a phase transition at some value nc{n}_{c}nc​ of the R\'enyi parameter nnn which depends on the Luttinger parameter RRR. A replica-free formulation establishes a connection to boundary entropies in conformal field theory and reveals that the transition is triggered by a vertex operator which becomes relevant at the boundary. Our numerical results (XXZ and ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ spin chains) match the continuum limit prediction, confirming its universal character. The replica approach used in previous works turns out to be correct only for n<ncn<{n}_{c}n<nc​. From the point of view of two-dimensional Rokhsar-Kivelson states, this transition reveals a singularity in the entanglement spectra.