arXiv:2610.13802
Replica Transition at Measurement-Altered Ising Criticality
Kabir Khanna, Sara Murciano, Romain Vasseur
Abstract
Performing measurements on gapless quantum ground states can give rise to new universal phenomena, whose origins remain poorly understood even for the paradigmatic Ising critical point. Replica methods offer a natural framework to study such post-measurement ensembles, with the replica limit $Q\to 1$ describing physical Born-averaged observables. Here we show that, for the monitored critical Ising chain, the replicated post-measurement ensemble of states itself undergoes a phase transition precisely at the physically relevant replica limit $Q \to 1$, preventing standard replica treatments. We use boundary conformal field theory (BCFT) methods to explain the underlying mechanism of this transition. Our methods yield a perturbative analytic calculation of the universal $O(1)$ constant in the Shannon entropy of the measurement record, previously known only numerically. We also apply our tools to study measurement-averaged spin correlators, providing a unified description of the universal properties of measurement outcomes and post-measurement states in the critical Ising chain.
AI Summary
The paper studies why the Born ensemble of order-parameter measurements on the critical Ising ground state lies at a replica transition at $Q=1$, and how to compute universal measurement-record entropies and post-measurement correlations there. The transition and Shannon-entropy constant were previously observed numerically; continuation from either neighboring replica phase does not recover the physical point. Folding $Q$ Ising replicas gives $2Q$ boundary theories. A simultaneous boundary-condition-changing insertion has scaling dimension $Q$: it destabilizes the aligned fixed boundary for $Q<1$, is irrelevant for $Q>1$, and is exactly marginal at $Q=1$. Boundary conformal field theory identifies the marginal family with the Ising defect line. Kraus completeness selects its defect-free point, with fugacity $\lambda_*=1/\pi$ and scattering angle $\theta_*=\pi/4$. The replica and thermodynamic limits therefore do not commute. An expansion over boundary-condition-changing insertions yields the universal constant in $S=\alpha L-s_{\rm eff}+\cdots$. Analytically, $s_{\rm eff}+\log 2=\theta_*^2-(\sqrt{3}/\pi)\theta_*^4+O(\theta_*^6)$; numerically evaluated higher orders approach the previously reported $s_{\rm eff}\simeq-0.254392$. The same framework predicts connected spin-correlation moments near the projective fixed point: $\mathcal C_k(x)\sim |x|^{-2k}$ for even $k$ and $|x|^{-2k-1/4}$ for odd $k$, including exponents $9/4$ and $4$ for the first two moments. The entropy calculation is perturbative rather than closed-form, and convergence of the angle expansion remains unproved. Extensions to other conformal theories are proposed but not established; identifying the relevant boundary operators in richer theories and treating higher dimensions remain open.
Error found: The dimension-Q BCC argument establishes local instability of the ordered boundary for Q<1, but the paper does not establish from that argument the asserted global flow to the free boundary or exclude an intervening fixed point. The Shannon-entropy discussion incorrectly identifies lim_{Q→1}(1−Q)^{-1}log g_Q with s_eff, whereas its definition S=αL−s_eff requires that limit to equal −s_eff.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 22 pages, 2 figures