Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.13602

Entanglement Catalysis Beyond the Asymptotic Rate

Alexander Streltsov

quant-phSubmitted Oct 9, 2026• Announced Oct 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum entanglement is a fundamental resource in quantum information science, commonly consumed to perform tasks like quantum teleportation and quantum key distribution. Entanglement concentration converts partially entangled pure states into nearly perfect Bell pairs. While its efficiency is well understood in the asymptotic limit, practical protocols must operate with finite systems. In this finite regime, and at the low error levels relevant in practice, performance is penalized by corrections that reduce the achievable yield. We investigate whether this fundamental finite-size penalty can be mitigated by an entanglement catalyst: an auxiliary state that aids the transformation but is returned exactly and uncorrupted. Although such a catalyst cannot increase the leading-order asymptotic yield, we show that it fundamentally alters the finite-size scaling. For every bipartite pure state with nonuniform Schmidt coefficients, we exactly determine the optimal second-order correction to the yield and show that catalysis completely overcomes this finite-size penalty.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether exact entanglement catalysis can improve finite-block pure-state entanglement concentration despite leaving the leading asymptotic rate unchanged. It considers deterministic LOCC transformations assisted by a finite-dimensional pure catalyst returned exactly and uncorrelated with the output. The output must be a pure state within trace distance $\varepsilon$ of $m$ Bell pairs; catalyst size is unrestricted. For every nonuniform Schmidt spectrum $p$ and fixed $0<\varepsilon<1$, it determines the optimal yield as $M_n^{\mathrm{cat}}(\varepsilon)=nH(p)+b_{\mathrm{cat}}(\varepsilon)\sqrt n+o(\sqrt n)$, where $b_{\mathrm{cat}}(\varepsilon)=\sqrt{2V(p)\ln[1/(1-\varepsilon^2)]}$. Here $H$ and the varentropy $V$ use base-2 logarithms. Without catalysis, the coefficient is $\sqrt{V(p)}\,\Phi^{-1}(\varepsilon^2)$. Thus, for $0<\varepsilon<1/\sqrt2$, catalysis changes the second-order correction from negative to positive. Achievability uses an output Schmidt spectrum with one component of weight $\varepsilon^2$ and a uniform remainder. Uniform control of its power sums over all positive Rényi orders, together with the Klimesh–Turgut characterization of catalytic majorization, establishes catalyst existence. The converse cancels the catalyst from Rényi power-sum inequalities and combines a fidelity bound with an expansion at orders $1-t/\sqrt n$. The construction does not bound the catalyst’s Schmidt rank or entanglement. The result takes $n\to\infty$ at fixed positive error, not the zero-error or vanishing-error limit. Quantifying the remainder, extending to mixed inputs or general targets, and addressing practical catalyst resources remain open.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
21 pages, 1 figure

Related papers

Finite-size catalysis in quantum resource theories

Patryk Lipka-Bartosik, Kamil Korzekwa

Quantum catalysis, the ability to enable previously impossible transformations by using auxiliary systems without degrading them, has emerged as a powerful tool in various resource theories. Although catalytically enabled state transformations have been formally characterized by the monotonic behavior of entropic quantifiers (e.g., the von Neumann entropy or nonequilibrium free energy), such characterizations often rely on unphysical assumptions, namely, the ability of using catalysts of infinitely large dimension. This approach offers very limited insights into the practical significance of using catalysis for quantum information processing. Here, we address this problem across a broad class of quantum resource theories. Leveraging quantum information tools beyond the asymptotic regime, we establish sufficient conditions for the existence of catalytic transformations with finite-size catalysts. We further unveil connections between finite-size catalysis and multicopy transformations. Notably, we discover a phenomenon of catalytic resonance: by carefully tailoring the catalysts's state, one can drastically reduce the required dimension of the catalyst, thus enabling efficient catalytic transformations with minimal resources. Finally, we illustrate our findings with examples from the resource theories of entanglement and thermodynamics, as well in the context of catalytic unitary transformations.

arXiv:2405.08914•Physical Review A•Feb 24, 2025•1 citation

Advantage of flexible catalysis for entanglement and quantum thermodynamics

Jingsong Ao, Aby Philip, Alexander Streltsov

Understanding the fundamental limits of state convertibility is crucial for establishing the boundaries of quantum information processing and thermodynamic efficiency. While auxiliary systems, catalysts, can facilitate otherwise impossible transformations, standard catalysis rigidly requires the auxiliary system to return to its exact initial state. In this work, we investigate the power of flexible catalysis, where the catalyst evolves through a cycle of states, restoring its initial configuration only after a finite number of steps. Focusing on the regime of fixed, finite dimensions, we analyze the capabilities of flexible catalysis within the resource theories of entanglement and quantum thermodynamics. In the context of entanglement, we derive conditions limiting flexible catalysts, yet show that flexible catalysis can be strictly more powerful than same-dimensional standard catalysis: it enables deterministic transformations achievable by no standard catalyst of the same dimension, and it strictly increases the success probability of stochastic local operations and classical communication. A similar deterministic advantage arises in quantum thermodynamics, where flexible catalysis enables state transformations that are impossible with any standard catalyst of fixed dimension and Hamiltonian but become achievable via flexible catalysis.

quant-pharXiv:2603.05146•Physical Review A•Mar 6, 2026•0 citations

Catalytic and Asymptotic Equivalence for Quantum Entanglement

Ray Ganardi, Tulja Varun Kondra, Alexander Streltsov

Entanglement is a fundamental resource in quantum information processing, yet understanding its manipulation and transformation remains a challenge. Many tasks rely on highly entangled pure states, but obtaining such states is often challenging due to the presence of noise. Typically, entanglement manipulation procedures involving asymptotically many copies of a state are considered to overcome this problem. These procedures allow for distilling highly entangled pure states from noisy states, which enables a wide range of applications, such as quantum teleportation and quantum cryptography. When it comes to manipulating entangled quantum systems on a single copy level, using entangled states as catalysts can significantly broaden the range of achievable transformations. Similar to the concept of catalysis in chemistry, the entangled catalyst is returned unchanged at the end of the state manipulation procedure. Our results demonstrate that despite the apparent conceptual differences between the asymptotic and catalytic settings, they are actually strongly connected and fully equivalent for all distillable states. Our methods rely on the analysis of many-copy entanglement manipulation procedures which may establish correlations between different copies. As an important consequence, we demonstrate that using an entangled catalyst cannot enhance the asymptotic singlet distillation rate of a distillable quantum state. Our findings provide a comprehensive understanding of the capabilities and limitations of both catalytic and asymptotic state transformations of entangled states, and highlight the importance of correlations in these processes.

arXiv:2305.03488•Physical Review Letters•Dec 19, 2024•20 citations

Correlated Catalysis Removes the Strong Converse for Entanglement Distillation

Piotr Masajada, Aby Philip, Alexander Streltsov

Entanglement distillation converts noisy shared quantum states into maximally entangled pairs using local operations and classical communication. The distillable entanglement $E_D$ determines the maximum asymptotic rate at which this process can be performed reliably. For several classes of quantum states, distillation above this rate obeys a strong converse: the fidelity with the target state vanishes asymptotically. Here we show that correlated catalysis removes the strong converse for every distillable bipartite state. Specifically, at any target rate $R>E_D$, the optimal asymptotic fidelity is given by $E_D/R$. Thus, although catalysis does not increase the maximum reliable distillation rate, it allows nonvanishing fidelity at every finite rate. Remarkably, this advantage persists even when the catalyst is returned exactly at every finite blocklength and the correlations between the output and catalyst vanish asymptotically. We further characterize the catalyst size required to sustain nonvanishing fidelity above the reliable distillation rate.

quant-pharXiv:2611.03148•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Catalyst-rank limits for second-order entanglement concentration

Sam Vaseghi

Exact catalysts can improve the second-order yield of pure-state entanglement concentration, but the optimal yield does not specify how the catalyst must grow. We obtain a necessary rank condition for this improvement. Let the source have a fixed nonuniform finite squared Schmidt vector, with entropy $H$ and information variance $V$ defined using base-two logarithms, and fix a required squared fidelity $q\in(0,1)$. For pure outputs of $n$ source copies, with a pure catalyst returned exactly and uncorrelated, suppose that the target contains $nH+b\sqrt n+o(\sqrt n)$ Bell pairs. If the catalyst rank $K_n$ satisfies $\limsup \log_2K_n/\sqrt n\le c<\infty$, we give an explicit necessary fidelity bound strictly below $e^{-b^2/(2V)}$ for every $b>0$. Consequently, attaining the known unrestricted coefficient $\sqrt{2V\ln(1/q)}$ requires $\log_2K_n/\sqrt n\to\infty$. Catalysts with $\log_2K_n=o(\sqrt n)$ cannot improve the unassisted coefficient. The proof combines a fidelity concentration estimate, a Gaussian limit of the majorization inequalities, and a positive tail term retained by the rank constraint. The record contains a standalone PDF preprint and an accompanying source archive with the LaTeX manuscript, figure files, reproducible Python figure source and build instructions. No experimental dataset is used. The preprint has not undergone journal peer review. AI assistance is disclosed in the manuscript.

•Nov 9, 2026•0 citations

Catalytic advantage in asymptotic entanglement manipulation

Ray Ganardi

Entanglement is a key quantum resource in various quantum protocols, with a rich set of laws governing its manipulation. In this context, catalysis refers to the possibility of an auxiliary state that enables a previously forbidden manipulation, while being completely returned at the end. While the catalytic setting has been thoroughly examined in the single-copy regime, much less is known in the asymptotically many copy regime. In this work, we focus on the entanglement cost of preparing asymptotically many copies of a given state exactly. We show that catalysis can significantly lower the exact entanglement cost by constructing an explicit catalytic protocol. Additionally, these findings generalize readily to other resource theories, showing a general catalytic advantage in the resource dilution task.

quant-pharXiv:2605.04879•May 7, 2026•1 citation
Quantum entanglement is a fundamental resource in quantum information science, commonly consumed to perform tasks like quantum teleportation and quantum key distribution. Entanglement concentration converts partially entangled pure states into nearly perfect Bell pairs. While its efficiency is well understood in the asymptotic limit, practical protocols must operate with finite systems. In this finite regime, and at the low error levels relevant in practice, performance is penalized by corrections that reduce the achievable yield. We investigate whether this fundamental finite-size penalty can be mitigated by an entanglement catalyst: an auxiliary state that aids the transformation but is returned exactly and uncorrupted. Although such a catalyst cannot increase the leading-order asymptotic yield, we show that it fundamentally alters the finite-size scaling. For every bipartite pure state with nonuniform Schmidt coefficients, we exactly determine the optimal second-order correction to the yield and show that catalysis completely overcomes this finite-size penalty.
The paper asks whether exact entanglement catalysis can improve finite-block pure-state entanglement concentration despite leaving the leading asymptotic rate unchanged. It considers deterministic LOCC transformations assisted by a finite-dimensional pure catalyst returned exactly and uncorrelated with the output. The output must be a pure state within trace distance ε\varepsilonε of mmm Bell pairs; catalyst size is unrestricted.
For every nonuniform Schmidt spectrum ppp and fixed 0<ε<10<\varepsilon<10<ε<1, it determines the optimal yield as Mncat(ε)=nH(p)+bcat(ε)n+o(n)M_n^{\mathrm{cat}}(\varepsilon)=nH(p)+b_{\mathrm{cat}}(\varepsilon)\sqrt n+o(\sqrt n)Mncat​(ε)=nH(p)+bcat​(ε)n​+o(n​), where bcat(ε)=2V(p)ln⁡[1/(1−ε2)]b_{\mathrm{cat}}(\varepsilon)=\sqrt{2V(p)\ln[1/(1-\varepsilon^2)]}bcat​(ε)=2V(p)ln[1/(1−ε2)]​. Here HHH and the varentropy VVV use base-2 logarithms. Without catalysis, the coefficient is V(p) Φ−1(ε2)\sqrt{V(p)}\,\Phi^{-1}(\varepsilon^2)V(p)​Φ−1(ε2). Thus, for 0<ε<1/20<\varepsilon<1/\sqrt20<ε<1/2​, catalysis changes the second-order correction from negative to positive.
Achievability uses an output Schmidt spectrum with one component of weight ε2\varepsilon^2ε2 and a uniform remainder. Uniform control of its power sums over all positive Rényi orders, together with the Klimesh–Turgut characterization of catalytic majorization, establishes catalyst existence. The converse cancels the catalyst from Rényi power-sum inequalities and combines a fidelity bound with an expansion at orders 1−t/n1-t/\sqrt n1−t/n​.
The construction does not bound the catalyst’s Schmidt rank or entanglement. The result takes n→∞n\to\inftyn→∞ at fixed positive error, not the zero-error or vanishing-error limit. Quantifying the remainder, extending to mixed inputs or general targets, and addressing practical catalyst resources remain open.
Quantum catalysis, the ability to enable previously impossible transformations by using auxiliary systems without degrading them, has emerged as a powerful tool in various resource theories. Although catalytically enabled state transformations have been formally characterized by the monotonic behavior of entropic quantifiers (e.g., the von Neumann entropy or nonequilibrium free energy), such characterizations often rely on unphysical assumptions, namely, the ability of using catalysts of infinitely large dimension. This approach offers very limited insights into the practical significance of using catalysis for quantum information processing. Here, we address this problem across a broad class of quantum resource theories. Leveraging quantum information tools beyond the asymptotic regime, we establish sufficient conditions for the existence of catalytic transformations with finite-size catalysts. We further unveil connections between finite-size catalysis and multicopy transformations. Notably, we discover a phenomenon of catalytic resonance: by carefully tailoring the catalysts's state, one can drastically reduce the required dimension of the catalyst, thus enabling efficient catalytic transformations with minimal resources. Finally, we illustrate our findings with examples from the resource theories of entanglement and thermodynamics, as well in the context of catalytic unitary transformations.
Understanding the fundamental limits of state convertibility is crucial for establishing the boundaries of quantum information processing and thermodynamic efficiency. While auxiliary systems, catalysts, can facilitate otherwise impossible transformations, standard catalysis rigidly requires the auxiliary system to return to its exact initial state. In this work, we investigate the power of flexible catalysis, where the catalyst evolves through a cycle of states, restoring its initial configuration only after a finite number of steps. Focusing on the regime of fixed, finite dimensions, we analyze the capabilities of flexible catalysis within the resource theories of entanglement and quantum thermodynamics. In the context of entanglement, we derive conditions limiting flexible catalysts, yet show that flexible catalysis can be strictly more powerful than same-dimensional standard catalysis: it enables deterministic transformations achievable by no standard catalyst of the same dimension, and it strictly increases the success probability of stochastic local operations and classical communication. A similar deterministic advantage arises in quantum thermodynamics, where flexible catalysis enables state transformations that are impossible with any standard catalyst of fixed dimension and Hamiltonian but become achievable via flexible catalysis.
Entanglement is a fundamental resource in quantum information processing, yet understanding its manipulation and transformation remains a challenge. Many tasks rely on highly entangled pure states, but obtaining such states is often challenging due to the presence of noise. Typically, entanglement manipulation procedures involving asymptotically many copies of a state are considered to overcome this problem. These procedures allow for distilling highly entangled pure states from noisy states, which enables a wide range of applications, such as quantum teleportation and quantum cryptography. When it comes to manipulating entangled quantum systems on a single copy level, using entangled states as catalysts can significantly broaden the range of achievable transformations. Similar to the concept of catalysis in chemistry, the entangled catalyst is returned unchanged at the end of the state manipulation procedure. Our results demonstrate that despite the apparent conceptual differences between the asymptotic and catalytic settings, they are actually strongly connected and fully equivalent for all distillable states. Our methods rely on the analysis of many-copy entanglement manipulation procedures which may establish correlations between different copies. As an important consequence, we demonstrate that using an entangled catalyst cannot enhance the asymptotic singlet distillation rate of a distillable quantum state. Our findings provide a comprehensive understanding of the capabilities and limitations of both catalytic and asymptotic state transformations of entangled states, and highlight the importance of correlations in these processes.
Entanglement distillation converts noisy shared quantum states into maximally entangled pairs using local operations and classical communication. The distillable entanglement EDE_DED​ determines the maximum asymptotic rate at which this process can be performed reliably. For several classes of quantum states, distillation above this rate obeys a strong converse: the fidelity with the target state vanishes asymptotically. Here we show that correlated catalysis removes the strong converse for every distillable bipartite state. Specifically, at any target rate R>EDR>E_DR>ED​, the optimal asymptotic fidelity is given by ED/RE_D/RED​/R. Thus, although catalysis does not increase the maximum reliable distillation rate, it allows nonvanishing fidelity at every finite rate. Remarkably, this advantage persists even when the catalyst is returned exactly at every finite blocklength and the correlations between the output and catalyst vanish asymptotically. We further characterize the catalyst size required to sustain nonvanishing fidelity above the reliable distillation rate.
Exact catalysts can improve the second-order yield of pure-state entanglement concentration, but the optimal yield does not specify how the catalyst must grow. We obtain a necessary rank condition for this improvement. Let the source have a fixed nonuniform finite squared Schmidt vector, with entropy HHH and information variance VVV defined using base-two logarithms, and fix a required squared fidelity q∈(0,1)q\in(0,1)q∈(0,1). For pure outputs of nnn source copies, with a pure catalyst returned exactly and uncorrelated, suppose that the target contains nH+bn+o(n)nH+b\sqrt n+o(\sqrt n)nH+bn​+o(n​) Bell pairs. If the catalyst rank KnK_nKn​ satisfies lim sup⁡log⁡2Kn/n≤c<∞\limsup \log_2K_n/\sqrt n\le c<\inftylimsuplog2​Kn​/n​≤c<∞, we give an explicit necessary fidelity bound strictly below e−b2/(2V)e^{-b^2/(2V)}e−b2/(2V) for every b>0b>0b>0. Consequently, attaining the known unrestricted coefficient 2Vln⁡(1/q)\sqrt{2V\ln(1/q)}2Vln(1/q)​ requires log⁡2Kn/n→∞\log_2K_n/\sqrt n\to\inftylog2​Kn​/n​→∞. Catalysts with log⁡2Kn=o(n)\log_2K_n=o(\sqrt n)log2​Kn​=o(n​) cannot improve the unassisted coefficient. The proof combines a fidelity concentration estimate, a Gaussian limit of the majorization inequalities, and a positive tail term retained by the rank constraint. The record contains a standalone PDF preprint and an accompanying source archive with the LaTeX manuscript, figure files, reproducible Python figure source and build instructions. No experimental dataset is used. The preprint has not undergone journal peer review. AI assistance is disclosed in the manuscript.
Entanglement is a key quantum resource in various quantum protocols, with a rich set of laws governing its manipulation. In this context, catalysis refers to the possibility of an auxiliary state that enables a previously forbidden manipulation, while being completely returned at the end. While the catalytic setting has been thoroughly examined in the single-copy regime, much less is known in the asymptotically many copy regime. In this work, we focus on the entanglement cost of preparing asymptotically many copies of a given state exactly. We show that catalysis can significantly lower the exact entanglement cost by constructing an explicit catalytic protocol. Additionally, these findings generalize readily to other resource theories, showing a general catalytic advantage in the resource dilution task.