arXiv:2610.13250
Zak Phase Quantization without Global Symmetry through Destructive Interference
Geonwoo Hwang, Jun-Won Rhim
Abstract
The Zak phase provides a fundamental geometric characterization of one-dimensional band structures and, when quantized by symmetry, serves as a bulk indicator of polarization and boundary phenomena. Conventionally, its exact quantization is tied to a global symmetry of the Bloch Hamiltonian, such as inversion or reflection symmetry. Here, we demonstrate a distinct mechanism by which the Zak phase remains exactly quantized even when the corresponding protecting symmetry is explicitly broken at the level of the full Hamiltonian. The mechanism is based on local support symmetry and destructive interference: symmetry-breaking degrees of freedom are coupled to a topological parent system in such a way that the relevant Bloch states cannot leak into them. The preserved states therefore retain their parent wave functions and inherit their quantized Zak phase exactly, despite the absence of the protecting global symmetry. We establish this mechanism for general one-dimensional insulators and demonstrate it in an inversion-broken minimal model and a reflection-broken armchair nanoribbon, where a quantized $π$ Zak phase and associated boundary-localized states persist. We further show that perturbations violating the exact destructive-interference condition continuously dequantize the Zak phase, while a finite regime with a near-$π$ Zak phase and boundary response can survive. Our results establish wave-function support, rather than global symmetry alone, as a mechanism for protecting quantized quantum geometry in one-dimensional systems.
AI Summary
Can a one-dimensional band retain an exactly quantized Zak phase after the corresponding protecting crystalline symmetry is broken in the full Hamiltonian? This paper studies a construction in which symmetry-breaking auxiliary orbitals couple to a symmetric parent insulator without altering selected parent eigenstates. For a block Hamiltonian with parent–auxiliary coupling $W(k)$, the central condition is $W^\dagger(k)|u_n(k)\rangle=0$ throughout the Brillouin zone. Destructive interference then makes $(|u_n(k)\rangle,0)^T$ an exact eigenstate with unchanged energy and Berry connection. The argument extends to occupied subspaces and Wilson loops, provided spectral isolation is maintained. Finite-range implementations are demonstrated in an inversion-broken three-band model and a reflection-broken seven-site armchair-nanoribbon model, with boundary-localized states shown in open-chain calculations. The minimal model permits a dispersive complementary parent band and has no proper momentum-independent invariant block containing the protected band. The armchair example instead admits an explicit decomposition into a reflection-symmetric four-dimensional block and a complementary three-dimensional block, giving a hidden-symmetry interpretation. Exact quantization requires the annihilation condition; generic leakage perturbations continuously shift the Zak phase without closing the direct gap. In one armchair example, a leakage hopping $t_1=0.2t$ gives $|\gamma_{\mathrm{occ}}|/\pi\approx0.981$. Along $t_2=0$, this ratio exceeds $0.98$ for $|t_1|/t<0.20231$. Such thresholds are model-dependent numerical diagnostics, not universal protection bounds. Auxiliary-band crossings can also invalidate the occupied-band interpretation even when the protected eigenstates remain exact.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 6 figures