arXiv:2610.13033
When irrelevance governs: dissipation-regression scaling in open quantum criticality
Fan Zhong
Abstract
The real-time dynamics of quantum phase transitions in open systems coupled to finite-temperature environments sits at the heart of contemporary condensed-matter and quantum-information science. Here, invoking a Schwinger-Keldysh formalism, we uncover that, within the coherence-dominated regime of critical real-time evolution, a dissipative coupling deemed naively irrelevant determines, counterintuitively, the longest timescale that holds sway. Possessing a well-defined temporal scaling dimension, it engenders a novel dissipation-regression scaling that systematically reproduces the unusual Kibble-Zurek scaling and relaxation observed in recent numerical studies. By contrast, dissipation-dominated dynamics behaves qualitatively differently. There, furthermore, we show that the discretized and diagonalized formulations of the same open quantum Ising chain realize distinct universality classes.
AI Summary
This paper addresses bath-dependent relaxation and Kibble–Zurek scaling in open quantum critical systems coupled to environments with spectral density $J(\omega)\propto\omega^s$. It proposes dissipation-regression scaling (DRS): in a coherence-dominated regime, a coupling that is irrelevant under equilibrium power counting nevertheless controls late-time relaxation, producing an effective temporal exponent $sz$ while retaining the underlying coherent critical exponents. The construction uses a Schwinger–Keldysh action for a scalar $\phi^4$ theory coupled to bosonic baths. At mean-field level, the competition between $\omega^2$ and dissipative $\omega^s$ terms places the coherent–dissipative boundary at $s=2$, with dissipative exponent $z=2/s$. A diagonal quasiparticle formulation instead gives a boundary at $s=1$. The paper interprets this difference as distinct dynamic universality classes for the corresponding open-system constructions. DRS predicts critical excitation-density decay $\mathfrak D\sim(\lambda t)^{-d/(sz)}$. For ramps $g=Rt^n$ and $T=\pm R_Tt^m$, it predicts rate exponents $\sigma_g=d\nu/(1+nsz\nu)$ and $\sigma_T=d/[z(1+ms)]$. These expressions are compared with previously published numerical and rate-equation results for Ising and Kitaev models, and with measurement-induced dephasing results; no new simulations are presented. The analysis is primarily mean-field and scaling-based. A full fluctuation RG calculation is deferred; corrections to the dissipative exponent and crossover boundary are expected. The dissipative regime of diagonalized models below $s=1$ remains unverified. The algebraic relaxation formula excludes $s=0$, where exponential decay is discussed, and initial-state memory is assumed negligible.
Central claim may not hold: The displayed quadratic-frequency bosonic propagator gives a quasiparticle lifetime proportional to λ⁻¹k^(1−s), not λ⁻¹k^(−s), invalidating the derivation of the proposed DRS exponent for that theory. The cited diagonalized-model agreements support a first-order-frequency dynamical setting but do not validate the claimed lifetime scaling of the distinct quadratic-frequency bosonic theory. The extension of DRS to interacting critical fluctuations is asserted without the RG calculation needed to establish it, which the paper defers. The asserted representation-dependent universality distinction is not established for a preserved system–bath model because the jump operators and their correspondence to the field-theoretic coupling are unspecified. The scaling-function arguments in Eqs. (sgrr) and (sgTr) contain incorrect powers of λ when derived from their preceding homogeneous scaling equations.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 10 pages, no figure. Substantially extended from 2607.11206v1