arXiv:2610.13016
Distinguishing Flat and Warped Extra Dimensions with Unruh-DeWitt Detectors
Ashmita Das, Anjana Krishnan, Soumitra Sengupta
Abstract
We examine the response of a two level Unruh-DeWitt (UD) detector interacting with the Kaluza-Klein (KK) mass modes of a bulk scalar field in extra dimensional models. Considering two of the promising extra dimensional models with distinct compactifications, such as large, flat extra dimensions in the Arkani Hamed, Dimopoulos \& Dvali (ADD) framework and warped extra dimensions in the Randall-Sundrum (RS) scenario, we compute the profile function of the detector. We extend this computation to the 6 dimensional doubly compactified spacetime geometry. The profile function of the detector has been examined as a function of the energy gap of the detector, the compactification radius of the extra dimension, and the dimensionality of spacetime, requiring the chosen parameter space appropriately such that the gauge hierarchy problem is duly addressed. We find that the pattern of the profile function is dictated by the spacing of the KK mass spectrum and the resolution of the detector. For ADD model, the spacing between successive KK modes decreases with the increasing compactification radius, yielding a smoothly increasing continuum pattern in the profile function. Whereas for the RS warped geometry model, a tiny deviation in the radius of the extra dimension produces a large change in the same, resulting a sharp increment. The resolvability of the KK mode structure is sensitive to the underlying geometry of the spacetime, providing a qualitative distinction between flat and warped extra dimensional scenarios within the UD detector framework.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether a two-level Unruh–DeWitt detector coupled to a bulk scalar field can distinguish flat ADD-type compactifications from warped Randall–Sundrum geometries. It derives detector profile functions for five-dimensional models and their six-dimensional extensions, then evaluates their dependence on detector energy gap, compactification radii and dimensionality. The calculation reduces the response to a sum over four-dimensional Kaluza–Klein modes, using $\mathcal F(E)=\sum_j\sqrt{E^2-m_j^2}\,\Theta(E-m_j)$ and a common Unruh thermal factor. Flat compactification gives $m_n=n/R$, while the five-dimensional warped model gives $m_n=x_n k e^{-\pi kR_y}$, with $x_n$ determined by a Bessel-function boundary condition. Numerical scans show threshold kinks as additional modes become accessible. Closely spaced flat-spectrum thresholds appear smooth over broad energy ranges; the illustrated warped spectrum retains resolved thresholds, with asymptotic spacing approximately $6.4\,\mathrm{TeV}$ for $k=10^{16}\,\mathrm{TeV}$ and $kR_y=11.5$. Radius scans show gradual growth for flat compactification and sharper growth from the exponential warped mass dependence. Additional compact dimensions increase the accessible mode density. The massive-field response approximation is stated to apply asymptotically for $E\gg m$, rather than being exact near thresholds. Resolving individual modes depends on the sampled energy range and detector resolution. The one-extra-dimension ADD example is observationally excluded and used illustratively; flat-model plots also use radii that do not solve the hierarchy problem. Apparent saturation in some radius scans is attributed to truncating the KK sum at roughly $10^3$–$10^4$ modes.
Central claim may not hold: The hard KK thresholds used to produce the principal detector signatures come from a massive-field approximation applied at E=m_n, outside its stated E much greater than m_n regime, while the exact accelerated response is nonzero below those thresholds. The smooth-ADD versus discrete-RS distinction is parameter- and resolution-dependent because both one-dimensional spectra have asymptotically constant spacing, and the paper supplies no operational scale-independent discrimination test. The abstract's hierarchy-compatible characterization does not cover the plotted ADD parameters, which the manuscript itself acknowledges depart from the assumed hierarchy-solving values. The RS mass table gives 10^4 TeV where its formula yields approximately 1.31×10^-4 TeV, and the six-dimensional warped derivation independently contains overconstraining boundary conditions and incorrect warp-factor weights in its mode equation. The unit-weight KK response is not derived from a local detector–bulk-field coupling, which would include mode-wavefunction weights and compactification normalization.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 18 pages, 9 figures, 5 tables