Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.12557

Frustrated Topological Orbital Magnetism

Sergio Garrido Bourkhaeva, Claudio Castelnovo, Wojciech J. Jankowski

cond-mat.mes-hallquant-phSubmitted Oct 8, 2026• Announced Oct 12, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

By studying the interplay of geometric frustration with Aharonov-Bohm fluxes in three dimensions, we unveil a rich playground exhibiting topological semimetallic ground states with orbital magnetic dipole, quadrupole and ferrotoroidic orders, akin to spin patterns in classical spin ices - a class of phenomena which we dub frustrated topological orbital magnetism. We demonstrate that the ground-state toroidizations underpinned by non-Abelian topological nodal lines induce measurable current-induced Hall phenomena. We further find that distinct 2-in-2-out and 3-in-1-out frustrated orbital current patterns can be associated with topological Weyl node charges, and corresponding anisotropic linear and nonlinear Hall effects. We propose signatures for experimental validation of distinct frustrated topological orbital magnetic orders in candidate materials.

AI Summary

The paper asks how imposed orbital-current patterns on a pyrochlore lattice combine geometric frustration with band topology, and whether transport can distinguish configurations analogous to spin-ice orders. It studies spinless, four-band tight-binding models with nearest-neighbor hopping and complex next-nearest-neighbor hopping within kagome planes. Calculations use $t_1=-1$ and $t_2=0.15$, varying the flux phase and chemical potential. Two flux patterns produce distinct responses. Antichiral patterns preserve $\mathcal{PT}$ while breaking inversion and time reversal separately; they support topological nodal-line networks, triple band crossings, and orbital toroidization with zero net magnetization. A projector formulation of the orbital magnetic quadrupole, numerical momentum-resolved calculations, and a local analysis near nodal lines connect toroidization to interband geometry. Chiral patterns preserve inversion but break time reversal, producing orbital magnetization, Weyl nodes, Fermi arcs, and, at suitable fillings, layered Chern-insulator phases with $C=1$. For both classes, 2-in-2-out configurations select $\langle100\rangle$ directions, whereas 3-in-1-out configurations select $\langle111\rangle$ directions. Proposed signatures are anisotropic anomalous Hall responses and a toroidization-associated current-induced transverse voltage quadratic in the applied current. Inversion-breaking perturbations additionally generate Berry-curvature-dipole nonlinear Hall responses. The flux configurations are fixed backgrounds: interactions selecting or dynamically coupling orbital currents, spin-ice degeneracy, and fractionalization are not established. The study treats translationally invariant systems; disorder, interactions, and realistic scattering require further investigation. Suggested pyrochlore iridate and ruthenate realizations remain speculative.

Little sign of AI-generated textOverclaimsStrong assumptionsPossible error

Error found: The paper demonstrates electronic ground states under prescribed ice-like flux patterns, but does not establish energetic selection, degeneracy, or dynamics of frustrated orbital-current order. Both displayed toroidization expressions omit the overall factor 1/2 required by the paper’s stated relation T_k = (1/2)ε_ijk Q_ij. The Discussion’s square-root Hall-current scaling does not follow from the earlier quadratic transverse-voltage relation, so its proposed scaling-based distinction from other nonlinear Hall responses is unsupported. The nodal-line appendix’s −i times three Berry connections is imaginary in the paper’s explicitly defined real-gauge convention, contradicting its interpretation as a real quadrupole contribution.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
13 pages, 8 figures

Related papers

Theory of Topological Phenomena in Condensed Matter Systems

Yi Zhang

Topological phenomena in physical systems are determined by topological structures and are thus universal and protected against perturbations. We theoretically establish exotic topological phenomena and their consequences for experiments in crystalline systems such as topological insulators and topologically ordered phases. We show that protected one-dimensional fermionic modes may be associated with the line defects such as dislocations in three-dimensional topological insulators, and strong electron-electron repulsion may lead to topological Mott insulators via spontaneous spin-orbit correlations in three dimensions. We also predict anomalous Aharonov Bohm conductance oscillations maximized at half integer multiples of a flux quantum in a topological insulator nanowire with strong surface disorder, arising from surface curvature induced Berry phase. In addition, we classify three-dimensional inversion symmetric insulators and their quantized responses.Quantum entanglement provides a promising probe to the properties of many-body systems, especially topological phases not captured by local order parameters. We present a characterization of topological insulators using entanglement spectrum based only on bulk ground-state wave function. Further, by studying entanglement of trivial partitions, we establish topological order in candidate Gutzwiller projected wave functions for gapped spin liquids and Laughlin states; and with entanglement's dependence on the ground states for bipartition of a torus into two cylinders, we demonstrate a method to extract the modular matrices and statistics and braiding of quasiparticle excitations. Our method helps to determine the topological order with only the set of ground-state wave functions on a torus. Our variational Monte Carlo calculations of topological entanglement entropy agree well with theory. We also find a violation of the boundary law for a critical spin liquid of Gutzwiller projected Fermi sea on the triangular lattice, where the entanglement entropy's enhancement by a logarithmic factor reflects the presence of emergent fermions in a bosonic wave function.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Topological quantum criticality in spin-orbit coupled fermions

Sumanta Tewari

Spin-orbit coupled fermions offer a fascinating playground for realizing interesting topological quantum phases and the associated quantum critical phenomena. In two dimensions and in the presence of an attractive s-wave pairing interaction and a Zeeman field, spin-orbit coupled fermions can condense into a fully gapped non-Abelian topological superfluid phase separated from a conventional s-wave superfluid phase by a topological quantum phase transition. The critical point for this transition is marked by the proliferation of gapless nodal quasiparticles which can be tracked by studying the momentumresolved excitation spectrum from the center of the Brillouin zone. In three dimensions the same system goes through a series of topological quantum transitions with increasing Zeeman field and the low energy excitations in some of these phases realize the long-sought low-temperature analog of Weyl fermions of particle physics. In this talk I will describe in some detail the interesting topological phases and the associated quantum criticality that can be realized using spin-orbit coupled fermions in cold atom systems.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Jun 5, 2012•0 citations

Topological orders of monopoles and hedgehogs: From electronic and magnetic spin-orbit coupling to quarks

Predrag Nikolić

Topological states of matter are, generally, quantum liquids of conserved topological defects. We establish this by constructing and analyzing topological field theories which introduce gauge fields to describe the dynamics of singularities in the original field configurations. Homotopy groups are utilized to identify topologically protected singularities, and the conservation of their protected number is captured by a topological action term that unambiguously obtains from the given set of symmetries. Stable phases of these theories include quantum liquids with emergent massless Abelian and non-Abelian gauge fields, as well as topological orders with long-range quantum entanglement, fractional excitations, boundary modes, and unconventional responses to external perturbations. This paper focuses on the derivation of topological field theories and basic phenomenological characterization of topological orders associated with homotopy groups ${\ensuremath{\pi}}_{n}({S}^{n}), n\ensuremath{\ge}1$. These homotopies govern monopole and hedgehog topological defects in $d=n+1$ dimensions, and enable the generalization of both weakly interacting and fractional quantum Hall liquids of vortices to $d>2$. Hedgehogs have not been in the spotlight so far, but they are particularly important defects of magnetic moments because they can be stimulated in realistic systems with spin-orbit coupling, such as chiral magnets and $d=3$ topological materials. We predict topological orders in systems with $\mathrm{U}(1)\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathrm{Spin}(d)$ symmetry in which fractional electric charge attaches to hedgehogs. Monopoles, the analogous defects of charge or generic U(1) currents, may bind to hedgehogs via Zeeman effect, or effectively emerge in purely magnetic systems. The latter can lead to spin liquids with different topological orders than that of the resonant valence bond spin liquid. Charge fractionalization of quarks in atomic nuclei is also seen as possibly arising from the charge-hedgehog attachment.

arXiv:1907.03779•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 30, 2020•11 citations

Anisotropic quantum quench in the presence of frustration or background gauge fields: A probe of bulk currents and topological chiral edge modes

Matthew Killi, Stefan Trotzky, Arun Paramekanti

Bosons and fermions, in the presence of frustration or background gauge fields, can form many-body ground states that support equilibrium charge or spin currents. Motivated by the experimental creation of frustration or synthetic gauge fields in ultracold atomic systems, we propose a general scheme by which making a sudden anisotropic quench of the atom tunneling across the lattice and tracking the ensuing density modulations provides a powerful and gauge-invariant route to probing diverse equilibrium current patterns. Using illustrative examples of trapped superfluid Bose and normal Fermi systems in the presence of artificial magnetic fluxes on square lattices, and frustrated bosons in a triangular lattice, we show that this scheme to probe equilibrium bulk current order works independent of particle statistics. We also show that such quenches can detect chiral edge modes in gapped topological states, such as quantum Hall or quantum spin Hall insulators.

arXiv:1210.4554•Physical Review A•Dec 26, 2012•34 citations

Topological order in interacting semimetals

Jinmin Yi, Xuzhe Ying, Lei Gioia +1 more

It has recently been demonstrated that it is possible to open a gap in a magnetic Weyl semimetal, while preserving the chiral anomaly along with the charge conservation and translational symmetries, which all protect the gapless nodes in a weakly interacting semimetal. The resulting state was shown to be a nontrivial generalization of a non-Abelian fractional quantum Hall liquid to three dimensions. Here we point out that a second fractional quantum Hall state exists in this case. This state has exactly the same electrical and thermal Hall responses as the first, but a distinct (fracton) topological order. Moreover, the existence of this second fractional quantum Hall state necessarily implies a gapless phase, which has identical topological response to a noninteracting Weyl semimetal, but is distinct from it. This may be viewed as a generalization (in a weaker form) of the known duality between a noninteracting two-dimensional Dirac fermion and ${\mathrm{QED}}_{3}$ to $3+1$ dimensions. In addition we discuss a $(3+1)$-dimensional topologically ordered state, obtained by gapping a nodal line semimetal without breaking symmetries.

arXiv:2301.03628•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 24, 2023•10 citations

Topological phases in narrow-band systems

Evelyn Tang

I discuss several novel topological phases in correlated electron systems, realized through spin-orbit interactions and lattice effects especially narrow-band systems. The first realizes the fractional quantum Hall effect using geometric frustration and ferromagnetism to obtain a nearly flat band with a large bandgap and non-zero Chern number. This system can support this effect at high temperatures upon partial filling of the flat band. The second proposal builds upon this system: as the ground state is a fractional quantum Hall state, excitations of this state are anyons when there is an incommensurate filling. The underlying lattice allows access to a new regime in which the anyon gas can form a charged superfluid, including states with intrinsic topological order or that similar to a BCS-type state. The third proposal studies topological crystalline insulators and strain as an effective gauge field on the surface state Dirac fermions. The zero-energy Landau orbitals form a flat band where the high density of states gives rise to the interface superconductivity observed in IV-VI semiconductor multilayers at high temperatures, with non-BCS behavior. A discussion of superconductivity in flat band systems concludes and is contrasted with classic results for a typical electron gas. This work closely parallels that in references [1, 2, 3].

•Jan 1, 2015•1 citation
By studying the interplay of geometric frustration with Aharonov-Bohm fluxes in three dimensions, we unveil a rich playground exhibiting topological semimetallic ground states with orbital magnetic dipole, quadrupole and ferrotoroidic orders, akin to spin patterns in classical spin ices - a class of phenomena which we dub frustrated topological orbital magnetism. We demonstrate that the ground-state toroidizations underpinned by non-Abelian topological nodal lines induce measurable current-induced Hall phenomena. We further find that distinct 2-in-2-out and 3-in-1-out frustrated orbital current patterns can be associated with topological Weyl node charges, and corresponding anisotropic linear and nonlinear Hall effects. We propose signatures for experimental validation of distinct frustrated topological orbital magnetic orders in candidate materials.
The paper asks how imposed orbital-current patterns on a pyrochlore lattice combine geometric frustration with band topology, and whether transport can distinguish configurations analogous to spin-ice orders. It studies spinless, four-band tight-binding models with nearest-neighbor hopping and complex next-nearest-neighbor hopping within kagome planes. Calculations use t1=−1t_1=-1t1​=−1 and t2=0.15t_2=0.15t2​=0.15, varying the flux phase and chemical potential.
Two flux patterns produce distinct responses. Antichiral patterns preserve PT\mathcal{PT}PT while breaking inversion and time reversal separately; they support topological nodal-line networks, triple band crossings, and orbital toroidization with zero net magnetization. A projector formulation of the orbital magnetic quadrupole, numerical momentum-resolved calculations, and a local analysis near nodal lines connect toroidization to interband geometry. Chiral patterns preserve inversion but break time reversal, producing orbital magnetization, Weyl nodes, Fermi arcs, and, at suitable fillings, layered Chern-insulator phases with C=1C=1C=1. For both classes, 2-in-2-out configurations select ⟨100⟩\langle100\rangle⟨100⟩ directions, whereas 3-in-1-out configurations select ⟨111⟩\langle111\rangle⟨111⟩ directions. Proposed signatures are anisotropic anomalous Hall responses and a toroidization-associated current-induced transverse voltage quadratic in the applied current. Inversion-breaking perturbations additionally generate Berry-curvature-dipole nonlinear Hall responses.
The flux configurations are fixed backgrounds: interactions selecting or dynamically coupling orbital currents, spin-ice degeneracy, and fractionalization are not established. The study treats translationally invariant systems; disorder, interactions, and realistic scattering require further investigation. Suggested pyrochlore iridate and ruthenate realizations remain speculative.
Topological phenomena in physical systems are determined by topological structures and are thus universal and protected against perturbations. We theoretically establish exotic topological phenomena and their consequences for experiments in crystalline systems such as topological insulators and topologically ordered phases. We show that protected one-dimensional fermionic modes may be associated with the line defects such as dislocations in three-dimensional topological insulators, and strong electron-electron repulsion may lead to topological Mott insulators via spontaneous spin-orbit correlations in three dimensions. We also predict anomalous Aharonov Bohm conductance oscillations maximized at half integer multiples of a flux quantum in a topological insulator nanowire with strong surface disorder, arising from surface curvature induced Berry phase. In addition, we classify three-dimensional inversion symmetric insulators and their quantized responses.Quantum entanglement provides a promising probe to the properties of many-body systems, especially topological phases not captured by local order parameters. We present a characterization of topological insulators using entanglement spectrum based only on bulk ground-state wave function. Further, by studying entanglement of trivial partitions, we establish topological order in candidate Gutzwiller projected wave functions for gapped spin liquids and Laughlin states; and with entanglement's dependence on the ground states for bipartition of a torus into two cylinders, we demonstrate a method to extract the modular matrices and statistics and braiding of quasiparticle excitations. Our method helps to determine the topological order with only the set of ground-state wave functions on a torus. Our variational Monte Carlo calculations of topological entanglement entropy agree well with theory. We also find a violation of the boundary law for a critical spin liquid of Gutzwiller projected Fermi sea on the triangular lattice, where the entanglement entropy's enhancement by a logarithmic factor reflects the presence of emergent fermions in a bosonic wave function.
Spin-orbit coupled fermions offer a fascinating playground for realizing interesting topological quantum phases and the associated quantum critical phenomena. In two dimensions and in the presence of an attractive s-wave pairing interaction and a Zeeman field, spin-orbit coupled fermions can condense into a fully gapped non-Abelian topological superfluid phase separated from a conventional s-wave superfluid phase by a topological quantum phase transition. The critical point for this transition is marked by the proliferation of gapless nodal quasiparticles which can be tracked by studying the momentumresolved excitation spectrum from the center of the Brillouin zone. In three dimensions the same system goes through a series of topological quantum transitions with increasing Zeeman field and the low energy excitations in some of these phases realize the long-sought low-temperature analog of Weyl fermions of particle physics. In this talk I will describe in some detail the interesting topological phases and the associated quantum criticality that can be realized using spin-orbit coupled fermions in cold atom systems.
Topological states of matter are, generally, quantum liquids of conserved topological defects. We establish this by constructing and analyzing topological field theories which introduce gauge fields to describe the dynamics of singularities in the original field configurations. Homotopy groups are utilized to identify topologically protected singularities, and the conservation of their protected number is captured by a topological action term that unambiguously obtains from the given set of symmetries. Stable phases of these theories include quantum liquids with emergent massless Abelian and non-Abelian gauge fields, as well as topological orders with long-range quantum entanglement, fractional excitations, boundary modes, and unconventional responses to external perturbations. This paper focuses on the derivation of topological field theories and basic phenomenological characterization of topological orders associated with homotopy groups ${\ensuremath{\pi}}_{n}({S}^{n}), n\ensuremath{\ge}1$. These homotopies govern monopole and hedgehog topological defects in d=n+1d=n+1d=n+1 dimensions, and enable the generalization of both weakly interacting and fractional quantum Hall liquids of vortices to d>2d>2d>2. Hedgehogs have not been in the spotlight so far, but they are particularly important defects of magnetic moments because they can be stimulated in realistic systems with spin-orbit coupling, such as chiral magnets and d=3d=3d=3 topological materials. We predict topological orders in systems with $\mathrm{U}(1)\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathrm{Spin}(d)$ symmetry in which fractional electric charge attaches to hedgehogs. Monopoles, the analogous defects of charge or generic U(1) currents, may bind to hedgehogs via Zeeman effect, or effectively emerge in purely magnetic systems. The latter can lead to spin liquids with different topological orders than that of the resonant valence bond spin liquid. Charge fractionalization of quarks in atomic nuclei is also seen as possibly arising from the charge-hedgehog attachment.
Bosons and fermions, in the presence of frustration or background gauge fields, can form many-body ground states that support equilibrium charge or spin currents. Motivated by the experimental creation of frustration or synthetic gauge fields in ultracold atomic systems, we propose a general scheme by which making a sudden anisotropic quench of the atom tunneling across the lattice and tracking the ensuing density modulations provides a powerful and gauge-invariant route to probing diverse equilibrium current patterns. Using illustrative examples of trapped superfluid Bose and normal Fermi systems in the presence of artificial magnetic fluxes on square lattices, and frustrated bosons in a triangular lattice, we show that this scheme to probe equilibrium bulk current order works independent of particle statistics. We also show that such quenches can detect chiral edge modes in gapped topological states, such as quantum Hall or quantum spin Hall insulators.
It has recently been demonstrated that it is possible to open a gap in a magnetic Weyl semimetal, while preserving the chiral anomaly along with the charge conservation and translational symmetries, which all protect the gapless nodes in a weakly interacting semimetal. The resulting state was shown to be a nontrivial generalization of a non-Abelian fractional quantum Hall liquid to three dimensions. Here we point out that a second fractional quantum Hall state exists in this case. This state has exactly the same electrical and thermal Hall responses as the first, but a distinct (fracton) topological order. Moreover, the existence of this second fractional quantum Hall state necessarily implies a gapless phase, which has identical topological response to a noninteracting Weyl semimetal, but is distinct from it. This may be viewed as a generalization (in a weaker form) of the known duality between a noninteracting two-dimensional Dirac fermion and QED3{\mathrm{QED}}_{3}QED3​ to 3+13+13+1 dimensions. In addition we discuss a (3+1)(3+1)(3+1)-dimensional topologically ordered state, obtained by gapping a nodal line semimetal without breaking symmetries.
I discuss several novel topological phases in correlated electron systems, realized through spin-orbit interactions and lattice effects especially narrow-band systems. The first realizes the fractional quantum Hall effect using geometric frustration and ferromagnetism to obtain a nearly flat band with a large bandgap and non-zero Chern number. This system can support this effect at high temperatures upon partial filling of the flat band. The second proposal builds upon this system: as the ground state is a fractional quantum Hall state, excitations of this state are anyons when there is an incommensurate filling. The underlying lattice allows access to a new regime in which the anyon gas can form a charged superfluid, including states with intrinsic topological order or that similar to a BCS-type state. The third proposal studies topological crystalline insulators and strain as an effective gauge field on the surface state Dirac fermions. The zero-energy Landau orbitals form a flat band where the high density of states gives rise to the interface superconductivity observed in IV-VI semiconductor multilayers at high temperatures, with non-BCS behavior. A discussion of superconductivity in flat band systems concludes and is contrasted with classic results for a typical electron gas. This work closely parallels that in references [1, 2, 3].