Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.12556

TLS loss in superconducting resonators on epitaxial hBN thin films

J. Christiansen-Salameh, D. J. Temples, R. Linehan, S. Sussman, Aloyse Maille, F. Abouzahr, L. Alexis, K. Anyang, D. Bowring, G. Bratrud, E. Celi, A. H. Colón Cesaní, R. Khatiwada, D. Molenaar, O. Peek, A. Rodriguez, O. Seidel, D. Schlom, D. Sotir, S. Uemura, Y. Wu, E. Figueroa-Feliciano, D. Baxter, Z. Tian

quant-phhep-exSubmitted Oct 8, 2026• Announced Oct 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The integration of low-loss dielectrics into superconducting circuits is of importance to the functionality of quantum computers and sensors. In this work, we fabricate and measure niobium resonators atop few-layer, epitaxial hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) grown by Molecular Beam Epitaxy on a sapphire substrate and compare against a control counterpart without hBN. We conduct radiofrequency measurements which probe the responses to power, temperature, and temporal fluctuations of two-level systems. The resonators integrating hBN maintain low dielectric loss with a low-power internal loss tangent on the order of $10^{-6}$, and demonstrate hBN can be added to the conventional superconducting qubit stack with minimal degradation of the quality factor. This research represents a first step towards a materials-driven strategy to eliminate phonon-mediated correlated errors in solid-state quantum systems, which leverages the thermal properties of 2D materials to prevent athermal phonons excited in the device substrate from transmitting across the superconductor-substrate interface. The same technique applied to quantum sensors would maximize phonon collection by blocking phonons from entering passive metal films.

AI Summary

The paper tests whether epitaxial, few-layer hBN can be inserted between a superconducting film and its substrate without excessive microwave dielectric loss. The motivation is to use hBN’s anisotropic thermal transport to suppress substrate-phonon-induced quasiparticle bursts, or redirect phonons in quantum sensors; phonon blocking itself is not measured. Eight Nb coplanar-waveguide resonators on approximately $3\,\mathrm{nm}$ of molecular-beam-epitaxy-grown hBN on sapphire are compared with eight on bare sapphire. Power-dependent spectroscopy gives median low-power internal losses of $4.50\times10^{-6}$ with hBN and $1.65\times10^{-6}$ without it. Fits to TLS-induced temperature-dependent frequency shifts below $300\,\mathrm{mK}$ give median effective zero-temperature TLS losses $F\delta^0_{\mathrm{TLS}}$ of $5.54\times10^{-6}$ and $3.43\times10^{-6}$, respectively, a factor of approximately $1.6$ increase. Noise measurements show stronger TLS fluctuations with hBN: the mean extracted TLS frequency-noise component at $1\,\mathrm{kHz}$ and approximately $10^4$ resonator photons is $4.65\times10^{-18}$ versus $8.16\times10^{-19}$. Most hBN resonators also exhibit pronounced frequency switching over several hours. The reported losses characterize the complete resonator stack, not intrinsic hBN. Finite-element estimates cannot cleanly separate hBN from interfacial losses. Reliable spectroscopy was unavailable at mean photon numbers $\leq1$, and the low-power TLS saturation plateau was not reached. An unexplained high-temperature frequency downturn restricts the temperature fitting range. Lorentzian-based models support a TLS interpretation of slow switching but do not fit all observed features well.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalOverclaims

Central claim may not hold: The abstract's description of minimal quality-factor degradation is inconsistent with the reported 2.73-fold increase in median low-power internal loss, corresponding to an approximately 63% reduction in representative internal quality factor. The reported low-power loss does not establish unsaturated single-photon loss because reliable measurements at mean photon number ≤1 and a low-power TLS plateau were not obtained. The conclusion's broad claim of no significant device-performance degradation requires qualification because the hBN resonators exhibit approximately 5.7-fold higher mean TLS noise and more pronounced frequency switching than the controls.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
14 pages, 11 figures

Related papers

Cryogenic microwave loss in epitaxial Al/GaAs/Al trilayers for superconducting circuits

C. R. H. McRae, A. McFadden, R. Zhao +7 more

Epitaxially grown superconductor/dielectric/superconductor trilayers have the potential to form high-performance superconducting quantum devices and may even allow scalable superconducting quantum computing with low-surface-area qubits such as the merged-element transmon. In this work, we measure the power-independent loss and two-level-state (TLS) loss of epitaxial, wafer-bonded, and substrate-removed Al/GaAs/Al trilayers by measuring lumped element superconducting microwave resonators at millikelvin temperatures and down to single-photon powers. The power-independent loss of the device is (4.8±0.1)×10−5, and the resonator-induced intrinsic TLS loss is (6.4±0.2)×10−5. Dielectric loss extraction is used to determine a lower bound of the intrinsic TLS loss of the trilayer of 7.2×10−5. The unusually high power-independent loss is attributed to GaAs’s intrinsic piezoelectricity.

arXiv:2009.10101•Journal of Applied Physics•Jan 12, 2021•16 citations

The effect of niobium thin film structure on losses in superconducting circuits

Maxwell Drimmer, Sjoerd Telkamp, Felix L Fischer +7 more

Abstract The performance of superconducting microwave circuits is strongly influenced by the material properties of the superconducting film and substrate. While progress has been made in understanding the importance of surface preparation and the effect of surface oxides, the complex effect of superconductor film structure on microwave losses is not yet fully understood. In this study, we investigate the microwave properties of niobium resonators with different crystalline properties and related surface topographies. We analyze a series of magnetron sputtered films in which the Nb crystal orientation and surface topography are changed by varying the substrate temperatures between room temperature and 975 K. The lowest-loss resonators that we measure have quality factors of over 10 6 at single-photon powers, among the best ever recorded using the Nb on sapphire platform. We observe the highest quality factors in films grown at an intermediate temperature regime of the growth series (550 K) where the films display both preferential ordering of the crystal domains and low surface roughness. Furthermore, we analyze the temperature-dependent behavior of our resonators to learn about how the quasiparticle density in the Nb film is affected by the niobium crystal structure and the presence of grain boundaries. Our results stress the connection between the crystal structure of superconducting films and the loss mechanisms suffered by the resonators and indicate that even a moderate change in temperature during thin film deposition can significantly affect the resulting quality factors.

arXiv:2403.12164•Materials for Quantum Technology•Oct 14, 2025•22 citations

Growth of titanium-nitride thin films for low-loss superconducting quantum circuits

Gustaf Olson

This is a study of the growth of titanium-nitride (TiN) by plasma assisted molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) for applications in low loss quantum circuits. Titanium nitride is a material known to have low loss at microwave frequencies which sees practical use in many emerging quantum device architectures. The goal of this research is to investigate improvements in TiN thin films utilizing MBE to produce highly pure, highly crystalline films. A review of the theory of superconducting qubits is given and recent developments in superconducting qubit research are summarized to elucidate how loss has been reduced historically and the importance of materials improvements to the future of scalable quantum computation. The dynamics of epitaxial film growth are discussed, focusing on the formation of a minimum energy surface, the thermally driven kinetics of atoms deposited on the surface, and how these lead to the formation of large scale crystalline domains in the film. An overview of the MBE growth chamber is given and the growth procedure for TiN is discussed. Transport and morphology measurement results are discussed for MBE TiN where, for optimized growth conditions, films are highly crystalline with superconducting transition temperatures(Tc) as high as Tc = 6.1K, matching the value for bulk crystals and exceeding all reported thin film values. Microwave loss measurements of transmission line resonators fabricated from these films are shown to have low-power quality factors(Q) as high as 200,000 and an increase to Q = 400,000 at high power, consistent with the saturation of two-level-systems (TLS) at high power. These results confirm a connection between the high quality crystalline materials produced in this work and low loss in quantum circuits.

•May 29, 2015•3 citations

Thin film metrology and microwave loss characterization of indium and aluminum/indium superconducting planar resonators

Corey Rae McRae, J. H. Béjanin, C. T. Earnest +6 more

Scalable architectures characterized by quantum bits (qubits) with low error rates are essential to the development of a practical quantum computer. In the superconducting quantum computing implementation, understanding and minimizing material losses are crucial to the improvement of qubit performance. A new material that has recently received particular attention is indium, a low-temperature superconductor that can be used to bond pairs of chips containing standard aluminum-based qubit circuitry. In this work, we characterize microwave loss in indium and aluminum/indium thin films on silicon substrates by measuring superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators and estimating the main loss parameters at powers down to the sub-photon regime and at temperatures between 10 and 450 mK. We compare films deposited by thermal evaporation, sputtering, and molecular beam epitaxy. We study the effects of heating in a vacuum and ambient atmospheric pressure as well as the effects of pre-deposition wafer cleaning using hydrofluoric acid. The microwave measurements are supported by thin film metrology including secondary-ion mass spectrometry. For thermally evaporated and sputtered films, we find that two-level state are the dominant loss mechanism at low photon number and temperature, with a loss tangent due to native indium oxide of ∼5×10−5. The molecular beam epitaxial films show evidence of the formation of a substantial indium-silicon eutectic layer, which leads to a drastic degradation in resonator performance.

arXiv:1712.08706•Journal of Applied Physics•May 24, 2018•14 citations

Tantalum-Encapsulated Niobium Superconducting Resonators: High Internal Quality Factor and Improved Temporal Stability via Surface Passivation

Anas Alkhazaleh, Juan Villegas, Florent Ravaux +1 more

Superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators are essential components in quantum processors, where their internal quality factor (Qi) constrains qubit coherence and readout fidelity. In niobium devices, microwave losses at millikelvin temperatures are strongly influenced by two-level systems (TLS) associated with the complex NbOx surface oxide. To mitigate these losses, we investigate a surface-engineering approach in which Nb films are capped in situ with a thin tantalum layer to suppress Nb2O5 formation and replace the native NbOx interface with a Ta-based oxide. We fabricate Nb/Ta bilayer and reference Nb resonators on high-resistivity silicon using identical DC sputtering and wet etching conditions, and characterize their performance at millikelvin temperatures. Fresh Ta-encapsulated devices exhibit internal quality factors up to 2.4 x 10^6 in the near-single-photon regime, with power dependence consistent with reduced TLS-related loss at the metal-air interface. A control Nb device fabricated under the same process shows comparatively lower Q_TLS, consistent with the beneficial effect of the Ta capping layer. Furthermore, ageing tests performed on Nb/Ta resonators after six months reveal a moderate reduction in Q_TLS relative to their initial values, yet the performance remains superior to newly fabricated Nb-only devices. These results suggest that thin Ta encapsulation enhances interface quality and contributes to improved temporal stability while remaining compatible with Nb-based fabrication workflows.

quant-pharXiv:2604.09050•Apr 13, 2026•2 citations

Epitaxial titanium nitride microwave resonators: Structural, chemical, electrical, and microwave properties

Ran Gao, Wenlong Yu, Hao Deng +6 more

Titanium nitride is an attractive material for a range of superconducting quantum-circuit applications owing to its low microwave losses, high surface inductance, and chemical stability. The physical properties and device performance, nevertheless, depend strongly on the quality of the materials. In this paper, we focus on the highly crystalline and epitaxial titanium nitride thin films deposited on sapphire substrates using magnetron sputtering at an intermediate temperature (${300}^{\ensuremath{\circ}}\mathrm{C}$). We performed a set of systematic and comprehensive material characterizations to thoroughly understand the structural, chemical, and transport properties. Microwave losses at low temperatures were studied using patterned microwave resonators, where the best internal quality factor in the single-photon regime is measured to be $3.3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ and that in the high-power regime $>1.0\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{7}$. Adjusted with the material filling factor of the resonators, the microwave loss-tangent here compares well with the previously reported best values for superconducting resonators. This work lays the foundation of using epitaxial titanium nitride for low-loss superconducting quantum circuits.

arXiv:2111.04227•Physical Review Materials•Mar 24, 2022•37 citations
The integration of low-loss dielectrics into superconducting circuits is of importance to the functionality of quantum computers and sensors. In this work, we fabricate and measure niobium resonators atop few-layer, epitaxial hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) grown by Molecular Beam Epitaxy on a sapphire substrate and compare against a control counterpart without hBN. We conduct radiofrequency measurements which probe the responses to power, temperature, and temporal fluctuations of two-level systems. The resonators integrating hBN maintain low dielectric loss with a low-power internal loss tangent on the order of 10−610^{-6}10−6, and demonstrate hBN can be added to the conventional superconducting qubit stack with minimal degradation of the quality factor. This research represents a first step towards a materials-driven strategy to eliminate phonon-mediated correlated errors in solid-state quantum systems, which leverages the thermal properties of 2D materials to prevent athermal phonons excited in the device substrate from transmitting across the superconductor-substrate interface. The same technique applied to quantum sensors would maximize phonon collection by blocking phonons from entering passive metal films.
The paper tests whether epitaxial, few-layer hBN can be inserted between a superconducting film and its substrate without excessive microwave dielectric loss. The motivation is to use hBN’s anisotropic thermal transport to suppress substrate-phonon-induced quasiparticle bursts, or redirect phonons in quantum sensors; phonon blocking itself is not measured.
Eight Nb coplanar-waveguide resonators on approximately 3 nm3\,\mathrm{nm}3nm of molecular-beam-epitaxy-grown hBN on sapphire are compared with eight on bare sapphire. Power-dependent spectroscopy gives median low-power internal losses of 4.50×10−64.50\times10^{-6}4.50×10−6 with hBN and 1.65×10−61.65\times10^{-6}1.65×10−6 without it. Fits to TLS-induced temperature-dependent frequency shifts below 300 mK300\,\mathrm{mK}300mK give median effective zero-temperature TLS losses FδTLS0F\delta^0_{\mathrm{TLS}}FδTLS0​ of 5.54×10−65.54\times10^{-6}5.54×10−6 and 3.43×10−63.43\times10^{-6}3.43×10−6, respectively, a factor of approximately 1.61.61.6 increase. Noise measurements show stronger TLS fluctuations with hBN: the mean extracted TLS frequency-noise component at 1 kHz1\,\mathrm{kHz}1kHz and approximately 10410^4104 resonator photons is 4.65×10−184.65\times10^{-18}4.65×10−18 versus 8.16×10−198.16\times10^{-19}8.16×10−19. Most hBN resonators also exhibit pronounced frequency switching over several hours.
The reported losses characterize the complete resonator stack, not intrinsic hBN. Finite-element estimates cannot cleanly separate hBN from interfacial losses. Reliable spectroscopy was unavailable at mean photon numbers ≤1\leq1≤1, and the low-power TLS saturation plateau was not reached. An unexplained high-temperature frequency downturn restricts the temperature fitting range. Lorentzian-based models support a TLS interpretation of slow switching but do not fit all observed features well.
Epitaxially grown superconductor/dielectric/superconductor trilayers have the potential to form high-performance superconducting quantum devices and may even allow scalable superconducting quantum computing with low-surface-area qubits such as the merged-element transmon. In this work, we measure the power-independent loss and two-level-state (TLS) loss of epitaxial, wafer-bonded, and substrate-removed Al/GaAs/Al trilayers by measuring lumped element superconducting microwave resonators at millikelvin temperatures and down to single-photon powers. The power-independent loss of the device is (4.8±0.1)×10−5, and the resonator-induced intrinsic TLS loss is (6.4±0.2)×10−5. Dielectric loss extraction is used to determine a lower bound of the intrinsic TLS loss of the trilayer of 7.2×10−5. The unusually high power-independent loss is attributed to GaAs’s intrinsic piezoelectricity.
Abstract The performance of superconducting microwave circuits is strongly influenced by the material properties of the superconducting film and substrate. While progress has been made in understanding the importance of surface preparation and the effect of surface oxides, the complex effect of superconductor film structure on microwave losses is not yet fully understood. In this study, we investigate the microwave properties of niobium resonators with different crystalline properties and related surface topographies. We analyze a series of magnetron sputtered films in which the Nb crystal orientation and surface topography are changed by varying the substrate temperatures between room temperature and 975 K. The lowest-loss resonators that we measure have quality factors of over 10 6 at single-photon powers, among the best ever recorded using the Nb on sapphire platform. We observe the highest quality factors in films grown at an intermediate temperature regime of the growth series (550 K) where the films display both preferential ordering of the crystal domains and low surface roughness. Furthermore, we analyze the temperature-dependent behavior of our resonators to learn about how the quasiparticle density in the Nb film is affected by the niobium crystal structure and the presence of grain boundaries. Our results stress the connection between the crystal structure of superconducting films and the loss mechanisms suffered by the resonators and indicate that even a moderate change in temperature during thin film deposition can significantly affect the resulting quality factors.
This is a study of the growth of titanium-nitride (TiN) by plasma assisted molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) for applications in low loss quantum circuits. Titanium nitride is a material known to have low loss at microwave frequencies which sees practical use in many emerging quantum device architectures. The goal of this research is to investigate improvements in TiN thin films utilizing MBE to produce highly pure, highly crystalline films. A review of the theory of superconducting qubits is given and recent developments in superconducting qubit research are summarized to elucidate how loss has been reduced historically and the importance of materials improvements to the future of scalable quantum computation. The dynamics of epitaxial film growth are discussed, focusing on the formation of a minimum energy surface, the thermally driven kinetics of atoms deposited on the surface, and how these lead to the formation of large scale crystalline domains in the film. An overview of the MBE growth chamber is given and the growth procedure for TiN is discussed. Transport and morphology measurement results are discussed for MBE TiN where, for optimized growth conditions, films are highly crystalline with superconducting transition temperatures(Tc) as high as Tc = 6.1K, matching the value for bulk crystals and exceeding all reported thin film values. Microwave loss measurements of transmission line resonators fabricated from these films are shown to have low-power quality factors(Q) as high as 200,000 and an increase to Q = 400,000 at high power, consistent with the saturation of two-level-systems (TLS) at high power. These results confirm a connection between the high quality crystalline materials produced in this work and low loss in quantum circuits.
Scalable architectures characterized by quantum bits (qubits) with low error rates are essential to the development of a practical quantum computer. In the superconducting quantum computing implementation, understanding and minimizing material losses are crucial to the improvement of qubit performance. A new material that has recently received particular attention is indium, a low-temperature superconductor that can be used to bond pairs of chips containing standard aluminum-based qubit circuitry. In this work, we characterize microwave loss in indium and aluminum/indium thin films on silicon substrates by measuring superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators and estimating the main loss parameters at powers down to the sub-photon regime and at temperatures between 10 and 450 mK. We compare films deposited by thermal evaporation, sputtering, and molecular beam epitaxy. We study the effects of heating in a vacuum and ambient atmospheric pressure as well as the effects of pre-deposition wafer cleaning using hydrofluoric acid. The microwave measurements are supported by thin film metrology including secondary-ion mass spectrometry. For thermally evaporated and sputtered films, we find that two-level state are the dominant loss mechanism at low photon number and temperature, with a loss tangent due to native indium oxide of ∼5×10−5. The molecular beam epitaxial films show evidence of the formation of a substantial indium-silicon eutectic layer, which leads to a drastic degradation in resonator performance.
Superconducting coplanar waveguide resonators are essential components in quantum processors, where their internal quality factor (Qi) constrains qubit coherence and readout fidelity. In niobium devices, microwave losses at millikelvin temperatures are strongly influenced by two-level systems (TLS) associated with the complex NbOx surface oxide. To mitigate these losses, we investigate a surface-engineering approach in which Nb films are capped in situ with a thin tantalum layer to suppress Nb2O5 formation and replace the native NbOx interface with a Ta-based oxide. We fabricate Nb/Ta bilayer and reference Nb resonators on high-resistivity silicon using identical DC sputtering and wet etching conditions, and characterize their performance at millikelvin temperatures. Fresh Ta-encapsulated devices exhibit internal quality factors up to 2.4 x 10^6 in the near-single-photon regime, with power dependence consistent with reduced TLS-related loss at the metal-air interface. A control Nb device fabricated under the same process shows comparatively lower Q_TLS, consistent with the beneficial effect of the Ta capping layer. Furthermore, ageing tests performed on Nb/Ta resonators after six months reveal a moderate reduction in Q_TLS relative to their initial values, yet the performance remains superior to newly fabricated Nb-only devices. These results suggest that thin Ta encapsulation enhances interface quality and contributes to improved temporal stability while remaining compatible with Nb-based fabrication workflows.
Titanium nitride is an attractive material for a range of superconducting quantum-circuit applications owing to its low microwave losses, high surface inductance, and chemical stability. The physical properties and device performance, nevertheless, depend strongly on the quality of the materials. In this paper, we focus on the highly crystalline and epitaxial titanium nitride thin films deposited on sapphire substrates using magnetron sputtering at an intermediate temperature (${300}^{\ensuremath{\circ}}\mathrm{C}$). We performed a set of systematic and comprehensive material characterizations to thoroughly understand the structural, chemical, and transport properties. Microwave losses at low temperatures were studied using patterned microwave resonators, where the best internal quality factor in the single-photon regime is measured to be $3.3\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{6}$ and that in the high-power regime $>1.0\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{7}$. Adjusted with the material filling factor of the resonators, the microwave loss-tangent here compares well with the previously reported best values for superconducting resonators. This work lays the foundation of using epitaxial titanium nitride for low-loss superconducting quantum circuits.