Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.12286

Accessing electronic entanglement via photo-assisted two-electron tomography

M. Paulet, G. Rebora, M. Bienioszek, G. Ménard, G. Fève, A. Feller, P. Degiovanni

cond-mat.mes-hallquant-phSubmitted Oct 8, 2026• Announced Oct 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Witnessing entanglement between electrons propagating in quantum circuits requires accessing their two-electron coherences, which encode the two-particle quantum correlations generated by Coulomb interactions. Yet, experimental reconstruction of two-electron coherence remains a major challenge. We introduce photo-assisted two-electron tomography, a quantum coherence reconstruction protocol from dc-currents and time-averaged current correlations, routinely measured in electron quantum optics experiments. Driving an energy filter with a small rf tone encodes off-diagonal coherences in the frequency domain into the dc-current response, enabling single-electron tomography without resorting to current-noise measurements. Extending it to two channels, current correlations after two photo-assisted filters reconstruct the two-electron Wigner distribution and isolate its irreducible two-body part. When applied to Coulomb-coupled quantum Hall edge channels, the protocol reveals interaction-induced energy entanglement. Signatures of this entanglement are visible through the violation of an entanglement witness based on Cauchy-Schwarz inequalities, as well as Wigner function negativities, which remain resolved above the thermal background for realistic device parameters. A generalized Franson geometry further extends the approach to intra-channel two-electron coherences. This opens a direct pathway to detect and characterize electronic entanglement in ballistic quantum circuits.

AI Summary

The paper proposes a transport-based protocol for reconstructing electronic coherences and detecting entanglement between propagating electrons. A weak, phase-controlled rf drive followed by an energy filter maps off-diagonal energy coherences onto dc-current responses. Applying two such filters makes the two-electron coherence accessible through time-averaged, low-frequency current cross-correlations. Reconstruction is organized as a nested inverse problem: single-electron tomography determines the direct and exchange Wick contributions, while correlation measurements recover the irreducible two-body remainder. When inter-channel single-particle coherence is nonzero, its exchange contribution must be subtracted before inversion. A Cauchy–Schwarz witness tests entanglement using the reconstructed full coherence; a beam-splitter extension accesses intra-channel two-electron coherence. Analytical scattering calculations and numerical evaluations illustrate the protocol for two wave packets in capacitively coupled chiral channels. For representative GaAs parameters—a $50\,\mu\mathrm{m}$ coupler and $v_F\simeq10^5\,\mathrm{m/s}$—the estimated interaction phase is $\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}}\sim9$, with energy-exchange frequency $\omega_{AB}/2\pi\sim2.9\,\mathrm{GHz}$. The calculations show witness violations and negative relative-particle Wigner fringes. Finite-filter calculations indicate resolvable coherence structures relative to the thermal scale of approximately $2\,\mathrm{GHz}$ at $100\,\mathrm{mK}$. No experimental reconstruction is reported. Narrow filters suppress the two-body signal through the product of their capture rates; exchange subtraction can further amplify reconstruction errors. The illustrative collision model neglects Fermi-sea excitations. Reconstruction assumes a regular irreducible coherence and uses necessary, not sufficient, physicality constraints. General entanglement quantification and broader-band detection are left open.

Little sign of AI-generated textStrong assumptions

Error found: The paper does not demonstrate finite-temperature survival of its entanglement-witness violation or Wigner negativity, and comparing 2.9 GHz with a 2.08 GHz thermal scale is insufficient to establish that robustness. The realistic collision example neglects Fermi-sea excitations without establishing that Coulomb coupling cannot generate them, so its entanglement prediction remains conditional on the two-particle approximation. The quoted 1% filter-decoherence threshold extrapolates a low-energy expansion to the non-small argument ωR_KC_mu ≈ 2.27 without validating that extrapolation. Equation (7) has incorrect phase-dependent coefficients: direct substitution gives a nonzero response for a real two-energy superposition where the printed equation predicts zero.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
44 paes, 20 figures

Related papers

Single-electron quantum tomography in quantum Hall edge channels

Charles Grenier, RÉMY HERVÉ, Erwann Bocquillon +5 more

We propose a quantum tomography protocol to measure single-electron coherence in quantum Hall edge channels, and therefore access for the first time the wavefunction of single-electron excitations propagating in ballistic quantum conductors. Its implementation would open the way to quantitative studies of single-electron decoherence and would provide a quantitative tool for analyzing single- to few-electron sources. We show how this protocol could be implemented using ultrahigh-sensitivity noise measurement schemes.

arXiv:1010.2166•New Journal of Physics•Sep 6, 2011•133 citations

Two-electron coherence and its measurement in electron quantum optics

É. Thibierge, Dario Ferraro, Benjamin Roussel +4 more

Engineering and studying few-electron states in ballistic conductors is a key step towards understanding entanglement in quantum electronic systems. In this Rapid Communication, we introduce the intrinsic two-electron coherence of an electronic source in quantum Hall edge channels and relate it to two-electron wave functions and to current noise in a Hanbury Brown--Twiss interferometer. Inspired by the analogy with photon quantum optics, we propose to measure the intrinsic two-electron coherence of a source using low-frequency current correlation measurements at the output of a Franson interferometer. To illustrate this protocol, we discuss how it can distinguish between a time-bin-entangled pure state and a statistical mixture of time-shifted electron pairs.

arXiv:1503.07446•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 12, 2016•22 citations

Continuous-variable tomography of solitary electrons

J. D. Fletcher, Nathan Johnson, E. Locane +7 more

A method for characterising the wave-function of freely-propagating particles would provide a useful tool for developing quantum-information technologies with single electronic excitations. Previous continuous-variable quantum tomography techniques developed to analyse electronic excitations in the energy-time domain have been limited to energies close to the Fermi level. We show that a wide-band tomography of single-particle distributions is possible using energy-time filtering and that the Wigner representation of the mixed-state density matrix can be reconstructed for solitary electrons emitted by an on-demand single-electron source. These are highly localised distributions, isolated from the Fermi sea. While we cannot resolve the pure state Wigner function of our excitations due to classical fluctuations, we can partially resolve the chirp and squeezing of the Wigner function imposed by emission conditions and quantify the quantumness of the source. This tomography scheme, when implemented with sufficient experimental resolution, will enable quantum-limited measurements, providing information on electron coherence and entanglement at the individual particle level.

arXiv:1901.10985•Nature Communications•Nov 22, 2019•63 citations

Electron quantum optics as quantum signal processing

Benjamin Roussel, Clément Cabart, Gwendal Fève +2 more

Abstract The recent developments of electron quantum optics in quantum Hall edge channels have given us new ways to probe the behavior of electrons in quantum conductors. It has brought new quantities called electronic coherences under the spotlight. In this paper, we explore the relations between electron quantum optics and signal processing through a global review of the various methods for accessing single‐ and two‐electron coherences in electron quantum optics. We interpret electron quantum optics interference experiments as analog signal processing, converting quantum signals into experimentally observable quantities such as current averages and correlations. This point of view also gives us a procedure to obtain quantum information quantities from electron quantum optics coherences. We illustrate these ideas by discussing two‐mode entanglement in electron quantum optics. We also sketch how signal processing ideas may open new perspectives for representing electronic coherences in quantum conductors and understand the properties of the underlying many‐body electronic state.

arXiv:1610.02086•physica status solidi (b)•Jan 23, 2017•73 citations

Single-electron entanglement and nonlocality

David Dasenbrook, Joseph Bowles, Jonatan Bohr Brask +3 more

Motivated by recent progress in electron quantum optics, we revisit the question of single-electron entanglement, specifically whether the state of a single electron in a superposition of two separate spatial modes should be considered entangled. We first discuss a gedanken experiment with single-electron sources and detectors, and demonstrate deterministic (i. e. without post-selection) Bell inequality violation. This implies that the single-electron state is indeed entangled and, furthermore, nonlocal. We then present an experimental scheme where single-electron entanglement can be observed via measurements of the average currents and zero-frequency current cross-correlators in an electronic Hanbury Brown–Twiss interferometer driven by Lorentzian voltage pulses. We show that single-electron entanglement is detectable under realistic operating conditions. Our work settles the question of single-electron entanglement and opens promising perspectives for future experiments.

arXiv:1511.04450•New Journal of Physics•Apr 26, 2016•49 citations

Coupling Single Electrons to Single Photons and Probing their Entanglement

Jan-Wilke Henke, Hao Jeng, Claus Ropers

Electron beams are a formidable tool for probing nanophotonic systems [1]. Combining electron microscopy with external optical excitation in ultrafast transmission electron microscopes has enabled the mapping of optical near-fields [2] and the bunching of electrons in attosecond pulses [3, 4]. These developments are based on the stimulated inelastic scattering between electrons and light [5, 6], in which the electrons gain energy from or lose energy to the optical field. Recently, the underlying interaction strength of this process has been increased significantly by harnessing resonant enhancement of the optical field and velocity phase matching [7]. Such an increased interaction strength also benefits the spontaneous scattering of electrons with light, thus promising applications like generating complex quantum states of light [8]. In this presentation, we discuss a set of experiments on free electron quantum optics that investigate single-electron-single-photon interactions and probe the resulting entanglement. Specifically, we consider scenarios in which optical waveguide structures are placed inside a transmission electron microscope (TEM) facilitating the interaction. Electrons passing by, for example, an integrated photonic structure (cf. Fig. 1a) can inelastically scatter with the optical mode, leading to the emergence of electron-photon pair states [9]. The resulting correlation between energy-loss electrons and photons, illustrated in Fig. 1b, can be probed employing time- and energy-resolved detection of both particles, revealing a pronounced coincidence peak between their arrival times, schematically shown in Fig. 1c. Extending the photon detection setup by a second detector to allow for Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) measurements, the photon statistics heralded by such energy-loss electrons can be studied [10]. The observed anti-bunching behavior indicates a nonclassical optical state with single-photon properties. The inelastic electron-light scattering underlying the electron-photon pair generation is further expected to induce entanglement in the particle energies [11], however, direct observation of quantum entanglement would be exceedingly difficult given the large number of independent quantum states available in these degrees of freedom. Therefore, we propose experiments based on the quantum eraser scheme to demonstrate this free-electron-photon entanglement in different degrees of freedom [12,13]. Specifically, we consider a double-slit geometry coherently illuminated by an electron beam such that an interference pattern can be observed on a distant screen (cf. Fig. 2a). If electrons passing through the left or right (denoted |Land |R⁠, respectively) slit generate distinct marker photons with vertical (|V)or horizontal (|H) polarization, this interference pattern would disappear due to the entanglement of electron path and photon polarisation (cf. Fig. 2b). However, if this which-path information carried by the marker photon is erased, e.g. by mixing the polarisation states, the interference pattern can be recovered when detecting electrons and photons in coincidence. We describe an extension of this idea to an entanglement test, before discussing possible realistic implementations and presenting preliminary results on several experimental key aspects. In summary, we discuss the inelastic electron-light scattering at integrated photonic structures with applications ranging from coherent electron beam modulation using continuous-wave optical fields to the electron-driven generation of quantum optical states of light. Delving deeper into single electron-single photon interactions, we outline feasible experiments to generate and verify electron-photon entanglement with a potential extension to electron pairs based on entanglement swapping. All this adds to the toolbox of free electron quantum optics, potentially enabling novel sources of quantum light as well as quantum-enhanced sensing in electron microscopy. Generation of correlated electron-photon pairs. (a) Electrons pass over a photonic integrated circuit placed in the sample plane of a TEM, generating photons in the optical waveguides via inelastic scattering. Energy-loss electrons are detected and time-tagged behind an imaging spectrometer in coincidence with photons exiting the waveguide. (b) Inelastic scattering links the electron energy loss (green, right ladder) to the generation of photons (red, left ladder), creating correlations in energy and time. (c) A strong temporal correlation between the loss electrons and detected photons, indicated by the red dot, is observed relative to the uncorrelated zero-loss background electrons (blue line). Free-electron-photon quantum eraser. (a) Coherent electron illumination of a double-slit structure results in interference between the two pathways |Land |R.(b) If the electrons generate distinguishable marker photons, e.g. of orthogonal polarizations |Vand |H⁠, no interference pattern can be observed due to the electron-photon entanglement. (c) Collecting these marker photons and erasing the which-path information, e.g. using a half-wave plate (⁠λ/2⁠), the electron interference can be recovered using electron-photon coincidence detection with single-photon detectors (SPDs) placed behind a polarizing beam splitter (PBS).

Microscopy and Microanalysis•Jul 1, 2025•0 citations
Witnessing entanglement between electrons propagating in quantum circuits requires accessing their two-electron coherences, which encode the two-particle quantum correlations generated by Coulomb interactions. Yet, experimental reconstruction of two-electron coherence remains a major challenge. We introduce photo-assisted two-electron tomography, a quantum coherence reconstruction protocol from dc-currents and time-averaged current correlations, routinely measured in electron quantum optics experiments. Driving an energy filter with a small rf tone encodes off-diagonal coherences in the frequency domain into the dc-current response, enabling single-electron tomography without resorting to current-noise measurements. Extending it to two channels, current correlations after two photo-assisted filters reconstruct the two-electron Wigner distribution and isolate its irreducible two-body part. When applied to Coulomb-coupled quantum Hall edge channels, the protocol reveals interaction-induced energy entanglement. Signatures of this entanglement are visible through the violation of an entanglement witness based on Cauchy-Schwarz inequalities, as well as Wigner function negativities, which remain resolved above the thermal background for realistic device parameters. A generalized Franson geometry further extends the approach to intra-channel two-electron coherences. This opens a direct pathway to detect and characterize electronic entanglement in ballistic quantum circuits.
The paper proposes a transport-based protocol for reconstructing electronic coherences and detecting entanglement between propagating electrons. A weak, phase-controlled rf drive followed by an energy filter maps off-diagonal energy coherences onto dc-current responses. Applying two such filters makes the two-electron coherence accessible through time-averaged, low-frequency current cross-correlations.
Reconstruction is organized as a nested inverse problem: single-electron tomography determines the direct and exchange Wick contributions, while correlation measurements recover the irreducible two-body remainder. When inter-channel single-particle coherence is nonzero, its exchange contribution must be subtracted before inversion. A Cauchy–Schwarz witness tests entanglement using the reconstructed full coherence; a beam-splitter extension accesses intra-channel two-electron coherence.
Analytical scattering calculations and numerical evaluations illustrate the protocol for two wave packets in capacitively coupled chiral channels. For representative GaAs parameters—a 50 μm50\,\mu\mathrm{m}50μm coupler and vF≃105 m/sv_F\simeq10^5\,\mathrm{m/s}vF​≃105m/s—the estimated interaction phase is αeff∼9\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}}\sim9αeff​∼9, with energy-exchange frequency ωAB/2π∼2.9 GHz\omega_{AB}/2\pi\sim2.9\,\mathrm{GHz}ωAB​/2π∼2.9GHz. The calculations show witness violations and negative relative-particle Wigner fringes. Finite-filter calculations indicate resolvable coherence structures relative to the thermal scale of approximately 2 GHz2\,\mathrm{GHz}2GHz at 100 mK100\,\mathrm{mK}100mK.
No experimental reconstruction is reported. Narrow filters suppress the two-body signal through the product of their capture rates; exchange subtraction can further amplify reconstruction errors. The illustrative collision model neglects Fermi-sea excitations. Reconstruction assumes a regular irreducible coherence and uses necessary, not sufficient, physicality constraints. General entanglement quantification and broader-band detection are left open.
We propose a quantum tomography protocol to measure single-electron coherence in quantum Hall edge channels, and therefore access for the first time the wavefunction of single-electron excitations propagating in ballistic quantum conductors. Its implementation would open the way to quantitative studies of single-electron decoherence and would provide a quantitative tool for analyzing single- to few-electron sources. We show how this protocol could be implemented using ultrahigh-sensitivity noise measurement schemes.
Engineering and studying few-electron states in ballistic conductors is a key step towards understanding entanglement in quantum electronic systems. In this Rapid Communication, we introduce the intrinsic two-electron coherence of an electronic source in quantum Hall edge channels and relate it to two-electron wave functions and to current noise in a Hanbury Brown--Twiss interferometer. Inspired by the analogy with photon quantum optics, we propose to measure the intrinsic two-electron coherence of a source using low-frequency current correlation measurements at the output of a Franson interferometer. To illustrate this protocol, we discuss how it can distinguish between a time-bin-entangled pure state and a statistical mixture of time-shifted electron pairs.
A method for characterising the wave-function of freely-propagating particles would provide a useful tool for developing quantum-information technologies with single electronic excitations. Previous continuous-variable quantum tomography techniques developed to analyse electronic excitations in the energy-time domain have been limited to energies close to the Fermi level. We show that a wide-band tomography of single-particle distributions is possible using energy-time filtering and that the Wigner representation of the mixed-state density matrix can be reconstructed for solitary electrons emitted by an on-demand single-electron source. These are highly localised distributions, isolated from the Fermi sea. While we cannot resolve the pure state Wigner function of our excitations due to classical fluctuations, we can partially resolve the chirp and squeezing of the Wigner function imposed by emission conditions and quantify the quantumness of the source. This tomography scheme, when implemented with sufficient experimental resolution, will enable quantum-limited measurements, providing information on electron coherence and entanglement at the individual particle level.
Abstract The recent developments of electron quantum optics in quantum Hall edge channels have given us new ways to probe the behavior of electrons in quantum conductors. It has brought new quantities called electronic coherences under the spotlight. In this paper, we explore the relations between electron quantum optics and signal processing through a global review of the various methods for accessing single‐ and two‐electron coherences in electron quantum optics. We interpret electron quantum optics interference experiments as analog signal processing, converting quantum signals into experimentally observable quantities such as current averages and correlations. This point of view also gives us a procedure to obtain quantum information quantities from electron quantum optics coherences. We illustrate these ideas by discussing two‐mode entanglement in electron quantum optics. We also sketch how signal processing ideas may open new perspectives for representing electronic coherences in quantum conductors and understand the properties of the underlying many‐body electronic state.
Motivated by recent progress in electron quantum optics, we revisit the question of single-electron entanglement, specifically whether the state of a single electron in a superposition of two separate spatial modes should be considered entangled. We first discuss a gedanken experiment with single-electron sources and detectors, and demonstrate deterministic (i. e. without post-selection) Bell inequality violation. This implies that the single-electron state is indeed entangled and, furthermore, nonlocal. We then present an experimental scheme where single-electron entanglement can be observed via measurements of the average currents and zero-frequency current cross-correlators in an electronic Hanbury Brown–Twiss interferometer driven by Lorentzian voltage pulses. We show that single-electron entanglement is detectable under realistic operating conditions. Our work settles the question of single-electron entanglement and opens promising perspectives for future experiments.
Electron beams are a formidable tool for probing nanophotonic systems [1]. Combining electron microscopy with external optical excitation in ultrafast transmission electron microscopes has enabled the mapping of optical near-fields [2] and the bunching of electrons in attosecond pulses [3, 4]. These developments are based on the stimulated inelastic scattering between electrons and light [5, 6], in which the electrons gain energy from or lose energy to the optical field. Recently, the underlying interaction strength of this process has been increased significantly by harnessing resonant enhancement of the optical field and velocity phase matching [7]. Such an increased interaction strength also benefits the spontaneous scattering of electrons with light, thus promising applications like generating complex quantum states of light [8]. In this presentation, we discuss a set of experiments on free electron quantum optics that investigate single-electron-single-photon interactions and probe the resulting entanglement. Specifically, we consider scenarios in which optical waveguide structures are placed inside a transmission electron microscope (TEM) facilitating the interaction. Electrons passing by, for example, an integrated photonic structure (cf. Fig. 1a) can inelastically scatter with the optical mode, leading to the emergence of electron-photon pair states [9]. The resulting correlation between energy-loss electrons and photons, illustrated in Fig. 1b, can be probed employing time- and energy-resolved detection of both particles, revealing a pronounced coincidence peak between their arrival times, schematically shown in Fig. 1c. Extending the photon detection setup by a second detector to allow for Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) measurements, the photon statistics heralded by such energy-loss electrons can be studied [10]. The observed anti-bunching behavior indicates a nonclassical optical state with single-photon properties. The inelastic electron-light scattering underlying the electron-photon pair generation is further expected to induce entanglement in the particle energies [11], however, direct observation of quantum entanglement would be exceedingly difficult given the large number of independent quantum states available in these degrees of freedom. Therefore, we propose experiments based on the quantum eraser scheme to demonstrate this free-electron-photon entanglement in different degrees of freedom [12,13]. Specifically, we consider a double-slit geometry coherently illuminated by an electron beam such that an interference pattern can be observed on a distant screen (cf. Fig. 2a). If electrons passing through the left or right (denoted |Land |R⁠, respectively) slit generate distinct marker photons with vertical (|V)or horizontal (|H) polarization, this interference pattern would disappear due to the entanglement of electron path and photon polarisation (cf. Fig. 2b). However, if this which-path information carried by the marker photon is erased, e.g. by mixing the polarisation states, the interference pattern can be recovered when detecting electrons and photons in coincidence. We describe an extension of this idea to an entanglement test, before discussing possible realistic implementations and presenting preliminary results on several experimental key aspects. In summary, we discuss the inelastic electron-light scattering at integrated photonic structures with applications ranging from coherent electron beam modulation using continuous-wave optical fields to the electron-driven generation of quantum optical states of light. Delving deeper into single electron-single photon interactions, we outline feasible experiments to generate and verify electron-photon entanglement with a potential extension to electron pairs based on entanglement swapping. All this adds to the toolbox of free electron quantum optics, potentially enabling novel sources of quantum light as well as quantum-enhanced sensing in electron microscopy. Generation of correlated electron-photon pairs. (a) Electrons pass over a photonic integrated circuit placed in the sample plane of a TEM, generating photons in the optical waveguides via inelastic scattering. Energy-loss electrons are detected and time-tagged behind an imaging spectrometer in coincidence with photons exiting the waveguide. (b) Inelastic scattering links the electron energy loss (green, right ladder) to the generation of photons (red, left ladder), creating correlations in energy and time. (c) A strong temporal correlation between the loss electrons and detected photons, indicated by the red dot, is observed relative to the uncorrelated zero-loss background electrons (blue line). Free-electron-photon quantum eraser. (a) Coherent electron illumination of a double-slit structure results in interference between the two pathways |Land |R.(b) If the electrons generate distinguishable marker photons, e.g. of orthogonal polarizations |Vand |H⁠, no interference pattern can be observed due to the electron-photon entanglement. (c) Collecting these marker photons and erasing the which-path information, e.g. using a half-wave plate (⁠λ/2⁠), the electron interference can be recovered using electron-photon coincidence detection with single-photon detectors (SPDs) placed behind a polarizing beam splitter (PBS).