arXiv:2610.11868
From Majorana to Bloch: two ways to generalize the Bloch sphere representation
Louis Hanotel
Abstract
While the Bloch sphere provides a canonical geometric representation for qubits, its generalization to pure qudit states ($d>2$) is not unique. This representation can be extended following two different approaches: increasing the number of points, as in the Majorana representation, or using a single point but in a space of larger dimension, as in the generalized Bloch representation. In this work, we compare these representations of pure qudit states by finding explicit analytical relations between them. In particular, a general formula of the Bloch vector in terms of the Majorana points of a given state is provided. We also analyze some suitable extensions of these representations in the case of pure permutation-symmetric two- and three-qubit states, deriving the corresponding relation between them. These analytical results allow us to study, from a geometric point of view, quantum correlations of special classes of two-qubit states.
AI Summary
The paper asks how two geometric descriptions of pure qudit states are related: the Majorana constellation of $d-1$ points on a sphere and the generalized Bloch vector in $\mathbb{R}^{d^2-1}$. It derives explicit expressions for the density matrix and Bloch-vector components from the constellation. The construction uses Vieta’s formulas to recover state amplitudes from elementary symmetric functions of the stereographically projected stars, followed by traces against generalized Gell-Mann generators. The inverse transformation requires polynomial root finding; a qutrit example is given, while Abel–Ruffini obstructs a general formula by radicals for $d>5$. For pure permutation-symmetric two- and three-qubit states, the paper expresses reduced Bloch vectors and correlation tensors directly in terms of the Majorana directions. For two qubits, writing $c=\hat n_1\cdot\hat n_2$, the reduced Bloch vector is $r=2(\hat n_1+\hat n_2)/(3+c)$. Explicit formulas also cover two-body correlations and, for three qubits, the full three-body tensor. As an application, two-qubit constellations are parametrized, up to collective rotations, by their separation angle $\alpha$. Their Hilbert–Schmidt geometric discord is $D_G=2\sin^4(\alpha/2)/(3+\cos\alpha)^2$, equal to half the corresponding spin-1 variance-based 1-anticoherence measure. Removing collective orientation reduces rotationally invariant optimization to one and three parameters for two and three qubits, respectively. General correlation-tensor formulas for arbitrary numbers of symmetric qubits, and extensions beyond pure symmetric states, remain open.
Error found: The general density-matrix and Bloch-vector formulas are undefined for south-pole Majorana stars, despite explicitly including those configurations, and need an unstated limiting prescription or coordinate-chart extension. The proof of Theorem 2 uses N rather than N squared in its intermediate correlation entries, although the final theorem's denominator is correct. Section 5 initially claims equality between geometric discord and total-variance anticoherence, whereas its calculation and Theorem 4 correctly establish A_1^V = 2D_G.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 20 pages