arXiv:2610.11865
Extended Results on Absorbing Boundary Conditions as Limits of Complex Potentials
Rashi Kaimal, Roderich Tumulka
Abstract
In quantum mechanics, among the proposals for how to compute the probability distribution of detection time and place along a given spatial surface or in a given volume, two leading candidates involve absorbing boundary conditions (ABCs) and complex absorbing potentials (CAPs) for the Schrödinger equation. Here, we extend earlier results on how the two are related. It was previously shown that ABCs arise as a limiting case of CAPs, but for that a (reflecting) Neumann boundary condition was assumed at the end of the region with the CAP. Here, we obtain ABCs in a different limit using a Dirichlet boundary condition at the end of the CAP region, which seems more practically relevant and realizable.
AI Summary
The paper asks whether absorbing boundary conditions (ABCs), used to model particle detection at a surface, can arise from complex absorbing potentials (CAPs) backed by a Dirichlet wall. Earlier constructions required a Neumann or Robin wall; simply increasing absorption can instead produce reflection and suppress detection. For a particle on $(-\infty,0]$ with $\psi(0)=0$, two potentials supported at or within distance $L$ of the wall are constructed to recover $\psi'(0)=\beta\psi(0)$, where $\operatorname{Im}\beta>0$. They are a constant layer potential $V=(\hbar^2/2m)[-(\pi/(2L)+2\beta/\pi)^2]$ on $[-L,0]$, and a delta potential $V=-(\hbar^2/2m)(L^{-1}+\beta)\delta(x+L)$. The layer’s leading attractive real part scales as $L^{-2}$, while its absorptive part scales as $L^{-1}$. Explicit stationary-state matching shows that, at each fixed positive energy, both reflection amplitudes converge to $(k+i\beta)/(k-i\beta)$ as $L\to0$, and the wave-function norm within the shrinking layer vanishes. Negative real eigenvalues are also excluded for sufficiently small $L$. Convergence of the detection-time distribution to the ABC density $\rho(t)=(\hbar/m)\operatorname{Im}\beta\,|\psi_t(0)|^2$ is argued from anticipated convergence of time evolution and survival probabilities, rather than established through a separate operator-convergence proof. Calculations are carried out in one dimension. Flat higher-dimensional boundaries are addressed by separation of coordinates; curved surfaces and associated detection-place distributions are discussed heuristically. Spin-dependent boundaries and relativistic cases are not treated.
Central claim may not hold: The claimed exhaustive spectrum of the absorbing-boundary Hamiltonian is incorrect because, whenever Re β>0, exp(βx) is a square-integrable eigenfunction with complex eigenvalue −ℏ²β²/(2m). The detection-distribution convergence argument assumes unproved evolution convergence and additionally infers density convergence by an unjustified interchange of differentiation and limits. The introduction incorrectly assigns order L⁻¹ to the constant layer potential's magnitude, whereas its specified leading real part has order L⁻². The advertised extensions to curved surfaces and multiple particles are not established by the planar separation argument and heuristic discussion provided.
Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.
- Comments
- 12 pages LaTeX, no figures