Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2610.11865

Extended Results on Absorbing Boundary Conditions as Limits of Complex Potentials

Rashi Kaimal, Roderich Tumulka

quant-phSubmitted Oct 8, 2026• Announced Oct 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum mechanics, among the proposals for how to compute the probability distribution of detection time and place along a given spatial surface or in a given volume, two leading candidates involve absorbing boundary conditions (ABCs) and complex absorbing potentials (CAPs) for the Schrödinger equation. Here, we extend earlier results on how the two are related. It was previously shown that ABCs arise as a limiting case of CAPs, but for that a (reflecting) Neumann boundary condition was assumed at the end of the region with the CAP. Here, we obtain ABCs in a different limit using a Dirichlet boundary condition at the end of the CAP region, which seems more practically relevant and realizable.

AI Summary

The paper asks whether absorbing boundary conditions (ABCs), used to model particle detection at a surface, can arise from complex absorbing potentials (CAPs) backed by a Dirichlet wall. Earlier constructions required a Neumann or Robin wall; simply increasing absorption can instead produce reflection and suppress detection. For a particle on $(-\infty,0]$ with $\psi(0)=0$, two potentials supported at or within distance $L$ of the wall are constructed to recover $\psi'(0)=\beta\psi(0)$, where $\operatorname{Im}\beta>0$. They are a constant layer potential $V=(\hbar^2/2m)[-(\pi/(2L)+2\beta/\pi)^2]$ on $[-L,0]$, and a delta potential $V=-(\hbar^2/2m)(L^{-1}+\beta)\delta(x+L)$. The layer’s leading attractive real part scales as $L^{-2}$, while its absorptive part scales as $L^{-1}$. Explicit stationary-state matching shows that, at each fixed positive energy, both reflection amplitudes converge to $(k+i\beta)/(k-i\beta)$ as $L\to0$, and the wave-function norm within the shrinking layer vanishes. Negative real eigenvalues are also excluded for sufficiently small $L$. Convergence of the detection-time distribution to the ABC density $\rho(t)=(\hbar/m)\operatorname{Im}\beta\,|\psi_t(0)|^2$ is argued from anticipated convergence of time evolution and survival probabilities, rather than established through a separate operator-convergence proof. Calculations are carried out in one dimension. Flat higher-dimensional boundaries are addressed by separation of coordinates; curved surfaces and associated detection-place distributions are discussed heuristically. Spin-dependent boundaries and relativistic cases are not treated.

No sign of AI-generated textIncrementalOverclaimsPossible error

Central claim may not hold: The claimed exhaustive spectrum of the absorbing-boundary Hamiltonian is incorrect because, whenever Re β>0, exp(βx) is a square-integrable eigenfunction with complex eigenvalue −ℏ²β²/(2m). The detection-distribution convergence argument assumes unproved evolution convergence and additionally infers density convergence by an unjustified interchange of differentiation and limits. The introduction incorrectly assigns order L⁻¹ to the constant layer potential's magnitude, whereas its specified leading real part has order L⁻². The advertised extensions to curved surfaces and multiple particles are not established by the planar separation argument and heuristic discussion provided.

Written by gpt-6.1-sol from the paper's full text. Automated: it can be wrong.

Comments
12 pages LaTeX, no figures

Related papers

Absorbing boundary condition as limiting case of imaginary potentials

Roderich Tumulka

Abstract Imaginary potentials such as V(x) = −iσ1Ω(x) (with σ > 0 a constant, Ω a subset of 3-space, and 1Ω its characteristic function) have been used in quantum mechanics as models of a detector. They represent the effect of a ‘soft’ detector that takes a while to notice a particle in the detector volume Ω. In order to model a ‘hard’ detector (i.e. one that registers a particle as soon as it enters Ω), one may think of taking the limit σ → ∞ of increasing detector strength σ. However, as pointed out by Allcock, in this limit the particle never enters Ω; its wave function gets reflected at the boundary ∂Ω of Ω in the same way as by a Dirichlet boundary condition on ∂Ω. This phenomenon, a cousin of the ‘quantum Zeno effect,’ might suggest that a hard detector is mathematically impossible. Nevertheless, a mathematical description of a hard detector has recently been put forward in the form of the ‘absorbing boundary rule’ involving an absorbing boundary condition on the detecting surface ∂Ω. We show here that in a suitable (non-obvious) limit, the imaginary potential V yields a non-trivial distribution of detection time and place in agreement with the absorbing boundary rule. That is, a hard detector can be obtained as a limit, but it is a different limit than Allcock considered.

arXiv:1911.12730•Communications in Theoretical Physics•Oct 19, 2022•12 citations

Quantum Simulation for Quantum Dynamics with Artificial Boundary Conditions

Shi Jin, Xiantao Li, Nana Liu +1 more

Abstract. Quantum dynamics, typically expressed in the form of a time-dependent Schrödinger equation with a Hermitian Hamiltonian, is a natural application for quantum computing. However, when simulating quantum dynamics that involves the emission of electrons, it is necessary to use artificial boundary conditions (ABCs) to confine the computation within a fixed domain. The introduction of ABCs alters the Hamiltonian structure of the dynamics, and existing quantum algorithms cannot be directly applied since the evolution is no longer unitary. The current paper utilizes a recently introduced Schrödingerization method that converts non-Hermitian dynamics into a Schrödinger form for the artificial boundary problems [S. Jin, N. Liu, and Y. Yu, Quantum Simulation of Partial Differential Equations via Schrödingerisation, preprint, arXiv:2212.13969 , 2022], [S. Jin, N. Liu, and Y. Yu, Phys. Rev. A, 108 (2023), 032603]. We implement this method for three types of ABCs, including the complex absorbing potential technique, perfectly matched layer methods, and Dirichlet-to-Neumann approach. We analyze the query complexity of these algorithms and perform numerical experiments to demonstrate the validity of this approach. This helps to bridge the gap between available quantum algorithms and computational models for quantum dynamics in unbounded domains.

arXiv:2304.00667•SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing•Jul 10, 2024•29 citations

Existence of Schrödinger Evolution with Absorbing Boundary Condition

Lawrence Frolov, Stefan Teufel, Roderich Tumulka

Abstract Consider a non-relativistic quantum particle with wave function inside a region $$\Omega \subset \mathbb {R}^3$$ Ω ⊂ R 3 , and suppose that detectors are placed along the boundary $$\partial \Omega $$ ∂ Ω . The question how to compute the probability distribution of the time at which the detector surface registers the particle boils down to finding a reasonable mathematical definition of an ideal detecting surface; a particularly convincing definition, called the absorbing boundary rule, involves a time evolution for the particle’s wave function $$\psi $$ ψ expressed by a Schrödinger equation in $$\Omega $$ Ω together with an “absorbing” boundary condition on $$\partial \Omega $$ ∂ Ω first considered by Werner in 1987, viz., $$\partial \psi /\partial n=i\kappa \psi $$ ∂ ψ / ∂ n = i κ ψ with $$\kappa >0$$ κ > 0 and $$\partial /\partial n$$ ∂ / ∂ n the normal derivative. We provide here a discussion of the rigorous mathematical foundation of this rule. First, for the viability of the rule it plays a crucial role that these two equations together uniquely define the time evolution of $$\psi $$ ψ ; we point out here how, under some technical assumptions on the regularity (i.e., smoothness) of the detecting surface, the Lumer-Phillips theorem implies that the time evolution is well defined and given by a contraction semigroup. Second, we show that the collapse required for the N-particle version of the problem is well defined. We also prove that the joint distribution of the detection times and places, according to the absorbing boundary rule, is governed by a positive-operator-valued measure.

arXiv:1912.12057•Mathematical Physics Analysis and Geometry•Sep 1, 2025•15 citations

Absorbing boundary conditions for Schrödinger equation in a time-dependent interval

O. Karpova, K.K. Sabirov, D.M. Otajanov +2 more

We consider the reflection-transmission of the Gaussian wave packet through the moving wall with absorbing boundary conditions based on the time dependent one-dimensional Schrödinger equation.The reflection coefficient is calculated for the case when the walls are fixed, and probability density is calculated for the case when the wall is moving linearly.

Nanosystems Physics Chemistry Mathematics•Feb 20, 2017•0 citations

Electron absorption by complex potentials: One-dimensional case

Patrici Molinàs-Mata, Pau Molinàs-Mata

We investigate the electronic absorption induced by a complex potential in one-dimensional quantum mechanics. By solving the Schr\"odinger equation for spatially localized and extended complex potentials, we derive the electronic absorption coefficient \ensuremath{\alpha}. Neither a single nor a double Dirac-\ensuremath{\delta} potential can represent a totally absorbing potential (\ensuremath{\alpha}=1) for any choice of the complex amplitude of the potential. Maximum absorption coefficients for these potential types are 0.5 and 2(\ensuremath{\surd}2-1)\ensuremath{\simeq}0.828, respectively. On the contrary, wall and well potentials do account for total absorption at a particular limit of the potential parameters. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1996•23 citations

The time-independent Schrödinger equation

Dževad Belkić

This chapter deals with the time-independent Schrödinger equation. The introduction of complex ‘Hamiltonians’ is essential for treating resonances that are inherently different from genuine (physical) bound states. True square-integrable bound-state eigenvectors are associated with discrete negative eigenenergies and Hermitean Hamiltonians. Resonant states are also square-integrable, but they are linked to complex energies with positive real parts that belong to a continuum. The concept of the absorbing boundary condition comes to rescue the situation via the introduction of complex ‘Hamiltonians’ with normalizable scattering wavefunctions as proper physical states. A method which can provide an adequate spectral representation of the total Green operator or resolvent G^(ω) would be one of the key inputs into an invaluable practical quantum-mechanical theory for scattering (E = 0) and spectroscopy (E < 0).

CRC Press eBooks•Aug 22, 2019•0 citations
In quantum mechanics, among the proposals for how to compute the probability distribution of detection time and place along a given spatial surface or in a given volume, two leading candidates involve absorbing boundary conditions (ABCs) and complex absorbing potentials (CAPs) for the Schrödinger equation. Here, we extend earlier results on how the two are related. It was previously shown that ABCs arise as a limiting case of CAPs, but for that a (reflecting) Neumann boundary condition was assumed at the end of the region with the CAP. Here, we obtain ABCs in a different limit using a Dirichlet boundary condition at the end of the CAP region, which seems more practically relevant and realizable.
The paper asks whether absorbing boundary conditions (ABCs), used to model particle detection at a surface, can arise from complex absorbing potentials (CAPs) backed by a Dirichlet wall. Earlier constructions required a Neumann or Robin wall; simply increasing absorption can instead produce reflection and suppress detection.
For a particle on (−∞,0](-\infty,0](−∞,0] with ψ(0)=0\psi(0)=0ψ(0)=0, two potentials supported at or within distance LLL of the wall are constructed to recover ψ′(0)=βψ(0)\psi'(0)=\beta\psi(0)ψ′(0)=βψ(0), where Im⁡β>0\operatorname{Im}\beta>0Imβ>0. They are a constant layer potential V=(ℏ2/2m)[−(π/(2L)+2β/π)2]V=(\hbar^2/2m)[-(\pi/(2L)+2\beta/\pi)^2]V=(ℏ2/2m)[−(π/(2L)+2β/π)2] on [−L,0][-L,0][−L,0], and a delta potential V=−(ℏ2/2m)(L−1+β)δ(x+L)V=-(\hbar^2/2m)(L^{-1}+\beta)\delta(x+L)V=−(ℏ2/2m)(L−1+β)δ(x+L). The layer’s leading attractive real part scales as L−2L^{-2}L−2, while its absorptive part scales as L−1L^{-1}L−1.
Explicit stationary-state matching shows that, at each fixed positive energy, both reflection amplitudes converge to (k+iβ)/(k−iβ)(k+i\beta)/(k-i\beta)(k+iβ)/(k−iβ) as L→0L\to0L→0, and the wave-function norm within the shrinking layer vanishes. Negative real eigenvalues are also excluded for sufficiently small LLL. Convergence of the detection-time distribution to the ABC density ρ(t)=(ℏ/m)Im⁡β ∣ψt(0)∣2\rho(t)=(\hbar/m)\operatorname{Im}\beta\,|\psi_t(0)|^2ρ(t)=(ℏ/m)Imβ∣ψt​(0)∣2 is argued from anticipated convergence of time evolution and survival probabilities, rather than established through a separate operator-convergence proof.
Calculations are carried out in one dimension. Flat higher-dimensional boundaries are addressed by separation of coordinates; curved surfaces and associated detection-place distributions are discussed heuristically. Spin-dependent boundaries and relativistic cases are not treated.
Abstract Imaginary potentials such as V(x) = −iσ1Ω(x) (with σ > 0 a constant, Ω a subset of 3-space, and 1Ω its characteristic function) have been used in quantum mechanics as models of a detector. They represent the effect of a ‘soft’ detector that takes a while to notice a particle in the detector volume Ω. In order to model a ‘hard’ detector (i.e. one that registers a particle as soon as it enters Ω), one may think of taking the limit σ → ∞ of increasing detector strength σ. However, as pointed out by Allcock, in this limit the particle never enters Ω; its wave function gets reflected at the boundary ∂Ω of Ω in the same way as by a Dirichlet boundary condition on ∂Ω. This phenomenon, a cousin of the ‘quantum Zeno effect,’ might suggest that a hard detector is mathematically impossible. Nevertheless, a mathematical description of a hard detector has recently been put forward in the form of the ‘absorbing boundary rule’ involving an absorbing boundary condition on the detecting surface ∂Ω. We show here that in a suitable (non-obvious) limit, the imaginary potential V yields a non-trivial distribution of detection time and place in agreement with the absorbing boundary rule. That is, a hard detector can be obtained as a limit, but it is a different limit than Allcock considered.
Abstract. Quantum dynamics, typically expressed in the form of a time-dependent Schrödinger equation with a Hermitian Hamiltonian, is a natural application for quantum computing. However, when simulating quantum dynamics that involves the emission of electrons, it is necessary to use artificial boundary conditions (ABCs) to confine the computation within a fixed domain. The introduction of ABCs alters the Hamiltonian structure of the dynamics, and existing quantum algorithms cannot be directly applied since the evolution is no longer unitary. The current paper utilizes a recently introduced Schrödingerization method that converts non-Hermitian dynamics into a Schrödinger form for the artificial boundary problems [S. Jin, N. Liu, and Y. Yu, Quantum Simulation of Partial Differential Equations via Schrödingerisation, preprint, arXiv:2212.13969 , 2022], [S. Jin, N. Liu, and Y. Yu, Phys. Rev. A, 108 (2023), 032603]. We implement this method for three types of ABCs, including the complex absorbing potential technique, perfectly matched layer methods, and Dirichlet-to-Neumann approach. We analyze the query complexity of these algorithms and perform numerical experiments to demonstrate the validity of this approach. This helps to bridge the gap between available quantum algorithms and computational models for quantum dynamics in unbounded domains.
Abstract Consider a non-relativistic quantum particle with wave function inside a region Ω⊂R3\Omega \subset \mathbb {R}^3Ω⊂R3 Ω ⊂ R 3 , and suppose that detectors are placed along the boundary ∂Ω\partial \Omega ∂Ω ∂ Ω . The question how to compute the probability distribution of the time at which the detector surface registers the particle boils down to finding a reasonable mathematical definition of an ideal detecting surface; a particularly convincing definition, called the absorbing boundary rule, involves a time evolution for the particle’s wave function ψ\psi ψ ψ expressed by a Schrödinger equation in Ω\Omega Ω Ω together with an “absorbing” boundary condition on ∂Ω\partial \Omega ∂Ω ∂ Ω first considered by Werner in 1987, viz., ∂ψ/∂n=iκψ\partial \psi /\partial n=i\kappa \psi ∂ψ/∂n=iκψ ∂ ψ / ∂ n = i κ ψ with κ>0\kappa >0κ>0 κ > 0 and ∂/∂n\partial /\partial n∂/∂n ∂ / ∂ n the normal derivative. We provide here a discussion of the rigorous mathematical foundation of this rule. First, for the viability of the rule it plays a crucial role that these two equations together uniquely define the time evolution of ψ\psi ψ ψ ; we point out here how, under some technical assumptions on the regularity (i.e., smoothness) of the detecting surface, the Lumer-Phillips theorem implies that the time evolution is well defined and given by a contraction semigroup. Second, we show that the collapse required for the N-particle version of the problem is well defined. We also prove that the joint distribution of the detection times and places, according to the absorbing boundary rule, is governed by a positive-operator-valued measure.
We investigate the electronic absorption induced by a complex potential in one-dimensional quantum mechanics. By solving the Schr\"odinger equation for spatially localized and extended complex potentials, we derive the electronic absorption coefficient \ensuremath{\alpha}. Neither a single nor a double Dirac-\ensuremath{\delta} potential can represent a totally absorbing potential (\ensuremath{\alpha}=1) for any choice of the complex amplitude of the potential. Maximum absorption coefficients for these potential types are 0.5 and 2(\ensuremath{\surd}2-1)\ensuremath{\simeq}0.828, respectively. On the contrary, wall and well potentials do account for total absorption at a particular limit of the potential parameters. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
This chapter deals with the time-independent Schrödinger equation. The introduction of complex ‘Hamiltonians’ is essential for treating resonances that are inherently different from genuine (physical) bound states. True square-integrable bound-state eigenvectors are associated with discrete negative eigenenergies and Hermitean Hamiltonians. Resonant states are also square-integrable, but they are linked to complex energies with positive real parts that belong to a continuum. The concept of the absorbing boundary condition comes to rescue the situation via the introduction of complex ‘Hamiltonians’ with normalizable scattering wavefunctions as proper physical states. A method which can provide an adequate spectral representation of the total Green operator or resolvent G^(ω) would be one of the key inputs into an invaluable practical quantum-mechanical theory for scattering (E = 0) and spectroscopy (E < 0).